You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Long term thinking...well...actually short term...
November 16 2026 8.08am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Long term thinking...well...actually short term...


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Maine Eagle Flag USA 19 Dec 17 10.44am

We have seriously suffered lately with muddled strategies from Parish and co and no long term approach to squad management. The goalkeeper and striker situations speak for themselves.

Two things are for absolute certain here, we will lose Zaha and Loftus Cheek for next season. The time to be thinking about that is the next window coming up here soon.

We should at least try to bring in a skillful creative winger type, because let alone the fact that Zaha is going to get sold, he could get injured, and that leaves us incredibly thin all of a sudden going forward. Without Zaha we would really struggle, the guy is by far our most important player in terms of goals and points.

We need to be thinking about next year a bit in the next window, not just the remainder of this season. I think we all feel that relegation is now much less of a concern, and with the new stadium plans, clearly the board are planning to still be in the league come next season.

Lets act that way in January and give new signings a chance to bed down into the side and be properly integrated before we rely on them heavily for the next campaign when we could easily be without Zaha, RLC, Cabaye, and a few others. In addition lets cover ourselves if we get injuries to those same key players this year.

Edited by Maine Eagle (19 Dec 2017 10.48am)

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Dec 17 10.51am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We have seriously suffered lately with muddled strategies from Parish and co and no long term approach to squad management. The goalkeeper and striker situations speak for themselves.

Two things are for absolute certain here, we will lose Zaha and Loftus Cheek for next season. The time to be thinking about that is the next window coming up here soon.

We should at least try to bring in a skillful creative winger type, because let alone the fact that Zaha is going to get sold, he could get injured, and that leaves us incredibly thin all of a sudden going forward. Without Zaha we would really struggle, the guy is by far our most important player in terms of goals and points.

We need to be thinking about next year a bit in the next window, not just the remainder of this season. I think we all feel that relegation is now much less of a concern, and with the new stadium plans, clearly the board are planning to still be in the league come next season.

Lets act that way in January and give new signings a chance to bed down into the side and be properly integrated before we rely on them heavily for the next campaign when we could easily be without Zaha, RLC, Cabaye, and a few others. In addition lets cover ourselves if we get injuries to those same key players this year.

Edited by Maine Eagle (19 Dec 2017 10.48am)

We have given ourselves a fighting chance but we arent "Out of the woods" yet and relegation is still a distinct possibility.All very close at the bottom of the table.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Dec 17 11.00am

There could be a big change in type of players if Roy stays.

Less wing play.

No Benteke or target man type strikers.

Less stars and more hard working team players that compliment each other and a system. That takes 2-3 windows as it would've done for Frank and Roy will have had 2 by then and 30 matches with us.

I trust Roy to know what he's doing. I trust Freedman to know a good player when he sees one, but he doesn't have the contacts we'd like. Hopefully that'll see us through because otherwise it's quite amateur.

 


COYP

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Dec 17 11.04am

I get the feeling that us 'looking for a midfielder' is us doing what we should've done on left backs, strikers and keepers. We don't need a midfielder next week but it's obvious that need is creeping up on us so it's good to hear, even if we don't sign one in January.

 


COYP

Maine Eagle Flag USA 19 Dec 17 11.26am

Originally posted by Willo

We have given ourselves a fighting chance but we arent "Out of the woods" yet and relegation is still a distinct possibility.All very close at the bottom of the table.

No doubt but I think we all feel a bit more comfortable now than after breaking a 1920 something record for losses and no goals scored to start a campaign. Point is we should be going into this window backing ourselves to be in the league next year, and act accordingly.

Frankly though what I want to see is that a leopard can actually change its spots, maybe with the help of some Scottish friends, and implement a cohesive long term plan for managing our squad. Its been a shambles for years, the amount of dead wood we have versus lack of depth in key areas is a joke.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 19 Dec 17 11.29am

Originally posted by Maine Eagle

We have seriously suffered lately with muddled strategies from Parish and co and no long term approach to squad management. The goalkeeper and striker situations speak for themselves.

Two things are for absolute certain here, we will lose Zaha and Loftus Cheek for next season. The time to be thinking about that is the next window coming up here soon.

We should at least try to bring in a skillful creative winger type, because let alone the fact that Zaha is going to get sold, he could get injured, and that leaves us incredibly thin all of a sudden going forward. Without Zaha we would really struggle, the guy is by far our most important player in terms of goals and points.

We need to be thinking about next year a bit in the next window, not just the remainder of this season. I think we all feel that relegation is now much less of a concern, and with the new stadium plans, clearly the board are planning to still be in the league come next season.

Lets act that way in January and give new signings a chance to bed down into the side and be properly integrated before we rely on them heavily for the next campaign when we could easily be without Zaha, RLC, Cabaye, and a few others. In addition lets cover ourselves if we get injuries to those same key players this year.


There is no "absolute certainty" that Zaha will leave in the summer and, if he does, that will be the time to replace him, plus the January window is notoriously expensive and competitive. If he's injured again we have others who can play on the wing. I agree that RLC has done enough to secure a regular place at his own club, but again replacement will be cheaper and easier in the summer. Our issues with the summer window have been our persistence with going late to try and squeeze a bargain, whilst nothing appears to happen when we are on pointless 'tours' and SP takes half a dozen holidays.

As Willo has pointed out, we are far from being safe from relegation and we could be right back in the bottom three after the Christmas/New Year games. You can forget about the "new stadium plans" until something actually happens; the whole thing is so long-term that anything could happen and we've had infrastructure "plans" before that have come to nought.

What we urgently need in the January window is at least one more striker and another keeper. Anything else will be a luxury and, I suspect, that money will be fairly tight as well.

Edited by bexleydave (19 Dec 2017 11.31am)

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Dec 17 11.33am

Originally posted by bexleydave


There is no "absolute certainty" that Zaha will leave in the summer and, if he does, that will be the time to replace him, plus the January window is notoriously expensive and competitive. If he's injured again we have others who can play on the wing. I agree that RLC has done enough to secure a regular place at his own club, but again replacement will be cheaper and easier in the summer. Our issues with the summer window have been our persistence with going late to try and squeeze a bargain, whilst nothing appears to happen when we are on pointless 'tours' and SP takes half a dozen holidays.

As Willo has pointed out, we are far from being safe from relegation and we could be right back in the bottom three after the Christmas/New Year games. You can forget about the "new stadium plans" until something actually happens; the whole thing is so long-term that anything could happen and we've had infrastructure "plans" before that have come to nought.

What we urgently need in the January window is at least one more striker and another keeper. Anything else will be a luxury and, I suspect, that money will be fairly tight as well.

Edited by bexleydave (19 Dec 2017 11.31am)

In terms of recruits in January don't rule out any Loan players.There will probably be a Loan fee but this will be far less than a transfer fee.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 19 Dec 17 11.47am

Originally posted by bexleydave


There is no "absolute certainty" that Zaha will leave in the summer

What we urgently need in the January window is at least one more striker and another keeper.

Edited by bexleydave (19 Dec 2017 11.31am)

Agree with the point on Zaha, but I disagree that we should be approaching urgency in January for a Keeper. Striker? Yes, but not a keeper.

I don't believe the level of keeper needed, to improve upon what we have already, would be available. The best we can hope for is a loan move from someone playing second fiddle at a bigger club, but even then why would the other club let them go at the halfway point.

I think we should get a striker in during January and wait until the Summer for a new keeper. The same reasons above may well apply to strikers at this time of year, but I believe that more on-field players would be available and you could take a risk on a 2nd striker to back up Benteke from Europe.

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 19 Dec 17 11.55am

Originally posted by pstrutt

Agree with the point on Zaha, but I disagree that we should be approaching urgency in January for a Keeper. Striker? Yes, but not a keeper.

I don't believe the level of keeper needed, to improve upon what we have already, would be available. The best we can hope for is a loan move from someone playing second fiddle at a bigger club, but even then why would the other club let them go at the halfway point.

I think we should get a striker in during January and wait until the Summer for a new keeper. The same reasons above may well apply to strikers at this time of year, but I believe that more on-field players would be available and you could take a risk on a 2nd striker to back up Benteke from Europe.

It's a question of numbers.
We only really have 2 senior keepers whereas some other clubs have 3 or 4 they can call on.

 

davehuggins Flag 19 Dec 17 11.58am

Fully understand and agree SP needs to plan an awful lot better than in the past. I am not so sure we will lose Wilf, he loves being with us and the fans love him. He is getting paid well I would imagine so its just down to how he sees his future. If we get relegated then this will not apply I'm sure.

 

Beanyboysmd Flag 19 Dec 17 12.15pm

At the start of the season, we were nearly set up for a formation and style we will likely never play again, we got good backup for that style and if we had stuck by it we would have only been a bit shallow in a couple of positions.
Luckily, that style and formation is dead but it means we have weaknesses in several positions. We wouldnt fix that short term unless we financially cripple ourselves. I think we might fix one or two of them the question is which ones should we focus on?
A better question is should we focus on any? Maybe we should just see who is available and if its in a position we need we should go for it. No point in overspending £20m to fix the goalie problem if we can fix our RB position for £6m.
We have some big weaknesses, it would be crazy to try to fix them all short term...

 

babylonjohn Flag St Leonards-on-Sea 19 Dec 17 12.46pm

I think Parish and co have already recognised our shortcomings in previous transfer dealings. That is why they appointed Dougie as director of football last summer. He was only appointed a week before that summer window closed so would of had little impact but this January we should be better prepared. I expect Parish, Dougie and Roy already have their targets and strategy planned.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 19 Dec 17 1.08pm

No doubt Palace will have a price for Wilf this summer and if it's hit, he'll be off. And if it isn't he'll stay. it's unthinkable there won't be bids...the question is only whether bigger clubs will value him as we do.

We can't afford to give him away.

Anyway, the bottom line is we need to have a clear plan for the eventuality that he goes. We can probably use the money on serious upgrades at goalkeeper, permanent right back, another striker. We'd need a replacement of some sort for Wilf.


Lastly and critically there's obviously the need for multiple contract renewals/replacements.

Keeping Wilf, of course, might make a lot of other things easier.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

beak Flag croydon 19 Dec 17 1.12pm

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

No doubt Palace will have a price for Wilf this summer and if it's hit, he'll be off. And if it isn't he'll stay. it's unthinkable there won't be bids...the question is only whether bigger clubs will value him as we do.

We can't afford to give him away.

Anyway, the bottom line is we need to have a clear plan for the eventuality that he goes. We can probably use the money on serious upgrades at goalkeeper, permanent right back, another striker. We'd need a replacement of some sort for Wilf.


Lastly and critically there's obviously the need for multiple contract renewals/replacements.

Keeping Wilf, of course, might make a lot of other things easier.



The player himself will have a say and that will be stay,he is happy,new born etc.It is hard to see a much bigger pay packet.

 

ItsCPFCforme Flag 19 Dec 17 2.26pm

I am under no illusions about Wilf staying forever. But we won’t lose him in January. At the same time, the only thing that’d pull him away is Champs League Football. He is a regular/main player for Ivory Coast already and our salary package is actually equivalent to what he’d get at bigger clubs. He likes living in London and has a young family so it would really have to be the right decision for him. Sure, if Man City or Chelsea offer to double that salary (think: Kevin de Bruyne’s mooted money) he might go for that but that sort of money seems reserved for those who have already made it at that club. De Bruyne is the best player at City and in the league right now. If we keep Zaha and sign RLC on perm in January (who knows?) and get in a striker of quality, that’d show some ambition.

 

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 19 Dec 17 11.11pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of recruits in January don't rule out any Loan players.There will probably be a Loan fee but this will be far less than a transfer fee.

Don't we already have the maximum loanees allowed?

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 19 Dec 17 11.33pm

Originally posted by ItsCPFCforme

I am under no illusions about Wilf staying forever. But we won’t lose him in January. At the same time, the only thing that’d pull him away is Champs League Football. He is a regular/main player for Ivory Coast already and our salary package is actually equivalent to what he’d get at bigger clubs. He likes living in London and has a young family so it would really have to be the right decision for him. Sure, if Man City or Chelsea offer to double that salary (think: Kevin de Bruyne’s mooted money) he might go for that but that sort of money seems reserved for those who have already made it at that club. De Bruyne is the best player at City and in the league right now. If we keep Zaha and sign RLC on perm in January (who knows?) and get in a striker of quality, that’d show some ambition.

Do you honestly think Chelski will sell RLC to us in Jan?!What drugs are you on?!

 

Welsh Eagle Flag 19 Dec 17 11.36pm

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of recruits in January don't rule out any Loan players.There will probably be a Loan fee but this will be far less than a transfer fee.

Willo's contacts sorry I mean his cat didn't realise we are up to our maximum loanees!

Edited by Welsh Eagle (19 Dec 2017 11.36pm)

 

alaneagle1 Flag Dunstable,Bedfordshire.England 20 Dec 17 12.15am

Originally posted by bexleydave


There is no "absolute certainty" that Zaha will leave in the summer and, if he does, that will be the time to replace him, plus the January window is notoriously expensive and competitive. If he's injured again we have others who can play on the wing. I agree that RLC has done enough to secure a regular place at his own club, but again replacement will be cheaper and easier in the summer. Our issues with the summer window have been our persistence with going late to try and squeeze a bargain, whilst nothing appears to happen when we are on pointless 'tours' and SP takes half a dozen holidays.

As Willo has pointed out, we are far from being safe from relegation and we could be right back in the bottom three after the Christmas/New Year games. You can forget about the "new stadium plans" until something actually happens; the whole thing is so long-term that anything could happen and we've had infrastructure "plans" before that have come to nought.

What we urgently need in the January window is at least one more striker and another keeper. Anything else will be a luxury and, I suspect, that money will be fairly tight as well.

Edited by bexleydave (19 Dec 2017 11.31am)

Agreed one more striker.
Goalkeeper can wait until the Summer.
Plus sort a few contracts out.

 


Palace 13th 2017/18.

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 20 Dec 17 8.14am

Originally posted by Willo

In terms of recruits in January don't rule out any Loan players.There will probably be a Loan fee but this will be far less than a transfer fee.

Don't we have our full quota of loans (two) is that only UK loans?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Long term thinking...well...actually short term...