You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who in the squad can and can't play 'total footy'
November 16 2026 9.39am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who in the squad can and can't play 'total footy'


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Stirlingsays Flag 24 Jun 17 11.51pm

With Frank de Boer most likely being our next entrance into the managerial lion's den it looks like we are going to be playing the 'Ajax' way.

I would be interested to know your thoughts on how this is likely to affect our squad.

Who do we have that can play 'total football' and who is likely to be heading for the exit?

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Qwijibo Flag Bournemouth 24 Jun 17 11.59pm

Who knows. Our most successful managers have been pretty direct, and pardew attempted expansive. But his failure doesn't mean they're not capable, depends on the coach. Remember Tony Adams' renaissance under Wenger? An old dog with new tricks.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 25 Jun 17 12.13am

So this is all my opinion based on the ball playing abilities of the players I have seen in my time watching them play. You may disagree but people like Macca I think are great players but I'm not sold on their ability to play the ball on the deck. There are other players like Papa who I love but a calm head playing out from the back is not how I would describe him, he bombs forward but is rash and is prone to poor control in my opinion. So here is the list. I have forgotten loads I'm sure.

CAN

Cabaye
Benteke
Tompkins
Wilf
Andros
Van aanholt
Mandanda
Joniesta
Lee
Punch
Millovoivic


CANT

Damo
Dann
Hennessy
Kelly
Souare
Ward
Sako

MAYBE

Wickham
Schlupp
MacArthur
Kaikai

I think it's really important that whoever we bring in in defence has to be able to play out from the back. RB is even more of a priority now and I think it is vital we get someone like Davide Santon who is classy on the ball to replace Ward.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 25 Jun 17 12.17am

pre Coppell we always played pretty light weight football - as for our total footballers I would say ... erm... we haven't got any. Vision and philosophy are great in the long term but I hope he just tries to get 3 points v Huddersfield and reconvenes on Monday morning for the following Saturday etc Re FDB I'm hopeful but I'm not entirely confident but fortunately I know f*ck all about football

 

Mad4palace Flag 25 Jun 17 12.32am

Those capable, starting from the back:

Hennessey, Mandanda are both comfortable with their feet, Speroni isn't too bad either
Dann, good passer, may struggle if we play a high defensive line but I don't think De Boer plays that.
Van Aanholt, was at PSV as a kid and Vitesse in his 20's, you can tell he's Dutch by the positions he takes up when going forward.
Milivojevic, no frills DM that knows the role, good first touch and passing.
Cabaye, he likes to press even if he gets tired, takes up intelligent positions in the half spaces, definitely works in a 4-3-3.
The likes of Townsend, Zaha should be capable, they'll still be wingers you'd assume but will have to add more intelligence off the balls with their positioning. Benteke should be ok unless De Boer wants him to chase every ball and play everything to his feet, he struggled at Liverpool but he was totally wrong for the way Klopp played.


 

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Jun 17 2.07am

Originally posted by Qwijibo

Who knows. Our most successful managers have been pretty direct, and pardew attempted expansive. But his failure doesn't mean they're not capable, depends on the coach. Remember Tony Adams' renaissance under Wenger? An old dog with new tricks.

Yeah, Pardew was unlucky with injuries as well.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 25 Jun 17 2.10am

Cheers guys some informative stuff.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Jamesrichards8 Flag 25 Jun 17 2.57am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

So this is all my opinion based on the ball playing abilities of the players I have seen in my time watching them play. You may disagree but people like Macca I think are great players but I'm not sold on their ability to play the ball on the deck. There are other players like Papa who I love but a calm head playing out from the back is not how I would describe him, he bombs forward but is rash and is prone to poor control in my opinion. So here is the list. I have forgotten loads I'm sure.

CAN

Cabaye
Benteke
Tompkins
Wilf
Andros
Van aanholt
Mandanda
Joniesta
Lee
Punch
Millovoivic


CANT

Damo
Dann
Hennessy
Kelly
Souare
Ward
Sako

MAYBE

Wickham
Schlupp
MacArthur
Kaikai

I think it's really important that whoever we bring in in defence has to be able to play out from the back. RB is even more of a priority now and I think it is vital we get someone like Davide Santon who is classy on the ball to replace Ward.

I wouldn't agree with any of those in the 'cant' column except for damo, sake and maybe souare. Hennessey's strength is his distribution. And I wouldn't have put benteke in the definite 'can' column. He was best receiving a long ball with his back to goal

 


When you’re knocked on your back and your life’s a flop...

coulsdoneagle Flag London 25 Jun 17 3.19am

Originally posted by Jamesrichards8

I wouldn't agree with any of those in the 'cant' column except for damo, sake and maybe souare. Hennessey's strength is his distribution. And I wouldn't have put benteke in the definite 'can' column. He was best receiving a long ball with his back to goal

Benteke has always been tidy with his feet. Look at his goal against Chelsea as an example. He has way more to his game than being a lump.

Hennessy has got terrible distribution he can't play it short and his long kicks and throws are not great either. Dann isn't a ball playing cb. He is better than Damo but he isn't great. Kelly is another one I can't see any evidence of either of them having any ball playing ability.

Anyway all opinion at the end of the day.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 25 Jun 17 5.57am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

pre Coppell we always played pretty light weight football - as for our total footballers I would say ... erm... we haven't got any. Vision and philosophy are great in the long term but I hope he just tries to get 3 points v Huddersfield and reconvenes on Monday morning for the following Saturday etc Re FDB I'm hopeful but I'm not entirely confident but fortunately I know f*ck all about football

I agree, not confident, do not think we have a squad to play the Ajax way - pressing from the front - NO, percentage play in midfield - NO, playing the ball out from the back - 100% NO.
I don't think there is a single player in our squad that doesn't need to change big-time to play the Ajax way in the Prem. Whether FdB can coach this or needs to be pragmatic for now until he gets the right players we will find out soon enough.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 25 Jun 17 6.05am

Although it sounds like Sakho will not join, if he does I would say he is deffo a can player.

 

BarEagle Flag Monmouth 25 Jun 17 7.12am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

Benteke has always been tidy with his feet. Look at his goal against Chelsea as an example. He has way more to his game than being a lump.

Hennessy has got terrible distribution he can't play it short and his long kicks and throws are not great either. Dann isn't a ball playing cb. He is better than Damo but he isn't great. Kelly is another one I can't see any evidence of either of them having any ball playing ability.

Anyway all opinion at the end of the day.

Can't agree with that. Hennessey has his faults but his kicking and throws are very, very good.

The final phrase is an over used one by Trollo 😉

 

Nobbybm Flag Dartford 25 Jun 17 8.13am

A (very) long while back when he was manager at Barca, Cruyff was asked what totaalvoetbal actually was. His response was basically saying it was the kind of football you played as a kid at school but with added direction/tactics/control. On that basis, any professional should be able to play that way - the crux is whether they are comfortable in doing so.

Much of it is about interchange of positions which I think th front 3 & midfield are quite capable of, PVA & Schlupp not a problem and Dann & Tomkins have both shown they can when needed. It remains to be seen if they can actually do it at EPL levels.

A few quality additions could make next season one to remember for the right reasons.

 


Will this be five? It's gonna be five! It IS five!

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 25 Jun 17 8.22am

Agreed Nobby.
Total Football is a theory of football in which any outfield player can take over the role of any other player in a team.
So for us I would say PVA and Townsend.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

slubglurge Flag welling 25 Jun 17 9.13am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

So this is all my opinion based on the ball playing abilities of the players I have seen in my time watching them play. You may disagree but people like Macca I think are great players but I'm not sold on their ability to play the ball on the deck. There are other players like Papa who I love but a calm head playing out from the back is not how I would describe him, he bombs forward but is rash and is prone to poor control in my opinion. So here is the list. I
have forgotten loads I'm sure.

CAN

Cabaye
Benteke
Tompkins
Wilf
Andros
Van aanholt
Mandanda
Joniesta
Lee
Punch
Millovoivic

I think thats a pretty acurate list but i think Hennessey will be ok. Remember the team of the 80s Burridge just used to roll the ball to Gilbert or Cannon. It depends ehether our players show for the ball as those two did


CANT

Damo
Dann
Hennessy
Kelly
Souare
Ward
Sako

MAYBE

Wickham
Schlupp
MacArthur
Kaikai

I think it's really important that whoever we bring in in defence has to be able to play out from the back. RB is even more of a priority now and I think it is vital we get someone like Davide Santon who is classy on the ball to replace Ward.

 

Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 25 Jun 17 12.20pm

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

So this is all my opinion based on the ball playing abilities of the players I have seen in my time watching them play. You may disagree but people like Macca I think are great players but I'm not sold on their ability to play the ball on the deck. There are other players like Papa who I love but a calm head playing out from the back is not how I would describe him, he bombs forward but is rash and is prone to poor control in my opinion. So here is the list. I have forgotten loads I'm sure.

CAN

Cabaye
Benteke
Tompkins
Wilf
Andros
Van aanholt
Mandanda
Joniesta
Lee
Punch
Millovoivic


CANT

Damo
Dann
Hennessy
Kelly
Souare
Ward
Sako

MAYBE

Wickham
Schlupp
MacArthur
Kaikai

I think it's really important that whoever we bring in in defence has to be able to play out from the back. RB is even more of a priority now and I think it is vital we get someone like Davide Santon who is classy on the ball to replace Ward.

No maybe about Macca whatsoever. Class player especially with one- two touch passing. He will thrive under De Boer.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jun 17 12.50pm

I hope we're not expecting too much of Mr de Boer or, worse still, that he's expecting too much of us. Our team has many good qualities and strengths, but Ajax we ain't. When we play to our strengths, with Pulis, Pardew (before he went nuts) and Sam (once he'd un-Pardewed us), we do look like a decent mid-table side. And we had the potential to be a bit better than that if Pulis and Sam hadn't decided to chuck the towel in and Pardew hadn't had some sort of breakdown. I'm sure we can evolve, over time, with the right recruitment, into a fixture in the top half, but if anyone, including Frank, tries to do it overnight, we'll be right where we were with Pardew in 2016, except the escape artists aren't available this time.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Jun 17 1.39pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

I hope we're not expecting too much of Mr de Boer or, worse still, that he's expecting too much of us. Our team has many good qualities and strengths, but Ajax we ain't. When we play to our strengths, with Pulis, Pardew (before he went nuts) and Sam (once he'd un-Pardewed us), we do look like a decent mid-table side. And we had the potential to be a bit better than that if Pulis and Sam hadn't decided to chuck the towel in and Pardew hadn't had some sort of breakdown. I'm sure we can evolve, over time, with the right recruitment, into a fixture in the top half, but if anyone, including Frank, tries to do it overnight, we'll be right where we were with Pardew in 2016, except the escape artists aren't available this time.

Completely agree but you'll probably get lambasted for this post.

I wanted Pellegrino for more of the same. I think Southampton have made the wrong choice and, let's face it, it was their choice first. But we've got another good quality choice with potential in this division. But, like you say, go for this 'total football' brand stuff could be a monumental error, again. Small changes please, and some of the deep and compact defending de Boer is reported to play vs big clubs.

I wasn't bothered before if Big Sam took another job come December. Now I might be. We could do with Sammy Lee not being taken away from us.

 


COYP

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 25 Jun 17 1.51pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Completely agree but you'll probably get lambasted for this post.

I wanted Pellegrino for more of the same. I think Southampton have made the wrong choice and, let's face it, it was their choice first. But we've got another good quality choice with potential in this division. But, like you say, go for this 'total football' brand stuff could be a monumental error, again. Small changes please, and some of the deep and compact defending de Boer is reported to play vs big clubs.

I wasn't bothered before if Big Sam took another job come December. Now I might be. We could do with Sammy Lee not being taken away from us.

I've no argument with what you're saying. Hopefully we'll get an idea of what Frank's all about in HK. I'm wishing to be pleasantly surprised rather than scared to death. It will be a good test as they're all PL sides.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 25 Jun 17 1.51pm

Actually a fair few more than I'd have first thought.

CAN

Mandanda
Hennessy
Van aanholt
Tompkins
Millovoivic
MacArthur
Cabaye
Lee
Punch
Wilf
Andros

CANT

Damo
Kelly
Sako
Benteke

MAYBE

Dann
Ward
Souare
Wickham
Schlupp
Kaikai


 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who in the squad can and can't play 'total footy'