You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tomkins the great
November 16 2026 9.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Tomkins the great


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
CPFC/SCCC Flag Sutton 14 May 17 9.48pm

His performances since January have been superb. With questions mark about puncheon regular starting spot. Is he a candidate for captain for next season. As much as I like dann as a player he's captaincy was pretty poor imo ? Any chance of Tomkins making an England squad?

 


Andy Johnson Magic, He wears a Magic Hat
When he Sees the match ball, he says he having that
He scores one with left foot, he scores one with his right
And When his playing Brighton, He scores all f***ING Night!

Mad4palace Flag 14 May 17 9.53pm

I didn't rate him initially but he's proved me wrong and looked a lot better since Sakho and Milivojevic have come in. A decent centre-back but not England quality. Not seen enough from him to indicate that he's captain material after Puncheon.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 14 May 17 9.57pm

Originally posted by Mad4palace

I didn't rate him initially but he's proved me wrong and looked a lot better since Sakho and Milivojevic have come in. A decent centre-back but not England quality. Not seen enough from him to indicate that he's captain material after Puncheon.

Not England quality? An awesome player then.

 

dg1937 Flag 14 May 17 10.03pm

Gutsy too. Played on at Anfield after that shocking tackle and clearly must have worked very hard to get back for today.

 

chateauferret Flag 15 May 17 9.42am

Originally posted by Mad4palace

I didn't rate him initially but he's proved me wrong and looked a lot better since Sakho and Milivojevic have come in. A decent centre-back but not England quality. Not seen enough from him to indicate that he's captain material after Puncheon.

Apparently Wilf is not England quality.

F*** England.

 


============
The Ferret
============

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 15 May 17 9.52am

Originally posted by CPFC/SCCC

His performances since January have been superb. With questions mark about puncheon regular starting spot. Is he a candidate for captain for next season. As much as I like dann as a player he's captaincy was pretty poor imo ? Any chance of Tomkins making an England squad?

Wet Sham fans were gutted when he left and we're beginning to see why they rated him so highly.

As for the Cpt's armband, I think that'll be Punch's to keep.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

dougster Flag 16 May 17 12.18pm

He has proven to be a bit of a bargain really. Was a bit surprised we paid so much when he signed, but he has proven to be a really good player. West Ham fans were right to be annoyed after they paid a similar amount for a 33 year old Jose Fonte 6 months later.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 May 17 12.21pm

Originally posted by sa_eagle

Wet Sham fans were gutted when he left and we're beginning to see why they rated him so highly.

As for the Cpt's armband, I think that'll be Punch's to keep.

Punch will be club captain. I think the modern day captain thing of having to be picked isn't quite how it used to be.

 


COYP

wally2606 Flag Cheltenham 16 May 17 12.41pm

I thought he had a great game on Sunday, strong in the air and good with ball at his feet and on top of that coming into the game carrying an injury, both him and Martin Kelly have stepped up when really needed during the run in, injuries to Tomkins have meant a stop start first season for him but i reckon he has been a top signing and hopefully he has a good pre season and can have a run of injury free games next season ...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 16 May 17 12.45pm

Originally posted by wally2606

I thought he had a great game on Sunday, strong in the air and good with ball at his feet and on top of that coming into the game carrying an injury, both him and Martin Kelly have stepped up when really needed during the run in, injuries to Tomkins have meant a stop start first season for him but i reckon he has been a top signing and hopefully he has a good pre season and can have a run of injury free games next season ...

Actual defending drills and training rather than going to the manager asking for some on Thursday, only to have to do it themselves on Friday. Truly facking shocking and the man responsible should hang his head in shame. All to justify the contract extension, which was beyond unbelievable.

 


COYP

chateauferret Flag 16 May 17 12.57pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Actual defending drills and training rather than going to the manager asking for some on Thursday, only to have to do it themselves on Friday. Truly facking shocking and the man responsible should hang his head in shame. All to justify the contract extension, which was beyond unbelievable.

Even though this is only coming from the Daily Fail Sheffield Wednesday fans are in meltdown at the very idea.

[Link]

And as if that wasn't bad enough they have a history of trying to sign Bumfluff.

Oh dear.

Edited by chateauferret (16 May 2017 12.58pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

coulsdoneagle Flag London 16 May 17 1.03pm

Tomkins doesn't have the leadership qualities to be captain and I think it would take away from his performance if he had to focus on that side of the game and defending. Sakho was the more vocal natural leader of the two but to be honest I think Puncheon is the best choice he can still captain the side without it hugely affecting his game and he is already a vocal natural leader.

 

Mstrobez Flag 16 May 17 1.20pm

Has done very well but I think he's a perfect example of how fickle is football fans can be. It's easy to forget Dann had arguably been our most important player for a couple of years and a hero to many. A small dip in form in a team that was all over the place and has already been deemed surplus to requirements by a few. I still think he has a big part to play in the future and I still rate him above Tomkins as a footballer, 100%

 


We're the Arthur over ere!

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 16 May 17 1.47pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Actual defending drills and training rather than going to the manager asking for some on Thursday, only to have to do it themselves on Friday. Truly facking shocking and the man responsible should hang his head in shame. All to justify the contract extension, which was beyond unbelievable.

Had not heard this before. Shocking.
No wonder the players were so lost.
Quite frightening that at this point in our stay in the PL we are suffering managers like this. It was almost acceptable when it was Ian Holloway, but he had the decency to fall on his sword.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

aashman12 Flag 16 May 17 5.55pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Apparently Wilf is not England quality.

F*** England.

f*** you too

 

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 16 May 17 6.04pm

Originally posted by dg1937

Gutsy too. Played on at Anfield after that shocking tackle and clearly must have worked very hard to get back for today.

Did "walking" training with the team to rehearse set-pieces before Sunday, and only played because he was dosed up with a pain-killer. He was expected to last maybe 60 minutes, but he played 86.

A great pick-up. Now, if he could work on not missing the goal from inside the 6-yard box...

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

chateauferret Flag 16 May 17 6.26pm

Originally posted by aashman12

f*** you too

What? Oh, I guess you've made that age-old mistake of thinking the flags next to our usernames denote our nationality, rather than our whereabouts.

If you were thinking at all, that is.


Edited by chateauferret (16 May 2017 6.28pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

The Dolphin Flag 17 May 17 7.50am

Like many players he looks way better under Sam than he did under Pardew.
If we were to sign Sakho I still think that Dann would be his best foil so would JT sit on the bench?
All ifs and buts but he has done well during the upturn in fortunes.
A good signing all in all.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 17 May 17 8.02am

Originally posted by sa_eagle

Wet Sham fans were gutted when he left and we're beginning to see why they rated him so highly.

As for the Cpt's armband, I think that'll be Punch's to keep.

He made a huge difference when he came back against Hull. Didnt put a foot wrong. He made a great contributiin to giving us defensive solidity that enabled us to win the match. A good PL standard CB. I think he would have to step up a level - and stay fit - to warrant an England call up

 

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 17 May 17 8.49am

Originally posted by chateauferret

What? Oh, I guess you've made that age-old mistake of thinking the flags next to our usernames denote our nationality, rather than our whereabouts.

If you were thinking at all, that is.


Edited by chateauferret (16 May 2017 6.28pm)

That's why I changed mine back to England, I live in Cape Town and got slagged off a few times for being a jonny come lately South African when I'm actually a Brit who's followed Palace since '79.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Tomkins the great