You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Fitness The Problem?
November 16 2026 11.15am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Is Fitness The Problem?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
bifffabazz Flag Highworth, Wiltshire 30 Nov 16 5.36am

Raising this old chestnut again but personally wondering if it's a big part of our problems.

Do we close down the opposition well enough?

Do we dictate the pace of a game?

Why do we seem to concede so many free kicks?

Do we get too many muscular injuries?

Why do we concede more late goals than we score?


Tactics, team selection, motivation, leadership: All valid areas to question, so why not fitness as well?

 


Spirit of 1974

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 30 Nov 16 9.16am

IMO its not fitness but Consentration and having players in postions that they clearly struggle with.Having a manager that says clean sheets are not his priorty can only expect to piss of his defenders with comments like that. They are judged by goals conceded, We have gone from having one of the best defensive records to one of the worst.

 

Part Time James Flag 30 Nov 16 9.23am

For me we got by for the first few seasons in the Prem by being a below average team with a WAY above average work rate/spirit. Now we are closer to being an average team but the work rate/spirit seems to not be AS good (not saying it's not there at all).

I've always said I'd rather have an average player giving 110% (which I know by definition isn't possible!) than a good player giving 70% and that's what I think set us aside in the past.

 




Part Time James Flag 30 Nov 16 9.25am

And to add some further conjecture, I wonder if actually some of our excellent spirit in the past has come from knowing we have to scrap to survive. Was the squad's problem this time going into a season with a mid-table expectancy and not anticipating to have to scrap it out and give 110% to survive?

 




Mad4palace Flag 30 Nov 16 9.43am

The worrying thing is that it seems to be just one of the issues:
Fitness
Concentration
Organisation
Discipline
Game management
Lack of Leadership and communication
Lack of effort from one or two players

There is crossover between these categories but they seem to in part stem from the fitness problems. I would even go as far as saying that Pardew's substitutions are a symptom of our fitness issues; going back to last season, Cabayes inability to finish a game must have cost us a lot of points. This season he's continued to take of central midfielders when in a narrow winning or closely contested draw, the sub completely messes up the organization of the midfield.

I also question the club and Pardew's transfer policy. We were supposedly in a period of 'transition', I took that as meaning bringing in better passing and possession players. I'm not really sure we've brought those players in; highlighted by the fact we signed no new midfielders and actually sold a key one who was also our captain. We seem to have become a more pressing team but that pressing style involved moving McArthur to the AM position and he and Benteke pressing as the 2 up front, this meant we sacrificed McArthurs energy in the midfield and we've gone on to see some horror show performances by the midfield, particularly against Leicester and Liverpool. Pardew did at least recognize this and moved McArthur back for the last 2 games, it seemed to work for the most part against Man City.

 

Rabbit-Tooth Flag London 30 Nov 16 10.06am

Lack of intelligence and no bottle.

 

slubglurge Flag welling 30 Nov 16 10.09am

A recent table put us in 19th pos for miles covered. Not a sirprise

 

Gidge Flag Romsey 30 Nov 16 10.53am

I think fitness is a really big part of our problem. We looked totally knackered most of the second half against Swansea and that contributed to the 24 free kicks we gave away (a lot of them around our box).

For me, it's obvious that a team that isn't sharp and fit will be slightly off the pace and will concede free kicks due to poorly timed tackles. Ball retention is another problem. We need to stop losing possession so cheaply.

All down to management and coaching I'm afraid.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Nov 16 11.12am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

The worrying thing is that it seems to be just one of the issues:
Fitness
Concentration
Organisation
Discipline
Game management
Lack of Leadership and communication
Lack of effort from one or two players

There is crossover between these categories but they seem to in part stem from the fitness problems. I would even go as far as saying that Pardew's substitutions are a symptom of our fitness issues; going back to last season, Cabayes inability to finish a game must have cost us a lot of points. This season he's continued to take of central midfielders when in a narrow winning or closely contested draw, the sub completely messes up the organization of the midfield.

I also question the club and Pardew's transfer policy. We were supposedly in a period of 'transition', I took that as meaning bringing in better passing and possession players. I'm not really sure we've brought those players in; highlighted by the fact we signed no new midfielders and actually sold a key one who was also our captain. We seem to have become a more pressing team but that pressing style involved moving McArthur to the AM position and he and Benteke pressing as the 2 up front, this meant we sacrificed McArthurs energy in the midfield and we've gone on to see some horror show performances by the midfield, particularly against Leicester and Liverpool. Pardew did at least recognize this and moved McArthur back for the last 2 games, it seemed to work for the most part against Man City.

Nailed it.

 


COYP

Bill Glazier Flag Mitcham 30 Nov 16 11.49am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Nailed it.

Far from nailing it.We Win more points with Cabaye off the pitch.In fact I think we have only won once with him on the pitch at 90 minutes.We purely need a left back and need to eradicate the schoolboy errors from the players.

 

The_postman Flag Forest Row 30 Nov 16 12.08pm

This is part of an interview with Scott Guyett the head fitness and conditioning coach at CPFC in Feb 2014.

Perhaps fitness is something which slid for Palace at the start of this season. I questioned the impact of Tony Pulis on this side of things.

“Under Tony, the lads do have to be very, very fit. We look at the Prozone stats now and the players are doing a lot more now than they were under the previous regime.”

I ask whether Guyett feels that is one of the reasons for the Eagles’ recent upturn in results.

“I think that’s probably showed. It was difficult because we’ve had four managers in the space of twelve months [Dougie Freedman, Ian Holloway, Keith Millen and Pulis] and they all have their different ways of working.”

Guyett is still at Palace but it seems that Pardew does not demand the same level of fitness that Pulis did. Pity!

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 30 Nov 16 1.02pm

Under pullis we seemed fitter and we also had a bit of a nastiness to us, we use to time waste a bit ( like a lot of teams do, not condoning it) and put bodies on the line. We're push overs now!

 

Gyro1780 Flag Leatherhead, Surrey 30 Nov 16 1.06pm

Originally posted by Loz83

Under pullis we seemed fitter and we also had a bit of a nastiness to us, we use to time waste a bit ( like a lot of teams do, not condoning it) and put bodies on the line. We're push overs now!

Was just going to post this. Agreed we did look a fitter team.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 30 Nov 16 1.10pm

Originally posted by Gyro1780

Was just going to post this. Agreed we did look a fitter team.

But 'this is the happiest group I've (Pardew) ever seen.'

Replaced togetherness and accepting no superstars for a happy group of players. That might suggest why we're a walkover.

 


COYP

Eustace H. Plimsoll Flag Aldershot 30 Nov 16 1.38pm

Originally posted by Part Time James

For me we got by for the first few seasons in the Prem by being a below average team with a WAY above average work rate/spirit. Now we are closer to being an average team but the work rate/spirit seems to not be AS good (not saying it's not there at all).

Pretty much bang on, to my mind.

I think we had (and still have, up to a point) a special group, in terms of spirit, which offered terrific work-rate and work-ethic with it. Incredible spirit can take you very far, if correctly harnessed - see: "Hillsborough Heroes", Leicester last year, 80s/90s f***ing Wimbledon etc. There was always a significant risk this would drop as the squad inevitably ages/evolves and I think we're seeing that. The 'better' players need to be a helluva lot better if they don't have the same spirit. Otherwise it's more a question of ability and tactics.

Bugger.

 


As a woman, I can step aside, or step up my game...

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 30 Nov 16 1.49pm

I remember the first few transfer windows we had in the premiership we were looking to buy players that would suit our style, fit into our team spirit and give 100% for the team. Don't really think benteke, townsend and Tompkins meet that criteria...is that where we've gone wrong?

 

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 30 Nov 16 2.11pm

We are 18th in distance covered. The top five are pretty obvious

1. Liverpool
2. Man City
3. Spurs
4. Burnley
5. WBA

it does show that fitness is key in modern football. The 3 best coaches in England all play high tempo high pressing. Dyche and Pulis also get there teams to work very hard to make up for lack of quality. Palace have always looked at their best when we have a high work rate and get at the oppo

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

si_1967 Flag Surrey 30 Nov 16 2.11pm

I agree with a lot of the sentiments on here, additionally I wonder if we miss a 'big' midfielder.

I'm not saying we shouldn't have sold Jedinak, but his size at set pieces (defending) must have added some peace of mind to the defending unit.

So should we have replaced Jedinak better? (to be honest, we couldn't have replaced him with worse, ie, the 'invisible flame' ini)

Edited by si_1967 (30 Nov 2016 2.40pm)

 


... what

Mad4palace Flag 30 Nov 16 2.35pm

Originally posted by si_1967

I agree with a lot of the sentiments on here, additionally I wonder if we miss a 'big' midfielder.

I'm not saying we shouldn't have sold Jedinak, but his size a set pieces (defending) must have added some piece of mind to the defending unit.

So should we have replaced Jedinak better? (to be honest, we couldn't have replaced him with worse, ie, the 'invisible flame' ini)

On its day, the trio of McArthur, Punch and Cabaye does work. But we've become overreliant on McArthur's energy and the fact that the creativity vanishes without Puncheon (Since our return, we have never won a game in the PL where Puncheon has not featured).

But you've got to look at players like Leroy Fer at Swansea and Capoue at Watford and wonder if we also need someone like them. I suggest an aggressive pursuit of Dembele of Spurs in January (without of course giving them Zaha as part of the deal). Schneiderlin would be another option.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 30 Nov 16 3.35pm

Personally I think fitness is the key. When you're knackered, concentration goes out the window. If a player runs past you you think 'f**k' and don't pick him up (or struggle to get there). Heads drop and you play to survive.

Seems like I see that week in and week out. I bet we've conceded the most goals in the last 5 mins in the league. With the current levels of fitness we have no chance to see a game out - and guess what... we haven't

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Is Fitness The Problem?