You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > At what point did you initially think it's time ..
November 16 2026 10.59am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

At what point did you initially think it's time ..


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
premier fan Flag BR4 23 Dec 16 8.11am

for AP to go?

Me : post Swansea Away

Edited by premier fan (23 Dec 2016 8.12am)

 

stayloa Flag Beckenham 23 Dec 16 8.15am

Aye, Swansea away. Burnley was a kick in the teeth but apart from the first 20 we bossed the game and felt it was right to go for the win. Some bad luck since then but Swansea was unforgiveable.

 

jimruss Flag Sidcup 23 Dec 16 8.20am

I had doubts towards the end of last season and felt he should have gone after the FA cup

 

BR6 Flag Orpington 23 Dec 16 8.37am

End of last season I figured things weren't good. Swansea away was the final nail in the coffin for me.

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 23 Dec 16 8.39am

Swansea, not that we lost, the fact that after saying our focus was on a clean sheet we ship 5 goals. Comical

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Shortbutts Flag Birmingham 23 Dec 16 8.42am

Yesterday

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 23 Dec 16 8.43am

As above (1) After the FA Cup final and (2) After Swansea. It was obvious there was something seriously wrong from last Christmas onwards and, when it continued into the new season, we should have acted decisively a lot earlier.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 23 Dec 16 8.46am

After the Cup final.

 

Paul67 Flag 23 Dec 16 8.48am

When Campbell replaced Mcarther at 1-1 v Man Utd. Frazer Campbell can score a late equalizer against one of his old clubs, lets try it again this time he'll get the winner. He'd run out of ideas.

 

CheeseRolls Flag Cheshire 23 Dec 16 8.52am

Dropping Punch for the cup final - doubts.

Selling Jedi - serious doubts.

Burnley away - game over.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 23 Dec 16 9.21am

Originally posted by stayloa

Aye, Swansea away. Burnley was a kick in the teeth but apart from the first 20 we bossed the game and felt it was right to go for the win. Some bad luck since then but Swansea was unforgiveable.

Same here. Burnley is always a hard place to go, and they've been getting results, against much better teams than us there.

But Swansea were s**t, barely capable of scoring, and we lost despite scoring 4 goals. In anyone's book that terrible. I thought Pardew had done a good job in sorting out the attack, but lost the balance of a team that previously could defend with ease. After that, the draw with an equally s**t Hull was the final straw.

Three games that he needed to get 7 points from, and despite netting eight times, we took a single point.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Littlebogreek Flag 23 Dec 16 9.28am

Originally posted by Paul67

When Campbell replaced Mcarther at 1-1 v Man Utd. Frazer Campbell can score a late equalizer against one of his old clubs, lets try it again this time he'll get the winner. He'd run out of ideas.

Exactly when I did too. I supported the project to change the style etc up till then and made constant excuses referring back to that. I blamed bad luck (we've had our fair share) and defending incompetence that couldn't have been his fault, then he made those changes. In fact all of the substitutions that game had an air of bizarreness to them, almost like he had a spinning wheel with player names on them and made changes accordingly. I suspect the Fryers change on the left instead of Townsend was a deliberate up yours to Townsend - yes I know Fryers "defending is better" but I've seen him play so we cant use that excuse!

 

Darkish Flag Croydon 23 Dec 16 9.28am

I still had faith and would like him to stay. He would have turned thinks around, building a good team and would have improved it further with time. Was moving towards a good style of football.

Now worry what we will get. Sure we will stay up with but this then maybe used as an argument for defensive dull football in the future.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 23 Dec 16 9.29am

Week after cup final onwards. A pause during the 3 game winning run vs sh1t teams. Apart from that it's been nowhere near good enough for 12 months.

 


COYP

essetwentyone Flag london 23 Dec 16 9.36am

December 14th 2016 at approx 9.45.

All my doubts were cemented when the 4th official raised his board for subs.

 

dannyb1 Flag Chichester 23 Dec 16 9.39am

Time he should have been sacked - Swansea

Reasons he should have been sacked - Selling Murray, Gayle, Jedinak and Bolasie.
Yes I know we were looking to transition into a more attacking type of fancy team but if the sub vs man u was Jedi instead of Cambell to just retain some order in def/mid we could have walked away with a point.

We were trying at times to play a 442 with 2 big guys upfront of similar attributes who couldn't really work off each other this is where we needed a fox in the box type of striker that we had in Gayle.

Bolasie sale I guess was to fund Benteke but I believe he wanted out from Pardew anyway.

All the above even if not in the first 11 could have attributed something from the bench.

The dance at Wembley, leaving Punch out, shipping 5 goals after being told defence had been training all week, letting 3 teams s***ter then us play like Barcelona and get results, being unable to defend his defenders inability's, the non blame culture of his tactics after defeats but full of self praise when results go our way, the CYL incident (if true)
6 WINS ALL YEAR
But I think (if true) the one that kicks in the teeth the most is being told it's time to step down and not taking it upon himself, yes I guess we were unlucky against mancs and chelsea but these are the teams we should be looking to take points from they are the ones that prove you can cut it.

 

Mad4palace Flag 23 Dec 16 9.55am

After the transfer window closed. I found the promise of "transition" to be hollow, the players he'd brought in were never going to change our style in the way he thought (no midfielders!). Selling Jedinak was a mess, as was giving Dann the captaincy IMO.

After the cup final I actually still wanted him. You could see he had a good thing going for the first half of 15/16, I wanted to see him build the squad but he didn't correct its imbalances in the transfer window and created new ones in the process; DM with Jedinak and LM with Townsend not wanting/capable of playing there.

 

Wisbech Eagle Flag Truro Cornwall 23 Dec 16 10.00am

I didn't think he should have been sacked at anytime. Selling various players wasn't always his choice. If they want to go, then go they will.

We have obviously had a terrible run of results but there are many reasons for it. Pardew tried to alter the system because he felt it had become too predictable and teams were picking us off. Losing Bolasie made that even more necessary. We have suffered particularly damaging injuries to key players, as well as a loss of form from others. Neither was Pardew's fault. He had obviously decided that, in the short term at least, he needed to revert to a more rugged, less expansive, style, and it seemed to be paying dividends with a result against Southampton, and decent performances against Man U and Chelsea.

We obviously needed a shake up defensively, either with new coaching or personnel, but changing the guy at the top seems a big step to me, and probably a step backwards.

I worry that this step has been forced by the Americans and was not wanted by Parish who wanted, as I did, to close ranks and fight our way through. Allardyce is reported to have made an effective job application, backed up with a statistical dossier of where we were going wrong, a month or so ago and sent this to our "investors". If true, and it is them who has forced the issue, then does this mean that the way the club is run has changed for ever? We all thought that Steve Parish was the one who made the decisions but maybe that isn't true anymore.

 


For the avoidance of doubt any comments in response to a previous post are directed to its ideas and not at any, or all, posters personally.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 23 Dec 16 10.05am

Originally posted by Wisbech Eagle

I didn't think he should have been sacked at anytime. Selling various players wasn't always his choice. If they want to go, then go they will.

We have obviously had a terrible run of results but there are many reasons for it. Pardew tried to alter the system because he felt it had become too predictable and teams were picking us off. Losing Bolasie made that even more necessary. We have suffered particularly damaging injuries to key players, as well as a loss of form from others. Neither was Pardew's fault. He had obviously decided that, in the short term at least, he needed to revert to a more rugged, less expansive, style, and it seemed to be paying dividends with a result against Southampton, and decent performances against Man U and Chelsea.

We obviously needed a shake up defensively, either with new coaching or personnel, but changing the guy at the top seems a big step to me, and probably a step backwards.

I worry that this step has been forced by the Americans and was not wanted by Parish who wanted, as I did, to close ranks and fight our way through. Allardyce is reported to have made an effective job application, backed up with a statistical dossier of where we were going wrong, a month or so ago and sent this to our "investors". If true, and it is them who has forced the issue, then does this mean that the way the club is run has changed for ever? We all thought that Steve Parish was the one who made the decisions but maybe that isn't true anymore.


I think you have an overly-rosy view of Pardew and rampant paranoia with respect to the US investors

Parish is his own man and won't do anything he doesn't think is best for the club. He's definitely no one's puppet.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Painter Flag Croydon 23 Dec 16 10.08am

When he insulted the Yanks, his days were numbered. He had lost the plot with bizarre substitutions.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > At what point did you initially think it's time ..