You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So What Did Roy Learn From Today?
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

So What Did Roy Learn From Today?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Brinscall Eagle Flag Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 16 Sep 17 5.17pm

Ok he saw us train for a couple of days and quite correctly went with the same team that lost but did reasonably well at Burnley just replacing Lee with RLC. Good move to try to keep the spirit shown last week going.
We all agree we were rubbish today so what did the match show Roy.
First I would say Luka stood out like a shining light when he came on. Sclupp is not a full back. Ward and Puncheon are not good enough. McAurther is too slow and Cabye had a " I was not interested game" Benteke is so isolated and he will lose interest if not given the service.
He will have to use the next no pressure games against Citeh Manure and Zchelski to sort out a better 11 for when the winnable games come along.

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 17 Sep 17 8.18am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

Ok he saw us train for a couple of days and quite correctly went with the same team that lost but did reasonably well at Burnley just replacing Lee with RLC. Good move to try to keep the spirit shown last week going.
We all agree we were rubbish today so what did the match show Roy.
First I would say Luka stood out like a shining light when he came on. Sclupp is not a full back. Ward and Puncheon are not good enough. McAurther is too slow and Cabye had a " I was not interested game" Benteke is so isolated and he will lose interest if not given the service.
He will have to use the next no pressure games against Citeh Manure and Zchelski to sort out a better 11 for when the winnable games come along.

Spot On

 

MKCPFC Flag Spain/MK 17 Sep 17 8.26am

Originally posted by Brinscall Eagle

Ok he saw us train for a couple of days and quite correctly went with the same team that lost but did reasonably well at Burnley just replacing Lee with RLC. Good move to try to keep the spirit shown last week going.
We all agree we were rubbish today so what did the match show Roy.
First I would say Luka stood out like a shining light when he came on. Sclupp is not a full back. Ward and Puncheon are not good enough. McAurther is too slow and Cabye had a " I was not interested game" Benteke is so isolated and he will lose interest if not given the service.
He will have to use the next no pressure games against Citeh Manure and Zchelski to sort out a better 11 for when the winnable games come along.

You are right , I hope he learnt Luka should be in the first XI, Frank did his best to ruin him by playing him at the the back pre season and then making him his favourite player to substitute.
Cabaye has started playing like he did under Pardew again, we can hope if Luka is played in correct position it will help Cabaye get back to how he can play.
I also think he may have learnt TMF is really quick but may well serve us better as a full back when Sakho is fit.
You are also right that he has 3 games with no real expectation to try and get the players drilled into an effective unit and system that will suit them and the premiership like what should have been done pre season.

 

Dodger Lane Flag Merstham 17 Sep 17 9.12am

One thing that stood out today and has done from week 2 is that "we are a one player team " Wilf missing the rest cannot function .

Another thing that stood out and has done for the last year is Ward and Pucheon are below the required standard Along with a few others.

A must when fit is Sakho to be made Captain with out delay .

 


A Lie travels round the world quicker than a man can put his trousers on

[Link]

Sportyteacher Flag London 17 Sep 17 9.13am

The real battle ahead in next 3 games is to at least battle it out for three draws working on defence frailties and building up from there. It may not look glamorous but it's about getting points on the board against top teams and gaining confidence to then chalk up key wins afterwards (by which time we should have essential players like Zaha back playing)

If Benteke gets injured then we have had it given that January window is too far away and we'd hardly be an attractive proposition for strikers wanting to join when rooted at the foot of the table.

 

The Dolphin Flag 17 Sep 17 9.19am

I am not a fan of Roy but his extended post match interview showed that he could see what was wrong and so for that I for one am hopeful.
He is just not inspiring to me though.
The problems are there for all to see though as per the OP.
Dropping Puncheon is a must - he is causing problems all over the pitch in my opinion.

 

eagleheath Flag Burgess Hill 17 Sep 17 9.28am

That Ward and Puncheon shouldn't be anywhere near the first team.

 

chateauferret Flag 17 Sep 17 9.53am

That if he is still here next season he had better keep Tuesday nights free.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Username Flag Horsham 17 Sep 17 2.06pm

Ward will give you absolutely everything, it was noticeable how in the depths of injury time our RB was playing a 1-2 with our CB and trying to get a shot off, but long term I find it hard to believe we wouldn't be better with Fosu Mensah at right back. Similarly, as bad as PVA might have been against Swansea, I just think he's a better left back than Schlupp. I would also rather have Schlupp coming off the bench than Lee or Sako as I think his pace and determination might be more userful.

Puncheon, really poor today, and on top of that his role as captain was a bit dodgy, on a yellow and having to get a talking to from the referee. If he's not going to be a leader, then what is he bringing?

Despite Luka's poor first couple of games, he showed yesterday why he's so vital. Not just defensively, but when he came on we suddenly had two players in him and Cabaye who have the ability to move the ball quickly and switch play. It also allows both Cabaye and RLC to get forward.

Cabaye can still play, the build up to RLC's first chance was masterful, the way Cabaye played about four short passes and got the ball back, all the while moving to his right. He dragged three Southampton players with him, then when play switched, they were still out of position and RLC had all that space to run in to.

We are still creating chances. How none of those crosses went in I will never know.

Benteke needs someone closer to him. He showed yesterday how good his link up play can be. The lay off for Loftus-Cheek, the flick for Townsend at the end of the first half.

Most worrying thing for me yesterday was the fitness, it's very reminiscent of last season. We started badly, but the 20-40 minute mark was ok. Then we switched off before half time and were lucky not to get caught out again. Second half we came out and looked well on top for 25 minutes, but then it just looked like we ran out of gas. Townsend in particular looked knackered for the last 20. It might be a rather crude indicator, but when Sako made some positive cameos last season he looked much trimmer than he did yesterday. As a team we look unfit, and that contributes to making individual errors.


 


Employee of the month is a good example of how someone can be both a winner and a loser at the same time.

heath_eagle Flag haywards heath 17 Sep 17 7.51pm

Originally posted by eagleheath

That Ward and Puncheon shouldn't be anywhere near the first team.

It's pretty obvious that moving Puncheon to left midfield / wing means he will be dropped when Zaha is fit.

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Sep 17 8.01pm

Originally posted by Username

Ward will give you absolutely everything, it was noticeable how in the depths of injury time our RB was playing a 1-2 with our CB and trying to get a shot off, but long term I find it hard to believe we wouldn't be better with Fosu Mensah at right back. Similarly, as bad as PVA might have been against Swansea, I just think he's a better left back than Schlupp. I would also rather have Schlupp coming off the bench than Lee or Sako as I think his pace and determination might be more userful.

Puncheon, really poor today, and on top of that his role as captain was a bit dodgy, on a yellow and having to get a talking to from the referee. If he's not going to be a leader, then what is he bringing?

Despite Luka's poor first couple of games, he showed yesterday why he's so vital. Not just defensively, but when he came on we suddenly had two players in him and Cabaye who have the ability to move the ball quickly and switch play. It also allows both Cabaye and RLC to get forward.

Cabaye can still play, the build up to RLC's first chance was masterful, the way Cabaye played about four short passes and got the ball back, all the while moving to his right. He dragged three Southampton players with him, then when play switched, they were still out of position and RLC had all that space to run in to.

We are still creating chances. How none of those crosses went in I will never know.

Benteke needs someone closer to him. He showed yesterday how good his link up play can be. The lay off for Loftus-Cheek, the flick for Townsend at the end of the first half.

Most worrying thing for me yesterday was the fitness, it's very reminiscent of last season. We started badly, but the 20-40 minute mark was ok. Then we switched off before half time and were lucky not to get caught out again. Second half we came out and looked well on top for 25 minutes, but then it just looked like we ran out of gas. Townsend in particular looked knackered for the last 20. It might be a rather crude indicator, but when Sako made some positive cameos last season he looked much trimmer than he did yesterday. As a team we look unfit, and that contributes to making individual errors.


Very fair assessment. Think you may have hit the nail on the head with the point about fitness as Southampton looked much sharper and quicker to the ball.

I wondered if it was just a case of too many slow 30 yr old players but probably a bit of both.

Sako looked hopeless.


 

MPE Flag Maidstone 17 Sep 17 8.54pm

We need a new keeper
Tomkins and Sakho need to be in the back 4
Luka needs to start, he was one of the reasons we got out the s*** last season and am amazed he ain't starting.
How does Puncheon get a game? needs to lose the arm band, the worry is every time Palace are spoke about in the media, Puncheon is mentioned as a key player, I think thats just laziness as he ain't anymore, has not scored since the cup final and is just a passenger south London boy or not.
need an out of contract striker, surely there is someone out there??

 


Just when I thought that I was out...........they pull me back in

Holmesdale Hibs Flag Sydenham Hill 17 Sep 17 9.15pm

Originally posted by Dodger Lane

One thing that stood out today and has done from week 2 is that "we are a one player team " Wilf missing the rest cannot function .

Another thing that stood out and has done for the last year is Ward and Pucheon are below the required standard Along with a few others.

A must when fit is Sakho to be made Captain with out delay .

Agree with this and Wilf missing meant Townsend had 2 men on him every time he got the ball and struggled to get a cross in.

With Wilf injured, I wonder why we don't play PVA and Schlopp on the left, can see them working well together and give us width on both sides.

If/when Sakho and Tempkins are both fit, I'd play them both in the Middle and move Fosu-Mensah to right back.

Luka looked better when he came in but was been average in other games this year. Would like to see the new Dutch boy (Riedawald, sp?) given a game as defensive mid.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 17 Sep 17 9.19pm

Originally posted by Holmesdale Hibs

Agree with this and Wilf missing meant Townsend had 2 men on him every time he got the ball and struggled to get a cross in.

With Wilf injured, I wonder why we don't play PVA and Schlopp on the left, can see them working well together and give us width on both sides.

If/when Sakho and Tempkins are both fit, I'd play them both in the Middle and move Fosu-Mensah to right back.

Luka looked better when he came in but was been average in other games this year. Would like to see the new Dutch boy (Riedawald, sp?) given a game as defensive mid.

Luka has been poor because of the handling of the team and him this summer and into the 1stvfew games. I've had to post this so many times I might make it my footer.

 


COYP

BigNasty12 Flag Halifax 19 Sep 17 12.59am

He's old and we should've kept Frank de Boer.

 

becky Flag over the moon 19 Sep 17 8.22am

Originally posted by BigNasty12

He's old and we should've kept Frank de Boer.

Often with age comes knowledge and wisdom .........

 


A stairway to Heaven and a Highway to Hell give some indication of expected traffic numbers

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 19 Sep 17 8.37am

Originally posted by becky

Often with age comes knowledge and wisdom .........


Too true and I think it's fair to assume that, without the benefit of longevity, the opposite may well apply.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Sep 17 10.14am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Luka has been poor because of the handling of the team and him this summer and into the 1stvfew games. I've had to post this so many times I might make it my footer.

And Luca comes back in and on v Southampton and the boss is back.

 


COYP

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 19 Sep 17 10.36am

Originally posted by becky

Often with age comes knowledge and wisdom .........

And respect...

 

slubglurge Flag welling 19 Sep 17 12.53pm

He would have learned that we are not physical enough. In our three home games the oppos midfield have completely outmuscled ours. Lemina and Romeu on Sat just trampled over our players who spent most of the tome on the floor after challenges. We need a Jedi Mk 2

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > So What Did Roy Learn From Today?