You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team against Man.U
November 16 2026 11.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team against Man.U


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Woolsy Flag Essex 12 Dec 16 12.47pm

Hennessey

Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins

Zaha Ledley Cabaye Fryers

McArthur

Benteke

Edited by Woolsy (12 Dec 2016 12.47pm)

Edited by Woolsy (12 Dec 2016 1.13pm)

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 12 Dec 16 1.11pm

Originally posted by Woolsy

Hennessey

Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins

Fryers Ledley Cabaye Zaha

McArthur

Benteke


Why is LB Fryers on the right wing and why is Zaha on the left? Neither of those changes look ideal to me.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Woolsy Flag Essex 12 Dec 16 1.14pm

Oops got the sides mixed up. Now changed.
Can't bear to see another Townsend poor performance. At least Fryers can get a good cross in.

 

Mad4palace Flag 12 Dec 16 1.37pm

Hennessey
Tomkins - Dann - Delaney - Ward
Zaha - McArthur - Cabaye - Townsend
Ledley
Benteke

Pardew surely has to play McArthur in a deeper position simply due to the inept defensive performances of the rest of the midfield. I think Ledley is better going forward where his lack of athleticism is less exposed.

Townsend probably keeps his spot by the sheer fact there is no one else who could come in, he has at least been better defensively since the Swansea defeat.

 

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 12 Dec 16 1.45pm

Martyn

Hinshelwood Cannon Young Sansom

McArthur Thomas

Zaha Benteke Wright Salako


Oh my giddy aunt.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Username Flag Horsham 12 Dec 16 2.59pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

Hennessey
Tomkins - Dann - Delaney - Ward
Zaha - McArthur - Cabaye - Townsend
Ledley
Benteke

Pardew surely has to play McArthur in a deeper position simply due to the inept defensive performances of the rest of the midfield. I think Ledley is better going forward where his lack of athleticism is less exposed.

Townsend probably keeps his spot by the sheer fact there is no one else who could come in, he has at least been better defensively since the Swansea defeat.


That really doesn't make any sense. The further forward he plays, the more ground he has to cover. Southampton worked for Ledley because he sat very, very deep and just patrolled in front of the back four.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

phillanth Flag London 12 Dec 16 3.10pm

Here is my team selection:

Hennessey

Tomkins - Dann - Delaney - Ward

McArthur - Ledley

Zaha - Cabaye - Townsend


Benteke

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 12 Dec 16 3.18pm

Originally posted by phillanth

Here is my team selection:

Hennessey

Tomkins - Dann - Delaney - Ward

McArthur - Ledley

Zaha - Cabaye - Townsend


Benteke

I think you're very likely to be correct with the possible difference that he'll swap McArthur and Cabaye, position-wise.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Mad4palace Flag 12 Dec 16 3.27pm

Originally posted by Username


That really doesn't make any sense. The further forward he plays, the more ground he has to cover. Southampton worked for Ledley because he sat very, very deep and just patrolled in front of the back four.

It worked against Southampton because they were very slow in building up the play and played a deep line, Ledley struggles against teams that press and play quickly when they have the ball. On Saturday he got dragged out wide for the 2nd and beaten for pace by Livermore for the 3rd. Neither he or Cabaye are reliable in those 2 sitting midfielder roles. Going forward he is at least good in the air and he does play neat one-two's that can trigger attacks.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Dec 16 3.31pm

Originally posted by Username


That really doesn't make any sense. The further forward he plays, the more ground he has to cover. Southampton worked for Ledley because he sat very, very deep and just patrolled in front of the back four.

Ledley really should play as an out and out defensive midfielder. Cabaye and McArthur fulfilling the more central midfield roles (Cabaye is an excellent interceptor of the ball, and McArthur has an all round midfield quality). Cabaye also can spit out a good diagional pass to Zaha and (Probbaly) Townsend, so they can hit the ball at full pace - something Ledley isn't great at.

Cabaye is too 'light' to be a full on defensive midfield.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 12 Dec 16 3.36pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

It worked against Southampton because they were very slow in building up the play and played a deep line, Ledley struggles against teams that press and play quickly when they have the ball. On Saturday he got dragged out wide for the 2nd and beaten for pace by Livermore for the 3rd. Neither he or Cabaye are reliable in those 2 sitting midfielder roles. Going forward he is at least good in the air and he does play neat one-two's that can trigger attacks.

Defensive midfielders aren't generally quick players. They need to be sturdy, good in the air, and able to anticipate the game, rather than rely on pace. Jedi and KG together were unbelievably good defensive partnership (and even solo Jedi was a class act in DM).

Same went for Shaun Derry. The good DM doesn't run, he covers space to protect the back four. You win balls in the air, put people under pressure, make tackles and when necessary take the player out. You don't have to make fancy passes, score goals - Your job is solely about choking the other team.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Beanyboysmd Flag 12 Dec 16 4.03pm

Originally posted by Woolsy

Hennessey

Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins

Zaha Ledley Cabaye Fryers

McArthur

Benteke

Edited by Woolsy (12 Dec 2016 12.47pm)

Edited by Woolsy (12 Dec 2016 1.13pm)

The more I look at this squad, the less I hate it! :-)

 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 12 Dec 16 5.38pm

Jules
Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins
Ledley Cabaye
Zaha McArthur Lee
Benteke

Edited by Goldfiinger (12 Dec 2016 5.39pm)

 

Podyonkers Flag Atlanta, Georgia 12 Dec 16 5.47pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Jules
Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins
Ledley Cabaye
Zaha McArthur Lee
Benteke

Edited by Goldfiinger (12 Dec 2016 5.39pm)

I like this but I'd swap Cabaye and McArthur around for the moment. If ever there was a time to concentrate on keeping a clean sheet, this would be it. Think Jimmy Mac would do a better job of getting stuck in and choking their midfield and forwards.

Wish we could bring Jules back. Not sentiment. He is just better, IMO.

Jules
Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins
Ledley McArthur
Zaha Cabaye Lee
Benteke

 


Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 12 Dec 16 5.47pm

Originally posted by Goldfiinger

Jules
Ward Delaney Dann Tomkins
Ledley Cabaye
Zaha McArthur Lee
Benteke

Edited by Goldfiinger (12 Dec 2016 5.39pm)

These are the players he'll play apart from Speroni who Pardew would rather he forgot his boots or had the wrong kick off time.

Their limitations going forward might just help us get a result if big head can grasp it.

 


COYP

tonymikejoe Flag UK 12 Dec 16 6.11pm

Assuming there is no Tomkins, McArthur as well as Puncheon.

Wayne H


Ward Kelly Dann DD Zeki


Ledley Cabaye


Zaha 'dros


CB

This gives us a left-foot (Zeki) on that side of the pitch with the added insurance of the left-footed DD inside offering extra protection.

Two defensive-placed midfielders in front and allow the three forwards to do what they like.

This mirrors the second-half line up at Hull to some extent, which is not encouraging, but I'm factoring in hours of preparation. Is that wishful thinking?

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 12 Dec 16 6.18pm

Just looked at manures bench yesterday.....
Bailly mata rooney blind rashford fellainI

Not really fair, Do you think they'd let us borrow a couple?

 

The Dolphin Flag 12 Dec 16 6.34pm

There are not many permutations left!
I would play Fryers in a back four - no Tomkins.
Then Cabaye, Ledley and JMac with Wilf and Townsend either side of CB.

 

Mad4palace Flag 12 Dec 16 6.41pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Defensive midfielders aren't generally quick players. They need to be sturdy, good in the air, and able to anticipate the game, rather than rely on pace. Jedi and KG together were unbelievably good defensive partnership (and even solo Jedi was a class act in DM).

Same went for Shaun Derry. The good DM doesn't run, he covers space to protect the back four. You win balls in the air, put people under pressure, make tackles and when necessary take the player out. You don't have to make fancy passes, score goals - Your job is solely about choking the other team.

I agree but Ledley is a player that could do with a bit more pace, also the higher press that teams are beginning to play more and more these days means that at least a bit of athleticism is needed from your DM. Jedinak struggled too when teams pressed him on the ball. McArthur is our best midfielder defensively but also useful to play a more advanced role to do that pressing job.

A bit of speed is needed to recover against a counter attack and quickly mop up any loose balls, that's what Kante does, McArthur can do and what Derry was capable of doing more so than Ledley or Cabaye. Puncheon is actually better at this than Cabaye or Ledley and IMO has better defensive intelligence than either.

Jedinak wasn't quick but he had the defensive intelligence that Ledley and Cabaye don't have. Cabaye wins tackles and makes interceptions but his positioning and awareness of that role is lacking. Ledley is error prone and players seem to catch him off guard if they're playing between the lines. Being able to recover your position from a mistake or able to win the ball back quickly does give players like McArthur and even Puncheon an edge.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 12 Dec 16 6.41pm

No Jedinak to mark Fellaini again as in the Cup Final who will get the job.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team against Man.U