You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > League or Cup?
November 16 2026 9.55am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

League or Cup?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Beastie Flag 24 Apr 17 3.19pm

I believe in the magic of the cup. When I’m on my deathbed, I’d like to look back at the day Palace lifted a major trophy. Remembering that good run in the premier league might not cut it.

But what the people want is Premier League status. Is there anyone who would swap the current revival if it meant that Puncheon goal had won us the FA Cup last May?

 

cpking191 Flag Georgia 24 Apr 17 3.23pm

It's a tough question. On the one hand, winning the Cup would have been fantastic, but probably wouldn't have meant much for improving a competing in the future if we hadn't turned it around and stayed up this season. I think staying in the top flight next year will do more to continue strengthening the squad for future and possibly contend for more silverware in the coming years, so no, I would not swap.

 


"Here's Gayle! IT'S THREE - THREE! ASTONISHING!"

glaziermart Flag 24 Apr 17 3.36pm

It is a balancing act. If we had won the FA Cup last season, we would not have had the squad at the beginning of this season to cope with the Europa League and with Pardew making a mess of things, we could have been in an even worse position by Christmas. At the end of the day, all that really matters is the 140 Million you get for staying in the Premier League. In the long term we could end up winning Cups on a fairly regular basis by staying in the Premier, who knows, because of the vast riches on offer

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 24 Apr 17 3.39pm

Well we made the final last season, and it had absolutely no impact on our league form which was s**t.

Have a crack at doing our best in both maybe. Put out the strongest side in the FA cup.

League cup - no one gives a f** about that unless they reach the quarter finals, then they start giving a f**k.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 24 Apr 17 3.39pm

Originally posted by Beastie

I believe in the magic of the cup. When I’m on my deathbed, I’d like to look back at the day Palace lifted a major trophy. Remembering that good run in the premier league might not cut it.

But what the people want is Premier League status. Is there anyone who would swap the current revival if it meant that Puncheon goal had won us the FA Cup last May?

Its a good question - would probably agree with you.
Things could be much worse though - we could have lost the final and gone down this year. All the time we are the the top flight we have the money to potentially win the cup another year.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Username Flag Horsham 24 Apr 17 3.39pm

I find it hard to see how I could have a better day out as a Palace fan than if we'd won the FA Cup last season, especially beating Utd. Hell, even though we didn't win it, I had a brilliant day out with my Dad at Wembley, and I even look back on the post-game pint near London Bridge with a bit of fondness.

Yes, we can strengthen the squad and it would have been a big blow to get relegated. However, that strengthening of the squad would surely be so we could compete in the cup competitions anyway. We might have an outside chance of sneaking a Europa League place, but our most realistic chance of success and getting in to Europe is the cups isn't it?

In which case, I'd find it hard to trade away winning the thing for the chance to maybe win the thing with some different players and a better manager in the future.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Part Time James Flag 24 Apr 17 3.40pm

The question was asked last year "win the cup at the cost of the league?"

Well in the end we didn't win the cup and we played like a bunch of divs in the league for several months afterwards.

I was salivating about the cup but frankly now I'd be happy to go out in round three every year if we can make progress in the league and improve our infrastructure along the way.

Edited by Part Time James (24 Apr 2017 3.41pm)

 




Username Flag Horsham 24 Apr 17 3.40pm

Originally posted by jamiemartin721

Well we made the final last season, and it had absolutely no impact on our league form which was s**t.

Have a crack at doing our best in both maybe. Put out the strongest side in the FA cup.

League cup - no one gives a f** about that unless they reach the quarter finals, then they start giving a f**k.

Doesn't mean it's not worth going after it. It's winnable, but you generally still have to beat a decent team to do it so it's not worthless. It's a major trophy with European football on offer as well.

 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 24 Apr 17 3.54pm

Originally posted by Username

I find it hard to see how I could have a better day out as a Palace fan than if we'd won the FA Cup last season, especially beating Utd. Hell, even though we didn't win it, I had a brilliant day out with my Dad at Wembley, and I even look back on the post-game pint near London Bridge with a bit of fondness.

Yes, we can strengthen the squad and it would have been a big blow to get relegated. However, that strengthening of the squad would surely be so we could compete in the cup competitions anyway. We might have an outside chance of sneaking a Europa League place, but our most realistic chance of success and getting in to Europe is the cups isn't it?

In which case, I'd find it hard to trade away winning the thing for the chance to maybe win the thing with some different players and a better manager in the future.


Coventry City won the cup a while ago. Now? They're about to be relegated into League Two.

I'm no fan of how the Premier League seems to suck all the air (and money) out of the domestic game but, while it continues to do so, I want Palace to be part of it.

We have much more chance of winning a cup with a squad put together on the back of Premier League moolah, than do, say, Coventry, on the back of money-spinning away games at Cheltenham, Yeovil, Crawley and Morecambe.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Username Flag Horsham 24 Apr 17 4.02pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


Coventry City won the cup a while ago. Now? They're about to be relegated into League Two.

I'm no fan of how the Premier League seems to suck all the air (and money) out of the domestic game but, while it continues to do so, I want Palace to be part of it.

We have much more chance of winning a cup with a squad put together on the back of Premier League moolah, than do, say, Coventry, on the back of money-spinning away games at Cheltenham, Yeovil, Crawley and Morecambe.

That's why this particular question doesn't make much sense to me. You're turning down winning the cup for the chance to maybe win the cup?

Besides, Coventry is a pretty extreme example with far more complex matters linked to it. They were a top division side for 17 years after they won the cup!


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 24 Apr 17 4.25pm

Originally posted by Username

That's why this particular question doesn't make much sense to me. You're turning down winning the cup for the chance to maybe win the cup?

Besides, Coventry is a pretty extreme example with far more complex matters linked to it. They were a top division side for 17 years after they won the cup!

I am turning down winning the cup for the long-term greater good of the club of Premier League status. Had we won the cup but been relegated, which was your "Sophie's Choice" premise, then we'd have a shiny bit of silverware for a cabinet while the club was dumped back into the monkey s***-fight that is the Championship.

Think of all that could go wrong in that scenario: we lose a bunch of our best players - and probably the manager - as they trigger transfers to Premier League sides; we don't make it back before the parachute payments run out; we lose American investment as we're no longer on worldwide telly; we don't get the ground redeveloped and we're right back in an uncertain financial future.

How is any of that worth the fleeting kudos of the cup win that will bring with it the trials of Europa League fixtures on top of the clogged, leg-sapping Championship schedule?

You think Coventry is delving back too far? Ok, Wigan.

FA Cup winners and relegatees - and now about to drop into League One unless they can beat playoff contenders Reading and Leeds while 'Appy 'Arry coincidentally fails to get Birmingham a single point.

The club will not suffer long term effects for not having won the FA Cup. Relegation from the Premiership, at this point in our recovery from administration, is an existential crisis.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 24 Apr 17 4.31pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I am turning down winning the cup for the long-term greater good of the club of Premier League status. Had we won the cup but been relegated, which was your "Sophie's Choice" premise, then we'd have a shiny bit of silverware for a cabinet while the club was dumped back into the monkey s***-fight that is the Championship.

Think of all that could go wrong in that scenario: we lose a bunch of our best players - and probably the manager - as they trigger transfers to Premier League sides; we don't make it back before the parachute payments run out; we lose American investment as we're no longer on worldwide telly; we don't get the ground redeveloped and we're right back in an uncertain financial future.

How is any of that worth the fleeting kudos of the cup win that will bring with it the trials of Europa League fixtures on top of the clogged, leg-sapping Championship schedule?

You think Coventry is delving back too far? Ok, Wigan.

FA Cup winners and relegatees - and now about to drop into League One unless they can beat playoff contenders Reading and Leeds while 'Appy 'Arry coincidentally fails to get Birmingham a single point.

The club will not suffer long term effects for not having won the FA Cup. Relegation from the Premiership, at this point in our recovery from administration, is an existential crisis.

Well, that sums up exactly what I think and put much better than I could have done.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

HeathMan Flag Purley 24 Apr 17 4.41pm

I am hoping that Sam decides that he needs to prove his quality. We would have players queueing to wear the shirt following winning the two Cups and the Premier League. Cup runs do give a chance to give our youth a chance. COYP

 

Podyonkers Flag Atlanta, Georgia 24 Apr 17 4.44pm

Originally posted by Beastie

I believe in the magic of the cup. When I’m on my deathbed, I’d like to look back at the day Palace lifted a major trophy. Remembering that good run in the premier league might not cut it.

But what the people want is Premier League status. Is there anyone who would swap the current revival if it meant that Puncheon goal had won us the FA Cup last May?

The five-odd moments of sheer and utter joy I got when Punch scored was almost enough.

Over here in Atlanta, we had a brilliant group laughing, singing, crying and yelling at the Man. U. fans around us in the pub. We sang when we went ahead, and we sang harder when they equalised. We sang hardest when we lost, and especially when their fans abandoned the pub before even seeing their team awarded the trophy. Have been Palace through and through all my life - born there, seen all those games through thick and thin over so many years... but our Cup Final was one of my favourite days of my life.

So no, would not swap. Because while winning would have been nice it was being a Palace fan in a pub 2000 miles away that meant everything to me.

 


Stealing their women and eating their food since 1987.

Beastie Flag 24 Apr 17 4.48pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston

I am turning down winning the cup for the long-term greater good of the club of Premier League status. Had we won the cup but been relegated, which was your "Sophie's Choice" premise, then we'd have a shiny bit of silverware for a cabinet while the club was dumped back into the monkey s***-fight that is the Championship.

Think of all that could go wrong in that scenario: we lose a bunch of our best players - and probably the manager - as they trigger transfers to Premier League sides; we don't make it back before the parachute payments run out; we lose American investment as we're no longer on worldwide telly; we don't get the ground redeveloped and we're right back in an uncertain financial future.

How is any of that worth the fleeting kudos of the cup win that will bring with it the trials of Europa League fixtures on top of the clogged, leg-sapping Championship schedule?

You think Coventry is delving back too far? Ok, Wigan.

FA Cup winners and relegatees - and now about to drop into League One unless they can beat playoff contenders Reading and Leeds while 'Appy 'Arry coincidentally fails to get Birmingham a single point.

The club will not suffer long term effects for not having won the FA Cup. Relegation from the Premiership, at this point in our recovery from administration, is an existential crisis.

I don’t think ‘which competition is more financially rewarding?’ is really the question.

I like to think as fans, we might view the game with a bit more romance than that.

 

Mad4palace Flag 24 Apr 17 4.50pm

Well put it this way:

Season on season in the prem and you're going to be in a decent position to have a good run at the cup every year, so I think our chances of reaching at least the quarters or Semi's in the next 4 years or so is pretty good, hopefully on current trajectory we can get some silverware in the next 6 years or so.

But if you were to give me the option that we'd either win the FA Cup last year but get relegated or that we have a good spell in the PL now for 15-20 years but I'd die not having seen us win anything, then I'd pick the first option every time.

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 24 Apr 17 5.10pm

Originally posted by Beastie

I don’t think ‘which competition is more financially rewarding?’ is really the question.

I like to think as fans, we might view the game with a bit more romance than that.


Trust me, I am not poo-pooing the romance of the cup. I was at the campaign in 1989/90, including the semi and both finals. It was glorious (well, except for the final replay).

But cpking gave us a theoretical choice: win the cup and go down, or lose the cup and stay up. Of course I'd rather win and stay up but, with those choices only, I choose lose the cup and stay up every single time.

And, in actuality, the cup run glossed over Pardew's utter failings as a coach and left us in the mess from which Big Sam has extricated us. So, in a way, the romance of the cup almost lead directly to our relegation from the Premier League and all the horrors that could have ensued thereafter.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 24 Apr 17 5.17pm

League all day everyday. Give the cup a bash but not at any expense in the league. Winning cup games gives no confidence boost to league games and a cup run is likely to loose focus. Do it when we have a squad big enough to dabble in cup games, for now concentrate on the bread and butter.

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 24 Apr 17 5.25pm

Originally posted by Beastie

I believe in the magic of the cup. When I’m on my deathbed, I’d like to look back at the day Palace lifted a major trophy. Remembering that good run in the premier league might not cut it.

But what the people want is Premier League status. Is there anyone who would swap the current revival if it meant that Puncheon goal had won us the FA Cup last May?

Yes I would. I may be in a minority, but I would love us to win a trophy before I peg it. I quite enjoyed being a yo-yo club in the past, although I do appreciate there is no guarantee to bounce straight back.

 

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 6.30pm

Originally posted by Andy_G

League all day everyday. Give the cup a bash but not at any expense in the league. Winning cup games gives no confidence boost to league games and a cup run is likely to loose focus. Do it when we have a squad big enough to dabble in cup games, for now concentrate on the bread and butter.

The premise of the question ignores the luck of the draw. One might do an Arsenal and get lower league and non-league opposition until the Sixth Round. OTOH you might be like us last season and get to the final having to beat other Premier League teams in every round.

Although it would have saved us some effort having to play Citeh and lose, who would have been happy getting knocked out by notloB? Not I.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > League or Cup?