This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
What's changed in a week?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
glaziermart 30 Apr 17 6.56pm |
|
|
I dont get it. One week ago we were being lauded for our performance at Liverpool and had won 6 games out of 8. Then we impressed against a very good Spurs team and were a bit unlucky. Now all of a sudden we look disorganised and nervous. Surely we can be so affected by the loss of one player, as good as Sakho is. We have been unlucky in losing 3 centre backs at the wrong time. This does not excuse the performance yesterday, but injuries and obviously the fact we had to play 2 tough games before yesterday did not help our preperation. But i still cannot understand why we were such a shambles!!!
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 30 Apr 17 7.03pm |
|
|
Having to play 3 games in 6 days towards the end of a hard season has caught up with us. Problems in central defence. Not looked the best in midfield with Cabaye absent. When we take Benteke off to be replaced by Campbell then things are bad.
|
rob1969 Banstead Surrey 30 Apr 17 7.04pm |
|
|
Maybe it just shows how thin on real quality our squad is and the effect injuries to three or four key players has. Lets hope we can get one or two back for the Hull game. Having said that playing three tough games in seven days didn't help. (or should that be six days?)
Edited by rob1969 (30 Apr 2017 7.06pm)
|
YT Oxford 30 Apr 17 7.20pm |
|
Originally posted by rob1969
Maybe it just shows how thin on real quality our squad is and the effect injuries to three or four key players has. Lets hope we can get one or two back for the Hull game. Having said that playing three tough games in seven days didn't help. (or should that be six days?)
Edited by rob1969 (30 Apr 2017 7.06pm)
I hope none of my 'sparring partners' from yesterday catch me saying this...but you are right; we played 3 games in seven days.
That aside, my point this evening is to ask whether we got our tactics wrong yesterday. Should we have played our usual game and tried to bank a draw in the hope of nicking a win by scoring on the break? Don't all shout at the H-word (hindsight) but a point yesterday would have made a significant difference right now (ie Swansea can now overtake us with two wins and a draw, but would now be needing three wins had we drawn yesterday - this of course assumes we get no more points).
Views please. Would it have been better to have been more cautious yesterday?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
Cucking Funt Clapham on the Back 30 Apr 17 7.21pm |
|
Originally posted by rob1969
Maybe it just shows how thin on real quality our squad is and the effect injuries to three or four key players has. Lets hope we can get one or two back for the Hull game. Having said that playing three tough games in seven days didn't help. (or should that be six days?)
Edited by rob1969 (30 Apr 2017 7.06pm)
As many have said, the ideal squad enables you to field two strong starting XIs. Very few clubs in the Premiership can afford this. We have had a simply shocking roll-call of injuries throughout the season, as bad as or worse than any I've seen before. To lose three strong centre backs in successive matches is unprecedented, for us or any other club, coupled with losing Wickham earlier in the season leaving us with f*ck all other than Benteke up front. Take two or three players out of the equation and suddenly we're an average championship side. Thank f*ck we've had a fit Zaha this season.
The threadbare nature of our squad has come into sharp relief this season and, notwithstanding Pardew and his inexplicable "tactics", it's a miracle we're not dead and buried already. Improving quality in depth is an absolute must if we are to even aspire to a mid/lower table finish next season.
Edited by Cucking Funt (30 Apr 2017 7.22pm)
Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham
|
chateauferret 30 Apr 17 7.24pm |
|
|
Obviously for us careful preparation is essential. Sam said as much in his interviews after the matches against Arsenal and Liverpool.
If you play three games in that time and with travel for one of them and obviously recuperate, how much training can you do? And if you have to change personnel and you have to respond to the strengths and weaknesses of each opponent, you need time on the training park to prepare properly. There wasn't enough time to prepare properly for the Burnley game with the changes required for injuries to Sakho and Cabaye.
It's not a coincidence that the only other game we have lost lately also involved a midweek match schedule (Southampton away). We have no more such situations.
In other news, McArthur seems to have gone to pot for some reason.
Edited by chateauferret (30 Apr 2017 7.28pm)
============ The Ferret ============
|
YT Oxford 30 Apr 17 7.25pm |
|
Originally posted by Cucking Funt
As many have said, the ideal squad enables you to field two strong starting XIs. Very few clubs in the Premiership can afford this. We have had a simply shocking roll-call of injuries throughout the season, as bad as or worse than any I've seen before. To lose three strong centre backs in successive matches is unprecedented, for us or any other club, coupled with losing Wickham earlier in the season leaving us with f*ck all other than Benteke up front. Take two or three players out of the equation and suddenly we're an average championship side. Thank f*ck we've had a fit Zaha this season.
The threadbare nature of our squad has come into sharp relief this season and, notwithstanding Pardew and his inexplicable "tactics", it's a miracle we're not dead and buried already. Improving quality in depth is an absolute must if we are to even aspire to a mid/lower table finish next season.
Edited by Cucking Funt (30 Apr 2017 7.22pm)
Shrewd analysis.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
mrfantasy maidstone 30 Apr 17 7.25pm |
|
|
Maybe it's easier to put in a backs to the wall cup tie like performance against a superior team than to actually take the initiative and take the game to the opponent with our current group of players which makes we worry about next season. Unfortunately I can't see Zaha, Cabaye or Sakho still being here and possibly Benteke as well which will make for a hell of a lot of re-building.
|
ger20 London 30 Apr 17 7.33pm |
|
|
Two championship center backs are a serious problem. Luckly we need a point or three. I cant see that happening at City. If Hull and Swansea win their next games or even draw we will be under serious preassure. Swansea will be on 35 and Hull on 37. Which means we just have to beat Hull.Lets hope we dont bottle it.
|
PZ Eagle Penzance 30 Apr 17 8.24pm |
|
Originally posted by YT
I hope none of my 'sparring partners' from yesterday catch me saying this...but you are right; we played 3 games in seven days.
3 games in six days actually as I proved in another thread. Time elapsed from Liverpool finish to KO time yesterday was 144 hours. 144 divided by 24 equals 6.
Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.
|
Brentmiester_General Front line in the battle against t... 30 Apr 17 8.51pm |
|
|
Sakho.
"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...
|
ParchmoreEagle Belair 30 Apr 17 8.55pm |
|
Originally posted by YT
I hope none of my 'sparring partners' from yesterday catch me saying this...but you are right; we played 3 games in seven days.
That aside, my point this evening is to ask whether we got our tactics wrong yesterday. Should we have played our usual game and tried to bank a draw in the hope of nicking a win by scoring on the break? Don't all shout at the H-word (hindsight) but a point yesterday would have made a significant difference right now (ie Swansea can now overtake us with two wins and a draw, but would now be needing three wins had we drawn yesterday - this of course assumes we get no more points).
Views please. Would it have been better to have been more cautious yesterday?
Keeping in mind the 'H' word, I think you maybe right. The Burnley defence was like Donald's 'WALL' and we were getting smashed against it, then caught out off the break. In 'hindsight', given Sahko's loss, battening down the hatches to play out a draw would have: 1: suited our fitness levels better, 2. gained 90+ minutes of defensive practice for Kelly & Delaney & Co, 3. Gained us a precious point, 4. Given Benteke and forwards less running to do, 5. Knowing Palace - got us a win. So I think you made a good point.
[Link]
|
rollercoaster Cornwall 30 Apr 17 9.07pm |
|
|
Given our centre back pairing against Vokes and Barnes I think sitting back would have a definite defeat. Second half we played the game in Burnley's half and looked a bit more secure. Burnley looked like they might score every time they got a ball into our penalty area. So, no, I don't think sitting back for the point would have worked.
If the match had been 11 v 11 and if we had taken a chance, (we did have 1 or 2, Milo's in the first half being the best), then I think we would have got at least a draw, even playing as badly as we did.
|
collier row eagle romford essex via another galaxy 30 Apr 17 9.12pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
Having to play 3 games in 6 days towards the end of a hard season has caught up with us. Problems in central defence. Not looked the best in midfield with Cabaye absent. When we take Benteke off to be replaced by Campbell then things are bad.
Plus a Cnut of a ref.
|
Booted Eagle Bristol 30 Apr 17 9.18pm |
|
|
Dyche knew what he was doing. Looking at their line up and our obvious frailties 3 in the middle of defence was required but do we have another CB ? if not let's hope for no further injuries.Then we might of held up in the middle.
Edited by Booted Eagle (30 Apr 2017 9.20pm)
“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ” —United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld
|
ParchmoreEagle Belair 30 Apr 17 9.20pm |
|
Originally posted by rollercoaster
Given our centre back pairing against Vokes and Barnes I think sitting back would have a definite defeat. Second half we played the game in Burnley's half and looked a bit more secure. Burnley looked like they might score every time they got a ball into our penalty area. So, no, I don't think sitting back for the point would have worked.
If the match had been 11 v 11 and if we had taken a chance, (we did have 1 or 2, Milo's in the first half being the best), then I think we would have got at least a draw, even playing as badly as we did.
Good point, not saying my thoughts are correct, but with a defensive set-up we are not looking at Vokes and Barnes being challenged 'on the break' with our midfielders out of contention (recall especially the last goal). Attacks are cleared well before they even 'look' like attacks. But I get your point: playing the game in your own half (which is not necessarily what I'm advocating) rather than in the opposition half isn't smart either. And this is hindsight. Big Sam took a well-calculated gamble and like us, all he knew was how well we played against Spurs, and if we could replicate half of that form, we would have beaten Burnley. Unfortunately, the 3 games in a week finally took its toll... Who was to know?
[Link]
|
YT Oxford 30 Apr 17 9.35pm |
|
Originally posted by PZ Eagle
3 games in six days actually as I proved in another thread. Time elapsed from Liverpool finish to KO time yesterday was 144 hours. 144 divided by 24 equals 6.
Thanks Einstein, but in the time period you describe, we played just one game; against Spurs.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
essetwentyone london 30 Apr 17 9.43pm |
|
|
Yes I have no doubt that 3 games in 6 days was a major factor in our 2 home defeats but I am a little bit surprised at Big Sam's team selections.
After the great win at Liverpool Sam said there would be changes for Spurs but the only changes were Sakho for Tomkins and Jimmy Mac for Cabaye both due to injury. The same team was then selected for Burnley apart from Damo in for the injured Sako plus swapping left backs. I really thought Sam would have targeted the Burnley game as winnable and rested key players for the Spurs game to have them in good shape for Burnley. I know our squad is thin but surely he could've played the likes of VanArnault, Flamini, Ledley, Sakho, Lee and Campbell on Wednesday? Yes it would've been a weak team but damage could've been limited. Of course the fans wouldn't have liked it but we would've all been much happier yesterday if we'd won and secured another Prem season.. Sam went to great lengths to explain the recovery problems beforehand and predicted exactly what happened so I just don't get why he played the same key players 3 times. Lucca, Punch, Townsend, Wilf and Benteke could've missed Spurs and been 100% recovered for Burnley. Scluup also would've been at his best on Saturday instead of Wednesday..
|
johnallen Weston-super-Mare, born in Croydon 30 Apr 17 9.56pm |
|
|
What has changed in a week is that the players are just overtired physically from three games in a week. It doesn't matter how fit you are you still get tired and your performance level drops. Sam should send them all home until Thursday then have a light training and tactics day on Thursday and then get up to Manchester on Friday. City will give us far more room to play than Burnley and this will suit our counter attacking game IF,IF, we can get the ball off them.
I am determined to live until I am as old as I look.
|
fan Caterham 30 Apr 17 9.57pm |
|
|
I know it is easy with hindsight but why didn't the club rearrange the spurs match for this week giving us the longest possible time to face Burnley which we all thought would be more winnable than spurs?
|