You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dear Sam
November 16 2026 10.25am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Dear Sam


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
CPFC1971 Flag 13 Feb 17 4.51pm

Dear Sam,
I’ve been a Palace Fan for 40 years and I’d like to help you keep our team in the Premier League.
I’ve never played football professionally, but I was on the club’s books during the mid-1980s in their School of Excellence, before playing non-league football for a number of local teams. At best I was average, but I do think I can read a game of football and its amazing how obvious things seem when looking down on the pitch from high up, rather than pitch side.

It seems to me that Alan Pardew over complicated matters and asked players to do things that they were not capable of achieving, as well as playing players out of position. He was also unable to see that Wayne Hennessey is not good enough to keep us in the league. One or two worldy saves every 3rd game does not make up for his lack of command in the box and his inability to read the game that is going on in front of him. It’s clear to me that the defence do not trust him. Please do not fall into the same trap as AP.

Here’s some other simple ideas to consider:

Play Julian Speroni until Steve Mandanda is fit (at least the crowd would be on board and Jules couldn’t be any worse than WH).

Play James McArthur alongside Yohan Cabaye or Luka Milivojevic. He is our most hardworking midfield player and makes the side tick by keeping the ball moving. He should not be played as our most advanced midfielder.

If you are going to play Jason Puncheon, then play him in further forward. Do not ask him to be a defensive midfielder because he cannot defend and you lose the one thing he is good at - his creativity.

Do not ask Wilfried Zaha to tuck in near Benteke, he needs space to play in. Every time Holloway and Pardew asked Bolasie and him to play more centrally, with the full backs providing the width, they were totally ineffective. Wilf frightens the opposition if played wide isolating a full back. Ask yourself if the opposition would be as concerned knowing the width is being provided by Joel Ward?

Perhaps allow Wilf and Andros / Schlupp to swap wings from time to time. Mix it up.

Benteke appears lazy, mainly because he is unable to anticipate and always look a yard slower in his thought processes than his marker, however he is remains a goal threat so play to his strengths, with genuine width and perhaps with Remy up top alongside him.

Please abandon 3/5 at the back as soon as possible. Milk turns faster than Dann, Delaney and Tomkins, hence CPFC 0-4 Sunderland.

Prior to your arrival, we were leaking goals due to having no left back, an inept goal keeper and no shield in front of back four. It looks like you have tried to address this with your signings, I hope they work out.

Keep things simple, our players do not appear to be the sharpest.

Find the players in training that are going to roll their sleeves up, they are the ones that will get us out of this mess.

Here are some suggested formations for you – a plan A, B & C if you like.

4-2-3-1
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Milivojevic, McArthur / Cabaye
Zaha, Puncheon / Cabaye, Townsend / Schlupp
Benteke / Remy

4-4-2
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Zaha, Milivojevic, McArthur / Cabaye, Puncheon /Schlupp / Townsend
Benteke, Remy

4-3-3
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Milivojevic, McArthur, Cabaye
Zaha, Benteke, Townsend / Schlupp

Don’t over complicate, defend together, attack together and show some f#cking b#ll#cks when the going gets tough.

If we, the fans see that, then that’s all we can ask for.

Good luck with that.

CPFC1971.

 

nairb75 Flag Baltimore 13 Feb 17 5.38pm

i think i agree with all of that. well stated.

 

gerry theagle Flag newbury 13 Feb 17 5.44pm

Hope not,but you could be in for a job come next season.Good post and hope SA reads it,lot of sense in the contents.

 

regal_eagle Flag somewhere 13 Feb 17 5.45pm

Dear CPFC1971,

Good post.
That is all.

Regal.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 13 Feb 17 7.10pm

I can tell why you never made it , I think Sam will be just fine without your advice , as for the players , thats something else .
If whatever eleven we put out is not better than the bottom 4 thats already down there then we deserve to go down
Simple .

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 13 Feb 17 7.31pm

I can also agreed with most of that especially the 3 / 5 at the back initially I was thinking great that should stand firm but disaster or what. Remy is starting to look a bit sharper we need someone nearer to Benteke two up front possibly. And Wilf is being marked out of the game by two or three defenders Andros must step it up, and draw players away or hope PVA/ Schlupp can overlap sometimes.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 13 Feb 17 8.34pm

Don't think Sam will read the OP.
Talk about don't over complicate.
Pardew wanted to replace Wayne hence the signing of Steeeve.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

essetwentyone Flag london 13 Feb 17 8.50pm

Good post.
I know loads of fans who are of the same opinion.
My concern is that Sam hasn't seen the light as shown by the team selection for the Stoke game. Let's hope he realises and shakes it up for the Boro game.

 

palacer Flag Crystal Palace 13 Feb 17 9.07pm

Originally posted by Croydonlad

I can tell why you never made it , I think Sam will be just fine without your advice , as for the players , thats something else .
If whatever eleven we put out is not better than the bottom 4 thats already down there then we deserve to go down
Simple .

I think a team doesn't have to be better they need to have more fight and determination to win. Lots of good teams go down and s*** ones stay up. We need to find our fight.

 


People standing in the rain just to see their dream again. The Damned

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 13 Feb 17 9.29pm

Agree with 99% of what the OP says.
Puncheon should only now be a squad player used on the wing occasionally IMO and Remy needs to come in and be given a go at 10.

MacArthur and the new bloke hopefully would offer plenty of protection to the back four.

Cabaye has quality but starting to look a bit brittle.

 

Asian Eagle Flag Cebu City 13 Feb 17 9.38pm

Yeah you are damned right.I have played a lot also and I can see you know a bit about this.

Originally posted by CPFC1971

Dear Sam,
I’ve been a Palace Fan for 40 years and I’d like to help you keep our team in the Premier League.
I’ve never played football professionally, but I was on the club’s books during the mid-1980s in their School of Excellence, before playing non-league football for a number of local teams. At best I was average, but I do think I can read a game of football and its amazing how obvious things seem when looking down on the pitch from high up, rather than pitch side.

It seems to me that Alan Pardew over complicated matters and asked players to do things that they were not capable of achieving, as well as playing players out of position. He was also unable to see that Wayne Hennessey is not good enough to keep us in the league. One or two worldy saves every 3rd game does not make up for his lack of command in the box and his inability to read the game that is going on in front of him. It’s clear to me that the defence do not trust him. Please do not fall into the same trap as AP.

Here’s some other simple ideas to consider:

Play Julian Speroni until Steve Mandanda is fit (at least the crowd would be on board and Jules couldn’t be any worse than WH).

Play James McArthur alongside Yohan Cabaye or Luka Milivojevic. He is our most hardworking midfield player and makes the side tick by keeping the ball moving. He should not be played as our most advanced midfielder.

If you are going to play Jason Puncheon, then play him in further forward. Do not ask him to be a defensive midfielder because he cannot defend and you lose the one thing he is good at - his creativity.

Do not ask Wilfried Zaha to tuck in near Benteke, he needs space to play in. Every time Holloway and Pardew asked Bolasie and him to play more centrally, with the full backs providing the width, they were totally ineffective. Wilf frightens the opposition if played wide isolating a full back. Ask yourself if the opposition would be as concerned knowing the width is being provided by Joel Ward?

Perhaps allow Wilf and Andros / Schlupp to swap wings from time to time. Mix it up.

Benteke appears lazy, mainly because he is unable to anticipate and always look a yard slower in his thought processes than his marker, however he is remains a goal threat so play to his strengths, with genuine width and perhaps with Remy up top alongside him.

Please abandon 3/5 at the back as soon as possible. Milk turns faster than Dann, Delaney and Tomkins, hence CPFC 0-4 Sunderland.

Prior to your arrival, we were leaking goals due to having no left back, an inept goal keeper and no shield in front of back four. It looks like you have tried to address this with your signings, I hope they work out.

Keep things simple, our players do not appear to be the sharpest.

Find the players in training that are going to roll their sleeves up, they are the ones that will get us out of this mess.

Here are some suggested formations for you – a plan A, B & C if you like.

4-2-3-1
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Milivojevic, McArthur / Cabaye
Zaha, Puncheon / Cabaye, Townsend / Schlupp
Benteke / Remy

4-4-2
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Zaha, Milivojevic, McArthur / Cabaye, Puncheon /Schlupp / Townsend
Benteke, Remy

4-3-3
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Milivojevic, McArthur, Cabaye
Zaha, Benteke, Townsend / Schlupp

Don’t over complicate, defend together, attack together and show some f#cking b#ll#cks when the going gets tough.

If we, the fans see that, then that’s all we can ask for.

Good luck with that.

CPFC1971.

 

Isley46 Flag Sanderstead 13 Feb 17 9.41pm

And can you stop the ground staff watering of the pitch just before kick off and at half time? Our players are not good at first touch control and the ball skidding off the wet turf doesn't do us any favours - just gives the opposition a chance to cut in when we fail to get it under control with the first touch.

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 13 Feb 17 10.07pm

Originally posted by essetwentyone

Good post.
I know loads of fans who are of the same opinion.
My concern is that Sam hasn't seen the light as shown by the team selection for the Stoke game. Let's hope he realises and shakes it up for the Boro game.

Shakes it up ?
What would your team be ?

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 13 Feb 17 10.11pm

Good observation...
I really don't think we have the type of midfield players to play the SA way...
Cabaye,Punch and McArthur used to play keep ball...little give and go's , one twos, really pleasing on the eye ...that's when we would dominate teams...didn't necessarily get the right result , but we looked good..
We just don't have the huge athletic powerfull players that SA likes....I know he wouldn't sign any of our midfield players if he were at another club...
A lot of people expressed worry over SA appointment...I did...i felt Pardew had assembled a squad that was designed for more possession football...not letting teams come on to you ...sit back, then counter attack at pace ...i.e. the Palace of the season before ...we went possession style this season because we couldn't unlock the door at home the season before..... now we seem just a confused team...
Let's hope perhaps a compromise in playing style can be sort...

 

Hutchyeagle Flag Hove 13 Feb 17 10.22pm

Originally posted by Hutchyeagle

Good observation...
I really don't think we have the type of midfield players to play the SA way...
Cabaye,Punch and McArthur used to play keep ball...little give and go's , one twos, really pleasing on the eye ...that's when we would dominate teams...didn't necessarily get the right result , but we looked good..
We just don't have the huge athletic powerfull players that SA likes....I know he wouldn't sign any of our midfield players if he were at another club...
A lot of people expressed worry over SA appointment...I did...i felt Pardew had assembled a squad that was designed for more possession football...not letting teams come on to you ...sit back, then counter attack at pace ...i.e. the Palace of the season before ...we went possession style this season because we couldn't unlock the door at home the season before..... now we seem just a confused team...
Let's hope perhaps a compromise in playing style can be found

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 14 Feb 17 1.29pm

Originally posted by CPFC1971

Dear Sam,
I’ve been a Palace Fan for 40 years and I’d like to help you keep our team in the Premier League.
I’ve never played football professionally, but I was on the club’s books during the mid-1980s in their School of Excellence, before playing non-league football for a number of local teams. At best I was average, but I do think I can read a game of football and its amazing how obvious things seem when looking down on the pitch from high up, rather than pitch side.

It seems to me that Alan Pardew over complicated matters and asked players to do things that they were not capable of achieving, as well as playing players out of position. He was also unable to see that Wayne Hennessey is not good enough to keep us in the league. One or two worldy saves every 3rd game does not make up for his lack of command in the box and his inability to read the game that is going on in front of him. It’s clear to me that the defence do not trust him. Please do not fall into the same trap as AP.

Here’s some other simple ideas to consider:

Play Julian Speroni until Steve Mandanda is fit (at least the crowd would be on board and Jules couldn’t be any worse than WH).

Play James McArthur alongside Yohan Cabaye or Luka Milivojevic. He is our most hardworking midfield player and makes the side tick by keeping the ball moving. He should not be played as our most advanced midfielder.

If you are going to play Jason Puncheon, then play him in further forward. Do not ask him to be a defensive midfielder because he cannot defend and you lose the one thing he is good at - his creativity.

Do not ask Wilfried Zaha to tuck in near Benteke, he needs space to play in. Every time Holloway and Pardew asked Bolasie and him to play more centrally, with the full backs providing the width, they were totally ineffective. Wilf frightens the opposition if played wide isolating a full back. Ask yourself if the opposition would be as concerned knowing the width is being provided by Joel Ward?

Perhaps allow Wilf and Andros / Schlupp to swap wings from time to time. Mix it up.

Benteke appears lazy, mainly because he is unable to anticipate and always look a yard slower in his thought processes than his marker, however he is remains a goal threat so play to his strengths, with genuine width and perhaps with Remy up top alongside him.

Please abandon 3/5 at the back as soon as possible. Milk turns faster than Dann, Delaney and Tomkins, hence CPFC 0-4 Sunderland.

Prior to your arrival, we were leaking goals due to having no left back, an inept goal keeper and no shield in front of back four. It looks like you have tried to address this with your signings, I hope they work out.

Keep things simple, our players do not appear to be the sharpest.

Find the players in training that are going to roll their sleeves up, they are the ones that will get us out of this mess.

Here are some suggested formations for you – a plan A, B & C if you like.

4-2-3-1
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Milivojevic, McArthur / Cabaye
Zaha, Puncheon / Cabaye, Townsend / Schlupp
Benteke / Remy

4-4-2
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Zaha, Milivojevic, McArthur / Cabaye, Puncheon /Schlupp / Townsend
Benteke, Remy

4-3-3
Speroni / Mandanda
Ward / Tomkins, Dann, Sakho, Schlupp / Van Aanholt
Milivojevic, McArthur, Cabaye
Zaha, Benteke, Townsend / Schlupp

Don’t over complicate, defend together, attack together and show some f#cking b#ll#cks when the going gets tough.

If we, the fans see that, then that’s all we can ask for.

Good luck with that.

CPFC1971.

Well said, exactly my thoughts. So obvious isn't it, not bloody rocket science!

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 14 Feb 17 2.15pm

Can we replace Sam with CPFC1971 the man knows what he is talking about

 

Jamesey Flag Wandsworth 14 Feb 17 3.18pm

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Can we replace Sam with CPFC1971 the man knows what he is talking about

Indeed why are we wasting millions on an experienced ex-pro player and long-time Prem manager when we could do it ourselves through the HOL on line? :-)

 


Nothing is fool-proof - fools are too ingenious

slubglurge Flag welling 14 Feb 17 6.58pm

What i would ask him to do is drop Puncheon. He slows our game down with all these needless 360° turns plus the number 10 should carry a goal threat and he has not scored a single goal all season. I would play Remy or Townsend in that role

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 14 Feb 17 8.13pm

Originally posted by slubglurge

What i would ask him to do is drop Puncheon. He slows our game down with all these needless 360° turns plus the number 10 should carry a goal threat and he has not scored a single goal all season. I would play Remy or Townsend in that role

Puncheon has been playing deeper than you would be suggesting and I haven't seen an out and out attacking central midfielder play (or a 'number 10' in modern speak) at Palace since .......er it was some time ago

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Dear Sam