You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Newcastle
November 16 2026 7.53am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Team for Newcastle


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
DANGERCLOSE Flag London 02 Feb 18 2.36pm

By the sounds of it roy is going to start Sorloth So think it will be a 442 formation

Strongest 11

Wayne Hennessey

Joel Ward
mamadou sakho
James Tomkins
Patrick van Aanholt

Andros Townsend
Luka Milivojevic
Yohan Cabaye
Wilfried Zaha

Alexander Sorloth
Christian Benteke

Subs: JS, Fosu-Mensah, Martin Kelly, Erdal Rakip, James McArthur, Jairo Riedewald

 

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 02 Feb 18 2.55pm

Maybe, but could also start with Jimmy Mc in a 5 man midfield and bring him on later when we see how the match is going. Interesting to see what happens.

 

JtCpfc Flag 02 Feb 18 2.56pm

TFM over Ward any day of the week

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Feb 18 3.22pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

TFM over Ward any day of the week

It's not that clear cut after TFM's performance on Tuesday, which was awful. Both have played good games this season and both have had stinkers. I would probably stick with TFM for his pace, though.

I really don't see a great deal of options right now if the Benfica lad isn't ready. I would bring Cabaye in for Sako and have Sorloth on the bench. I know it seems harsh on Kelly, but if Sakho is fit then I would switch those two. Kelly has done well, but Sakho has a bigger presence and pushes us up the pitch. Other than that I would keep it the same.

 

pstrutt Flag Busselton, WA 02 Feb 18 3.27pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

By the sounds of it roy is going to start Sorloth So think it will be a 442 formation

Strongest 11

Wayne Hennessey

Joel Ward
Martin Kelly
James Tomkins
Patrick van Aanholt

Andros Townsend
Luka Milivojevic
Yohan Cabaye
Wilfried Zaha

Alexander Sorloth
Christian Benteke

Subs: JS, Fosu-Mensah, mama, Erdal Rakip, James McArthur, Jairo Riedewald

I think Mama might not even make the bench - but I’m guessing

 


So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 02 Feb 18 3.27pm

Originally posted by pstrutt

I think Mama might not even make the bench - but I’m guessing

Why not? He was on the bench vs Wet Spam. I'd have him starting.

 

Griffish Flag Croydon 02 Feb 18 3.37pm

Hennessy

TFM - Tomkins - Sakho - PVA

McArthur - Luka - Cabaye

Townsend - Benteke - Zaha

Subs: Speroni, Ward, Kelly, Riedewald, Souare, Lee, Sorloth

Roy has said that Sorloth needs match sharpness but is fit so he will be on the bench I reckon. He also strongly hinted that Rakip and Jach are not quite ready when he said we have the same 18 players from West Ham + Delaney fit for sunday(Sorloth in for Bakary) .

 

DBCPFCJosh Flag Hampshire 02 Feb 18 3.48pm

Considering Kelly has been so good recently how about...

Hennessey

Kelly
Tomkins
Sakho
PVA

McArthur
Cabaye
Luka
Townsend

Zaha
Benteke

Bench: Jules, Jairo, Souare, Lee, Sorloth, Ward, TFM.

I know he hasn't been great at full-back in the past but it COULD be an option.

(Just to make it clear, this wouldn't be my team. I'd leave TFM in and drop Kelly to the bench)

 


" Even if I built a 50,000-seater stadium and bought Messi, there'd still be complaints about crap hotdogs."

JtCpfc Flag 02 Feb 18 3.55pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

It's not that clear cut after TFM's performance on Tuesday, which was awful. Both have played good games this season and both have had stinkers. I would probably stick with TFM for his pace, though.

I really don't see a great deal of options right now if the Benfica lad isn't ready. I would bring Cabaye in for Sako and have Sorloth on the bench. I know it seems harsh on Kelly, but if Sakho is fit then I would switch those two. Kelly has done well, but Sakho has a bigger presence and pushes us up the pitch. Other than that I would keep it the same.

Agreed he didn't play well on Tuesday, but when you look at how he played again City he was different mustard, and his pace is vital in the premier league.

Don't get me wrong ward has put a few shifts in this year but his pace lets him down and if he gets out of position he could be exploited, TFM can always get himself out of those situations as he is so rapid

 

JtCpfc Flag 02 Feb 18 3.58pm

Originally posted by DANGERCLOSE

By the sounds of it roy is going to start Sorloth So think it will be a 442 formation

Strongest 11

Wayne Hennessey

Joel Ward
mamadou sakho
James Tomkins
Patrick van Aanholt

Andros Townsend
Luka Milivojevic
Yohan Cabaye
Wilfried Zaha

Alexander Sorloth
Christian Benteke

Subs: JS, Fosu-Mensah, Martin Kelly, Erdal Rakip, James McArthur, Jairo Riedewald

My 11 would be:

Hennessey

TFM
Sakho (if fit enough, if not then kelly)
Tomkins
PVA

Townsend
mcarthur
milivojevic
cabaye
zaha

benteke

Sorloth to come on 65th min mark hopefully

Edited by JtCpfc (02 Feb 2018 3.59pm)

 

homes Flag New Eltham 02 Feb 18 4.08pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

Agreed he didn't play well on Tuesday, but when you look at how he played again City he was different mustard, and his pace is vital in the premier league.

Don't get me wrong ward has put a few shifts in this year but his pace lets him down and if he gets out of position he could be exploited, TFM can always get himself out of those situations as he is so rapid

Funny how we see things differently, I respect your opinions but I thought he played well Tuesday.

 


IH: "I thought Jonny and Wilf were brilliant but it took a 39 year old master to watch the ball and keep his eye on it to finish it".

JtCpfc Flag 02 Feb 18 4.12pm

Originally posted by homes

Funny how we see things differently, I respect your opinions but I thought he played well Tuesday.

I feel as though we should have high expectations of TFM as a Man U prospect so I may be slightly harsh on the lad.

I believe he has the ability to be a standout performer regularly. Tuesday he didn't quite do that for me.

 

Mapletree Flag Croydon 02 Feb 18 4.14pm

I would go for:

Hennessy

Ward
Tomkins
Kelly
PVA

McArthur
Milivoyevic
Cabaye

Zaha
Townsend

Benteke

Sakho coming off the bench, I worry he is still likely to be off the pace/fragile. TFM also coming on as Ward will likely be lacking match fitness.

Sorloth coming on either for or with Benteke depending upon how we are doing at the 70th minute.

Ward has done well recently and is a better defender but TFM has the legs when the game starts to stretch.

 

steven_t92 Flag Orpington 02 Feb 18 4.25pm

Roy said Sorloth will have some involvement, hopefully at least 15mins so we can get a look at him. Would like to see Rakip as well, can't see Jach getting anywhere near the team straight away unfortunately but I'm sure he will look good when he does play.

Similar lineup as to the one against West Ham except with Sako swapped out for someone

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 02 Feb 18 4.42pm

Roy likes to play two strikers, sorloth could start alongside Benteke, doubtful mind.

but I see that happening soon, for home matches against bottom half sides.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Feb 18 5.45pm

With two giants up top we could launch an aerial bombardment if we're chasing games, plus teams won't be able to use half their defence to challenge each header that Tekkers goes for.

 

mattteo Flag 02 Feb 18 5.58pm

Originally posted by taylors lovechild

With two giants up top we could launch an aerial bombardment if we're chasing games, plus teams won't be able to use half their defence to challenge each header that Tekkers goes for.

Aaaand........with two giants up top it's gonna be a "who scores more competition?". Palace or the opponents. Every lost ball will lead to a counter attack. The 2 main strikers don't have the mobility to close down spaces and run down to do defensive work.
Plus, attacks would only be like long balls for their headers, nothing more

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 02 Feb 18 6.08pm

WH

TFM Tomkins Sakho PVA

Luka

Cabaye McArthur

Wilf Benteke Townsend

Subs: Speroni, Jach (if he's close to the level), Sorloth, Ward, Rakip, Riedewald, Souare


Agree about TFM with his superior pace against Atsu. It would be great to give Souare minutes if humanly possible as we probably need to consider him and/or PVA as cover for the wing...so he could do with playing.

I'd love it if Roy could let Wilf roam a bit...sniff out weaknesses.

And can i just say...given the injuries ( and the fuss) that is one heck of a match day squad.


 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

silvertop Flag Portishead 02 Feb 18 6.15pm

Originally posted by JtCpfc

TFM over Ward any day of the week

Nope, not if Sakho plays. Ward has some weird Sympatico with him. He goes from liability to world class.

 

Helmet46 Flag Croydon 02 Feb 18 6.19pm

Originally posted by silvertop

Nope, not if Sakho plays. Ward has some weird Sympatico with him. He goes from liability to world class.

He’s probably scared of him!

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Team for Newcastle