You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are agents ruining the game AGAIN
November 16 2026 8.50am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Are agents ruining the game AGAIN


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Sep 17 9.56pm

I posted that Simon Jordan refused Tim Cahill due to last minute agent demands
Charlton 2_2 and down I think
Asked if Cahill who went to EVerton and got goals would have saved us he said yes but didn't want to be mugged off.
Hindsight is wonderful but was Jordan right
And if so does it make parish right about niasse.
Other factors of enough time to do a deal not included
Just morality of his decision
Back then Jordan was highlighted as a bit of a hero for finally standing up to agents.


 

Goldfiinger Flag Just down the road 26 Sep 17 10.05pm

Agents are business men, Parish is a business man.

Parish thought the last day he'd be in a stronger position to get terms he wanted.

Agent thought otherwise.

Deal off.

Who won ?

Clearly now we have no striker and niasse is knocking them in the agent did.

We played poker and lost.

Not sure I'd blame the agent for anything, but then i don't know what his demands were.

Its pretty clear you leave business to the last days and hours then you might get a deal or you might be forced to pay up.

Not sure you can blame an agent, we was the ones that left it to the last day / hours. Our fault.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 26 Sep 17 10.15pm

Jordan was not a hero. People thought he was right for all of 5 minutes but it ultimately got him nowhere. Jordan and Crystal Palace can't change the industry.

Jordan says he could have signed Cahill and he's right that he'd probably be enough for survival, or Dean Ashton would've been if it wasn't for Dario Gradi, advising him to go to Norwich, but I think it's from Millwall that Cahill's agent used us to flush out Everton into putting the money up.

Having morals is admirable but in football it's wasted and may hurt.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 26 Sep 17 10.19pm

Fair points well made gold
Sort of thought that
Suppose I wanted to be made wrong to think it and that maybe just maybe there was some right in his decision. I'm not a parish fan club member.ironic that it's twice and maybe a similar outcome sadly.
That's the end of that then !

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 26 Sep 17 10.24pm

Do we know what it was the the agent demanded?

Would help to know why the deal was called off.

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 27 Sep 17 6.25am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Jordan was not a hero. People thought he was right for all of 5 minutes but it ultimately got him nowhere. Jordan and Crystal Palace can't change the industry.

What a defeatist attitude it is that if your actions are unlikely to be successful in righting wrongs then you shouldn't even bother trying.

I see nothing wrong in having principles and sticking to them

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 27 Sep 17 7.26am

It's not agents ruining it it's money. Before long the top 6 or 7 clubs will completely break away. It is pretty much there now. Man City were at a different level to us on sarurday.
I can see a super Euro league coming.
We are now way out of our depth in the premier. We don't have anything needed.
2 premier players, 1 injured. Poor direction. Poor ground. Good fans but they count for nearly nothing other than noise.
This has been coming for the past 2 seasons.
I think after Newcastle reality will dawn.
I can see big changes coming to footballs structure. The champions league will become just that. Entry will be based on financials as well as performance. It is coming.

 

Geoff Thomas Flag Tonbridge - 27 Sep 17 8.16am

Originally posted by cryrst

I posted that Simon Jordan refused Tim Cahill due to last minute agent demands
Charlton 2_2 and down I think
Asked if Cahill who went to EVerton and got goals would have saved us he said yes but didn't want to be mugged off.
Hindsight is wonderful but was Jordan right
And if so does it make parish right about niasse.
Other factors of enough time to do a deal not included
Just morality of his decision
Back then Jordan was highlighted as a bit of a hero for finally standing up to agents.



And standing up to them neatly killed the club. They are leaches but part and parcel of the game.

Gt

 


Eagles S*** on Seagulls, Eagles S*** on Seagulls,
La La La La,!
La La La La!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Sep 17 9.37am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

What a defeatist attitude it is that if your actions are unlikely to be successful in righting wrongs then you shouldn't even bother trying.

I see nothing wrong in having principles and sticking to them

It went so well for Jordan and us after all. Unless you get a majority vote you have to play the game.

'Part and parcel of the game'

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Sep 17 9.43am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

It's not agents ruining it it's money. Before long the top 6 or 7 clubs will completely break away. It is pretty much there now. Man City were at a different level to us on sarurday.
I can see a super Euro league coming.
We are now way out of our depth in the premier. We don't have anything needed.
2 premier players, 1 injured. Poor direction. Poor ground. Good fans but they count for nearly nothing other than noise.
This has been coming for the past 2 seasons.
I think after Newcastle reality will dawn.
I can see big changes coming to footballs structure. The champions league will become just that. Entry will be based on financials as well as performance. It is coming.

Our issues have nothing to do with and aren't the responsibility of the league. We're another club that's made poor choices and as a result of them added together may suffer relegation.

The top 4 will still drop points this season. Arguably it's more exciting as 3 teams could win the league and 6 make top 4. Leicester won the league very recently. Anyone out of nearly 10 can go down. It's up to them to get their house in order.

 


COYP

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 27 Sep 17 10.36am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Our issues have nothing to do with and aren't the responsibility of the league. We're another club that's made poor choices and as a result of them added together may suffer relegation.

The top 4 will still drop points this season. Arguably it's more exciting as 3 teams could win the league and 6 make top 4. Leicester won the league very recently. Anyone out of nearly 10 can go down. It's up to them to get their house in order.


Who wants a "house in order" anyway? We are Palace, we are a mess but God I love this mess!! As someone recently said - Never A Dull Moment!!!

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Sep 17 10.51am

Originally posted by thai-eagle


Who wants a "house in order" anyway? We are Palace, we are a mess but God I love this mess!! As someone recently said - Never A Dull Moment!!!

I do. Each season I hope for a comfortable season and if you don't know, it makes it more possible to forward plan, which makes these fvck ups even more stupid and irresponsible.

 


COYP

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Sep 17 11.25am

I get that Midlands
I went totally south. Literally
It's a shame at the time that all the plaudits about his actions weren't followed by more clubs and the presenters who patted him on the back.
Small club,small support
Outside not inside
If a so called big club took a stand and highlighted it then it may have took off.
But they won't will they
Dosh is god.
There surely has to be a set % on a sale or purchase

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 27 Sep 17 11.27am

It went south
I did as well though moved to Kent
Garden of England
Maidstone might be a derby soon !!!!

 

The Dolphin Flag 27 Sep 17 12.38pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

It's not agents ruining it it's money. Before long the top 6 or 7 clubs will completely break away. It is pretty much there now. Man City were at a different level to us on sarurday.
I can see a super Euro league coming.
We are now way out of our depth in the premier. We don't have anything needed.
2 premier players, 1 injured. Poor direction. Poor ground. Good fans but they count for nearly nothing other than noise.
This has been coming for the past 2 seasons.
I think after Newcastle reality will dawn.
I can see big changes coming to footballs structure. The champions league will become just that. Entry will be based on financials as well as performance. It is coming.

Pretty much agree with your sentiments on this and I too expect there to be a breakaway League sometime soon.
Our League whilst still more competitive than most will create a huge gap (nearly there) between the haves and have nots shortly and so they and the Barcelona's, Paris St Germain's etc of this world will create their own game on their terms.
Shed loads of money, lots of rest between games etc.
In the long run it might be more fun for the rest of us in a way - we will see.

 

EagleEssex Flag Essex 27 Sep 17 1.14pm

Most agents are blood sucking leeches who suck huge amounts of money out of the game for their own personal gain, that could otherwise have gone to the clubs to develop facilities.
They are also partly responsible for the hyper inflation in player's wages and transfer fees, which have reached ludicrous levels.
Many agents are personally making more money in profit than most football clubs and it is they and the players who are the main benficiaries of the TV money in the game, not the Clubs, the Community, or the Supporters.

 

EagleEssex Flag Essex 27 Sep 17 1.17pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

It's not agents ruining it it's money. Before long the top 6 or 7 clubs will completely break away. It is pretty much there now. Man City were at a different level to us on sarurday.
I can see a super Euro league coming.
We are now way out of our depth in the premier. We don't have anything needed.
2 premier players, 1 injured. Poor direction. Poor ground. Good fans but they count for nearly nothing other than noise.
This has been coming for the past 2 seasons.
I think after Newcastle reality will dawn.
I can see big changes coming to footballs structure. The champions league will become just that. Entry will be based on financials as well as performance. It is coming.

Got to disagree with you there.
It was only 2 seasons ago that Leicester won the premier league.
We ourselves beat some top clubs last season, like Arsenal and Chelsea and we usually take a big scalp every season.

The premier league is more competitive than its ever been, and anyone can beat anyone on the day.

Its just that Man City are looking incredibly good at the moment, and we are incredibly poor. Remember they beat a fellow Champions league team, Liverpool 5-0!

Edited by EagleEssex (27 Sep 2017 1.22pm)

 

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 27 Sep 17 1.27pm


You do not really believe a single p more would be spent by clubs on facilities if they saved on agent's fees do you?
I have no sympathy at all for agents, their business and their fees but it surely is the responsibility of clubs to deal with it. The complete lack of solidarity in football is the main reason why it did not get stamped out. Otherwise there long time ago would have been a player wages cap and certain standards on how and at what fees players are negeotiating

Originally posted by EagleEssex

Most agents are blood sucking leeches who suck huge amounts of money out of the game for their own personal gain, that could otherwise have gone to the clubs to develop facilities.
They are also partly responsible for the hyper inflation in player's wages and transfer fees, which have reached ludicrous levels.
Many agents are personally making more money in profit than most football clubs and it is they and the players who are the main benficiaries of the TV money in the game, not the Clubs, the Community, or the Supporters.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 27 Sep 17 1.29pm

Whilst there's billions to be made in the USA and the Far East from tv rights for Arsenal v West Brom I don't see any change on the way. Money talks and its flowing in still.

 


COYP

The Dolphin Flag 27 Sep 17 1.45pm

I think this season and next will see the top clubs take it to a different level in the way that they spend money on players purchase and wages and this is where the breakaway will come from.
We were crap on Saturday and they were excellent but they, United, maybe Chelsea and Spurs will start to dominate the rest of the league in a way they haven't before in my opinion.
Arsenal and Liverpool are second class Citizens now and will top the also rans.
Let's look again at the end of the season - I hope I am wrong but fear that Rudi's staement was pretty much spot on!

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Are agents ruining the game AGAIN