You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Proposed changes : Timekeeping,Free-kicks etc
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Proposed changes : Timekeeping,Free-kicks etc


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jun 17 7.03pm

Just seen this :

[Link]

Need to consider in detail before I form a judgement on the various proposals.

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 17 Jun 17 7.25pm

Nice spot Willo
1. 30 minute halves with clock stops when the ball is dead.
2. Penalty kicks either score or not with no scoring from the rebound (like a penalty shoot out)
3. Penalty shoot outs change the order from ABAB to ABBA.
4. passing to yourself at a free-kick, corner and goal-kick
5. a stadium clock which stops and starts along with the referee's watch
6. allowing the goal-kick to be taken even if the ball is moving
7.a goal-kick being taken on the same side that the ball went out on
8. a "clearer and more consistent definition" of handball
9. a player who scores a goal or stops a goal with his hands gets a red card
10.a keeper who handles a backpass or throw-in from a team-mate concedes a penalty
11. the referee can award a goal if a player stops a goal being scored by handling on or close to the goal-line
12. referees can only blow for half-time or full-time when the ball goes out of play

I agree with 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11

For number 3, the winner takes it all I guess

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jun 17 7.35pm

My immediate reaction is that with all the 'Timekeeping' changes, supporters would miss the last train home for night matches if they stayed until the end !

 

CPFC_1905 Flag 17 Jun 17 7.40pm

Originally posted by MrCParrot

Nice spot Willo
1. 30 minute halves with clock stops when the ball is dead.

Not sure about this. How long could halves potentially last in comparison to a standard 45. If there are no 'dead balls' (goals, penalties, injuries,
subs etc.) what would 30 mins of football be like

2. Penalty kicks either score or not with no scoring from the rebound (like a penalty shoot out)

Like the sound of this

3. Penalty shoot outs change the order from ABAB to ABBA.

This too. Change the potential advantage.

4. passing to yourself at a free-kick, corner and goal-kick

This is being considered? Find it strange.

5. a stadium clock which stops and starts along with the referee's watch.

Kind of like rugby. Guess it could make point 1 better.

6. allowing the goal-kick to be taken even if the ball is moving

Nope.

7.a goal-kick being taken on the same side that the ball went out on

This is what I grew up on. Does it matter much?!

8. a "clearer and more consistent definition" of handball

Thought it was okay already. Below the shoulder, arm moving towards the ball, away from the body.

9. a player who scores a goal or stops a goal with his hands gets a red card

I thought this was already the case for stopping a goal?

10.a keeper who handles a backpass or throw-in from a team-mate concedes a penalty

Maybe better than the current red card rule.

11. the referee can award a goal if a player stops a goal being scored by handling on or close to the goal-line

YES!

12. referees can only blow for half-time or full-time when the ball goes out of play

Rugby-esque. That could add to the drama. I like that.


I agree with 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11

For number 3, the winner takes it all I guess

Parrot

The question is. How would this affect things like Sunday football, especially the time keeping? Would there be professional rules and amateur or development rules?

Edited by CPFC_1905 (17 Jun 2017 7.48pm)

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 17 Jun 17 7.46pm

Originally posted by CPFC_1905

The question is. How would this affect things like Sunday football, especially the time keeping? Would there be professional rules and amateur or development rules?

Very good point.
I can see some park referees not being keen on stopping and starting their watches numerous times !
And many would be late for their Sunday lunch !

At the end of the day, there should always be considertion as to how to improve the game as a spectacle etc etc, but one has to be careful not to introduce too many changes which could alter the dynamic of the great game.

Going out soon - will give all of this consideration in the next couple of days.

Edited by Willo (17 Jun 2017 7.51pm)

 

MrCParrot Flag Taunton 17 Jun 17 8.06pm

4. passing to yourself at a free-kick, corner and goal-kick4.

Wonder if Wilf can just pick himself up and keep going, he can't be challenged due to the 10 yard or does the ref stop the kick being taken quickly?

Parrot

 


Mr Cadbury's Parrot says "Hello"

PALACE FOR EVER Flag London 17 Jun 17 8.56pm

1. 30 minute halves with clock stops when the ball is dead.

No

2. Penalty kicks either score or not with no scoring from the rebound (like a penalty shoot out)

Yes - I presume they also mean own goals from post/bar will not be allowed.

3. Penalty shoot outs change the order from ABAB to ABBA.

Yes, as I have felt this before, the way Tie-breaks are in tennis.

4. passing to yourself at a free-kick, corner and goal-kick

No.

5. a stadium clock which stops and starts along with the referee's watch

No.

6. allowing the goal-kick to be taken even if the ball is moving

Not sure.

7.a goal-kick being taken on the same side that the ball went out on

No, the change hasn't caused any problems.

8. a "clearer and more consistent definition" of handball

No, Just keep it as it is, whatever it is there will be problems.

9. a player who scores a goal or stops a goal with his hands gets a red card

No, it just increases the problems if a ref gets it wrong.

10.a keeper who handles a backpass or throw-in from a team-mate concedes a penalty

No

11. the referee can award a goal if a player stops a goal being scored by handling on or close to the goal-line

Definitely not. Crossing the line is a goal, not perhaps or maybes.

12. referees can only blow for half-time or full-time when the ball goes out of play

Yes

 


The pyramid to beat all pyramids!!

[Link]

Find out what team is in which division, eg which division is Coppull United in?

m/k mick Flag milton keynes 17 Jun 17 9.06pm

Most of this seems a tad unecessary to me, if people are cheating time wasting, let the ref sort it out, punish them they will soon get the message, one thing i personally would like stopped is the subs in the last ten minutes, easy to solve, on the 80th minute , no more subs allowed regardless, i pay to see 90minutes, and i get really p......d off when you have subs late in a game, designed to kill the game, when it could ,should be the most exciting period of a game

 

Bobtail Flag Crowborough 17 Jun 17 9.48pm

I am opposed to any tinkering with the rules which will give MotD and Talks***e pundits more points to pontificate about.

 


Open your eyes, look up to the skies and see

Pierre Flag Purley 18 Jun 17 5.05pm

Originally posted by Bobtail

I am opposed to any tinkering with the rules which will give MotD and Talks***e pundits more points to pontificate about.

Anything that speeds the game up in terms of the 'ball actually being in play' must surely be a good thing.

This is an area that has been severely eroded over the years as the price of supporting or watching football spirals in price!
One of the reasons why nearly all commentators of live matches have to talk such utter b*ll*cks!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 18 Jun 17 5.21pm

Surprised nobody likes 7. Stop all those keepers wasting more time.

 


COYP

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 19 Jun 17 2.22pm

1. 30 minute halves with clock stops when the ball is dead.
- NO
2. Penalty kicks either score or not with no scoring from the rebound (like a penalty shoot out)
- NO
3. Penalty shoot outs change the order from ABAB to ABBA.
- YES
4. passing to yourself at a free-kick, corner and goal-kick
- POSSIBLY.
5. a stadium clock which stops and starts along with the referee's watch
- NO
6. allowing the goal-kick to be taken even if the ball is moving
- YES
7.a goal-kick being taken on the same side that the ball went out on
- YES but not that bothered.
8. a "clearer and more consistent definition" of handball
- IS IT NEEDED? WILL IT HELP?
9. a player who scores a goal or stops a goal with his hands gets a red card
- YES but think this already happens
10.a keeper who handles a backpass or throw-in from a team-mate concedes a penalty
- NO
11. the referee can award a goal if a player stops a goal being scored by handling on or close to the goal-line
- NO
12. referees can only blow for half-time or full-time when the ball goes out of play
- NO but may be interesting to see.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

kenbarr Flag Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 20 Jun 17 7.55am

Number 5 was tried in the early years of MLS and didn't work due to a lack of communication between the refs and the scoreboard operators. Number 9 was proposed years ago as a "penalty goal" but it was decided to give a PK and send off the offending player. The earliest I saw that enforced was in the Palace 3-2 Wimbledon match in 1991 reffed by David Elleray. Afterwards he said he was personally in favour of the penalty goal concept. Sending off for deliberate hand ball for a "goal" (HoG) is new but should have been enforced in 1986.

 


Divorced...And LOVING it!
VJRAM Rev.
CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC
Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach
Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach
Trevor Francis, International PRAT

sa_eagle Flag Just outside Cape Town 22 Jun 17 7.01am

I've got mixed feelings about much of this but mainly bacause of a sense of nostalgia.

One change I would like to see is a yellow card for a non-defensive backpass to the keeper, that would stop a lot of time wasting.

 


Cynic or realist? It's a fine line!

Littlebogreek Flag 22 Jun 17 4.24pm

I quite like football. Wish they would stop f*cking about with it.

Edited by Littlebogreek (22 Jun 2017 4.24pm)

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 22 Jun 17 4.51pm

Stopping the clock when the ball is out of play would - categorically - lead to more football being played per match.

However, it would grossly advantage stronger teams. What chance the cup upset / Palace away win at Chelsea with backs to the wall where any row Z clearance will do?

Edited by Mr_Gristle (22 Jun 2017 4.52pm)

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 26 Jun 17 8.46pm

1. 30 minute halves with clock stops when the ball is dead.
I saw a stat once that said the ball is in play, on average, for 60-something minutes. So this is about the same amount of play if they stop the clock for all dead balls and give 60 mins as opposed to letting it run and give 90. It adds certainty, eliminates time wasting and should have very little impact on the flow of the game - other than to get rid of the flurry of injury time, ponderous substitutions.

2. Penalty kicks either score or not with no scoring from the rebound (like a penalty shoot out)
I don't like this. The penalty is a free kick, so the ball should stay live. Making the ball dead after a save just benefits the offending team.

3. Penalty shoot outs change the order from ABAB to ABBA.
Meh

4. passing to yourself at a free-kick, corner and goal-kick
Yes! This is the "Wilf" rule, so he can get up after being hauled down cynically, take a free kick to himself and continue on his merry way. For corners, it forces the defense, who would otherwise have a man extra in the middle, to go out and cover the potential dribble from the corner.

5. a stadium clock which stops and starts along with the referee's watch
A must if they do #1.

6. allowing the goal-kick to be taken even if the ball is moving
If they do #4, then the keeper is just starting a dribble so what's the harm.

7.a goal-kick being taken on the same side that the ball went out on
Doesn't matter much either way if they implement #4 and #1.

8. a "clearer and more consistent definition" of handball
Please! Basically, if a player isn't trying not to handball (e.g. hands clasped behind his back), then it should be handball.

9. a player who scores a goal or stops a goal with his hands gets a red card
Stopping a goal is already a red, so this just evens the punishment for an offense that carries equal potential to f*** with the result.

10.a keeper who handles a backpass or throw-in from a team-mate concedes a penalty
WTF? This is far too punitive. Of course, I don't even think that all fouls in the penalty area should be penalties and that some fouls outside the area should be penalties.

11. the referee can award a goal if a player stops a goal being scored by handling on or close to the goal-line
Penalty goals...interesting. If the refs were more competent, I'd be more confident about this one. I still think the penalty kick - and a card - is an appropriate punishment.

12. referees can only blow for half-time or full-time when the ball goes out of play
Not a fan of this one, but it makes sense if they introduce the hard clock from #1.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 26 Jun 17 8.53pm

Originally posted by kenbarr

Number 5 was tried in the early years of MLS and didn't work due to a lack of communication between the refs and the scoreboard operators.

I imagine now that they could get it done. In fact, it's weird that some sports still have clock operators who are supplied by the home team and aren't match officials. I remember one Rockets-Jazz game in Utah (mid-90s), when the Jazz were down with about 10 seconds on the clock, and the Jazz-supplied clock operator didn't start the clock for 9 seconds after the ball was in play. They still didn't score, but what a cluster it would have been if they had.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 26 Jun 17 8.55pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Stopping the clock when the ball is out of play would - categorically - lead to more football being played per match.

However, it would grossly advantage stronger teams. What chance the cup upset / Palace away win at Chelsea with backs to the wall where any row Z clearance will do?

It wouldn't really, as the time the ball is in play for about the same either way.

Edited by Ray in Houston (26 Jun 2017 8.58pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

buzby1 Flag Devon 27 Jun 17 9.29am

Originally posted by Littlebogreek

I quite like football. Wish they would stop f*cking about with it.

Edited by Littlebogreek (22 Jun 2017 4.24pm)

Spot on. Leave the game as it is. It works. Don't start messing about with the rules like they do with rugby union. That's become a stop - start boring sport. Also no video reviews. Holds up the game. Refs making mistakes are all part of it and gives us lots of lovely reasons to despise them..

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Proposed changes : Timekeeping,Free-kicks etc