You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > AJ vs Benteke
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

AJ vs Benteke


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Jules111 Flag Preston, Lancashire 24 Aug 17 11.51am

Every time AJ was one on one with the keeper I felt confident he would score, I feel totally the opposite with Big Ben unless the ball is head height.

Regardless of Bentekes aerial prowess I would rather AJ any day of the week.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 24 Aug 17 11.55am

Aj and benteke would make a dream partnership

Different players. Ones a target man ones a vardy type.

 

Part Time James Flag 24 Aug 17 12.06pm

Originally posted by matthau

Aj and benteke would make a dream partnership

Different players. Ones a target man ones a vardy type.

Bingo. This is like comparing Mark Bright to Julian Speroni.

 




chateauferret Flag 24 Aug 17 12.25pm

Allardyce was on TalkSh!te this morning and one of the things he said was that it's meaningless to compare players from one era of the game with players from another because everything is so different. Very true.

Obviously it was TalkSh!te so they weren't allowed to mention Palace.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Lakeview Flag Lincoln 24 Aug 17 1.27pm

I have fond memories of the A.J & Shipperley front 2 that produced the play-off final goal against West Ham at the Cardiff Stadium. A.J & Benteke would quite possibly have been a great front 2, but the days of us playing that system seem distant and unlikely to reappear-even more until we buy a 2nd striker. They are far too different in play and role to be compared.

 

Part Time James Flag 24 Aug 17 1.30pm

Originally posted by Lakeview

I have fond memories of the A.J & Shipperley front 2 that produced the play-off final goal against West Ham at the Cardiff Stadium. A.J & Benteke would quite possibly have been a great front 2, but the days of us playing that system seem distant and unlikely to reappear-even more until we buy a 2nd striker. They are far too different in play and role to be compared.

That was a great day despite a 12 hour round-trip train journey with every West Ham supporter in the country.

Not convinced Shipperley knew much about that goal, it just sort of ricocheted off his knee if I remember correctly. But I'll take it!

 




n wales eagles Flag llandudno 24 Aug 17 5.39pm

Completely different players one gave 100% closed down keepers and defenders and scored plenty of goals the others benteke

Edited by n wales eagles (24 Aug 2017 5.43pm)

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 24 Aug 17 5.40pm

Originally posted by n wales eagles

Completely different players one gave 100% closed down keepers and defenders and scored plenty of goals the others benteke

 

EaglesEaglesEagles Flag 24 Aug 17 5.46pm

Benteke vs Courtois was pretty sweet.

 


I ain't got nuthin' funny to say. Sorry.

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 24 Aug 17 5.49pm

I think a better comparison is Benteke and Sonogo

 

Reknaw Flag 24 Aug 17 6.33pm

Originally posted by Jules111

Every time AJ was one on one with the keeper I felt confident he would score, I feel totally the opposite with Big Ben unless the ball is head height.

Regardless of Bentekes aerial prowess I would rather AJ any day of the week.

What a pointless thread ffs. Why does everyone feel the need to put our players down for no reason?

f***. Off.

 

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 24 Aug 17 6.45pm

As much as I loved AJ, Benteke has consistently scored goals in the top division for what 5-6 seasons and looks like he will continue to do so. Different types of players. In the record books Benteke will go down as the better. We should appreciate him. He depends on service.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 24 Aug 17 7.14pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

What a pointless thread ffs. Why does everyone feel the need to put our players down for no reason?

f***. Off.

No reason????
Great thread and if Benteke put himself about like AJ and stopped being one dimensional he would be a threat every week. At present he relies the majority of the time on service. When it doesn't happen he is largely anonymous. Not what you want at any time and definitely not from a £30m man. Also show a bit of respect to the OP not resort to abuse!

 


Bring back Brolin

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 24 Aug 17 7.15pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

What a pointless thread ffs. Why does everyone feel the need to put our players down for no reason?

f***. Off.

You don't come on here much do you?

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 24 Aug 17 8.38pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

As much as I loved AJ, Benteke has consistently scored goals in the top division for what 5-6 seasons and looks like he will continue to do so. Different types of players. In the record books Benteke will go down as the better. We should appreciate him. He depends on service.

Maybe Benteke will go down in the records as a better player however I doubt he will go down for his time at Palace as the better player.

Clive Allen was a prolific goalscorer but not during his time with us.

I rate Benteke and see his quality however AJ during his time at Palace was proper special.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

baldeagle73 Flag Leamington spa 24 Aug 17 8.42pm

Aj if only for the fact he could actually take a penalty properly

 


walking down the holmesdale road to see the palace aces!

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 24 Aug 17 9.22pm

Originally posted by fish mitten

As much as I loved AJ, Benteke has consistently scored goals in the top division for what 5-6 seasons and looks like he will continue to do so. Different types of players. In the record books Benteke will go down as the better. We should appreciate him. He depends on service.

And what is his plan b when the service doesn't always happen?

 


Bring back Brolin

fish mitten Flag Chelmsford 24 Aug 17 9.35pm

Originally posted by dynamicdick

And what is his plan b when the service doesn't always happen?

It's up to the team to make sure it does. Even AJ couldn't score unless the balls were put through to him. I thought he was great by the way. I just hope we have Benteke banging them in for the next 3-4 years for us.

Currently AJ is the greater Palace hero. I want Benteke to beat that because it should mean we will have been successful.

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 24 Aug 17 9.37pm

Originally posted by Reknaw

What a pointless thread ffs. Why does everyone feel the need to put our players down for no reason?

f***. Off.

Reknaw no need you ressot it's all about opinions although you eloquently put your view across well done

 

Reknaw Flag 24 Aug 17 10.24pm

How is a comparison between AJ and Benteke relevant, or even a fair one? They're completely different players.

Its just yet another thread to be negative about what we currently have.

Benteke is class, if you can't see that then you've never played at a decent level of football yourself.

Rant over.

Actually not yet; f*** off.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > AJ vs Benteke