This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Clearly a very talented player and we are lucky to have him, however are going to see him fulfil this talent at Palace this season? He is clearly more suited to a central role. Although doing a job, he is not a wide midfielder. With Cabaye out yesterday I would of hoped to see Ruben paired in the middle with Luka and maybe Macarthur out wide. I just feel we are wasting his obvious qualities. He best bits yesterday were when he was driving through the middle. He gets caught too often for my liking trying to beat his man out wide. I know you could argue Roys recent tactic change has culminated in points but surely we'll pose more of a goal threat with Ruben through the middle and Wilf out wide. Yes, although we dont need Mc or RLC or Cabaye or Luka (whichever 3 play) out wide as we have two wide men already. I would like to see RLC playing almost as a number 10. Wilf, Andros and RLC should provide more than adequate support in attack for Benteke with the occasional foray forward by Cabaye/Mc. You are right though, as dull going forward as it has been away from home the last few games, you cannot knock the clean sheets and what could prove to be invaluable points come the end of the season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Yes, although we dont need Mc or RLC or Cabaye or Luka (whichever 3 play) out wide as we have two wide men already. I would like to see RLC playing almost as a number 10. Wilf, Andros and RLC should provide more than adequate support in attack for Benteke with the occasional foray forward by Cabaye/Mc. You are right though, as dull going forward as it has been away from home the last few games, you cannot knock the clean sheets and what could prove to be invaluable points come the end of the season.
|
|
|
Originally posted by MonsterMunch
Originally posted by Eaglecoops
Yes, although we dont need Mc or RLC or Cabaye or Luka (whichever 3 play) out wide as we have two wide men already. I would like to see RLC playing almost as a number 10. Wilf, Andros and RLC should provide more than adequate support in attack for Benteke with the occasional foray forward by Cabaye/Mc. You are right though, as dull going forward as it has been away from home the last few games, you cannot knock the clean sheets and what could prove to be invaluable points come the end of the season.
yep, you won't find many on here arguing with you.
|
|
|
Agreed, watching Wilf play through the middle is infuriating, get him on the f***ing wing!!
|
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
I would of thought when we played Brighton, we'd have put wilf out wide unning at their 37 year old right back all game. He only did it once and the guy got booked.... Yep. He's sh1t and we didn't target him. I just hope this trickle of points accumulated works when we haven't taken teams that are there for the taking.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by spartakev2
I would of thought when we played Brighton, we'd have put wilf out wide unning at their 37 year old right back all game. He only did it once and the guy got booked.... I said this tues when watching the game, wilf would have roasted him!
|
|
|
Originally posted by Loz83
I said this tues when watching the game, wilf would have roasted him! He did in the first few minutes and then returned to instructions in the middle.
COYP |
|
|
Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid
After initially thinking he might be able to play up front I had the end product doubt a few weeks ago. Seems to have the split second hesitation or need another look. I think he likes to set people up and cannot do that at right mid with a whole team behind the ball.
COYP |
|
|
Also may be lacking a bit of confidence but despite his physique is still a young lad.had a couple of fair chances sat to have a shot but chose to pass
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
My question is, if we do get another striker in to play alongside Bentenke, then where does that leave RLC? I think this could a case of a very good player who is just not suited to the team. Hopefully he and Roy prove otherwise and he helps us climb the table. Yes this is the problem I feel, we don't seem to be able to fit him in, centrally anyway. Can't see Roy breaking the current Luka and Cabaye Partnership as they offer more protection. Personally I'd like to see the below, but what do I know! Ward Tomkins Sakho Schlupp Cabaye Luka Wilf RLC Townsend Benteke
|
|
|
Originally posted by taylors lovechild
My question is, if we do get another striker in to play alongside Bentenke, then where does that leave RLC? I think this could a case of a very good player who is just not suited to the team. Hopefully he and Roy prove otherwise and he helps us climb the table. Perhaps we won't get another striker in to pair Benteke; more one to play instead, or come on as sub?
|
|
|
Originally posted by silvertop
Perhaps we won't get another striker in to pair Benteke; more one to play instead, or come on as sub? It's possible, but Roy does seem to like his 4-4-2, to the point he is willing to play Wilf and RLC out of position; plus I can't believe we won't get a new striker in, even if it's not someone of the quality we might hope for. Personally I think Roy will want someone who will work hard for the team rather than necessarily being a regular goal scorer (eg Shane Long type). I do have more faith in Roy than I have had in any of our previous managers in the PL and his surprise selections have generally worked (like dropping Dann and Speroni against Stoke and playing Zaha and Townsend as a front two). Whatever happens with RLC I feel confident that Roy will focus on the team rather than one player.
|
|
|
Originally posted by NEILLO
Well I'm not really getting the big fuss over RLC Agreed that where he is being played at the moment maybe doesn't play to his strengths. And perhaps that's why I think he flatters to deceive - I don't think his end product is all that. Obviously that will improve with experience, but at the moment I think we are in greater need of a more rounded player at Prem level. I also don't think he has a great 'engine ' - without the ball he doesn't contribute as much as he could. He seems to be too top heavy physically. He may be taking one for the team at the moment and playing out of position and clearly Roy thinks he's the best man for that job. Anyway, I fully expect to be slated for my opinion, bring it on... I agree with you. flatters to deceive is the exact phrase I was using to describe rlc just before he scored the other day... he's had a lot of squandered chances - then again he's only 20 or summat? whats Benteke's excuse?
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.