You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > How Long Before MLS Is Bigger Than Prem?
November 22 2026 8.16pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How Long Before MLS Is Bigger Than Prem?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Lyons550 Flag Shirley 26 Oct 17 10.57am

[Link]

Not too long...methinks

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

matthau Flag South Croydon 26 Oct 17 11.04am

I'm just not sure the sheer distances between matches will ever help USA ie away fans. A think smaller countries historically create better leagues. Spain... Italy England.. The kind of distance for away fans to travel created a following and atmosphere for the tv channels to want to get in on the act.

The mls will grow no doubt.. And will grow bigger than baseball and American football.. I mean it must lol... Ultimate padded rugby and rounders can't compete with the beautiful game can they?

I just can't quite picture the states being the center point of the future of our game... But if it does happen... It'll take over no doubt.

Edited by matthau (26 Oct 2017 11.05am)

 

Fatherken Flag 26 Oct 17 11.08am

MLS is a place that players at the end of there careers go to get an extra pay day or ones that failed in British football

 

Stuk Flag Top half 27 Oct 17 4.58pm

Never. The question should be more like how long before the Prem is bigger than MLB or NFL?

 


Optimistic as ever

iheartcpfc Flag SE25 30 Oct 17 9.51pm

Never. They just don't have the history and love of the sport.

 

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 31 Oct 17 12.12am

Originally posted by iheartcpfc

Never. They just don't have the history and love of the sport.

The love is there Ok, but the MLS is a joke league(I am currently watching NY Red Bulls v Toronto)there is a growing grassroots disatisfaction about the way MLS is run the bone of contention that there is no pro/rel

 


Pro USA & Israel

Stuk Flag Top half 31 Oct 17 2.31pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

The love is there Ok, but the MLS is a joke league(I am currently watching NY Red Bulls v Toronto)there is a growing grassroots disatisfaction about the way MLS is run the bone of contention that there is no pro/rel

Yeah, especially from the NASL teams. Although the owners would hate it, I think it could be the thing that finally got the American fans to truly understand the passion in the rest of the world. When a season goes badly we can't just shrug our shoulders and say, oh well we'll start again next year.

Imagine the mind blowing experience it will be for the fans of the 1st team to get promoted!

 


Optimistic as ever

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 31 Oct 17 3.26pm

Originally posted by matthau

I'm just not sure the sheer distances between matches will ever help USA ie away fans. A think smaller countries historically create better leagues. Spain... Italy England.. The kind of distance for away fans to travel created a following and atmosphere for the tv channels to want to get in on the act.

The mls will grow no doubt.. And will grow bigger than baseball and American football.. I mean it must lol... Ultimate padded rugby and rounders can't compete with the beautiful game can they?

I just can't quite picture the states being the center point of the future of our game... But if it does happen... It'll take over no doubt.

The Prem's money all comes from broadcasting rights. Teams make a fraction of their overall revenue from ticket sales and even less from away fan ticket sales.

The US broadcast market is massive so, as MLS grows its audience, so will its revenue from TV money. And in this country, you gotta make the money first. Then when you get the money, you get the power. Then when you get the power, then you get the players.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 31 Oct 17 3.29pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

MLS is a place that players at the end of there careers go to get an extra pay day or ones that failed in British football

Yes, cast-offs from British and European and Central/South American football abound. But, as the money ramps up, this will change.

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

Jimenez Flag SELHURSTPARKCHESTER,DA BRONX 01 Nov 17 1.01am

Originally posted by Stuk

Yeah, especially from the NASL teams. Although the owners would hate it, I think it could be the thing that finally got the American fans to truly understand the passion in the rest of the world. When a season goes badly we can't just shrug our shoulders and say, oh well we'll start again next year.

Imagine the mind blowing experience it will be for the fans of the 1st team to get promoted!

The problem with the MLS is that in essence it's a ponzi scheme, with each team paying a 'franchise fee' to join. There is talk of the league having as many as 28 teams in it. To join you (usually need) a Soccer specific built stadium usually at tax payers expense. teams trying to join are the likes of San antonio & Cincinatti whilst it looks like poor old Columbus (Crew) are about to move to Austin (Texas)
Further down the ladder teams like NY Cosmos, Rochester Rhinos etc who get solid support have no chance of any promotion know matter how they do...

 


Pro USA & Israel

Stuk Flag Top half 01 Nov 17 3.50pm

Originally posted by Jimenez

The problem with the MLS is that in essence it's a ponzi scheme, with each team paying a 'franchise fee' to join. There is talk of the league having as many as 28 teams in it. To join you (usually need) a Soccer specific built stadium usually at tax payers expense. teams trying to join are the likes of San antonio & Cincinatti whilst it looks like poor old Columbus (Crew) are about to move to Austin (Texas)
Further down the ladder teams like NY Cosmos, Rochester Rhinos etc who get solid support have no chance of any promotion know matter how they do...

Daft, isn't it. As is the fact that they play some teams more often than others.

Everyone should either have 1 game against each team, home and away, or split the two conferences completely and don't play them at all in the regular season.

It's almost as weird as Scotland's leagues are now where they split them in half after so many games.

 


Optimistic as ever

Ray in Houston Flag Houston 01 Nov 17 8.57pm

Originally posted by Stuk

Daft, isn't it. As is the fact that they play some teams more often than others.

Everyone should either have 1 game against each team, home and away, or split the two conferences completely and don't play them at all in the regular season.

It's almost as weird as Scotland's leagues are now where they split them in half after so many games.


The unbalanced schedule is by design because MLS follows the US sports model of having regional divisions (cuts down on travel time/cost) who you compete with directly for a playoff spot. It's deemed more fair that you play more against those teams who are in the same division for this reason.

A good example of how the American model works is reaching its denouement as I type. We have Game #7 of the World Series tonight, which is the decider for all the marbles. The Houston Astros won the Western division of the American League to get into the playoffs. They then beat the Boston Red Sox in the divisional series (best of 5 games) to get to the American League Conference Final where they played and beat the Yankees (best of 7). On the other side of the bracket, the National League, the LA Dodgers went through the same process, beating Arizona and the Cubs. The "World Series" is the final proper, where the two conference champions meet, and it's tied a 3-3.

So, after 162 regular season games - mostly against your own division and scant few against the other conference - 5 games in the divisional series, 7 games in the conference final and 6 games up to now in the World Series, it's come down to one game, winner takes all, Houston vs. LA.

That's pretty f***ing exciting!

Edited by Ray in Houston (01 Nov 2017 8.58pm)

 


We don't do possession; we do defense and attack. Everything else is just wa**ing with a football.

rikz Flag Croydon 02 Nov 17 10.50pm

It will never be big in Europe purely down to the time difference.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 03 Nov 17 1.53am

In 5 years MLS will dwarf England. Their crowds are already bigger.
Once they buy the top players they will be world leaders.

 

Lombardos barber Flag 03 Nov 17 6.17am

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

In 5 years MLS will dwarf England. Their crowds are already bigger.
Once they buy the top players they will be world leaders.

Nope.

Their crowds are not bigger.

 

lefty27 Flag ipswich 03 Nov 17 7.08am

Apart from the fact the clubs have no history or prestige, there is also nothing to win as a player.
There is no FA cup no champions league no premier league title. There is no Manchester United, Arsenal, Liverpool, a 100 years of history and records to beat.
Plenty of leagues have wealth, China ibeing obvious but that will only attract a certain type of player. Also no one outside America will ever watch the MLS for the same reasons.
The MLS may become bigger than the premier within its own country due to population but worldwide it won’t get close.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Nov 17 5.32pm

Originally posted by Ray in Houston


The unbalanced schedule is by design because MLS follows the US sports model of having regional divisions (cuts down on travel time/cost) who you compete with directly for a playoff spot. It's deemed more fair that you play more against those teams who are in the same division for this reason.

A good example of how the American model works is reaching its denouement as I type. We have Game #7 of the World Series tonight, which is the decider for all the marbles. The Houston Astros won the Western division of the American League to get into the playoffs. They then beat the Boston Red Sox in the divisional series (best of 5 games) to get to the American League Conference Final where they played and beat the Yankees (best of 7). On the other side of the bracket, the National League, the LA Dodgers went through the same process, beating Arizona and the Cubs. The "World Series" is the final proper, where the two conference champions meet, and it's tied a 3-3.

So, after 162 regular season games - mostly against your own division and scant few against the other conference - 5 games in the divisional series, 7 games in the conference final and 6 games up to now in the World Series, it's come down to one game, winner takes all, Houston vs. LA.

That's pretty f***ing exciting!

Edited by Ray in Houston (01 Nov 2017 8.58pm)

It would be if I wasn't an Indians fan. Great regular season, f*** the Yankees!

I watch a lot of US sports and understand the conferences, wildcards and playoffs etc. I just prefer a system where everyone has equal games v every opponent, which seems like it should be more easily achievable in the MLS.

 


Optimistic as ever

Stuk Flag Top half 03 Nov 17 5.38pm

Originally posted by rikz

It will never be big in Europe purely down to the time difference.

Huh? Any daytime game is prime time over here. It'll never be big in Europe as our own leagues are better.

 


Optimistic as ever

Canterbury Palace Flag Whitstable 04 Nov 17 8.59pm

I'm not worried so long as this nonsense is going on... [Link]

 


We were somewhere around Barstow, on the edge of the desert, when the drugs began to take hold...

Cy Bais Flag Minneapolis MN 05 Nov 17 12.50am

Originally posted by Canterbury Palace

I'm not worried so long as this nonsense is going on... [Link]

^^ I can't stop laughing. Seriously, I went to a local MLS game in MN and have to say it's not the same as Selhurst Park or even non-league footy. Not the same "sawkerr" is LOL

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > How Long Before MLS Is Bigger Than Prem?