You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke to be sold
November 16 2026 10.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Benteke to be sold


Page 1 of 12 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
essetwentyone Flag london 10 Jan 17 11.40pm

According to the Mirror, Big Sam will sell Benteke and use the money to strengthen the squad. I suppose he has to say that it's a reluctant sale to get the best price but he obviously doesn't fancy him and I think he's spot on. Benteke is too lazy for a relegation fight and will only cost us more points than he already has.
Big Sam should be applauded for having the guts to do this and undo Pardews folly.

 

Mstrobez Flag 10 Jan 17 11.56pm

Looks to me, after reading the article that big Sams leaked this to the press to basically send a message to SP saying he doesn't have enough money. Clearly states it's to free up funds in the article, seems all abbit odd

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 10 Jan 17 11.57pm

Probably bullsh1t but would be good if we could get two strikers instead for same money. Possible but in this window unlikely.
He may improve as the team get fitter he did well last season.

Edited by palacer (10 Jan 2017 11.58pm)

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 10 Jan 17 11.57pm

If we can get between us 40 and 50 million then sell him. If we go down he'll leave anyway. Reinforcing now makes sense as we can attract better players than if we hAve just dropped.

 

xomnea Flag 10 Jan 17 11.59pm

I can't see this happening but I think it would be a marvellous piece of business if we could get our money back on him.
I started a thread criticising his movement over a month ago which I got absolutely shot down for, he's done nothing since then to change my opinion.
Good touch and if the ball is played to his feet/head I feel reasonably confident he might score, however his anticipation, movement, work rate etc is dreadful.
No idea who we'd replace him with but if big Sam has got signings in mind I'm all for it.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Jan 17 12.03am

Absolute tosh.

The guy's one of if not the best strikers we've ever had at Selhurst. Strong, powerful, incredible in the air, good feet....can't believe people are saying get rid after one missed penalty and a couple of sub-bar performances. He's not exactly getting stellar service, is he?

 

wrightandbright Flag reigate 11 Jan 17 12.11am

hope he doesn't want andy carroll

 

chateauferret Flag 11 Jan 17 12.18am

Bonkers. Even if it made economical sense, which in a winter window for a club under pressure is hardly likely, it doesn't make practical sense because you'd never get the deals done in time without spending so much that the numbers wouldn't add up. And where would he go? He couldn't get regular starts in a club above us, he wouldn't want to go down to the Championship and nobody abroad would pay the sums required.

And I can't think of anyone available for say £15m who's more likely to score goals than he is.

Must be some sort of psychological legerdemain. I hope.

 


============
The Ferret
============

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 11 Jan 17 12.18am

Originally posted by sprites

Absolute tosh.

The guy's one of if not the best strikers we've ever had at Selhurst. Strong, powerful, incredible in the air, good feet....can't believe people are saying get rid after one missed penalty and a couple of sub-bar performances. He's not exactly getting stellar service, is he?

basically agree with your rating of his abilities, but for £32mil a player should not have to rely quite so much on the team around him, he should be initiating and creating attacks or at the very least taking penalties at least as well as Andy Johnson not worse than Jim Cannon.

 

xomnea Flag 11 Jan 17 12.21am

Originally posted by sprites

Absolute tosh.

The guy's one of if not the best strikers we've ever had at Selhurst. Strong, powerful, incredible in the air, good feet....can't believe people are saying get rid after one missed penalty and a couple of sub-bar performances. He's not exactly getting stellar service, is he?

Think it's 2 missed penalties and about 10-15 sub-par performances. I was as excited as the next fan when we signed him and think he could still come good, but just watch him. He never gets on the end of anything and is often in a different post code when we're attacking. He's shown flashes, but for the money, we need more than flashes.

 

pax3908 Flag 11 Jan 17 12.37am

Originally posted by chateauferret

Bonkers. Even if it made economical sense, which in a winter window for a club under pressure is hardly likely, it doesn't make practical sense because you'd never get the deals done in time without spending so much that the numbers wouldn't add up. And where would he go? He couldn't get regular starts in a club above us, he wouldn't want to go down to the Championship and nobody abroad would pay the sums required.

And I can't think of anyone available for say £15m who's more likely to score goals than he is.

Must be some sort of psychological legerdemain. I hope.

Defoe!!

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 11 Jan 17 1.13am

Originally posted by CPFC1965

If we can get between us 40 and 50 million then sell him. If we go down he'll leave anyway. Reinforcing now makes sense as we can attract better players than if we hAve just dropped.

Huh ??

We will be lucky to get 25 million tops

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 11 Jan 17 1.15am

I had so many arguments on here that Wickham was just as good if not better than Benteke and the more I see of him the more Im convinced I was spot on

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Jan 17 1.30am

Originally posted by pax3908

Defoe!!

No point. Had someone in same mold - Gayle - never used him. Need a big fella.

 

sprites Flag Auckland 11 Jan 17 1.33am

Originally posted by xomnea

Think it's 2 missed penalties and about 10-15 sub-par performances. I was as excited as the next fan when we signed him and think he could still come good, but just watch him. He never gets on the end of anything and is often in a different post code when we're attacking. He's shown flashes, but for the money, we need more than flashes.

Well he absolutely banged in the goals for Villa...had a decent goal/mins ration for Liverpool and is a Belgium international. So unless class and ability disappears overnight, I just don't think the issues lie with him.

10 - 15 sub par performances? We've only played about that many bloody games so far...Sam will get the best out of him. Give him a chance.

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 11 Jan 17 1.51am

Originally posted by essetwentyone

According to the Mirror, Big Sam will sell Benteke and use the money to strengthen the squad. I suppose he has to say that it's a reluctant sale to get the best price but he obviously doesn't fancy him and I think he's spot on. Benteke is too lazy for a relegation fight and will only cost us more points than he already has.
Big Sam should be applauded for having the guts to do this and undo Pardews folly.

Sorry but "according to the Mirror* in January really does mean jack s***.
Journos will pick every teams star players to get those fans attention. ie. Deli Ali wanted by R. Madrid , Courtinhio to Barcelona , Defoe wanted everywhere etc etc.so and so to china... Personally I think Wilf. Jimmy Mac and Benteke are the only 3 players we cannot afford to lose...which is sad really as it should be more.... Anyway its bulls*** ...sell Benteke and whats left ... Frazier Campbell , Remy and Wickham on crutches

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 11 Jan 17 5.25am

Originally posted by xomnea

I can't see this happening but I think it would be a marvellous piece of business if we could get our money back on him.
I started a thread criticising his movement over a month ago which I got absolutely shot down for, he's done nothing since then to change my opinion.
Good touch and if the ball is played to his feet/head I feel reasonably confident he might score, however his anticipation, movement, work rate etc is dreadful.
No idea who we'd replace him with but if big Sam has got signings in mind I'm all for it.

[Link]

What happened to the £20m we were supposed to have anyway? It really has to be: in BFS we trust. I never thought I'd say that!

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 11 Jan 17 6.44am

I don't get why we never play through balls for him. I don't think I've seen is try one in spite of him clearly pointing where he wants it played and there being a gap. I don't think I've seen us play a through ball since AJ left

 

BelfastEagle Flag 11 Jan 17 6.59am

Seems to make sense. ....make it so.

 

big stu Flag milton keynes 11 Jan 17 7.07am

I really think that Bentekkers will come good...BFS likes to play with 2 up top and we do have a dream team in Remy and Bentekkers (if remy can stay fit). BFS has alot more passion that pards and tends to get the best out of whatever team he goes to. we have a fit team for saturday , the players have had a rest as it seems pards played the same 11 for so long without really rotating...so if we win on saturday then its onwards and upwards, if we lose...NEXT EXCUSE

but what ever happens ill still be a palace fan regardless

COYP

 

Page 1 of 12 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Benteke to be sold