You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bright v Benteke
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Bright v Benteke


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 14 Aug 17 5.50pm

Who do you think was better?

Similar kind of players, both tall target men.

According to Wikepdia their Palace goal scoring record is:

Bright: Played 227 - scored 91
Benteke: Played 37 - scored 15

Similar records although most of Brights were in the second tier.

Benteke commanded the big fee and is an international unlike Bright however Bright played for us during our most successful period by far.
I imagine Bright also made a lot more assists (to Wrighty).

Personally I think this is a close one however (and it maybe through rose tinted glasses) I would probably edge Bright.


 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Casual Flag Orpington 14 Aug 17 9.55pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Who do you think was better?

Similar kind of players, both tall target men.

According to Wikepdia their Palace goal scoring record is:

Bright: Played 227 - scored 91
Benteke: Played 37 - scored 15

Similar records although most of Brights were in the second tier.

Benteke commanded the big fee and is an international unlike Bright however Bright played for us during our most successful period by far.
I imagine Bright also made a lot more assists (to Wrighty).

Personally I think this is a close one however (and it maybe through rose tinted glasses) I would probably edge Bright.


Benteke gets games for a good Belgium team, Bright never got an England cap , or was wanted by any of the top teams.
But my glasses are the same as yours , loved him , grafted all day long and him and Wright were mustard. The winner against millwall in the 4-3 at home (with Hopkins 40 yard own goal) , has one of many highlights.
He'd be in my all time eleven I've seen and I've seen Benteke.
Like Benteke though.

 

ZIGnZAG Flag Stoke 14 Aug 17 11.18pm

The only real difference.....

Bright had Wright next to him.

Now....

If Benteke had Dwight next to him, now that would be some partnership.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 15 Aug 17 6.09am

Originally posted by ZIGnZAG

The only real difference.....

Bright had Wright next to him.

Now....

If Benteke had Dwight next to him, now that would be some partnership.

I agree. 2nd most irritating thing over the weekend for me was listening to Alan Pardew talking about what a good player and finisher Dwight Gayle is. Didn't he leave him on the bench and then flog him?

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 15 Aug 17 7.36am

Brighty .......work rate, aggression, clever and when the chips were down he would invariably deliver. Great link up player as well, oh and didn't sulk!

 


Bring back Brolin

Part Time James Flag 15 Aug 17 7.39am

Not saying Benteke won't ever get there but NO!!!

 




Face in Wetherspoons Flag 15 Aug 17 7.43am

Originally posted by Part Time James

Not saying Benteke won't ever get there but NO!!!

 

Face in Wetherspoons Flag 15 Aug 17 7.48am

Originally posted by Face in Wetherspoons

It has to be Bright any time. Johnny Byrne and Cliff Holton were also great strikers for us back in the old days. A bit of nostalgia does no harm.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 11 Feb 18 11.58am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Who do you think was better?

Similar kind of players, both tall target men.

According to Wikepdia their Palace goal scoring record is:

Bright: Played 227 - scored 91
Benteke: Played 37 - scored 15

Similar records although most of Brights were in the second tier.

Benteke commanded the big fee and is an international unlike Bright however Bright played for us during our most successful period by far.
I imagine Bright also made a lot more assists (to Wrighty).

Personally I think this is a close one however (and it maybe through rose tinted glasses) I would probably edge Bright.



Just bumping a thread I started back in August.

How times have changed!

This question would not even be asked now!

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

chateauferret Flag 11 Feb 18 9.40pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


Just bumping a thread I started back in August.

How times have changed!

This question would not even be asked now!

Sorry, I misread the title. I thought it said "Bumfluff v Benteke". That might be a valid question.

Edited by chateauferret (11 Feb 2018 9.42pm)

 


============
The Ferret
============

ZIGnZAG Flag Stoke 11 Feb 18 10.32pm

Your still completely oblivious to a certain massive difference, which your stupid to overlook.

One is played as a lone striker.

One was part of a partnership.

SAS Sutton and shearer.

York and Cole.

Bright and Wright.

Benteke and......

That's the difference. Your comparing one man doing the whole job, alone. To another man who did 50% of the job, while someone else did the other 50%.

So maybe.... just to be fair.... ask yourself.... Does benteke do 50% of a job?
Because that's what bright did.

 

OldFella Flag London 15 Feb 18 11.16pm

Originally posted by ZIGnZAG

Your still completely oblivious to a certain massive difference, which your stupid to overlook.

One is played as a lone striker.

One was part of a partnership.

SAS Sutton and shearer.

York and Cole.

Bright and Wright.

Benteke and......

That's the difference. Your comparing one man doing the whole job, alone. To another man who did 50% of the job, while someone else did the other 50%.

So maybe.... just to be fair.... ask yourself.... Does benteke do 50% of a job?
Because that's what bright did.

Think you're on a sticky wicket calling someone stupid....

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 16 Feb 18 5.13am

For sheer guts, determination and a willingness to sweat blood for your team and bring others into the game, it’s a no brainer and an embarrassing comparison!! Mark Bright would put his head where Benteke wouldn’t even put a foot in.
A much better comparison with Brighty would be Muzza and worth the debate.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 16 Feb 18 6.22am

Originally posted by ZIGnZAG

Your still completely oblivious to a certain massive difference, which your stupid to overlook.

One is played as a lone striker.

One was part of a partnership.

SAS Sutton and shearer.

York and Cole.

Bright and Wright.

Benteke and......

That's the difference. Your comparing one man doing the whole job, alone. To another man who did 50% of the job, while someone else did the other 50%.

So maybe.... just to be fair.... ask yourself.... Does benteke do 50% of a job?
Because that's what bright did.

So Benteke must get twice as many chances , as they would all fall to him ?
So the real question should be ‘would Mark Bright have scored 1 goal if he was playing this season?’

 

Casual Flag Orpington 16 Feb 18 6.24am

Originally posted by Casual

So Benteke must get twice as many chances , as they would all fall to him ?
So the real question should be ‘would Mark Bright have scored 1 goal if he was playing this season?’

I think he would be on more than 1 goal, even at his current age, wearing a suit , with Parish playing as a number 10.

 

OldFella Flag London 16 Feb 18 7.58am

Originally posted by Casual

I think he would be on more than 1 goal, even at his current age, wearing a suit , with Parish playing as a number 10.

Parish playing in the hole behind Bright?

 


Jackson.. Wan Bissaka.... Sansom.. Nicholas.. Cannon.. Guehi.... Zaha... Thomas.. Byrne... Holton.. Rogers.. that should do it..

Casual Flag Orpington 16 Feb 18 9.48am

Originally posted by OldFella

Parish playing in the hole behind Bright?

[/quote

Ha. I’d have assumed it would be the other way around

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 16 Feb 18 9.58am

Originally posted by Casual

Originally posted by OldFella

Parish playing in the hole behind Bright?

[/quote

Ha. I’d have assumed it would be the other way around

Ha ha - your on form today mate

Edited by Tom-the-eagle (16 Feb 2018 9.59am)

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Andy_G Flag Wimbledon 16 Feb 18 10.01am

That' not a serious question right?

Benteke or Langley who is better?

 


The ups and downs of Palace have left me older than my years

Fatherken Flag 16 Feb 18 10.09am

In my view Bright was a better all round player than Wright , never stopped running and looking to get other player into the game . Unfortunately Big Ben does not do this so it's Bright for me .

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Bright v Benteke