You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scotland's 21% tax band on over £24k
November 21 2026 11.34pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Scotland's 21% tax band on over £24k


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 14 Dec 17 2.52pm

Could be an epic thread.

 


COYP

Southampton_Eagle Flag At the after party 14 Dec 17 2.57pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

Could be an epic thread.

Give it a couple of hours and the usual sh*tfest will be in full flow.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Dec 17 3.09pm

Originally posted by Southampton_Eagle

Give it a couple of hours and the usual sh*tfest will be in full flow.

Lol. It's all the Tories fault.

You couldn't make it up.

 

europalace Flag Europe 14 Dec 17 3.17pm

I think there should be several tax bands in the UK as a whole, based on cost of living. The lower the cost of living, the lower the tax thresholds start. It should be a combination of address and work location.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 3.36pm

Should be flat 27% above 10k across the board
That includes National insurance
that way it's easy to
1_ work it out yourself
2_ budget us and government
3_ stops dodgy accounts as nothing to protect
Then all the employers need to do is top up the NI as they do now.
It's not hard. But blue sky thinking doesn't appear to be easy for anyone incharge lately
Mine as well nick

 

europalace Flag Europe 14 Dec 17 3.44pm

Originally posted by cryrst

Should be flat 27% above 10k across the board
That includes National insurance
that way it's easy to
1_ work it out yourself
2_ budget us and government
3_ stops dodgy accounts as nothing to protect
Then all the employers need to do is top up the NI as they do now.
It's not hard. But blue sky thinking doesn't appear to be easy for anyone incharge lately
Mine as well nick

I think there should be a 30% witholding tax for the self employed deducted at source. When they fill in their tax return, they will be refunded or sent a further bill based on their income. That will stop the tax evasion by some self employed and put them on a temporary PAYE type arrangement. They'll pay the same tax due anyway, so no reason to complain about it.

Edited by europalace (14 Dec 2017 3.46pm)

 

DanH Flag SW2 14 Dec 17 3.47pm

Originally posted by europalace

I think there should be a 30% witholding tax for the self employed deducted at source. When they fill in their tax return, they will be refunded or sent a further bill based on their income. That will stop the tax evasion by some self employed and put them on a temporary PAYE type arrangement. They'll pay the same tax due anyway, so no reason to complain about it.

Edited by europalace (14 Dec 2017 3.46pm)

Cash flow is huge for the self-employed; would kill a lot.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 4.06pm

Originally posted by europalace

I think there should be a 30% witholding tax for the self employed deducted at source. When they fill in their tax return, they will be refunded or sent a further bill based on their income. That will stop the tax evasion by some self employed and put them on a temporary PAYE type arrangement. They'll pay the same tax due anyway, so no reason to complain about it.

Edited by europalace (14 Dec 2017 3.46pm)

The self employed working for an 'employer' are not the ones who could get away with it so easily
The one man bands working for us and the public can cook the books if they want to.
Lots of greenbacks being paid out and how can that be monitored.
Trust and honour disappear where money is involved.
That's all of us for the record not just self employed.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 4.07pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The self employed working for an 'employer' are not the ones who could get away with it so easily
The one man bands working for us and the public can cook the books if they want to.
Lots of greenbacks being paid out and how can that be monitored.
Trust and honour disappear where money is involved.
That's all of us for the record not just self employed.

COULDNT I MEANT

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards robdave2k Flag 14 Dec 17 4.08pm

Originally posted by europalace

I think there should be a 30% witholding tax for the self employed deducted at source. When they fill in their tax return, they will be refunded or sent a further bill based on their income. That will stop the tax evasion by some self employed and put them on a temporary PAYE type arrangement. They'll pay the same tax due anyway, so no reason to complain about it.

Edited by europalace (14 Dec 2017 3.46pm)

There speaks someone who isn't self employed. And HMRC are moving towards quarterly bills with making tax digital. However HMRC being HMRC have made a total F******* of it. Along with the messed up IR35 regulations it's a melting pot of crap.

But with a 30% withholding tax herein lies the issue.

I send you a bill for £20k. I've got £20k of profit and the tax that comes associated with it.

However until you pay me I've got no cash.

Yes they should in an ideal world put a withholding tax on it like in the construction industry, but bearing in mind the amount of s*** genuine small businesses are having to put up with then the last thing you need to do is make life harder for them.

It won't hit people who evade tax (via cash in hand) as you will then be expecting householders (Joe Public) to deduct 30% and what are the odds of that getting paid over.

It won't affect the big companies as they will be exempt.

So what you will hit is the genuine self employed persons who are already at breaking point.

Personally I'd go for flat taxation system - and that's from someone who makes his living because tax is complicated.


 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 4.08pm

Originally posted by cryrst

COULDNT I MEANT

Wtf am I on
Sorry just like a keyboard warrior,

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 4.10pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

There speaks someone who isn't self employed. And HMRC are moving towards quarterly bills with making tax digital. However HMRC being HMRC have made a total F******* of it. Along with the messed up IR35 regulations it's a melting pot of crap.

But with a 30% withholding tax herein lies the issue.

I send you a bill for £20k. I've got £20k of profit and the tax that comes associated with it.

However until you pay me I've got no cash.

Yes they should in an ideal world put a withholding tax on it like in the construction industry, but bearing in mind the amount of s*** genuine small businesses are having to put up with then the last thing you need to do is make life harder for them.

It won't hit people who evade tax (via cash in hand) as you will then be expecting householders (Joe Public) to deduct 30% and what are the odds of that getting paid over.

It won't affect the big companies as they will be exempt.

So what you will hit is the genuine self employed persons who are already at breaking point.

Personally I'd go for flat taxation system - and that's from someone who makes his living because tax is complicated.


Said that earlier Rudi and solves many issues

 

europalace Flag Europe 14 Dec 17 4.24pm

Originally posted by robdave2k

There speaks someone who isn't self employed. And HMRC are moving towards quarterly bills with making tax digital. However HMRC being HMRC have made a total F******* of it. Along with the messed up IR35 regulations it's a melting pot of crap.

But with a 30% withholding tax herein lies the issue.

I send you a bill for £20k. I've got £20k of profit and the tax that comes associated with it.

However until you pay me I've got no cash.

Yes they should in an ideal world put a withholding tax on it like in the construction industry, but bearing in mind the amount of s*** genuine small businesses are having to put up with then the last thing you need to do is make life harder for them.

It won't hit people who evade tax (via cash in hand) as you will then be expecting householders (Joe Public) to deduct 30% and what are the odds of that getting paid over.

It won't affect the big companies as they will be exempt.

So what you will hit is the genuine self employed persons who are already at breaking point.

Personally I'd go for flat taxation system - and that's from someone who makes his living because tax is complicated.


I've been self employed for the last 25 years.

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 14 Dec 17 4.29pm

Originally posted by europalace

I've been self employed for the last 25 years.

When do you think the EU will get around to abolishing self-employment?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

europalace Flag Europe 14 Dec 17 5.30pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

When do you think the EU will get around to abolishing self-employment?

Actually, since I moved to the Eurozone around 20 years ago my business has boomed. Plenty of tax breaks for the self employed in many EU countries. No nonsense such as IR35 and easy peasy to set up a business in many EU countries. Best thing we ever did. How's Thornton Heath nowadays?

Edited by europalace (14 Dec 2017 5.33pm)

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 14 Dec 17 6.40pm

Originally posted by europalace

Actually, since I moved to the Eurozone around 20 years ago my business has boomed. Plenty of tax breaks for the self employed in many EU countries. No nonsense such as IR35 and easy peasy to set up a business in many EU countries. Best thing we ever did. How's Thornton Heath nowadays?

Edited by europalace (14 Dec 2017 5.33pm)

Vibrant and diverse I understand. A fine example of multi-culturalism in action with no 'community' problems whatsoever.
Interesting program on the radio about Malta today, painted the place as corrupt and f-uped.

Edited by hedgehog50 (14 Dec 2017 6.47pm)

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

europalace Flag Europe 14 Dec 17 6.47pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

Vibrant and diverse I understand. A fine example of multi-culturalism in action with no 'community' problems whatsoever.

In my experience of living in several EU countries, no more than anywhere else and often much less. The UK really does have an 'us and them' mentaity, one of the reasons I decided to move my family away all those years ago. My friends who still live there say it's much, much worse now. Still, you obviously fit in very well there and like it

 

hedgehog50 Flag Croydon 14 Dec 17 7.16pm

Originally posted by europalace

In my experience of living in several EU countries, no more than anywhere else and often much less. The UK really does have an 'us and them' mentaity, one of the reasons I decided to move my family away all those years ago. My friends who still live there say it's much, much worse now. Still, you obviously fit in very well there and like it

I haven't been in Thornton Heath for 20 years (apart from some Palace games). Any journalists been murdered by the local mafia lately?

 


We have now sunk to a depth at which the restatement of the obvious is the first duty of intelligent men. [Orwell]

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 8.22pm

Originally posted by hedgehog50

I haven't been in Thornton Heath for 20 years (apart from some Palace games). Any journalists been murdered by the local mafia lately?

Reporter was hacked up in Sydenham a few years ago.
Golden lion pub.
Got a bit close!!!!

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 14 Dec 17 8.25pm

I'm sure if you are in the wrong circle you could be in a bit of bother.
It does go on but isn't reported in capital letters until it's solved.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Scotland's 21% tax band on over £24k