You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window mixed feelings
November 16 2026 9.11am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Transfer Window mixed feelings


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
ItsCPFCforme Flag 01 Sep 17 2.52am

Getting Sakho is the deal we all wanted and I am super chuffed but, as with Benteke, we got it at the 11th hour, 3 games in. Riedewald and the loan signings seem reasonable signings too and RLC has been our best player so far.

However, only having one first team striker on the books and fit and one out and out RB in Ward as well as two very mediocre keepers still, I can't say this has been a success. In fact, we needed the Sakho signing to make this Window anywhere approaching reasonable. Our first 11 - assuming FDB swallows his pride- is good, but - my God - that squad is thin. We have been unlucky with injuries in the past couple of seasons so I am AMAZED we are taking risks the way we are. I wouldn't be worried with a manager better than FDB but, unfortunately , I think this is going to be yet another season of struggle with that squad. All I desired is a season where we avoid relegation without a desperate struggle. I can't see us avoiding the struggle; I do see our team having enough quality to just about avoid the drop but I am just so frustrated that we are facing a season yet again with one hand tied behind our backs.

Edited by ItsCPFCforme (01 Sep 2017 2.53am)

 

BelfastEagle Flag 01 Sep 17 3.42am

Any sort of injury or suspension to Ben and we are screwed, it's laughable we have one striker.

 

Michaelawt85 Flag Bexley 01 Sep 17 4.34am

Wonderful about sakho . Scandalous about the rest of the poor window.

 


When I was a young girl my Mother said to me.. You listen here kid you're CPFC

Dodger Lane Flag Merstham 01 Sep 17 5.39am

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

Wonderful about sakho . Scandalous about the rest of the poor window.

I totally agree. SP and the board talk the talk and roll out all the propaganda saying 'we hope to get 3 players over the line' how many times have we heard that before ?
Basically if we do not improve by January and pick up points we will be right in the s***.
We can blame FdB all we like and the system hes trying to playing, but on Saturday apart from one player this was last seasons players on the pitch, also know one knows how long it will be before Sakho is match fit ? so it could be same old same old for a few more matches to come ? we will see
I would not blame FdB one bit if he decided to walk away , although the dutch are very stubborn people by nature. This lack of transfer activity seems to me to be either we are skint or we are just useless at dealing in the transfer market .

Edited by Dodger Lane (01 Sep 2017 5.40am)

 


A Lie travels round the world quicker than a man can put his trousers on

[Link]

Casual Flag Orpington 01 Sep 17 6.13am

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

Wonderful about sakho . Scandalous about the rest of the poor window.

Yep agree. Also that our number 1 goalkeeper has the same sized b*llocks as the lion in the wizard of oz

 

Dave58 Flag Ipswich 01 Sep 17 6.33am

Happy with Sakho. Really disappointed and concerned. I agree we needed a striker, a br and a gk. our squad is weak. I'm not sure what our bank balance is but we needed more to be spent.
I think we lost out on several players who were attracted to other clubs for whatever reason.
I will still go and support our great club, but I now think a painful season is ahead of us.

 

Petereagle Flag Brockley 01 Sep 17 6.37am

Originally posted by BelfastEagle

Any sort of injury or suspension to Ben and we are screwed, it's laughable we have one striker.

We dont know what happened with respect to deals with Niasse and Cenk. Had these happened it would have been a very good transfer window. Without them the squad is dangerously vulnerable in the striker dept

 

crvenaeagle Flag 01 Sep 17 6.42am

Teams are gonna be smashing that right flank all season and we“re going to suffer because of it. Ward not signing an extension suggested something was going to be done about it but apparently not. Getting rid of Campbell (and J Benteke) suggested we were going to be getting a replacement in as well, but again apparently not. Same story with selling Mandanda.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 01 Sep 17 6.44am

Originally posted by Petereagle

We dont know what happened with respect to deals with Niasse and Cenk. Had these happened it would have been a very good transfer window.

Rumours are that the Niasse deal was scuppered by a problem over agents fees and whilst we had agreed a fee for Cenk we apparently wanted to pay it over four years

 

Maine Eagle Flag USA 01 Sep 17 6.45am

Originally posted by crvenaeagle

Teams are gonna be smashing that right flank all season and we“re going to suffer because of it. Ward not signing an extension suggested something was going to be done about it but apparently not. Getting rid of Campbell (and J Benteke) suggested we were going to be getting a replacement in as well, but again apparently not. Same story with selling Mandanda.

We have players that can play right back. Fosu Mensah can play right wing back also if necessary. Ward does not need to be playing. Tomkins can play right back. Riedewald has played right back. Kelly can play right back (he had a clanger last time but can do a job sometimes). For me I would put TFM there with Sakho and Tomkins in the middle. Include Riedewald/Dann if its 3 centre backs with other as cover. Dont get me wrong, I am not saying I am happy about what Parish and Freedman just pulled off, but we dont need to be playing Joel Ward anyway.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 01 Sep 17 6.46am

all stay fit with manager showing pragmatism and social skills: top 8 form, no bother
key men injured and 343: relegation form

Parish rolled the dice big time. when's Wilf back?


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

crvenaeagle Flag 01 Sep 17 6.48am

"Board to back struggling Fdb" all the headlines read in these last few days.
Pish. We all know that Parish“ skills lie with public image, it“s how he made his millions after all, so getting the above into public eye is very pretty, but Palace fans are starting to see through it now.
As somebody else stated, Sakho is a Parish signing, not FdB. All they“ve given him is eight million and two loanees.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 01 Sep 17 7.35am

Originally posted by Michaelawt85

Wonderful about sakho . Scandalous about the rest of the poor window.

Agree with this

 

becky Flag over the moon 01 Sep 17 7.59am

Interesting reading the comments on the transfer window, and for the most part I would agree with them, but a lot of blame for the shambles seems to be being thrown about willy-nilly, so, trying to take a balanced view here's a few thoughts.........

Lots of complaints we should have gone earlier for Sakho and just paid the £30 mill and not wasted 3 games: well we actually saved £6 MILLION and got a player who is STILL not fit (so would not have played those three games anyway). This is who the biggest mob were baying for and this is who you got, so stop complaining and let's hope that he will be the saviour that everyone thinks he will!


Two wonderful contrasting views going on - a) the board did not back Frank in the transfer window and b) Frank has no experience in the EPL - so was it that the board did not back him or did Frank actually not know who he wanted for the club to be able to go in for them if he is that unfamiliar with English team players? Easier to blame Parish for it all though.


We didn't get a striker, we didn't get a goalie...... just look at our record over the past few years: a revolving door of managers and of players in/out of favour with each change, a relegation struggle every year - possibly we are not the most attractive club to a player with ambition, and sadly even the best fans in the EPL can't advance any players' career in world football.

As for the reported admin cock-up on one deal - well is anyone who has ever dealt with the box office really surprised at that..........

We will never know what went on behind the scenes in the weeks, days and hours before the deadline - perhaps we were actually better off in the old -pre digital media days, when the first anyone knew about a transfer was the earlier of them playing in a match or the weekly publication of the Croydon Addo...

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

rob1969 Flag Banstead Surrey 01 Sep 17 9.42am

Good post Becky !

 

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 01 Sep 17 10.07am

Good post Becky.
As a window or a deadline day it has me baffled. The early 3 signings/loans were clearly FdB influenced, everything since then baffling.
We signed an injured player who won't be ready for about a month and I'm not even sure the manager even wanted him. Much is expected of Sakho and I hope many are right and he will be a big influence off the pitch, which always helps.
The word leaked is FdB is on borrowed time and I have to assume that's true as no leak has come out denying or even backing the manager. So was this the force Frank to walk deadline day, cos he surely can't be happy?
We are weak at rb/rwb, keeper and centre forward and none of these issues were addressed. I'd say the happiest people with that deadline day are Wayne, Jules, Ladapo and Anderson. We have to hope that the new Harry Kane is bursting to get out of one of those two.
We failed to remove the dead wood on big wages and only really offloaded some youth prospects. Do we only have one negotiator with a landline? As Becky pointed out we aren't as attractive as we think we are and at least we haven't lumbered ourselves with more dead wood on big wages.
I'm old enough now to be more rational and I'll never be abusive to the people who represent our club on or off the field, but I am concerned with developments.
The next window will be massive and Dougie will be well settled in so hopefully we can get some real business done.
Finally we need someone (Parish) to come out and explain the financial situation, cos earning £100m a year from TV plus commercial business and claiming to be broke needs explaining to idiots like me? It's not as if we're currently spending £200m on stadium and infrastructure improvements is it?


Edited by Dangermouse (01 Sep 2017 10.08am)

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 01 Sep 17 11.07am

Personally I think all those on here pinning their hopes on Sakho being a saviour are setting themselves up for disappointment.

1) He's not yet fully fit
2) I have my doubts that he can play in a back 3 (should FdB persist with it) and he'd need time to adjust
3) We need more than a CB...we need a Keeper and a Striker (as we all know)

So by putting all your faith in one player to address our deficiencies is unfair on him.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

chateauferret Flag 01 Sep 17 11.31am

Originally posted by Lyons550

Personally I think all those on here pinning their hopes on Sakho being a saviour are setting themselves up for disappointment.

1) He's not yet fully fit
2) I have my doubts that he can play in a back 3 (should FdB persist with it) and he'd need time to adjust
3) We need more than a CB...we need a Keeper and a Striker (as we all know)

So by putting all your faith in one player to address our deficiencies is unfair on him.

But nobody can dispute that we need a world-class centre back and a defensive leader under either system and Sakho is both of those things.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Sep 17 11.46am

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

all stay fit with manager showing pragmatism and social skills: top 8 form, no bother
key men injured and 343: relegation form

Parish rolled the dice big time. when's Wilf back?


I agree but change that to top 17.,

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 01 Sep 17 11.47am

Who did we make the admin c0ck up with?

 


COYP

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Transfer Window mixed feelings