You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain Puncheon
November 16 2026 9.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Captain Puncheon


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Shortbutts Flag Birmingham 24 Apr 17 6.27pm

I was surprised when Puncheon was made Captain - but what a revelation. I think General Puncheon would be more appropriate.

He is vocal, cajoles the team and is leading by example - although admittedly still does not have his shooting legs. I am convinced that this has contributed to our improvement in form.

 

chateauferret Flag 24 Apr 17 6.39pm

I think his confidence was suffering from not scoring goals but he sees that he has something else important to contribute that we've been missing ever since Pardew showed Jedinak the door.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Ricaldos Flag Exeter 24 Apr 17 7.27pm

Totally agree,and I hope the tag of 'General Puncheon' sticks

 

streathameagles Flag Streatham - Palace territory 24 Apr 17 7.47pm

Before his inauguration as captain, I lost track of the number of times I berated him for losing possession cheaply and playing the wrong pass. He just looked increasingly out of his depth at this level.

Since being made captain he looks a totally different player. Smart, composed, reliable, consistently excellent. Kudos to him first of all, but also to Big Sam for having the emotional intelligence to realise the positive effect that captaincy would have on him.

 


I post when I'm pissed
I post when I'm piiiiiiiiiised
I'm streathameagles
I post when I'm pissed

Glazier#1 Flag 24 Apr 17 8.42pm

And doesn't he jump high?

Is it my imagination, or does he continually win arial balls when he competes for them? He's not the tallest, is he but he consistently wins these challenges.

Anyone else noticed?

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 27 Apr 17 7.57pm

Excellent against Liverpool. That said against spurs look slow in possession. Is puncheon undroppable now his captain?

 

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Apr 17 8.10pm

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

Excellent against Liverpool. That said against spurs look slow in possession. Is puncheon undroppable now his captain?

I'm not a Puncheon fan, has done well as captain, but a number 10 should be getting 6-10 goals a season, I think he's on none.
Think we need to upgrade in the summer, but thought he was decent yesterday.

 

Jamesrichards8 Flag 27 Apr 17 8.11pm

Puncheon has been consistently rated by every manager we've had since Holloway. Must say something about his attitude and also skill level. I think he's a better player than some on here give him credit for being

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

Casual Flag Orpington 27 Apr 17 8.21pm

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Puncheon has been consistently rated by every manager we've had since Holloway. Must say something about his attitude and also skill level. I think he's a better player than some on here give him credit for being

I think every Palace player is better than some on here give them credit for . Also worse than some on here give them credit for. I think that's because there's loads of people on here with different opinions.

 

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 28 Apr 17 2.24am

It's all part of the finished puzzle.

Sure, some don't rate him, some wouldn't pick him - good thing BS has the brains and knowledge - as with him as capt we have gone on our best run that has almost single handedly kept us up.

But sure, replace him in the summer.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Noz Flag North Hampshire 28 Apr 17 8.19am

Apparently he has the most shots in the premier league without scoring this season. Quite an accolade!

 

leejaneagles Flag 28 Apr 17 8.52am

He has been good overall since being made Captain but I think it's an odd time to start this thread after a shocker against Tottenham.

He seemed to think he needed to be more than he is on Wednesday, trying first time clipped passes, or if there was a winger open on the left he'd fool the Tottenham players by playing it right...only to fool his team mates as well and turn over possession.

He's giving his all the last few seasons and I for one will be cheering him on as our Captain for the next 4 matches but I wouldn't be happy to see him starting in this important and seemingly undroppable role next season.

I believe he has 0 assists and 0 goals, that's near impossible for someone in his position. He moved around the midfield a bit under Pardew but under Sam he has only been a number 10 and stayed behind the striker, I don't see how he can't have scored or assisted Benteke by now.

If you look at time spent at number 10 by both Puncheon and McCarthur, I'm sure McCarthur has been a lot more effective, thinking back to things like his goal against Man Utd, you just don't see Puncheon end up in those positions but it seems to come naturally to Jimmy Mac and he's definitely not an out and out number 10 either.

Next season if we have Luka breaking up play and Cabaye doing a combination of breaking up play and setting up play, there's going to be no need for a solid all-rounder like Puncheon, instead we can get someone that might not track back as much or as someone else mentioned, win as many aerial balls as Punch but scores and assists a lot more and that's all he brings to the table.

 

chateauferret Flag 28 Apr 17 10.17am

I'm pretty sure Sam has more he can do with this player yet. Sam's still only been working with a team comprising players who were badly broken plus four new acquisitions for about three months yet.

Puncheon's looked to me a bit like a general dogsbody doing whatever comes up in the middle of the pitch but not being clear on what is actual job is, oh and often ending up playing too deep (which would explain the lack of goals a bit). Being captain has given him more focus and contributed something that was badly lacking, and we now look more robust as a team. I still don't think we're making the most of his technical capabilities, but it's a refreshing change that Sam is addressing character, psychology and personalities, matters to which Pardew paid no attention whatsoever.

 


============
The Ferret
============

We are goin up! Flag Coulsdon 28 Apr 17 10.28am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

Puncheon has been consistently rated by every manager we've had since Holloway. Must say something about his attitude and also skill level. I think he's a better player than some on here give him credit for being

Yep he's actually decent in the air. Unlike Wilf, who I can only ever remember heading the ball once (wasn't bad timing to do it in a play-off semi-final to be fair) despite being 6ft+

 


The problem with socialism is that you eventually run out of other people's money.

Holmesdale 1989 Flag 29 Apr 17 12.09am

Love Punch

 

tpuffpendants Flag 29 Apr 17 3.39am

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Yep he's actually decent in the air. Unlike Wilf, who I can only ever remember heading the ball once (wasn't bad timing to do it in a play-off semi-final to be fair) despite being 6ft+

Zaha's 5' 11", and yes def. known as a player with no heading prowess- usually sending in crosses rather than receiving them

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 29 Apr 17 7.17am

It's an amazing stat that puncheon featured in every cpfc win since promotion. However his contribution as a player 0 goals and a few assists is not good enough to warrant an instant pick due to his captaincy. We bought puncheon as a winger. So for me his a failed winger. Just like when we signed mark Kennedy

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 29 Apr 17 8.44am

Originally posted by GladAllOver27

We bought puncheon as a winger. So for me his a failed winger. Just like when we signed mark Kennedy

Chelsea bought Victor Moses as a winger so do you see him as a failure too?

 

GladAllOver27 Flag 29 Apr 17 10.31am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Chelsea bought Victor Moses as a winger so do you see him as a failure too?

Obviously you don't understand. Puncheon playing in the centre of midfield because he legs are gone. He's been great for Palace since promotion however we need an upgrade.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 29 Apr 17 10.40am

Originally posted by We are goin up!

Yep he's actually decent in the air. Unlike Wilf, who I can only ever remember heading the ball once (wasn't bad timing to do it in a play-off semi-final to be fair) despite being 6ft+

I seem to remember a beautiful header he scored a few seasons back, errrr think it was somewhere down the south coast area, mmmmm

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Captain Puncheon