You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Where does your politics come from?
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Where does your politics come from?


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>
tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 31 Oct 17 9.21pm

As most of us know there's been a fair bit of argument from quite polarised and fixed positions of late. It got me wondering how political views are formed. Was there a major event that stirred you? Part of what was handed down by your parents, or part of a group formed by friends or interest groups?

I've generally considered myself middle of the road, but pretty cynical. Much of that came from how pointless it felt marching against the war in Iraq, given everything went ahead anyway. I also read The Gun Seller - actually a fantastically funny book but paints a bit of a grim picture of how the world seemed to me to operate. That and Flat Earth News, which demonstrated the flaws in the way media works, and then I get exasperated about how decisions are framed.

What are your backgrounds?

 


A one and a two...

johnfirewall Flag 31 Oct 17 10.07pm

My granddad attended the Cable Street marches as part of the Jewish/Communist contingent. He then went on vote Tory as a business owner. My mum was a LibDem member later voting Labour and now Conservative despite a close call between that and spoiling her paper.

My colleagues largely vote Tory and friends mostly Labour.

Without sounding condescending I think it's out of a mentality of having been personally unaffected by the actions of whichever government was in power (but possibly most pertinently receiving free meals and generous grants at school from the Tory council) and not working in the public sector or arts. Later Labour looked after me as part of the New Deal which even my more impartial friends view as a bit of a frivolous handout.

Ironically the factors I observe in others are some sort of working class obligation (I've actually been told explicitly this year that I should be voting Labour to look after my own, which is laughable), and on the other side of the coin middle-class guilt from people who never had to worry regardless, but now have rendered themselves poor.

The other daft objection to my stance was on the grounds that I'm just a product of the system. Fcuk me, I'm more centrist now thanks to May, but patronising cnuts like that do swing me back to the right. Suggesting the majority of the population have been brainwashed by the evils of capitalism is one step below the more absurd conspiracy theories.

Edited by johnfirewall (31 Oct 2017 10.16pm)

 

nickgusset Flag Shizzlehurst 31 Oct 17 10.22pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

My granddad attended the Cable Street marches as part of the Jewish/Communist contingent. He then went on vote Tory as a business owner. My mum was a LibDem member later voting Labour and now Conservative despite a close call between that and spoiling her paper.

My colleagues largely vote Tory and friends mostly Labour.

Without sounding condescending I think it's out of a mentality of having been personally unaffected by the actions of whichever government was in power (but possibly most pertinently receiving free meals and generous grants at school from the Tory council) and not working in the public sector or arts. Later Labour looked after me as part of the New Deal which even my more impartial friends view as a bit of a frivolous handout.

Ironically the factors I observe in others are some sort of working class obligation (I've actually been told explicitly this year that I should be voting Labour to look after my own, which is laughable), and on the other side of the coin middle-class guilt from people who never had to worry regardless, but now have rendered themselves poor.

The other daft objection to my stance was on the grounds that I'm just a product of the system. Fcuk me, I'm more centrist now thanks to May, but patronising cnuts like that do swing me back to the right. Suggesting the majority of the population have been brainwashed by the evils of capitalism is one step below the more absurd conspiracy theories.

Edited by johnfirewall (31 Oct 2017 10.16pm)


What would centrist policy look like out of interest.

 

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 31 Oct 17 10.28pm

Having voted Tory when I became old enough to vote, my politics have moved further and further away from what now seems like a dystopian corporate fascism embodied by that party and its media / business sponsors.

State control of the BBC? Check. Rabid jingoism, fearmongering, scapegoating of the poor and cheerleading for privatision in the press? Check. Complicity in perpetual war? Check. Tax breaks for the rich and food banks for the working poor? Check.

Blair had me reaching for the Lib Dem box on the ballot, but the recent rediscovery of socialism by Labour has me firmly in their camp.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

johnfirewall Flag 31 Oct 17 10.30pm

I'm not in a position to write a manifesto just yet, but to give a flavour, I disagree with most things from both sides. Corbyn said something good the other day. I can't remember what, but it wouldn't have been about nationalisation or exalting the poor.

 

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 31 Oct 17 10.37pm

Originally posted by Mr_Gristle

Having voted Tory when I became old enough to vote, my politics have moved further and further away from what now seems like a dystopian corporate fascism embodied by that party and its media / business sponsors.

State control of the BBC? Check. Rabid jingoism, fearmongering, scapegoating of the poor and cheerleading for privatision in the press? Check. Complicity in perpetual war? Check. Tax breaks for the rich and food banks for the working poor? Check.

Blair had me reaching for the Lib Dem box on the ballot, but the recent rediscovery of socialism by Labour has me firmly in their camp.

What was it that shunted you away from voting Tory initially do you reckon? Was it mostly the coverage of the things you describe in your second paragraph?

 


A one and a two...

tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 31 Oct 17 10.40pm

Originally posted by johnfirewall

My granddad attended the Cable Street marches as part of the Jewish/Communist contingent. He then went on vote Tory as a business owner. My mum was a LibDem member later voting Labour and now Conservative despite a close call between that and spoiling her paper.

My colleagues largely vote Tory and friends mostly Labour.

Without sounding condescending I think it's out of a mentality of having been personally unaffected by the actions of whichever government was in power (but possibly most pertinently receiving free meals and generous grants at school from the Tory council) and not working in the public sector or arts. Later Labour looked after me as part of the New Deal which even my more impartial friends view as a bit of a frivolous handout.

Ironically the factors I observe in others are some sort of working class obligation (I've actually been told explicitly this year that I should be voting Labour to look after my own, which is laughable), and on the other side of the coin middle-class guilt from people who never had to worry regardless, but now have rendered themselves poor.

The other daft objection to my stance was on the grounds that I'm just a product of the system. Fcuk me, I'm more centrist now thanks to May, but patronising cnuts like that do swing me back to the right. Suggesting the majority of the population have been brainwashed by the evils of capitalism is one step below the more absurd conspiracy theories.

Edited by johnfirewall (31 Oct 2017 10.16pm)

You reckon that it was the excessive generosity of the Labour years that lended you more towards the Conservatives? Interesting. I'm also a bit suspicious of money for nothing but the dole money is pretty miserly. But at least it is means tested.

 


A one and a two...

johnfirewall Flag 31 Oct 17 10.49pm

Originally posted by tome

You reckon that it was the excessive generosity of the Labour years that lended you more towards the Conservatives? Interesting. I'm also a bit suspicious of money for nothing but the dole money is pretty miserly. But at least it is means tested.

Yeah I guess it seemed unsustainable and I associated conservatives more with working for your money. The traditional notion of the working class was already in the distant past and I had seen family break out of it. I guess there'd be a more significant internal conflict if my grandparents had worked down a coalmine.

 

Slimey Toad Flag Karsiyaka, North Cyprus 01 Nov 17 7.44am

I guess a large proportion of HOLers were politically informed in the Sixties and Seventies, when amongst book reading teenagers it was de rigeur to be leftist (Vietnam War, black rights, gay liberation etc.).

The right didn't really have a widespread intellectual kudos until the late Seventies, when the likes of Milton Friedman, Enoch Powell, Alfred Sherman and other libertarian voices filtered through at the time of Margaret Thatchers's governments.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 01 Nov 17 7.53am

Where does my politics come from? By observing what is in front of my nose.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 01 Nov 17 7.57am

Originally posted by tome

As most of us know there's been a fair bit of argument from quite polarised and fixed positions of late. It got me wondering how political views are formed. Was there a major event that stirred you? Part of what was handed down by your parents, or part of a group formed by friends or interest groups?

I've generally considered myself middle of the road, but pretty cynical. Much of that came from how pointless it felt marching against the war in Iraq, given everything went ahead anyway. I also read The Gun Seller - actually a fantastically funny book but paints a bit of a grim picture of how the world seemed to me to operate. That and Flat Earth News, which demonstrated the flaws in the way media works, and then I get exasperated about how decisions are framed.

What are your backgrounds?


Great question.... For me my political outlook was initially formed by my working class parents...Dinner Lady/shelf stacker & Postman.... They taught me the only way to get on in life is through hard work.

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Mr_Gristle Flag In the land of Whelk Eaters 01 Nov 17 8.06am

Originally posted by tome

What was it that shunted you away from voting Tory initially do you reckon? Was it mostly the coverage of the things you describe in your second paragraph?

Fair question. I soon realised that, despite what One Nation conservatives may espouse,governing Tories proved themselves to be no more than a front for the plundering of the average citizen and the erosion of individual freedoms.

The veil they attempt to obscure this with has just become more and more transparent to me over time.

The only difference with Blair was that he initially used a different, thicker veil.

 


Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 01 Nov 17 9.13am

I suspect that my political views were influenced by my middle-class and privileged background with my parents being professionals and mixing in those circles.For avoidance of doubt, this does not elevate me to a status above those of working-class stock.

I have been a dyed-in-the-wool Conservative for as long as I can remember and I am unashamedly on the Thatherite right-wing of the party - and a Brexiteer ! I am a member of the party, take an active role and of course campaign at elections both national and local.

The dastardly Corbyn and all that left-wing hogwash is anathema to me, always has been and always will be.My wife tires of my vituperation and vitriol which I direct in that direction often with a raised voice in front of the TV or having perused the papers. !

I try and stay clear of political debates on here as there is every chance they would evolve into WILLO threads and as a such would veer well off the subject matter.Accordingly in the interests of HOL this is my last post on this thread.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 01 Nov 17 9.23am

Some of my family fought against da brits. Some of my family were da brits. No more messed up than the average family. Many emigrated to the new world. General mistrust of politicians , flags, ideologies , religions and corporates. A fondness for booze , good food, and a lively conversation. A dislike for lazy scroungers, traffic jams, bureaucracy, bigotry, fundamentalism, ignorance. Nostalgic for living in caves and hunting mammoth.

Background : celt Viking Norman

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

npn Flag Crowborough 01 Nov 17 9.23am

I'm the poster-boy for floating voters! I consider myself fairly centrist, and I've voted for all of the 3 main parties over the years. I tend to do it on an election by election basis, based on manifesto (although I admit that's published summaries not the whole thing).

I've gone slightly further left as I've got older, because I don't really like what I see today as a "f*** 'em" attitude to certain things. I'm in favour of curbing benefits and returning them to a safety net rather than a lifestyle choice, but against seeing people in genuine poverty through accidents of life.

Upbringing was firmly working class, if I remember right, Dad would vote Tory, Mum Lib, but we never really discussed it in depth.

 

johnno42000 Flag 01 Nov 17 10.00am

My dad was a miner and then moved to London and was a docker. A lot of my relatives (many who have passed away due to the dust) came from the Rhondda and the tales I heard about how the wealthy mine owners treated the workers were shocking (and after researching when I was older were true). His mates on the docks were a weird mixture, very left wing in some ways and very right wing in other.

I should add that my mum died when I was very young so I was not really influenced by her politics but her family owned a big garage in Warlingham.

This has made me incredibly suspicious about employers as, if not reined in by certain regulation, I am sure, even today, they would exploit workers to gain more profits for themselves.

There is a flip side to this in the fact that I really do not like the pc stupidity that has happened in the last 20 years or so. My dad told jokes that would probably get him arrested these days and I told these at school and no-one objected. I hate the fact when anyone gets treated unfairly or not equally, that goes for men or women. I think I am quite left wing in most of my views but am edging right in some of them.

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 01 Nov 17 10.03am

I blame Thatcher for mine.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


tome Flag Inner Tantalus Time. 01 Nov 17 10.07am

Originally posted by Willo

I suspect that my political views were influenced by my middle-class and privileged background with my parents being professionals and mixing in those circles.For avoidance of doubt, this does not elevate me to a status above those of working-class stock.

I have been a dyed-in-the-wool Conservative for as long as I can remember and I am unashamedly on the Thatherite right-wing of the party - and a Brexiteer ! I am a member of the party, take an active role and of course campaign at elections both national and local.

The dastardly Corbyn and all that left-wing hogwash is anathema to me, always has been and always will be.My wife tires of my vituperation and vitriol which I direct in that direction often with a raised voice in front of the TV or having perused the papers. !

I try and stay clear of political debates on here as there is every chance they would evolve into WILLO threads and as a such would veer well off the subject matter.Accordingly in the interests of HOL this is my last post on this thread.

What do you think it was about your upbringing that made you convinced the Conservative side was right? You seem to infer that it was partly to do with the strength of feeling in your family, is that so? Where did it come from?

 


A one and a two...

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 01 Nov 17 10.08am

A good number of years ago I was a member of the Labour party and canvassed on their behalf. On the whole it was a decent party that represented the interests of ordinary British working people. Now it is led and populated by crypto-communist agitprop cretins who represent the interests of various ethnic and sexual minorities and show contempt for ordinary British working people.

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

Kermit8 Flag Hevon 01 Nov 17 10.11am

Originally posted by Willo

I suspect that my political views were influenced by my middle-class and privileged background with my parents being professionals and mixing in those circles.For avoidance of doubt, this does not elevate me to a status above those of working-class stock.

I have been a dyed-in-the-wool Conservative for as long as I can remember and I am unashamedly on the Thatherite right-wing of the party - and a Brexiteer ! I am a member of the party, take an active role and of course campaign at elections both national and local.

The dastardly Corbyn and all that left-wing hogwash is anathema to me, always has been and always will be.My wife tires of my vituperation and vitriol which I direct in that direction often with a raised voice in front of the TV or having perused the papers. !

I try and stay clear of political debates on here as there is every chance they would evolve into WILLO threads and as a such would veer well off the subject matter.Accordingly in the interests of HOL this is my last post on this thread.

Correct it doesn't but I have met more than one or two dyed-in-the-wool Tories who are so because it gives them a perception of higher status. Snobs, in short, inverted or otherwise.

 


Big chest and massive boobs

[Link]


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 4 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Where does your politics come from?