You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > hmrc
November 22 2026 12.22am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

hmrc


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 26 Apr 17 10.35am

See that HMRC have raided and made several arrests at West Ham and Newcastle and over 180 HMRC officers are involoved. All to do with Tax and National Insurance fraud. Have often wondered how footballers are deemed Self Employed when their salary is paid by the same company each month. I worked in sales years ago and was self employed but the tax man put a stop to it as i was paid by one company all the time. Whats the difference? same with actors on soaps.

 

DanH Flag SW2 26 Apr 17 10.40am

Footballers aren't self-employed but the majority will have their own limited companies for sponsorships, image rights etc.

Professional footballers are paid through a payroll and have PAYE and NIC withheld at source just like a regular employee - or at least they should anyway.

See Rangers in recent times who have been through the courts for trying to get away with something else.

This looks like it's to do with transfer dealings so imagine it will likely be relating to payments to various parties relating to any transactions.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 26 Apr 17 10.45am

Originally posted by DanH

Footballers aren't self-employed but the majority will have their own limited companies for sponsorships, image rights etc.

Professional footballers are paid through a payroll and have PAYE and NIC withheld at source just like a regular employee - or at least they should anyway.

See Rangers in recent times who have been through the courts for trying to get away with something else.

This looks like it's to do with transfer dealings so imagine it will likely be relating to payments to various parties relating to any transactions.

Palace player i know was talking about how he claims back everything he can as he is Self employed. He is not a high earner at the club. A few have been made bankrupt before for owing Tax and NI so they must have been self employed. Maybe things have changed now and i hope so as why should certain high earners be allowed to reduced their tax and others cannot.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 26 Apr 17 10.51am

Originally posted by bubble wrap


Palace player i know was talking about how he claims back everything he can as he is Self employed. He is not a high earner at the club. A few have been made bankrupt before for owing Tax and NI so they must have been self employed. Maybe things have changed now and i hope so as why should certain high earners be allowed to reduced their tax and others cannot.

He is probably an employee of his own Limited Company as many in a similar position tend to refer to themselves as self employed which of course they are not as they are under contract to the football club.

 

OknotOK Flag Cockfosters, London 26 Apr 17 11.07am

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Palace player i know was talking about how he claims back everything he can as he is Self employed. He is not a high earner at the club. A few have been made bankrupt before for owing Tax and NI so they must have been self employed. Maybe things have changed now and i hope so as why should certain high earners be allowed to reduced their tax and others cannot.

Can't think of any that have been made bankrupt while still playing, but owed tax could be related to image rights or commercial income (sponsorship, media appearances, etc). They should be paid directly through the football club for their football-related income.

 


"It's almost like a moral decision. Except not really cos noone is going to find out," Jez, Peep Show

npn Flag Crowborough 26 Apr 17 11.31am

The "self employed" or more accurately, employed via their own limited company, approach is perfectly legit (I did it for 15 years when I was a dirty tax dodging IT contractor). There has to be more to this than just that, or anyone who employs contractors for IT etc (i.e. all the big companies in the country) would be getting raided

 

Chubskip Flag 26 Apr 17 11.33am

My question is will they get points deductions? If so when?

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 26 Apr 17 11.35am

Originally posted by npn

The "self employed" or more accurately, employed via their own limited company, approach is perfectly legit (I did it for 15 years when I was a dirty tax dodging IT contractor). There has to be more to this than just that, or anyone who employs contractors for IT etc (i.e. all the big companies in the country) would be getting raided

My point was a bit different to what the raids are about. From what i have read i think it is based on Image rights and players being paid vast amounts of money this way when they do not really have a public profile. Image rights are taxed at a lesser rate. not sure why as its all income.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 26 Apr 17 11.38am

Originally posted by npn

The "self employed" or more accurately, employed via their own limited company, approach is perfectly legit (I did it for 15 years when I was a dirty tax dodging IT contractor). There has to be more to this than just that, or anyone who employs contractors for IT etc (i.e. all the big companies in the country) would be getting raided

I suspect its related to 'tax schemes' rather than just limited companies, specifically related to avoiding the increased taxation on dividends and expenses (accommodation, mileage) that came in over the last two years.

Contracting now is probably on the receiving end of being too excessively clamped down on (as IR35 is almost unavoidable if the end client is a UK Government body) - In which case PAYE and NI is deducted prior to payment to the limited company, by the subcontractor or agency.

 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 26 Apr 17 11.55am

Originally posted by Chubskip

My question is will they get points deductions? If so when?

Well look at what happened to Rangers.

If they do receive a points deduction surely the sooner the better, then we won't have to put up with the Geordies next season as well.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 26 Apr 17 11.57am

Even then it will be down to tax schemes that have probably not been disclosed or actual evasion.

If you disclosed under DOTAS it's very rare to get raided and most schemes are disclosed and HMRC discuss with the promoters of the scheme.


 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 26 Apr 17 11.59am

Surely points deduction for the not so appy ammers and the toon.

Lets say 20 points each.

 

bubble wrap Flag Carparks in South East London 26 Apr 17 12.02pm

Originally posted by black eagle.

Surely points deduction for the not so appy ammers and the toon.

Lets say 20 points each.

Relegation from their current leagues would be suitable. West Ham in the Champ and Newcastle L1
How funny would that be.

 

orpingtoneagle Flag Orpington 26 Apr 17 12.03pm

No player at any club will be a self employed footballer.

They are contracted to the club and be an employee. But...

That will be just for playing for that club. The boot deals the 'image rights,' and all the stuff around actually training and playing will (it is argued,) not be to do with that employment. That will be run via a limited Co of some sort (personal service or umbrella) and that can be used to manipulate tax particularly for overseas players.

Then there is the use of employment products which use investments ot trusts etc than reduce tax.

As this is a raid on clubs rather than players guessing it is linked to something they have done or organised

 

Painter Flag Croydon 26 Apr 17 12.39pm

Originally posted by bubble wrap

Relegation from their current leagues would be suitable. West Ham in the Champ and Newcastle L1
How funny would that be.

The smug faces of Ashley, Gold, Sullivan and Brady deserve to have that expression wiped off.
Send them to league 2, similar to the penalty Rangers were given in Scotland. The thought of all the Premier money gone, will be only sanction they deserve.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 26 Apr 17 12.45pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

No player at any club will be a self employed footballer.

They are contracted to the club and be an employee. But...

That will be just for playing for that club. The boot deals the 'image rights,' and all the stuff around actually training and playing will (it is argued,) not be to do with that employment. That will be run via a limited Co of some sort (personal service or umbrella) and that can be used to manipulate tax particularly for overseas players.

Then there is the use of employment products which use investments ot trusts etc than reduce tax.


As this is a raid on clubs rather than players guessing it is linked to something they have done or organised


You would have to be Bat-s*** crazy to do the loans from a trust now with the new "related loan" charges coming in 2019

Bearing in mind it's an actual raid I'd be thinking it's to do with agents fees/signing on bonus' etc

Edited by robdave2k (26 Apr 2017 12.47pm)

 

Y Ddraig Goch Flag In The Crowd 26 Apr 17 12.49pm

My understanding from evens this morning is this:

Players are employed by clubs and salaries are paid as such, subject to usual taxes etc

Image rightsand some other additional payments can be paid separately, usually into a company set up by the player, this incurs 19% (compared to 45%) tax and 0 NI

There is a limit of 10% of total salary that can be paid to the "company" this was a deal beteen the FA/PL I can't remember which and the HMRC

HMRC are under pressure as surprisingly, there has only ever been one prosecution of a "super rich" person for tax dodging. This investigation is part of a task force to redress that

 


the dignified don't even enter in the game

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 26 Apr 17 12.54pm

This is HMRC going after evasion, so they will be looking for stuff that has been evaded not avoided

It will be things they have not been told about (DOTAS)

Arrests are based round criminality, for you to be dawn raided with officers with the power of arrest there, its way beyond the day to day setups involving trusts etc - HMRC use there enquiry powers for those!

 

Sportyteacher Flag London 28 Apr 17 4.57pm

The first two football clubs out of many undertaking criminal tax practices. Agents representing footballers need to be investigated as well.

 

jamiemartin721 Flag Reading 28 Apr 17 5.06pm

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

No player at any club will be a self employed footballer.

Depends on the terms of their contract.

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

They are contracted to the club and be an employee. But...

I'm contracted to a company, and I'm not an employee of that company either. I don't get any benefits from the company other than a day rate for provision of services though.

Given the plethora of complex additional payments, its probably true that most players are set up within limited companies that manage their assorted interest, expenses and wages. Possibly run by their agents.

Originally posted by orpingtoneagle

That will be just for playing for that club. The boot deals the 'image rights,' and all the stuff around actually training and playing will (it is argued,) not be to do with that employment. That will be run via a limited Co of some sort (personal service or umbrella) and that can be used to manipulate tax particularly for overseas players.

That would be a dangerous move - Because they get paid whilst injured, and during the off period. Things like Image Rights etc are taxable income, its really a question of what kind of taxable income it is.


 


"One Nation Under God, has turned into One Nation Under the Influence of One Drug"
[Link]

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > hmrc