You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > My take on things.
November 16 2026 8.35am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

My take on things.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Oct 17 9.58am

In advance sorry if I ramble.
In less than a year we have had four different managers, seven since the prem years. All were backed by the board and now we have a squad full of disenchanted not interested players that have been assembled over the years by these different managers. That's seven different philosophies, seven different training regimes. Different players being frozen out at various times and all this leading to a general confusion about the place a lethargy and a total loss of identity around the club.
Each season a squad needs to be refreshed, but that really needs to be on a one in one out basis in reality, but for clubs like us that's difficult because of the money we have to offer in wages to get them to come. When the player doesn't work out we're stuck with him, even if clubs want him because they can't afford his wages. This then fills a squad place and we are strangled financially by all those wages on our bill.
Too many managers all buying their own players killed Villa and Sunderland and now it seems we are this seasons basket case.
Remember this is not Roy's squad, he bought none of these players in. We have a good 14 or so, but after that nothing. The squad is filled up by players we don't want and ones who are only here to now pick up their money. We can slag them all we want, but we'd all do the same if it was us.
Last night was always likely to happen. We are all bought up being told players need games to be match fit, match sharp. They need games to get an understanding with each other, form partnerships. Last night we threw 11 players together who had none of this and lets face facts, many knew they were only playing in this because they are not in the managers first team plans. Subconsciously that must affect them? How can we be surprised what happened, happened? The ones on the fringes of the first team have no chance to shine if 6 or more players are just not at the races. It all fell into place in last nights debacle and once the wonder goal went in the confidence was gone and it just got worse. Mentally many are shot.
Goals like their third change matches, yet we appear to have no one that can strike a ball cleanly at the club, mentally we are choking on a weekly basis. We start most games playing nice football, even last night, but unable to take advantage because we choke in front of goal on a regular basis. Then the first strike by the opposition goes in and heads drop and it happens all over again.
The club has totally lost its identity and if we don't pick up a couple of wins soon the rift between players and fans will be irreparable, the Souare incident was a very bad sign and then it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Who wants to do well for a bunch of fans who constantly abuse you? Who wants to support players that seem to not care?
Personally, I believe the players do care, but when confidence is gone players become reactive, not proactive, they just play safe, sideways and backwards and it just starts to look like they aren't trying, always on the back foot. The crowd reacts and it all goes s*** shaped again.
I don't run a club, so don't understand how things work, but if we want to have any chance of bringing in the right players to stay up we will have to pay off contracts to free up places. Yes it's expensive, but cheap compared to going down, surely?
Till January we have to win our home games to have any chance. So that means we need atmospheres like against Chelsea. So it really has a lot to do with us now.
Again, sorry for this unplanned,unstructured ramble.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 17 10.20am

Decent post apart from different players being frozen out at different times. Can't agree with that. The only time that's happened is Frank. Usually it's Pardew's shyte squad additions that never get near the team ascits pretty much the same as much as possible, with no competition to raise standards.

The high turnover in managers has this time exposed the lack of scouting and planning. If there was more of that and less of going for the odd big transfer then things would be salvageable. Unfortunately I doubt it is and our 'inevitable' relegation is premature and unnecessary rather than inevitable.

 


COYP

Gidge Flag Romsey 25 Oct 17 11.45am

This post nails it for me. Badly managed from top to bottom.

The only thing I would add is we've been unlucky with the two best managers we had.

Pulis shafted us and I will never forgive him for that. Big Sam left for personal reasons and after the job he did, it was hard to argue. I'm afraid as soon as Big Sam left, I got a terrible sinking feeling and it's still there many months later.

People have suggested that the likes of Pulis and Big Sam left us because of Parish and the general set up at the club but I don't buy that. Pulis is proven to be a nasty piece of work and Big Sam??? Well, one day we'll find out why he left.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 17 11.54am

If we go down then the one thing that gives me some confidence is Freedman wll be looking into major football decisions. He isn't qualified for this level yet but I feel he could be for the championship. I just hope Parish lets DF make the calls because, let's face it, we're wasting our time thinking Parish should be. Start looking into managers now in case Roy doesn't want it, FFS.

 


COYP

Pierre Flag Purley 25 Oct 17 12.12pm

Your right it's not Roy's squad. But he accepted the job!
However last night was an excellent chance for those chosen 11 to exhibit/showcase exactly what they are capable of. Of course they care but did it really show in 90 minutes in terms of application, determination and effort?
For 30 minutes they played well but then it started to turn BC upped the physicality, Palace didn't match them and the confidence started to evaporate.
Supporters were magnificent and deserved far more from the players last night.

None of those players enhanced their pedigrees after last night in fact some senior players who should have worked harder, rallied and cajoled the others were even worse.


Also set pieces again we are fragile in defence yet we cause no threat ourselves, why?

Last night In a word embarrassing!
The Souare incident was a disgrace as any true Palace fan would not dream of doing that to Pape after all he has been through!

Also once again not having a quality striker cost us big time!


 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 17 12.26pm

Originally posted by Pierre

Your right it's not Roy's squad. But he accepted the job!
However last night was an excellent chance for those chosen 11 to exhibit/showcase exactly what they are capable of. Of course they care but did it really show in 90 minutes in terms of application, determination and effort?
For 30 minutes they played well but then it started to turn BC upped the physicality, Palace didn't match them and the confidence started to evaporate.
Supporters were magnificent and deserved far more from the players last night.

None of those players enhanced their pedigrees after last night in fact some senior players who should have worked harder, rallied and cajoled the others were even worse.


Also set pieces again we are fragile in defence yet we cause no threat ourselves, why?

Last night In a word embarrassing!
The Souare incident was a disgrace as any true Palace fan would not dream of doing that to Pape after all he has been through!

Also once again not having a quality striker cost us big time!

I don't think you'll find many people falling over themselves to get the job after the summer fiasco, what with the 7 CBs and one striker and writing off 3-however many games.

 


COYP

The Dolphin Flag 25 Oct 17 1.02pm

Good post Dangermouse - I alluded to the managerial problems elsewhere on here a few days ago.
Pardew did freeze players out though - it was not just De Boer - Jedinak and Murray were prime examples and he only used them when he absolutely had to.
We are definitely losing our identity as you say - maybe with some dross gone in January we can fight again and the second half of the season can be an " all for one and one for all" mentality?
We shall see of course but right now the Club has issues from top to bottom.

 

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 25 Oct 17 1.39pm

Good post but I don't buy into last nights horrorshow at the back being down to not playing together. In this cup we have beaten Ipswich and Huddersfield and we were no way near the shower last night. Every round barring maybe the quarters onwards where there is a sniff of a Wembley appearance and trophy we would see major changes. Lack of leadership at the back cost us. Need a strong leader at the back. I'm sure Jedi use to play in these games in the past. Damo could of been a possibility, giving him the armband instead of Punch ?Also this dross gone in Jan idea unfortunately won't happen. Mutch may well go, he didn't in the summer, but he wasn't even in the side last night. Not just him but these type of players may well sink us, that is the worry from last night.

Edited by Booted Eagle (25 Oct 2017 1.44pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 25 Oct 17 1.56pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

In advance sorry if I ramble.
In less than a year we have had four different managers, seven since the prem years. All were backed by the board and now we have a squad full of disenchanted not interested players that have been assembled over the years by these different managers. That's seven different philosophies, seven different training regimes. Different players being frozen out at various times and all this leading to a general confusion about the place a lethargy and a total loss of identity around the club.
Each season a squad needs to be refreshed, but that really needs to be on a one in one out basis in reality, but for clubs like us that's difficult because of the money we have to offer in wages to get them to come. When the player doesn't work out we're stuck with him, even if clubs want him because they can't afford his wages. This then fills a squad place and we are strangled financially by all those wages on our bill.
Too many managers all buying their own players killed Villa and Sunderland and now it seems we are this seasons basket case.
Remember this is not Roy's squad, he bought none of these players in. We have a good 14 or so, but after that nothing. The squad is filled up by players we don't want and ones who are only here to now pick up their money. We can slag them all we want, but we'd all do the same if it was us.
Last night was always likely to happen. We are all bought up being told players need games to be match fit, match sharp. They need games to get an understanding with each other, form partnerships. Last night we threw 11 players together who had none of this and lets face facts, many knew they were only playing in this because they are not in the managers first team plans. Subconsciously that must affect them? How can we be surprised what happened, happened? The ones on the fringes of the first team have no chance to shine if 6 or more players are just not at the races. It all fell into place in last nights debacle and once the wonder goal went in the confidence was gone and it just got worse. Mentally many are shot.
Goals like their third change matches, yet we appear to have no one that can strike a ball cleanly at the club, mentally we are choking on a weekly basis. We start most games playing nice football, even last night, but unable to take advantage because we choke in front of goal on a regular basis. Then the first strike by the opposition goes in and heads drop and it happens all over again.
The club has totally lost its identity and if we don't pick up a couple of wins soon the rift between players and fans will be irreparable, the Souare incident was a very bad sign and then it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Who wants to do well for a bunch of fans who constantly abuse you? Who wants to support players that seem to not care?
Personally, I believe the players do care, but when confidence is gone players become reactive, not proactive, they just play safe, sideways and backwards and it just starts to look like they aren't trying, always on the back foot. The crowd reacts and it all goes s*** shaped again.
I don't run a club, so don't understand how things work, but if we want to have any chance of bringing in the right players to stay up we will have to pay off contracts to free up places. Yes it's expensive, but cheap compared to going down, surely?
Till January we have to win our home games to have any chance. So that means we need atmospheres like against Chelsea. So it really has a lot to do with us now.
Again, sorry for this unplanned,unstructured ramble.

read the manager's post-match comments. This was a chance for second-choice players to make a claim for the first team. Roy was bitterly disappointed that no one performed. It shows that none of the rest of the squad have the character or ability to step up to the starting 11.

 

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 25 Oct 17 1.59pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

If we go down then the one thing that gives me some confidence is Freedman wll be looking into major football decisions. He isn't qualified for this level yet but I feel he could be for the championship. I just hope Parish lets DF make the calls because, let's face it, we're wasting our time thinking Parish should be. Start looking into managers now in case Roy doesn't want it, FFS.

this is one of the problems. We have no plan B or longterm idea of what a Palace manager should be. Top/upper-half Prem clubs will know the profile of their club's manager and be following candidates for when the inevitable happens. For us it's always a complete surprise and we start from 0 when one manager doesn't work out.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 25 Oct 17 2.27pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

this is one of the problems. We have no plan B or longterm idea of what a Palace manager should be. Top/upper-half Prem clubs will know the profile of their club's manager and be following candidates for when the inevitable happens. For us it's always a complete surprise and we start from 0 when one manager doesn't work out.

Frank was certainly a surprise. Surprise SP thought he was suitable.

 


COYP

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Oct 17 2.33pm

Originally posted by Frickin Saweet

read the manager's post-match comments. This was a chance for second-choice players to make a claim for the first team. Roy was bitterly disappointed that no one performed. It shows that none of the rest of the squad have the character or ability to step up to the starting 11.

Sorry, that's just management spiel. Barring some kind of world class performance these players knew they won't be playing on Saturday. Makes the decision to play PvA an interesting one.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Frickin Saweet Flag South Cronx 25 Oct 17 2.34pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Frank was certainly a surprise. Surprise SP thought he was suitable.

kind of to my point, if we start doing due diligence on managers before it's an absolute necessity and our hand is forced, then we'll know more about them and make a more informed decision rather than ill-thought-out panic buys

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 25 Oct 17 4.51pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

In advance sorry if I ramble.
In less than a year we have had four different managers, seven since the prem years. All were backed by the board and now we have a squad full of disenchanted not interested players that have been assembled over the years by these different managers. That's seven different philosophies, seven different training regimes. Different players being frozen out at various times and all this leading to a general confusion about the place a lethargy and a total loss of identity around the club.
Each season a squad needs to be refreshed, but that really needs to be on a one in one out basis in reality, but for clubs like us that's difficult because of the money we have to offer in wages to get them to come. When the player doesn't work out we're stuck with him, even if clubs want him because they can't afford his wages. This then fills a squad place and we are strangled financially by all those wages on our bill.
Too many managers all buying their own players killed Villa and Sunderland and now it seems we are this seasons basket case.
Remember this is not Roy's squad, he bought none of these players in. We have a good 14 or so, but after that nothing. The squad is filled up by players we don't want and ones who are only here to now pick up their money. We can slag them all we want, but we'd all do the same if it was us.
Last night was always likely to happen. We are all bought up being told players need games to be match fit, match sharp. They need games to get an understanding with each other, form partnerships. Last night we threw 11 players together who had none of this and lets face facts, many knew they were only playing in this because they are not in the managers first team plans. Subconsciously that must affect them? How can we be surprised what happened, happened? The ones on the fringes of the first team have no chance to shine if 6 or more players are just not at the races. It all fell into place in last nights debacle and once the wonder goal went in the confidence was gone and it just got worse. Mentally many are shot.
Goals like their third change matches, yet we appear to have no one that can strike a ball cleanly at the club, mentally we are choking on a weekly basis. We start most games playing nice football, even last night, but unable to take advantage because we choke in front of goal on a regular basis. Then the first strike by the opposition goes in and heads drop and it happens all over again.
The club has totally lost its identity and if we don't pick up a couple of wins soon the rift between players and fans will be irreparable, the Souare incident was a very bad sign and then it becomes a self fulfilling prophecy. Who wants to do well for a bunch of fans who constantly abuse you? Who wants to support players that seem to not care?
Personally, I believe the players do care, but when confidence is gone players become reactive, not proactive, they just play safe, sideways and backwards and it just starts to look like they aren't trying, always on the back foot. The crowd reacts and it all goes s*** shaped again.
I don't run a club, so don't understand how things work, but if we want to have any chance of bringing in the right players to stay up we will have to pay off contracts to free up places. Yes it's expensive, but cheap compared to going down, surely?
Till January we have to win our home games to have any chance. So that means we need atmospheres like against Chelsea. So it really has a lot to do with us now.
Again, sorry for this unplanned,unstructured ramble.

I’m afraid it’s the same for other clubs and new managers. That’s modern football and managers have to deal with it.

 

chateauferret Flag 25 Oct 17 5.02pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Sorry, that's just management spiel. Barring some kind of world class performance these players knew they won't be playing on Saturday. Makes the decision to play PvA an interesting one.

If van Aanholt thinks he's playing on Saturday he's even stupider than he looks. Even if he's picked he still won't play. He didn't last night.

 


============
The Ferret
============

JRW2 Flag Dulwich 25 Oct 17 5.18pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Frank was certainly a surprise. Surprise SP thought he was suitable.

Not everybody favoured Sean Dyche when we were looking for a manager in the summer, but there was plenty of support for him on this site, the media thought he was just the man, and I imagine he would have bitten off SP's hand if he'd been offered the job. But SP had a grand vision, which didn't embrace hiring a bald man with a squeaky voice, who'd spent most of his career in the lower reaches of football and was managing a team based in some former mill town on the Lancashire moors...........and who is now one of the favourites to manage Everton.

I know this is a useless and futile post, but I don't speak just with the benefit of hindsight. It's what was staring us in the face as a good outcome, and SP bungled it. I'm just so annoyed.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 25 Oct 17 5.33pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Not everybody favoured Sean Dyche when we were looking for a manager in the summer, but there was plenty of support for him on this site, the media thought he was just the man, and I imagine he would have bitten off SP's hand if he'd been offered the job. But SP had a grand vision, which didn't embrace hiring a bald man with a squeaky voice, who'd spent most of his career in the lower reaches of football and was managing a team based in some former mill town on the Lancashire moors...........and who is now one of the favourites to manage Everton.

I know this is a useless and futile post, but I don't speak just with the benefit of hindsight. It's what was staring us in the face as a good outcome, and SP bungled it. I'm just so annoyed.

Edited for accuracy

Edited by Brentmiester_General (25 Oct 2017 5.34pm)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Oct 17 5.47pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Not everybody favoured Sean Dyche when we were looking for a manager in the summer, but there was plenty of support for him on this site, the media thought he was just the man, and I imagine he would have bitten off SP's hand if he'd been offered the job. But SP had a grand vision, which didn't embrace hiring a bald man with a squeaky voice, who'd spent most of his career in the lower reaches of football and was managing a team based in some former mill town on the Lancashire moors...........and who is now one of the favourites to manage Everton.

I know this is a useless and futile post, but I don't speak just with the benefit of hindsight. It's what was staring us in the face as a good outcome, and SP bungled it. I'm just so annoyed.

I understand the sentiment, but exactly who's vision should he be following then? Surely all of us would follow our vision, rightly or wrongly. SP screwed up, but I'd rather he screwed up his way rather than do it trying to pander to other people's ideas and vision.
Dyche was never in for the job as far as I know and why do people think he would have wanted it?
I'm more pissed off that SP didn't address the keeper and forward issue. These were fixable and obvious problems and to ignore them was negligent.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

Dangermouse Flag Hastings 25 Oct 17 5.48pm

Originally posted by JRW2

Not everybody favoured Sean Dyche when we were looking for a manager in the summer, but there was plenty of support for him on this site, the media thought he was just the man, and I imagine he would have bitten off SP's hand if he'd been offered the job. But SP had a grand vision, which didn't embrace hiring a bald man with a squeaky voice, who'd spent most of his career in the lower reaches of football and was managing a team based in some former mill town on the Lancashire moors...........and who is now one of the favourites to manage Everton.

I know this is a useless and futile post, but I don't speak just with the benefit of hindsight. It's what was staring us in the face as a good outcome, and SP bungled it. I'm just so annoyed.

I understand the sentiment, but exactly who's vision should he be following then? Surely all of us would follow our vision, rightly or wrongly. SP screwed up, but I'd rather he screwed up his way rather than do it trying to pander to other people's ideas and visions.
Dyche was never in for the job as far as I know and why do people think he would have wanted it?
I'm more pissed off that SP didn't address the keeper and forward issue. These were fixable and obvious problems and to ignore them was negligent.

 


That's Life
And as funny as it may seem
Some people get their kicks stompin' on a Dream.
KEEP THE FAITH!!!!!

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 25 Oct 17 5.51pm

Originally posted by Dangermouse

Sorry, that's just management spiel. Barring some kind of world class performance these players knew they won't be playing on Saturday. Makes the decision to play PvA an interesting one.

Maybe they knew they woudn't be playing Saturday, as you say, but they could have at least tried to put themselves in the shop window, given Roy something to think about, and yes, PVA is very interesting, hope he is dropped, but who to come in?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > My take on things.