You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ward / Benteke /Sorloth
November 16 2026 7.43am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Ward / Benteke /Sorloth


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Croydonlad Flag sydenham 21 Apr 18 11.58pm

I think the only reason Roy is playing Ward is to put him in the shop window for sale in the Summer .
Same for Benteke's cameo appearances .
As for Sorloth ,
Well my prediction after the Everton game that he wouldn't reach 3 goals in the Premiership now looks pretty safe .
Next year I very much doubt if he will start the season with us .
I fancy Roy will try to move Benteke , and make a major forward signing .
Wickham and the new fella will be our strikers .
In midfield and defence we are spoiled for choice .
But Im still not sure about RLC , he's injury prone and doesn't really get involved when the going is tough .
Ironically the only player to play worse since FDB is him

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 22 Apr 18 12.06am

You really think that roy will rusk our premiership survival to put wArd in the shop window? What a ridiculous statement, not like we'd get much for him anyway.and if you think putting benteke on for 5 mins at thd end of a game is going to increase his transfer value, Im not sure what planet you're on.

Edited by spartakev2 (22 Apr 2018 12.08am)

 

h.smith91 Flag Sanderstead 22 Apr 18 1.07am

While everyone is entitled to their opinion I think you are way off here. Firstly no need to put Ward in ‘the shop window’ as he is out of contract this summer so if Roy wants to get rid of him he just doesn’t offer him a new contract... done!

Secondly Benteke’s reputation and name will superceed any poor form he is displaying and, if the club wish, could quite easily sell him for £20-25m. Therefore playing him with is current rock bottom confidence won’t do anyone any good.

Thirdly Sorloth is young, younger than people realise, especially for a tall, strong centre forward who had had barely any game time, less time to get used to the Prem and the team and is recovering from an injury. Writing him off already makes no sense to me at all. I expect we will sign at least one striker in the summer, but a smaller, pacy one.

Edited by h.smith91 (22 Apr 2018 1.08am)

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 22 Apr 18 1.17am

Originally posted by h.smith91

While everyone is entitled to their opinion I think you are way off here. Firstly no need to put Ward in ‘the shop window’ as he is out of contract this summer so if Roy wants to get rid of him he just doesn’t offer him a new contract... done!

Secondly Benteke’s reputation and name will superceed any poor form he is displaying and, if the club wish, could quite easily sell him for £20-25m. Therefore playing him with is current rock bottom confidence won’t do anyone any good.

Thirdly Sorloth is young, younger than people realise, especially for a tall, strong centre forward who had had barely any game time, less time to get used to the Prem and the team and is recovering from an injury. Writing him off already makes no sense to me at all. I expect we will sign at least one striker in the summer, but a smaller, pacy one.

Edited by h.smith91 (22 Apr 2018 1.08am)


Ok , here we go
I didn't say it was a risk playing Ward
But if you think Ward is better than AWB then you must be kidding yourself
As for Benteke , if he doesn't make appearances for a club such as us , how are we gonna recoup our money .
As for reputation being enough , clearly you are also wrong there hence his dropping from the national squad .
I wrote Sorloth off after his first game v Everton
He will NEVER make a Premiership footballer

 

Terry Vegetables Flag Forest Hill 22 Apr 18 1.32am

Such assurity roys going to do this, roys going to do that...

Will Roy be here next season?

 


catford kid, caught up supporting "team of the 80s" in the 70s..
1st actual Match - PALACE 1-1 LEEDS (Sat 13 Nov 1982)

Bangell Flag Oxford 22 Apr 18 1.33am

Another genius thread from Croydonlad. Ward's contract runs out in the summer.

 

dp Flag Tunbridge Wells 22 Apr 18 4.44am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

I think the only reason Roy is playing Ward is to put him in the shop window for sale in the Summer .
Same for Benteke's cameo appearances .
As for Sorloth ,
Well my prediction after the Everton game that he wouldn't reach 3 goals in the Premiership now looks pretty safe .
Next year I very much doubt if he will start the season with us .
I fancy Roy will try to move Benteke , and make a major forward signing .
Wickham and the new fella will be our strikers .
In midfield and defence we are spoiled for choice .
But Im still not sure about RLC , he's injury prone and doesn't really get involved when the going is tough .
Ironically the only player to play worse since FDB is him

I think you have a while to wait before you can start to claim bragging rights over Sorloth. As I recall, you did not limit your prophecy to this season.

 

Croydonlad Flag sydenham 22 Apr 18 6.21am

Read above , I predicted that Sorloth won’t feature if we stay up which we now will .
So for the most part his Palace Premier career is over

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Apr 18 7.06am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

I think the only reason Roy is playing Ward is to put him in the shop window for sale in the Summer .

Ward's contract runs out this summer so he's a free agent which makes your thread a bit of a nonsense

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 22 Apr 18 8.08am

Originally posted by Midlands Eagle

Ward's contract runs out this summer so he's a free agent which makes your thread a bit of a nonsense

Agreed, and not just the Ward part, the complete thread.

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Apr 18 8.36am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Read above , I predicted that Sorloth won’t feature if we stay up which we now will .
So for the most part his Palace Premier career is over

Sorloth cost 9 mil - he's not a loan signing, maybe you're confusing him with Rakip? I understand that for all Sorloth's application, willingness and ability to retain the ball intelligently he has not really shown much cutting edge yet - but he has hardly been played centrally so we must give him a chance. Part of Roy's rationale in getting him in is that he is an intelligent player with the ability to work out how to adapt and improve. He's not been brought in as a 'finisher' like Gayle, and he seems the type of centre forward who is not expected to get 20 goals in a season - somewhere between 8 and 15, but helping to create goals with his team play, so I can see why you think he may have limitations as a forward, but it is far too early for hard and fast opinions, in the Everton game he played well, especially so considering he was not match fit and he was droppped in at the deep end. I do hope you want to be wrong.

 

Fatherken Flag 22 Apr 18 10.02am

don't worry about who leaves or we recruit in the summer it will not be down to RH but SP so except more championship type players

 

Palace03 Flag 22 Apr 18 10.16am

In my opinion, Ward has been a little bit off these last few years, however some of that is down to the pace of wingers getting faster bad the premier league gets faster, look at Sane, Sterling and wilf!
I think perhaps he should be intergrated into a def mid role like he was a few seasons ago, don’t need a lot of pace, none of our cm are fast anyway, and Cabaye and jimmy Mac are both at least 30, they haven’t got long left, still their quality players atm! Or perhaps CB as Kelly has done, but not sure if it would suit him!

Benteke has been rubbish all season, and tbh last season wasn’t great, yes he scored goals, but did very little of the team and was a bottle job to a lot of physical battles! He was never worth 32million, not even in his villa days, and certainly not in his Liverpool days where he was a joke, as he is now! Roy and other managers have given there trust in him, but so far he has not made a return on it and i would much rather see Sorloth play!

The fact that some people think that Sorloth is not premier league quality is rubbish! We have only really seen him play up front for 90mins, which the first 45 wasn’t great, but that was with Benteke, who was useless and they had no understanding! However second half, which was at Chelsea, was very good, he was playing against one of the best defences in the league and the former champions! And he should have scored, but ref made a wrong call! And he chased after the ball and made a nuisance of himself, I don’t think I’ve ever seen Benteke win the ball back a defender whilst chasing a lose ball but Sorloth did, with Zahas help!

Ward I would keep, he’s a good squad player with experience and he’s got that never die attitude which we seriously lack now, whereas 5 years ago that was our whole team!

Benteke sell, has never hit the hype, and his all round striker ability is not prem standard!

Sorloth is a good shout for the future, he is 22/23 as far as I am aware, and playing in an alien environment in England, I think he has got it in him, and so long as he works hard, we will love him!

 

Gary St.Andrews Flag Kenley 22 Apr 18 10.54am

Looking at the last 2 games, I think Ward has played his worst 2 games ever in a Palace shirt. I am not sure why he has been picked, when Wan Bisakka was doing well.

Also Wan Bisakka gives us more of an attacking threat down the right plus he can send in a great cross...

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 22 Apr 18 11.05am

Originally posted by h.smith91

While everyone is entitled to their opinion I think you are way off here. Firstly no need to put Ward in ‘the shop window’ as he is out of contract this summer so if Roy wants to get rid of him he just doesn’t offer him a new contract... done!

Secondly Benteke’s reputation and name will superceed any poor form he is displaying and, if the club wish, could quite easily sell him for £20-25m. Therefore playing him with is current rock bottom confidence won’t do anyone any good.

Thirdly Sorloth is young, younger than people realise, especially for a tall, strong centre forward who had had barely any game time, less time to get used to the Prem and the team and is recovering from an injury. Writing him off already makes no sense to me at all. I expect we will sign at least one striker in the summer, but a smaller, pacy one.

Edited by h.smith91 (22 Apr 2018 1.08am)

If that’s the case we can get 20-25 for Benteke then we should sell him asap but there is the added issue of £130k per week that’ll make clubs think hard.

 


COYP

Spiderman Flag Horsham 22 Apr 18 11.11am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Read above , I predicted that Sorloth won’t feature if we stay up which we now will .
So for the most part his Palace Premier career is over

Unless you are actually Roy how can you possibly say this?

 

PZ Eagle Flag Penzance 22 Apr 18 11.12am

Originally posted by Gary St.Andrews

Looking at the last 2 games, I think Ward has played his worst 2 games ever in a Palace shirt. I am not sure why he has been picked, when Wan Bisakka was doing well.

Also Wan Bisakka gives us more of an attacking threat down the right plus he can send in a great cross...

tbf he did nearly score a goal yesterday albeit at the wrong end

 


Conjunctivitis.com - A site for sore eyes.

Jacey Flag 22 Apr 18 11.16am

Originally posted by Croydonlad

Read above , I predicted that Sorloth won’t feature if we stay up which we now will .
So for the most part his Palace Premier career is over

If your assumption is correct,what a truly dreadful January window we had,signing three unknowns for the Championship possibly??

If and when we stay up,will they be good enough at this level??

 

Midlands Eagle Flag 22 Apr 18 11.27am

Originally posted by Fatherken

don't worry about who leaves or we recruit in the summer it will not be down to RH but SP so expect more championship type players

If that were to be true I would expect Roy to walk but I don't expect that to be the case anyway

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 22 Apr 18 5.06pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

don't worry about who leaves or we recruit in the summer it will not be down to RH but SP so except more championship type players

like Luka, Cabaye, Wilf, Townsend, Tompkins, Sakho, Van Aarnolt ... oh and doesn't that new stand look awful, and hasn't SP got a big nose ...

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Ward / Benteke /Sorloth