This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Todays Ref !
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
pax3908 16 Dec 17 4.20pm |
|
|
I know we won 3-0,but thought the ref today was spot on!
|
eagleman13 On The Road To Hell & Alicante 16 Dec 17 4.24pm |
|
|
FFS......Mods please don't let Willo see this post 
we'll NEVER hear the end of it 
This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.
|
Goldfiinger Just down the road 16 Dec 17 4.30pm |
|
|
Ref was spot on but Dann WTF. Was he trying to make it look he was fouling, i mean that could have gone against him even though no contact was made. Or did he do it on purpose to get the guy to buy the dive.. ? Who knows, but very similar to the Naisse dive when he pulled out the challange.
Ref got it spot on!
Cabaye made me laugh, he was patting the fella on the chest, saying well done mate... now get off the pitch. hahaha
|
peterg Anerley 16 Dec 17 4.43pm |
|
|
Yes, he gave two marginal calls in our favour- disallowing their goal and the second yellow for simulation. But the tackle on Tekkers was a 100% pen. Perhaps he felt he couldn't give us a third big call in a row.
Edited by peterg (16 Dec 2017 4.50pm)
The right place at the right time
|
pstrutt Busselton, WA 16 Dec 17 4.43pm |
|
|
Apart from Albright-un felling Benteke in the box he was spot on all day.
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.
|
Norway Eagle Singapore 16 Dec 17 5.12pm |
|
|
should have had a penalty when Benteke was tackled from behind, otherwise the ref was spot on.
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 16 Dec 17 5.14pm |
|
|
Guess he didn't give it cause it happened straight after the red card!
|
boo909 Figeac 16 Dec 17 6.37pm |
|
|
I love you lot, as soon as calls go our way the ref is "spot on". Definitely liked the geezer though, can we have him every match? 
Bangell - If Camus wrote The Myth of Sisyphus today, it would be about Jason Puncheon eternally trying and failing to pass with his right foot.
|
coulsdoneagle London 16 Dec 17 6.55pm |
|
|
Thought the ref was having a great game and got 2 or 3 tough calls right, then bottled it for the penalty. It was stonewall, but 4 descisions for us in a row was just too much even though it was clear. I think he was very good but not a strong enough character to make that call at that point.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 16 Dec 17 7.05pm |
|
Originally posted by eagleman13
FFS......Mods please don't let Willo see this post 
we'll NEVER hear the end of it 
A tremendous performance by Martin Atkinson. Well done Sir !
|
chateauferret 16 Dec 17 8.07pm |
|
Originally posted by Willo
A tremendous performance by Martin Atkinson. Well done Sir !
Got some important decisions right and got one very wrong. Still, you set quite low standards for referees. At least this one wasn't crooked though.
============ The Ferret ============
|
BuckinghamshireEagle 16 Dec 17 8.55pm |
|
Originally posted by coulsdoneagle
Thought the ref was having a great game and got 2 or 3 tough calls right, then bottled it for the penalty. It was stonewall, but 4 descisions for us in a row was just too much even though it was clear. I think he was very good but not a strong enough character to make that call at that point.
The ref has to be really sure to give a penalty. Because the ball bounced off Benteke’s leg, it looked as though Albrighton had got it in the tackle. Atkinson’s a good ref. He won’t get every decision right though.
|
deetee 16 Dec 17 9.19pm |
|
|
Ref was spot on to 2nd yellow far to much diving going on in the Prem.
|
PalazioVecchio south pole 16 Dec 17 9.23pm |
|
|
and for a f....king change, we got a decent ref..
i am still cross with antonio valencia for that dive.
Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford
|
Goal Machine The Cronx 16 Dec 17 9.56pm |
|
|
Thought he had a blinder. Got two major decisions in our favour correct in quick succession (push for disallowed goal & second yellow for Ndidi for diving). We’ve had these go against us recently and I’d have been fuming if we didn’t win today due to bad refereeing decisions.
Thought he was also right on the Benteke penalty appeal as in my opinion he’d lost control of the ball (due to a shot attempt which came off his heel!)
Well done ref!
|
YT Oxford 16 Dec 17 11.10pm |
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Thought he had a blinder. Got two major decisions in our favour correct in quick succession (push for disallowed goal & second yellow for Ndidi for diving). We’ve had these go against us recently and I’d have been fuming if we didn’t win today due to bad refereeing decisions.
Thought he was also right on the Benteke penalty appeal as in my opinion he’d lost control of the ball (due to a shot attempt which came off his heel!)
Well done ref!
Sorry I disagree with you about the penalty. A foul is a foul - it doesn't matter where the ball is or whether the player being challenged has control of it.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
kenbarr Jackson Heights, Queens, New York ... 16 Dec 17 11.57pm |
|
|
[Link]
Scroll down about a quarter way down to Craig Burley's video about two diving incidents, one in the Stoke v Wet Spam match where Lanzini got a penalty and ours where Ndidi was called for diving and got sent off. Atkinson's positioning allowed him to see it clearly while the ref i the other match was too far away. With the exception of the missed call on Benteke, where Atkinson didn't have a good position, he got virtually everything right. He's been a top ref for many years and could teach guys like Clattenrat a thing or two about positioning and consistency. He also knows that not even his family goes to a match to see him officiate.
Divorced...And LOVING it! VJRAM Rev. CPFC since Boxing Day 1989 CPFC 2-2 CFC Gregg Berhalter, US International & USMNT Head Coach Jill Ellis, England International & Retired USWNT Head Coach Trevor Francis, International PRAT
|
thai-eagle chiang mai 17 Dec 17 2.11am |
|
|
Always have liked Atkinson ever since he was ref in our play-off win vs Zola's Watford. Made most calls right at King Power. Think he did not not give penalty for foul on Benteke due to red card a couple of minutes before.
|
dreamwaverider London 17 Dec 17 4.11am |
|
Originally posted by Goal Machine
Thought he had a blinder. Got two major decisions in our favour correct in quick succession (push for disallowed goal & second yellow for Ndidi for diving). We’ve had these go against us recently and I’d have been fuming if we didn’t win today due to bad refereeing decisions.
Thought he was also right on the Benteke penalty appeal as in my opinion he’d lost control of the ball (due to a shot attempt which came off his heel!)
Well done ref!
What’s that got todo with being flattened from behind??
|
dreamwaverider London 17 Dec 17 4.17am |
|
|
Maguire should have got a second yellow when he floored Wilf who was through. Trouble was it was soon after their disallowed goal and their sending off.. Refs are up against it to be straight when you are an away team playing as well as we did. If we keep this level of play up we are really going to expose most refs. On yesterday’s show we really are just too good for them.
|