This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by Stuk
A coroner in London has been told that she is unlawful for dealing with her cases on a chronological basis. She's been told that Jewish and Muslim deaths must take priority. In fairness, if someone has a good reason for an inquiry to be held sooner, then I don't see why that shouldn't be permitted. Seems a bit lazy and jobsworthy to just do things in the order the come in irrespective of need or preference. As long as everyone has the right to ask for reasonable expediency I don't see the problem, and I agree she shouldn't have been so rigid and dogmatic.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
In fairness, if someone has a good reason for an inquiry to be held sooner, then I don't see why that shouldn't be permitted. Seems a bit lazy and jobsworthy to just do things in the order the come in irrespective of need or preference. As long as everyone has the right to ask for reasonable expediency I don't see the problem, and I agree she shouldn't have been so rigid and dogmatic. It should be you who writes to the families telling them that it's ok that their loved one is seen later because you think someone's particular religious belief is more important than their beliefs or lack of one. I know what my reply to you would be.
'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen) |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
In fairness, if someone has a good reason for an inquiry to be held sooner, then I don't see why that shouldn't be permitted. Seems a bit lazy and jobsworthy to just do things in the order the come in irrespective of need or preference. As long as everyone has the right to ask for reasonable expediency I don't see the problem, and I agree she shouldn't have been so rigid and dogmatic. Religion isn't a good reason. Isn't burying/cremating someone about closure? Why should one set of people have to wait longer because they don't believe in fairy stories? Or the right fairy stories?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
A coroner in London has been told that she is unlawful for dealing with her cases on a chronological basis. She's been told that Jewish and Muslim deaths must take priority. I don't agree with this. So she was discriminatory for telling people they should wait their turn. The courts solution is to allow people of certain faiths to queue jump and that's not discriminatory? Anyone who has a loved one that dies and it needs to be investigated wants this done as quickly as possible. Why should a secular person be discriminated against in favour of a religious group? The only queue jumping should be where the authorities have asked for it e.g. the police believe someone has been murdered and they need to get an investigation started.
One more point |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
In fairness, if someone has a good reason for an inquiry to be held sooner, then I don't see why that shouldn't be permitted. Seems a bit lazy and jobsworthy to just do things in the order the come in irrespective of need or preference. As long as everyone has the right to ask for reasonable expediency I don't see the problem, and I agree she shouldn't have been so rigid and dogmatic. You have finally lost it.
|
|
|
Simple - If you're terminally ill, become a Muslim.
|
|
|
Originally posted by Stuk
Religion isn't a good reason. Isn't burying/cremating someone about closure? Why should one set of people have to wait longer because they don't believe in fairy stories? Or the right fairy stories? Absolutely. Doing cases in date order - unless the judicial system has an interest - surely is the only way? Bloody monotheists.
Well I think Simon's head is large; always involved in espionage. (Name that tune) |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Absolutely. Doing cases in date order - unless the judicial system has an interest - surely is the only way? Bloody monotheists. She has been done for "discrimination" for not discriminating. It's properly f***ed up. You want it expedited you hire a private one, at your expenses.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by Mr_Gristle
Absolutely. Doing cases in date order - unless the judicial system has an interest - surely is the only way? Bloody monotheists. Why is that the only way? In my view once someone's dead they're dead and waiting a bit longer for a funeral/cremation isn't going to make much difference, but other people have beliefs that mean having a burial ASAP is important to them. I don't see why their requests were just being dismissed out of hand. I would think someone in this position should have some compassion and be a bit more flexible. She could easily take requests into consideration and ask relatives of those higher up the queue if they minded waiting a little longer so she could grant a request made for religious reasons. I personally wouldn't mind if it was a matter of a day or two, but equally if others did mind then she could reasonably say to the person making the request sorry but I tried. The real issue is that she lacked compassion or any common sense.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Why is that the only way? In my view once someone's dead they're dead and waiting a bit longer for a funeral/cremation isn't going to make much difference, but other people have beliefs that mean having a burial ASAP is important to them. I don't see why their requests were just being dismissed out of hand. I would think someone in this position should have some compassion and be a bit more flexible. She could easily take requests into consideration and ask relatives of those higher up the queue if they minded waiting a little longer so she could grant a request made for religious reasons. I personally wouldn't mind if it was a matter of a day or two, but equally if others did mind then she could reasonably say to the person making the request sorry but I tried. The real issue is that she lacked compassion or any common sense. What if a large number of her clients are Jews or Muslims? Is she expected to keep putting them to the front of the queue whilst agnostics and other religions get put to the back? Ms Van Der Zyl just wants preferential treatment for Jews for no other reason that she is one.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses. |
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
What if a large number of her clients are Jews or Muslims? Is she expected to keep putting them to the front of the queue whilst agnostics and other religions get put to the back? Ms Van Der Zyl just wants preferential treatment for Jews for no other reason that she is one. No. As I said there is no reason she couldn't have been a bit more sensible and compassionate. She acted like a complete jobsworth. If she'd been kinder and at least showed she was doing her best to take people's wishes into consideration while reminding them that she has other cases to deal with then none of this would have happened. Most people will be reasonable and willing to wait a bit if they can see the person on the other side is at least listening to them and doing their best to accommodate reasonable requests.
|
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
Why is that the only way? In my view once someone's dead they're dead and waiting a bit longer for a funeral/cremation isn't going to make much difference, but other people have beliefs that mean having a burial ASAP is important to them. I don't see why their requests were just being dismissed out of hand. I would think someone in this position should have some compassion and be a bit more flexible. She could easily take requests into consideration and ask relatives of those higher up the queue if they minded waiting a little longer so she could grant a request made for religious reasons. I personally wouldn't mind if it was a matter of a day or two, but equally if others did mind then she could reasonably say to the person making the request sorry but I tried. The real issue is that she lacked compassion or any common sense. Insert the word "fair", between "only" and "way" in your opening question.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
What if a large number of her clients are Jews or Muslims? Is she expected to keep putting them to the front of the queue whilst agnostics and other religions get put to the back? Ms Van Der Zyl just wants preferential treatment for Jews for no other reason that she is one. Or start to decompose?
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
No. As I said there is no reason she couldn't have been a bit more sensible and compassionate. She acted like a complete jobsworth. If she'd been kinder and at least showed she was doing her best to take people's wishes into consideration while reminding them that she has other cases to deal with then none of this would have happened. Most people will be reasonable and willing to wait a bit if they can see the person on the other side is at least listening to them and doing their best to accommodate reasonable requests. I'm sure they'd all appreciate it if she decided to tell them how to do their jobs and in what order. Religion shouldn't be taken into consideration for giving anyone preferential treatment. It's the very opposite of equality.
Optimistic as ever |
|
|
Originally posted by CambridgeEagle
No. As I said there is no reason she couldn't have been a bit more sensible and compassionate. She acted like a complete jobsworth. If she'd been kinder and at least showed she was doing her best to take people's wishes into consideration while reminding them that she has other cases to deal with then none of this would have happened. Most people will be reasonable and willing to wait a bit if they can see the person on the other side is at least listening to them and doing their best to accommodate reasonable requests. Surely she was just being honest? In the interests of equality, she was refusing to prioritise one religious group over any other - which is the very definition of equality. Of course, she could have lied and said "I'll do my best but we are very busy" and just continued to treat all cases equally, but what would that have achieved?
|
|
|
Originally posted by topcat
Under Jewish and Islamic law, bodies must be buried on the day of death or as soon as possible afterwards. Which is what was happening. This case has nothing to do with the rights of the dead but Ms Van Der Zyl and The Board of Deputies of British Jews wanting preferential treatment for Jews. Not content with (ridiculously) winning their case, they want the coroner to resign for doing her job. I am starting a new religion which only belief is that when I die The Board of Deputies of British Jews have to pay for my funeral and wake. For them not to would be against my human rights. This is the crux of it. Anyone, any group of people, is free to start a potty religion - equally potty to any existing religion. We could start a HOL religion that believes a person should be buried What we know would happen is that m'learned friends would then absorb pots of taxpayers' money adjudicating on what is a "proper" and what is a "frivolous" religion (completely overlooking the absurdity of the established religious texts).
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes) |
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.