You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Clubs on the Rise...Clubs on the Wane..Longterm .
November 22 2026 8.15pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Clubs on the Rise...Clubs on the Wane..Longterm .


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 14 Feb 18 10.43pm

A single season, with all its promotions and relegations, may be regarded as the weekend's weather forecast, a soap opera. Short-term, transient and maybe not even of much significance.


Over the ten or twenty year timespan a pattern will often emerge. Like Climate change, or demographic change silent but relentless.

Clubs rise in importance and power, great clubs settle down to mediocrity and lose out. A single relegation does not a downfall make. A brief promotion is likewise not statistically significant.

Thinking about Stadium size, Fanbase, Training infrastructures, Football Academy, Financial muscle etc etc. What clubs are going from strength to strength. What clubs are looking tattered and tired ? Large or small. Domestic or Worldwide, over a 20 year timespan.

Rising :
Us, new stadium plans, new owners, New Beckenham, nice.


ManCity, obviously. Remember when they were rubbish ?

WestHam, courtesy of the taxpayer.

MK Dons, from humble beginnings of empty farmland with a few ( non concrete) cattle in 1967.

Athletico Madrid

Tottenham...from 36,000 to 61,000 capacity. Surely looking to eclipse Arsenal.

Schalke, in the Bundesligue. Never even heard of them 20 years ago. Now a regular face in the big European competitions.


Falling :

Portsmouth

Coventry, great stadium, great flop

Charlton, who the f... is laughing now. Sandwiched between growing WestHam and Palace.

Leeds Utd, Former european champions. who ever thought they would stay in the Championship for that long ? will the next move be up or down ?

AC Milan, gone very quiet in the last few years. 119 years of history and greatness. what glory next year ?

Inter Milan. also looking tired compared to just a decade ago.

Newcastle : they may be doing ok this year, but broadly the trend is not great.

Arsenal...will they win any significant silverware over the next few seasons ? the only thing similar to 15 years ago is the home kit.


What other clubs ? Or feel to disagree with any of the teams mentioned above. Help with foreign clubs less familiar to the rest of us.

Rising/Falling ....your opinions ?


Edited by PalazioVecchio (15 Feb 2018 11.30am)

Edited by PalazioVecchio (15 Feb 2018 6.23pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

sprites Flag Auckland 15 Feb 18 12.23am

There's an argument to say Man Utd also fall into the 'falling' camp. But then when you dominate everything for years like that have under Sir Alex, there was only one way to go.

 

matthau Flag South Croydon 15 Feb 18 12.36am

I agree totally.

I often think back to my childhood, ac Milan were the best team in the world, easily. Look where they are now. Still big but hardly doing much considering.

Our turn for a few pieces of silverware soon I hope, long as we beat the drop this year

 

steph_eagle Flag Thornton Heath 15 Feb 18 7.24am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

A single season, with all its promotions and relegations, may be regarded as the weekend's weather forecast, a soap opera. Short-term, transient and maybe not even of much significance.


Over the ten or twenty year timespan a pattern will often emerge. Like Climate change, or demographic change silent but relentless.

Clubs rise in importance and power, great clubs settle down to mediocrity and lose out. A single relegation does not a downfall make. A brief promotion is likewise not statistically significant.

Thinking about Stadium size, Fanbase, Training infrastructures, Football Academy, Financial muscle etc etc. What clubs are going from strength to strength. What clubs are looking tattered and tired ? Large or small. Domestic or Worldwide, over a 20 year timespan.

Rising :
Us, new stadium plans, new owners, New Beckenham, nice.


ManCity, obviously. Remember when they were rubbish ?

WestHam, courtesy of the taxpayer.

MK Dons, from humble beginnings.

Athletico Madrid

Tottenham...from 36,000 to 61,000 capacity. Surely looking to eclipse Arsenal.


Falling :

Portsmouth

Coventry, great stadium, great flop

Charlton, who the f... is laughing now. Sandwiched between growing WestHam and Palace.

Leeds Utd, Former european champions. who ever thought they would stay in the Championship for that long ? will the next move be up or down ?

AC Milan, gone very quiet in the last few years. 119 years of history and greatness. what glory next year ?

Inter Milan. also looking tired compared to just a decade ago.

Newcastle : they may be doing ok this year, but broadly the trend is not great.

Arsenal...will they win any significant silverware over the next few seasons ? the only thing similar to 15 years ago is the home kit.


What other clubs ? Or feel to disagree with any of the teams mentioned above. Help with foreign clubs less familiar to the rest of us.

Rising/Falling ....your opinions ?

Edited by PalazioVecchio (14 Feb 2018 10.49pm)

Humble beginning? Lets hope they get relegated and rot where they belong.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 15 Feb 18 7.35am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

A single season, with all its promotions and relegations, may be regarded as the weekend's weather forecast, a soap opera. Short-term, transient and maybe not even of much significance.


Over the ten or twenty year timespan a pattern will often emerge. Like Climate change, or demographic change silent but relentless.

Clubs rise in importance and power, great clubs settle down to mediocrity and lose out. A single relegation does not a downfall make. A brief promotion is likewise not statistically significant.

Thinking about Stadium size, Fanbase, Training infrastructures, Football Academy, Financial muscle etc etc. What clubs are going from strength to strength. What clubs are looking tattered and tired ? Large or small. Domestic or Worldwide, over a 20 year timespan.

Rising :
Us, new stadium plans, new owners, New Beckenham, nice.

Based on your own criteria, I don't really see how you can include Palace and exclude Brighton.

Our 'fanbase' halves when we're not in the PL, there are plans for a new stand, not a 'new stadium', whilst the American shareholders may be individually wealthy, the amount they appear to be prepared to sink into the club is quite limited and the training ground plans were rejected, plus there's a limit anyway to what we can do on that site, and we don't have a grade one academy.

Brighton on the other hand got 25K plus in the Championship, they have a new stadium, Bloom bankrolls them without any real prospect of a return and they have a state-of-the-art training ground and grade one academy. Even if they're relegated they will still have all of this.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 Feb 18 8.58am

Originally posted by bexleydave

Based on your own criteria, I don't really see how you can include Palace and exclude Brighton.

Our 'fanbase' halves when we're not in the PL, there are plans for a new stand, not a 'new stadium', whilst the American shareholders may be individually wealthy, the amount they appear to be prepared to sink into the club is quite limited and the training ground plans were rejected, plus there's a limit anyway to what we can do on that site, and we don't have a grade one academy.

Brighton on the other hand got 25K plus in the Championship, they have a new stadium, Bloom bankrolls them without any real prospect of a return and they have a state-of-the-art training ground and grade one academy. Even if they're relegated they will still have all of this.

ok. Much as it galls me, i will give a nod towards the Seaweed.

But for us, surely a long stretch in the Prem will strengthen our numbers, especially among the young.

And with the relative demise of the clowns, surely our standings to the East of our borders - places like Lewisham/Greenwich/Bromley. Schoolboy growing up...will i support Charlton or Palace ? Equal distance flight to both stadia. Which looks like more fun ? who are my schoolmates supporting ? what Arsenal , oh no.


And anyway, another team on the Rise. PSG - can you believe they were only founded in 1970 ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 18 9.17am

The history of the MK Dons has been well documented.

When I was assigned to a game there in 2007 I was looking forward to seeing the new stadium and what was noticeable straight away was that there were no seats in the top tier just concrete and this was not apparent on the TV.Seats have now been fitted.Decent modern stadium.

At present MK Dons are not having the best of times.Last season they were 19th out of 24 when they changed manager and appointed Robbie Nielson who took them up to 12th.They have struggled this season and sacked Neilson when they were 21st appointing the unknown Dan Micciche from within, who has managed the England U16 team.Under him they have lost all 4 games, 3 in League 1 in cup and remain in the relegation zone.The direction of travel is not positive at all.

Edited by Willo (15 Feb 2018 9.17am)

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 15 Feb 18 9.28am

Originally posted by Willo

The history of the MK Dons has been well documented.

When I was assigned to a game there in 2007 I was looking forward to seeing the new stadium

Assigned!

 


COYP

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 18 9.33am

Going back way into yesteryear, Preston, Blackpool,Blackburn, Wolves etc were all big clubs.

It does look as through Wolves will be returning to the 'Big time' next season.I remember the 'Molyneux' of old - much more modern now !

Edited by Willo (15 Feb 2018 9.37am)

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 15 Feb 18 9.41am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman


Assigned!

Community service

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 15 Feb 18 9.44am

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

A single season, with all its promotions and relegations, may be regarded as the weekend's weather forecast, a soap opera. Short-term, transient and maybe not even of much significance.


Over the ten or twenty year timespan a pattern will often emerge. Like Climate change, or demographic change silent but relentless.

Clubs rise in importance and power, great clubs settle down to mediocrity and lose out. A single relegation does not a downfall make. A brief promotion is likewise not statistically significant.

Thinking about Stadium size, Fanbase, Training infrastructures, Football Academy, Financial muscle etc etc. What clubs are going from strength to strength. What clubs are looking tattered and tired ? Large or small. Domestic or Worldwide, over a 20 year timespan.

Rising :
Us, new stadium plans, new owners, New Beckenham, nice.


ManCity, obviously. Remember when they were rubbish ?

WestHam, courtesy of the taxpayer.

MK Dons, from humble beginnings.

Athletico Madrid

Tottenham...from 36,000 to 61,000 capacity. Surely looking to eclipse Arsenal.


Falling :

Portsmouth

Coventry, great stadium, great flop

Charlton, who the f... is laughing now. Sandwiched between growing WestHam and Palace.

Leeds Utd, Former european champions. who ever thought they would stay in the Championship for that long ? will the next move be up or down ?

AC Milan, gone very quiet in the last few years. 119 years of history and greatness. what glory next year ?

Inter Milan. also looking tired compared to just a decade ago.

Newcastle : they may be doing ok this year, but broadly the trend is not great.

Arsenal...will they win any significant silverware over the next few seasons ? the only thing similar to 15 years ago is the home kit.


What other clubs ? Or feel to disagree with any of the teams mentioned above. Help with foreign clubs less familiar to the rest of us.

Rising/Falling ....your opinions ?

Edited by PalazioVecchio (14 Feb 2018 10.49pm)

Very interesting, M.K. Dons are strange one, got to being quite successful, but now seem to be fighting to stay in their league, where as AFG Wimbledon have gone from strength to strength and look like overtaking the Dons

 

crvenaeagle Flag 15 Feb 18 9.52am

I wouldn't consider us a team on the rise personally, what were experiencing right now can be considered a bubble as there's little suggesting otherwise. We don't have the stability nor the assets to be considered a club on the rise. In fact if you exclude our position in the leagues and the digital hoarding nothing has really changed.

I can't really see Newcastle to be a team on the decline. Yes, they're not achieving as much as they used to, but they have a faithful fanbase who follow the one team from that region.

As for any more to add to the list, well, any team with a barmy owner; Fulham, Blackpool, Cardiff to and extent.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 18 9.55am

Originally posted by ARGILE OLD GEEZER

Very interesting, M.K. Dons are strange one, got to being quite successful, but now seem to be fighting to stay in their league, where as AFG Wimbledon have gone from strength to strength and look like overtaking the Dons

AFC Wimbledon are just one place above the MK Dons in the table and both are in the relegation zone.AFC finished 15th last season so their direction of travel isn't positive as well.

In matches between the teams this season :
AFC Wimbledon 0 MK Dons 2
MK Dons 0 AFC Wimbledon 0

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 Feb 18 12.38pm

Surprised to see Brentford in the Championship. 12,000 capacity ground and not much of a public profile.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 18 12.57pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Surprised to see Brentford in the Championship. 12,000 capacity ground and not much of a public profile.

This is Brentford's 4th season in the Championship since they were promoted in season 2013/14.It was Mark Warburton who got them promoted.

 

Willo Flag South coast - west of Brighton. 15 Feb 18 1.04pm

Let's consider Portsmouth.

They were in the PL - Four years later, they had gone into administration twice, suffered three relegations and had seven different owners.

Today they get excellent crowds in League 1, with a number of their home attendances around 18,000.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 15 Feb 18 1.28pm

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Community service

Confirmed he is Clattenburg!!

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 15 Feb 18 2.23pm

Up: Napoli. Sitting pretty on the top of Serie A.

Down. Juve. They have usually won the league by January but this season are struggling to top Napoli and managed to blow a 2-0 home lead against the Spuds. Could be their earliest exit from the Champions league for years (from memory).

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

Eaglecoops Flag CR3 15 Feb 18 2.26pm

Originally posted by Willo

Let's consider Portsmouth.

They were in the PL - Four years later, they had gone into administration twice, suffered three relegations and had seven different owners.

Today they get excellent crowds in League 1, with a number of their home attendances around 18,000.

Sounds like they must have had a Parish type character as Chairman in the past who made appalling decisions on transfers and who dragged them down into the depths of the league through his failed guidance. Or maybe not.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 15 Feb 18 2.32pm

Originally posted by Eaglecoops

Sounds like they must have had a Parish type character as Chairman in the past who made appalling decisions on transfers and who dragged them down into the depths of the league through his failed guidance. Or maybe not.

i thought it was the toxic financial landslide known as Harry rednapp. From the Prem and winning the FA cup down to playing against pub teams every weekend.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Clubs on the Rise...Clubs on the Wane..Longterm .