This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Singing section next to away fans
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
SwordFish Peasmarsh,East Sussex 20 Dec 16 8.26pm |
|
|
I sit in block b and I think the atmosphere is great. We literally sing non stop! But.... I do think it would create a better atmosphere if it were next to the away fans. I know block w of Arthur is quite bouncy but still that is not next to them block y is and that is very quiet. I think either we create another singing section in block y or maybe the HF move to there. Just a thought because you can't hear anything the away fans sing hardly from the holmesdale so when it is just the HF singing I'm sure you can't hear it from the away end. Hence why we weren't voted best atmosphere in England And only came 6th
“This is a crisis, a large crisis.... in fact if you have a moment, it’s a 12 storey crisis, magnificent entrance hall, carpeting throughout, 24 hour portage , and an enormous sign on the roof saying “This , is a large crisis” - Edmund Blackadder
|
Mstrobez 20 Dec 16 8.53pm |
|
|
It's also partly because our atmosphere is nothing special anymore whether we like that or not. It's a shame, but inevitably went down hill as he seasons went on in the prem. If I remember correctly block b was situated there with your exact reasoning in mind, away fans used to occupy that section in Arthur a while back.
Think the HF would take some convincing to relocate - had a season ticket at the top of W a few seasons back and it used to be rocking every single game, sometimes we'd even sing "can you hear the Holmesdale sing!"... but the view is truly appalling since they moved the gantry over there.
Edited by Mstrobez (20 Dec 2016 8.54pm)
We're the Arthur over ere!
|
You What se25 20 Dec 16 9.25pm |
|
Originally posted by Mstrobez
It's also partly because our atmosphere is nothing special anymore whether we like that or not. It's a shame, but inevitably went down hill as he seasons went on in the prem. If I remember correctly block b was situated there with your exact reasoning in mind, away fans used to occupy that section in Arthur a while back.
Think the HF would take some convincing to relocate - had a season ticket at the top of W a few seasons back and it used to be rocking every single game, sometimes we'd even sing "can you hear the Holmesdale sing!"... but the view is truly appalling since they moved the gantry over there.
Back of Block V is better than W Edited by Mstrobez (20 Dec 2016 8.54pm)
|
bubble wrap Carparks in South East London 20 Dec 16 9.45pm |
|
|
Years back the Arthur used to be the singing stand. Can barely hear the HF most games when in the Arthur and when in the Holmesdale you cannot hear the away fans much. I liked it at Leicester with their fans either side of the away fans on the corner. Away fans were moved to save policing fees, would be such a better atmosphere if away fans were moved back to the other side of the Arthur with our fans either side. Would be more banter between fans. Would also stop our family section getting abuse from the away fans. Cannot be many clubs who site the away fans next to the family stand.
|
Casual Orpington 20 Dec 16 9.54pm |
|
|
When we were at the bottom of the championship, decent away fans would make the the game for me , next to the Holmesdale. The away fans are an irrelevance nowadays, if you are sat in the Holmesdale, don't even think Pompey could be heard that far away. We still get a decent atmosphere , but there's no edge to the atmosphere. Modern football, its not changing.
|
Username Horsham 21 Dec 16 9.29am |
|
|
The away fans always used to be next to the Holmesdale, they were moved precisely because that's where the HF are and the Police kicked up a fuss about policing costs.
Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.
|
bexleydave Barnehurst 21 Dec 16 9.35am |
|
Originally posted by Username
The away fans always used to be next to the Holmesdale, they were moved precisely because that's where the HF are and the Police kicked up a fuss about policing costs.
The police wanted to increase their presence, at extra cost, if the away supporters remained next to the HF. The board decided to move the away support to avoid that.
Bexley Dave
Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!
"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)
|
Brentmiester_General Front line in the battle against t... 21 Dec 16 9.37am |
|
Originally posted by Casual
When we were at the bottom of the championship, decent away fans would make the the game for me , next to the Holmesdale. The away fans are an irrelevance nowadays, if you are sat in the Holmesdale, don't even think Pompey could be heard that far away. We still get a decent atmosphere , but there's no edge to the atmosphere. Modern football, its not changing.
Halcyon days. Had a season ticket in Block B myself back then and it was great entertainment.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...
|
DocSavage1 Brackley 21 Dec 16 10.20am |
|
|
block y always appears to be full of "lost souls" we often stroll to the back of this block to have a gander at the away fans before taking our places and this lot look like they have entered the wrong venue and meant to go the the crystal palace bowl or an ice rink
they make no noise, show no colours (but there again nor do I), and very little interest in the game.
I am beginning to suspect that they are time travellers from the future coming back to see how life was in the early 21st century
Originally posted by SwordFish
I sit in block b and I think the atmosphere is great. We literally sing non stop! But.... I do think it would create a better atmosphere if it were next to the away fans. I know block w of Arthur is quite bouncy but still that is not next to them block y is and that is very quiet. I think either we create another singing section in block y or maybe the HF move to there. Just a thought because you can't hear anything the away fans sing hardly from the holmesdale so when it is just the HF singing I'm sure you can't hear it from the away end. Hence why we weren't voted best atmosphere in England And only came 6th
|
DocSavage1 Brackley 21 Dec 16 10.24am |
|
|
its awesome compared to 1. the first 40 yrs of me visiting 2. most other grounds
but
1. oppos have upped their game when they come here and make more noise than they used to 2. our noise is a little less intense this year but is more extensive when viewed from centre of arthur everyone to the left seems to be involved
Originally posted by Mstrobez
It's also partly because our atmosphere is nothing special anymore whether we like that or not. It's a shame, but inevitably went down hill as he seasons went on in the prem. If I remember correctly block b was situated there with your exact reasoning in mind, away fans used to occupy that section in Arthur a while back.
Think the HF would take some convincing to relocate - had a season ticket at the top of W a few seasons back and it used to be rocking every single game, sometimes we'd even sing "can you hear the Holmesdale sing!"... but the view is truly appalling since they moved the gantry over there.
Edited by Mstrobez (20 Dec 2016 8.54pm)
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 21 Dec 16 11.09am |
|
|
If we stay up, it would be nice if we could move the away fans back again and pay the extra Police costs. Not sure how happy ST holders in these blocks would feel about being moved though.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
bexleydave Barnehurst 21 Dec 16 11.15am |
|
Originally posted by topcat
If we stay up, it would be nice if we could move the away fans back again and pay the extra Police costs. Not sure how happy ST holders in these blocks would feel about being moved though.
I believe that, whilst the costs were a factor, the board also decided that they didn't want a substantial increase in the police presence inside the stadium. It's likely that they won't have changed their minds on that.
Bexley Dave
Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!
"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)
|
spartakev2 Anerley 21 Dec 16 11.31am |
|
Originally posted by Casual
When we were at the bottom of the championship, decent away fans would make the the game for me , next to the Holmesdale. The away fans are an irrelevance nowadays, if you are sat in the Holmesdale, don't even think Pompey could be heard that far away. We still get a decent atmosphere , but there's no edge to the atmosphere. Modern football, its not changing.
Hate to say it but I thought the united fans were very loud. No problem hearing them frpm holmesdsle. Chelsea were poor, I was in the loo when they scored and didn't realise it was a goal because they were so quiet.
|
gambler Kent 21 Dec 16 11.45am |
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Hate to say it but I thought the united fans were very loud. No problem hearing them frpm holmesdsle. Chelsea were poor, I was in the loo when they scored and didn't realise it was a goal because they were so quiet.
Last season i was right next to Chelsea, Tottenham and West Ham in the Arthur. Chelsea were shocking then too compared to the other two.
|
CJr94 Holmesdale Road 21 Dec 16 12.24pm |
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
Hate to say it but I thought the united fans were very loud. No problem hearing them frpm holmesdsle. Chelsea were poor, I was in the loo when they scored and didn't realise it was a goal because they were so quiet.
I agree, I'm in the holmesdale and man united made some bloody noise to be fair to them.
|
MKCPFC Spain/MK 21 Dec 16 12.35pm |
|
|
I came back for the Chelsea game , and the atmosphere since I was last back , West Ham , had noticeably gone downhill. It's a shame but I think inevitable because of our poor home form. We need a good run of three or four home wins to get the belief and buzz back in the fans.
|
cardiff eagle 21 Dec 16 1.13pm |
|
Originally posted by MKCPFC
I came back for the Chelsea game , and the atmosphere since I was last back , West Ham , had noticeably gone downhill. It's a shame but I think inevitable because of our poor home form. We need a good run of three or four home wins to get the belief and buzz back in the fans.
Yep- the atmosphere in general this season hasn't been great. Think it's the apathy setting in.
It's hard to get a good atmosphere going when you know you're probably going to lose again! It will stay this way until Pardew leaves
|
Isley46 Sanderstead 21 Dec 16 2.02pm |
|
|
Have been in a number of sections this season.
Was in main stand C for Manu and main stand D for Man city. On both occasions the away support was louder than the Holmesdale.
Normally sit in Y at the front with the kids as we need four seats together. If you are in Y then you don't hear the away support at all.
Think it's all to do with the layout of the ground and how sound travels / is lost - If the Holmesdale singing moved to behind the goal it would give a totally different perspective.
|
Dean_CPFC South london 21 Dec 16 7.07pm |
|
|
Isn't it frustrating that we can outsing the manks at wembley but then they get to outsing us at our own ground?!! Its in a large way down to the stadium setup, at wembley the singing section was right behind the goal and the two blocks either side so the noise could travel both ways, thats why it was so successful! If we could replicate the wembley set up at home games it would make Selhurst a fun place to go again and we can have that wembley atmosphere week in week out
Unfortunately the atmosphere is getting worse and worse each year and we need some kind of change to bring it back to a decent level, we're living on past glories.
|
stodis Polegate East Sussex 21 Dec 16 11.39pm |
|
|
Yes, and it might help if we find some new songs to sing as the one's we have now are getting a bit tired.
year 55
|