You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Mane red card
November 22 2026 8.28pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Mane red card


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Icepick Tony Flag Chester 09 Sep 17 1.38pm

Hope Ederson is ok, looked a nasty one. No intent from Mane though but it brings back memories of Calvin Andrews and his karate kick to the keepers face.

I often think that keepers get too much protection from the ref but incidents like this show how much they throw themselves in the way.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

Bearcage Flag Welling 09 Sep 17 1.51pm

Originally posted by Icepick Tony

Hope Ederson is ok, looked a nasty one. No intent from Mane though but it brings back memories of Calvin Andrews and his karate kick to the keepers face.

I often think that keepers get too much protection from the ref but incidents like this show how much they throw themselves in the way.

If your foot is that high it's you that is playing dangerously if it connects with someone's face. Red card every day of the week.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 09 Sep 17 1.58pm

Originally posted by Bearcage

If your foot is that high it's you that is playing dangerously if it connects with someone's face. Red card every day of the week.

Agree 100%, intent or not, it's dangerous play. Hearing that the keeper may have cheekbone and jaw fractures, hope it's not the case and just some bad bruising.

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

NickinOX Flag Sailing country. 09 Sep 17 2.02pm

Spot on. Whether there was intent or not that is seriously dangerous play. That should be a red card all day long.

 


If you come to a fork in the road, take it.

youngpalacefan111 Flag 09 Sep 17 2.03pm

Hope the Keeper recoverers quickly however he was down for 10 mins and got stretched off for a fracture in his jaw? Come on now, footballers are the biggest pussies in the world of sports.

 

Icepick Tony Flag Chester 09 Sep 17 2.12pm

Originally posted by youngpalacefan111

Hope the Keeper recoverers quickly however he was down for 10 mins and got stretched off for a fracture in his jaw? Come on now, footballers are the biggest pussies in the world of sports.

I would imagine it's more down to the medical team worrying about neck injuries than the keeper himself but having never run full pelt into the studs of someone else running full pelt I can't be sure....

 


"They got his own song 'He's just too good for you', it's quite unbelievable but when you see it and he's facing up someone - I actually feel sorry for them, 'Cos he actually is" - Ian Holloway

youngpalacefan111 Flag 09 Sep 17 2.43pm

fair enough, though i would say you don't see that many stoppages in say the NFL unless somebody is seriously injured and thats 2 250lbs men smashing into each other head first. Or in Muay thai where people are having shinbones smashed into there skulls, or boxing where they've been knocked out cold. To me it seems that they are made of soft stuff.

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 09 Sep 17 2.43pm

One of those where you see it being given a yellow sometimes but it obviously did endanger the keeper despite no malice from Mane. Shame as it spoiled the game.

City obviously went on to win at a canter however against 11 their back 3(5) were all over the place at times. Just shows how difficult the system is to master even when you have supposed high quality players/manager. Does make you think if they struggle at it then how the hell will we pull it off with the likes of Kelly still lurking around!

Edited by samprior (09 Sep 2017 2.44pm)

 

youngpalacefan111 Flag 09 Sep 17 2.43pm

wasn't meant as just a dig on the city lad just footballers in general.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 09 Sep 17 7.41pm

Should Mane have been sent off today? Maybe, maybe not. His foot was chest high, the keeper's head was below shoulder height.

Should bicycle kicks/overhead kicks be banned in that case? Should a foot over waist height be a foul? Is it only if a player is stupid/brave enough to put his head in the way?

Take a look at this Benteke bicycle kick for Liverpool v Manchester United. Had the Man U defender not have bottled it he'd have lost his head yet the goal counted.

So, should this type of goal be banned?

[Link]

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Sep 17 7.56pm

Mane came lunging in and both feet were off the ground when his high foot made contact so a definite 'Red' for me.

 

TheExpatEagle Flag 09 Sep 17 8.41pm

Originally posted by Willo

Mane came lunging in and both feet were off the ground when his high foot made contact so a definite 'Red' for me.

Pick a bicycle lick or overhead kick and both feet are of the ground. Mane didn't lunge he went for a chest high ball, the keeper put his head down to get it.

So, no over waist high kicking and no below the shoulder heading.

Wait, how do we enforce this for different height players?

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 09 Sep 17 9.20pm

Frank as a CB scored an overhead kick in the box for Ajax. Ahead of his time. Hopefully not ahead of our's.

It wasn't like Pele in Escape to victory. More of a ball hanging and only way to make use of it was to spoon it behind himself at goal. Wasn't a bicycle kick as it was kicking foot from floor straight to ball without other foot leading. Great skill though.

Edited by Rudi Hedman (09 Sep 2017 9.26pm)

 


COYP

Direwolf Flag Lincoln 09 Sep 17 9.41pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Should Mane have been sent off today? Maybe, maybe not. His foot was chest high, the keeper's head was below shoulder height.

Should bicycle kicks/overhead kicks be banned in that case? Should a foot over waist height be a foul? Is it only if a player is stupid/brave enough to put his head in the way?

Take a look at this Benteke bicycle kick for Liverpool v Manchester United. Had the Man U defender not have bottled it he'd have lost his head yet the goal counted.

So, should this type of goal be banned?

[Link]



There was a Jerome goal against us at Norwich a couple of seasons back that was disallowed because the ref thought it dangerous. Was rather contentious at the time

 

teedee Flag Croydon 09 Sep 17 10.24pm

Shame Moss missed so many fouls on Zaha when we played Huddersfield

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 09 Sep 17 11.21pm

Originally posted by TheExpatEagle

Pick a bicycle lick or overhead kick and both feet are of the ground. Mane didn't lunge he went for a chest high ball, the keeper put his head down to get it.

So, no over waist high kicking and no below the shoulder heading.

Wait, how do we enforce this for different height players?

Mane DID lunge in - Both feet of the ground, foot high in order to make contact with the ball.And he knew there was an on-rushing keeper so totally reckless.

My goodness if that was our keeper and a player made a similar contact our supporters would be incensed if a red card was not brandished with cries that the referee had "Bottled it". You can just imagine the vitriol on HOL if this had happened !

I have had the opportunity to speak to some people (Not Palace supporters) and a couple of non-league referees (Good standard) and they all agree that it was a 'Red'.

Edited by Willo (09 Sep 2017 11.22pm)

 

Bearcage Flag Welling 09 Sep 17 11.25pm

Reckless and dangerous,
[Link]
Red every time

 

Pure Palace Flag Worthing 10 Sep 17 10.15am

I have seen pictures of injured goalkeeper with stitches and plasters on one side of his face, then the other ... no doubt he was hurt, but what was that all about?

 

moylerg Flag Cofton Hackett, Worcestershire 10 Sep 17 10.42am

Originally posted by Pure Palace

I have seen pictures of injured goalkeeper with stitches and plasters on one side of his face, then the other ... no doubt he was hurt, but what was that all about?

Shaving injury?

 


Most certainly not European.

TheExpatEagle Flag 10 Sep 17 11.54am

Originally posted by Willo

Mane DID lunge in - Both feet of the ground, foot high in order to make contact with the ball.And he knew there was an on-rushing keeper so totally reckless.

My goodness if that was our keeper and a player made a similar contact our supporters would be incensed if a red card was not brandished with cries that the referee had "Bottled it". You can just imagine the vitriol on HOL if this had happened !

I have had the opportunity to speak to some people (Not Palace supporters) and a couple of non-league referees (Good standard) and they all agree that it was a 'Red'.

Edited by Willo (09 Sep 2017 11.22pm)

Yes, Mane jumped to win the ball. Yes both feet were off the ground. The fact he was a goalkeeper makes no difference, it was outside the box so he was an outfield player.

No, I would not be incensed if it were our keeper. I'm more even minded than that.

But, the keeper had his head below shoulder height. Does that make a difference? Maybe not. Mane had his feet above waist height, so what made this a foul?

Was it the contact? The high boot? The fact the keeper didn't pull out?

Pick any bicycle kick goal and they are all, without exception, dangerous and would be red card offences if the defenders didn't bottle it.

This is a prime example, Benteke's for Liverpool v Man U. [Link]

So football needs a conversation about if a high boot, in any circumstance, is a foul or not. If so the introduction of another player's head should not be the deciding factor to it being a foul because it means the defender being brave is what makes or breaks the referee's decision.

We then have to decide what is too high. Benteke is taller than Cabaye so one player's head height is safe another is dangerous.

Should we say no player should put his head below shoulder height? What is shoulder height?

If a player goes to kick a ball at waist height but another player stoops to head the ball is it dangerous play?

I am glad I am not a referee because there are too many variables in play so just make it black and white. Any foot above waist height is a foul regardless of proximity of opposing players.

The attached screen grab doesn't accurately reflect how the Man U player almost got his head kicked in.

Edited by TheExpatEagle (10 Sep 2017 11.57am)

CHRISTIAN BENTEKE BICYCLE KICK GOAL VS MANCHESTER UNITED [720p].mp4_20170910_125608.981.jpg Attachment: CHRISTIAN BENTEKE BICYCLE KICK GOAL VS MANCHESTER UNITED [720p].mp4_20170910_125608.981.jpg (225.90Kb)

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Mane red card