You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How good actually is Zaha?!
November 16 2026 7.42am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

How good actually is Zaha?!


Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>
osborny99 Flag 11 Apr 18 8.23pm

All this talk of Zaha being the best player outside of the top 6 and being valued >£40 million got me thinking- where would you rate Zaha in a FIFA like list of players in the Premier League?!

On his day, for me, Zaha has to be in the top 5 players in the entire league- including clubs from within the top 6 but then, like every player to have ever lived, he has the odd off day.

Therefore looking through the top 6 clubs, who from their teams would you rather have at Palace ahead of Zaha?!

Arsenal- Aubemyang, Argubaly Ozil?

Chelsea- Hazard

Man City- Aguero, De Bruyne, Sterling, Sane?

Spurs- Kane, Eriksen

United- De Gea

Liverpool- Salah, Firmino, Van Dijk?

If those players all sat in a hypothetical list above Zaha in the league, it would classify him as the 14th best player..... who would you add/ remove to that list?!

Edited by osborny99 (11 Apr 2018 8.24pm)

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Apr 18 8.30pm

Originally posted by osborny99

All this talk of Zaha being the best player outside of the top 6 and being valued >£40 million got me thinking- where would you rate Zaha in a FIFA like list of players in the Premier League?!

On his day, for me, Zaha has to be in the top 5 players in the entire league- including clubs from within the top 6 but then, like every player to have ever lived, he has the odd off day.

Therefore looking through the top 6 clubs, who from their teams would you rather have at Palace ahead of Zaha?!

Arsenal- Aubemyang, Argubaly Ozil?

Chelsea- Hazard

Man City- Aguero, De Bruyne, Sterling, Sane?

Spurs- Kane, Eriksen

United- De Gea

Liverpool- Salah, Firmino, Van Dijk?

If those players all sat in a hypothetical list above Zaha in the league, it would classify him as the 14th best player..... who would you add/ remove to that list?!

Edited by osborny99 (11 Apr 2018 8.24pm)


Dont think he would be in the starting 11 for any of the top 4 , so the way you are working it out , that’s 45th before you look at the other teams players and the top 4s reserves that are better then him like: rashford, son etc.
So probably in the top 60.
But as a winger he’s in the top 10.
Good fit for us, but would fail elsewhere IMO.

Edited by Casual (11 Apr 2018 8.34pm)

 

aashman12 Flag 11 Apr 18 8.31pm

Great player, not as good as our fans make out he is.

 

ZIGnZAG Flag Stoke 11 Apr 18 8.46pm

He was better when he paid more attention to the game than his hair.

Daft but true. Since his new dread man bun thing, he spends more time trying to keep that tidy and looses a bit of focus on the game.

Otherwise, he's fcuking top draw.

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 11 Apr 18 9.03pm

Wilf has developed well as a player and I think he would walk into most Premiership sides and I am not just saying that because he is a Palace player....

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Apr 18 9.13pm

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Wilf has developed well as a player and I think he would walk into most Premiership sides and I am not just saying that because he is a Palace player....

I agree. But the op is saying he maybe the 14th best player in the league. Not sure he would be the 14th best player at Man City

 

chateauferret Flag 11 Apr 18 9.47pm

Remind me how many games we've won this season without using Wilf.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Apr 18 9.54pm

Originally posted by chateauferret

Remind me how many games we've won this season without using Wilf.

Agree. Good fit for us.
Champions league? Don’t think so.

 

davehuggins Flag 11 Apr 18 9.55pm

I think he really is top draw, if he played in a high-quality team I reckon he would be lethal, The only question mark is his temperament, could he fit in with other high-quality players. IMO he is worth in today's market in excess of 50m.

 

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 11 Apr 18 10.09pm

The criticism will be he doesnt score enough goals

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Apr 18 10.17pm

I love wilf. But he could play 20 bad games for Palace and still be a starter, see Benteke . If he had a bad game for a top team he’d be lucky to be on the bench the following game. Aguero couldn’t even get a start for city when they needed 3 goals last night.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 11 Apr 18 10.18pm

If you replaced Wilf with Gareth Bale we would have a piece of dynamite who would be even better than Wilf. Yet he struggles to make it into Real team. Subbed at half time tonight.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Apr 18 10.22pm

Originally posted by dreamwaverider

If you replaced Wilf with Gareth Bale we would have a piece of dynamite who would be even better than Wilf. Yet he struggles to make it into Real team. Subbed at half time tonight.

How many Palace players do you think would get in the Madrid team?

 

Holmesdale 1989 Flag 11 Apr 18 10.27pm

I reckon he turn out for Barcelona

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 11 Apr 18 10.28pm

None but I reckon the madrid team would get IN the crystals.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 11 Apr 18 10.33pm

Originally posted by cryrst

None but I reckon the madrid team would get IN the crystals.

I’d have thought so.

 

bozsufc Flag SHEFFIELD 11 Apr 18 11.39pm

Originally posted by Casual

I’d have thought so.

HAHAHA, another classic post casual, you do come out with some really good one liners mate.

 

Honey Gee Flag 12 Apr 18 1.17am

After watching Ruben Neves tonight, and that amazing goal, I can see why he’s rated the best player to ever play in the championship and by many the best player outside the top 6 in Prem. Ronaldo wants him to take his place in Portugal’s squad for years to come after breaking his own record as their youngest ever captain.

Love him to replace Cabaye, but the problem for us is he’s on his way to Real Madrid!

But yeah, I’d say Wilf has gotta be up there

Edited by Honey Gee (12 Apr 2018 1.18am)

Edited by Honey Gee (12 Apr 2018 2.15am)

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards grumpymort Flag US/Thailand/UK 12 Apr 18 1.54am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Wilf has developed well as a player and I think he would walk into most Premiership sides and I am not just saying that because he is a Palace player....


Nope

To be a top player you need to be consistent plus have end product (look how many chances he misses or doesn't just put ball in box)

He needs to learn to stop doing the tricks all the time.

The other big problem is his attitude and look how he gets wound up so easily

 


(VPN) - [Link]
(Alt VPN) - [Link]

jimruss Flag Sidcup 12 Apr 18 7.34am

Originally posted by aashman12

Great player, not as good as our fans make out he is.

I think this sums it up for me.

He's an excellent player for us almost talismanic but is he good enough to play for the very top sides? I don't think so personally.

My two gripes with him would be as someone else said, not enough goals and he has a petulant side to him. We all know he gets rough treatment but he does tend to sit on the pitch with his puss in boots from Shrek look on his face if he doesn't get a decision.

I love the guy and would never want him to leave, he's a good fit for us, if he goes elsewhere would he get the same adulation he gets here? Probably not. I think he's the type of player that needs that to be at his best.

 

Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > How good actually is Zaha?!