You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Heathrow Expansion
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Heathrow Expansion


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 22 Jun 18 10.45am

So rather than keep his promise to his constituents, Boris is hiding away in a foreign country to avoid having to vote against the Government on expansion.

You really can't trust a single word he says.

In terms of Heathrow I would bulldoze the airport and build new housing and a new town centre. Would create tons of new jobs, help London's housing issue and remove the blight of planes flying low over thousands of homes and schools in West London and improve residents' health.

I'd then go for a brand new Thames estuary airport which could operate 24/7 with new fast connections into central London (not Paddington), 4 to 7 runways (Amsterdam has 7), and again would generate huge amounts of work and business. Could incorporate dedicated freight terminals and runway as well.

The choice between Heathrow and Gatwick was ridiculous as well. They should do both. We're way behind other major European cities in terms of capacity and need both runways.

Another huge infrastructure project delayed and totally mismanaged by the government and BoJo is an embarrassment and his constituents deserve someone who cares about someone other than himself.

 

jeeagles Flag 22 Jun 18 12.01pm

It's gone through inquiry after inquiry and the result has been the same.

Expansion of Heathrow is the best option.

The scheme had been delayed by two decades and resulted in huge extra costs and lost opportunity due to petty nimbyism and political point scoring.

It seems like your agenda is to critise Boris and has very little to do with the engineering, environmental, and social impact.

Edited by jeeagles (22 Jun 2018 12.16pm)

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 22 Jun 18 12.12pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

So rather than keep his promise to his constituents, Boris is hiding away in a foreign country to avoid having to vote against the Government on expansion.

You really can't trust a single word he says.

In terms of Heathrow I would bulldoze the airport and build new housing and a new town centre. Would create tons of new jobs, help London's housing issue and remove the blight of planes flying low over thousands of homes and schools in West London and improve residents' health.

I'd then go for a brand new Thames estuary airport which could operate 24/7 with new fast connections into central London (not Paddington), 4 to 7 runways (Amsterdam has 7), and again would generate huge amounts of work and business. Could incorporate dedicated freight terminals and runway as well.

The choice between Heathrow and Gatwick was ridiculous as well. They should do both. We're way behind other major European cities in terms of capacity and need both runways.

Another huge infrastructure project delayed and totally mismanaged by the government and BoJo is an embarrassment and his constituents deserve someone who cares about someone other than himself.

I like your thinking. Of course if Boris can oust Theresa and become PM we may well see Boris Island.

I don't have strong feelings either way on Heathrow I do think it fair to say that if we were starting from scratch you would not build an airport there however we have and capacity in the south east is a major issue.

Boris is wrong to miss the vote as he was a vocal opponent. As I mentioned on another thread it is ridiculous that MPS have to vote in person. At elections we have postal voting and we can even nominate someone to cast our vote (proxy). Surely Parliament can come up with something better. I thing most of us believe Boris is hiding if he could vote remotely he would have to be accountable to his constituents.

 


One more point

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 22 Jun 18 1.46pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

It's gone through inquiry after inquiry and the result has been the same.

Expansion of Heathrow is the best option.

The scheme had been delayed by two decades and resulted in huge extra costs and lost opportunity due to petty nimbyism and political point scoring.

It seems like your agenda is to critise Boris and has very little to do with the engineering, environmental, and social impact.

Edited by jeeagles (22 Jun 2018 12.16pm)

Boris is massively in favour of the Thames Estuary airport. I just think his hiding from this vote is worthy of criticism.

I've read plenty of analyses of the options and the decisions but I disagree that Heathrow only expansion is the right decision social, environmentally or economically. It doesn't do enough and is hugely disruptive and not value for money. The fact it's taken this long to make a decision is ridiculous.

Should never have been a straight Gatwick vs Heathrow decision. Discounting the biggest and most ambitious (and best IMO) option was short sighted and lacked imagination or vision. Real opportunity wasted.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jun 18 2.03pm

I liked the idea of Boris island.....but it isn't a topic I know enough about.

You would hope that the people at the top were bright enough to make sensible decisions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jun 2018 2.04pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stuk Flag Top half 22 Jun 18 2.10pm

They should do both Heathrow and Gatwick so neither could moan that it wasn't fair.

Knocking it all down and starting again would be monumentally daft.

He's the foreign secretary, if anyone is going to be out of the country often it's them. Beside the fact that "the bulldozers aren't there to lie down in front of" as if anyone ever believed that to begin with.

He's not voting in favour of it is he?

 


Optimistic as ever

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 22 Jun 18 2.13pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I liked the idea of Boris island.....but it isn't a topic I know enough about.

You would hope that the people at the top were bright enough to make sensible decisions.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jun 2018 2.04pm)

Where is the evidence of that?

 

jeeagles Flag 22 Jun 18 2.15pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Boris is massively in favour of the Thames Estuary airport. I just think his hiding from this vote is worthy of criticism.

I've read plenty of analyses of the options and the decisions but I disagree that Heathrow only expansion is the right decision social, environmentally or economically. It doesn't do enough and is hugely disruptive and not value for money. The fact it's taken this long to make a decision is ridiculous.

Should never have been a straight Gatwick vs Heathrow decision. Discounting the biggest and most ambitious (and best IMO) option was short sighted and lacked imagination or vision. Real opportunity wasted.

It wasn't a Gatwick v Heathrow decision. Gatwick had a 50 year covenant stopping it from building a new runway which expires next year so options have only been considered relatively recently.

You probably new that bit of basic information as you have read loads.

 

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 22 Jun 18 2.19pm

What is the prospect of this Heathrow expansion actually being done ?

 

Stirlingsays Flag 22 Jun 18 2.27pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

Where is the evidence of that?

It's always surprising that in a supposed meritocracy that we don't have the brightest at the top levels. They just aren't always attracted to these fields. Perhaps it's because they want to be genuinely useful in life....or maybe more truthfully most of them want to make more money.

I wonder what the average IQ is at the various levels.

Edited by Stirlingsays (22 Jun 2018 2.29pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 22 Jun 18 4.54pm

Originally posted by Stuk

They should do both Heathrow and Gatwick so neither could moan that it wasn't fair.

That's what I thought at the time, the capacity will be needed at some point may as well get on with it.

 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

jeeagles Flag 22 Jun 18 6.15pm

Originally posted by topcat

That's what I thought at the time, the capacity will be needed at some point may as well get on with it.

There both private companies, they have to propose the expansion but require planning permission from the government.

Gatwick is more than likely for more runways next year, Manchester and/or Stansted are likely to follow.

 

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 25 Jun 18 12.02pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

It wasn't a Gatwick v Heathrow decision. Gatwick had a 50 year covenant stopping it from building a new runway which expires next year so options have only been considered relatively recently.

You probably new that bit of basic information as you have read loads.

The 2015 Airports Commission Report looked at 3 proposals; 2 for Heathrow and 1 for Gatwick and advised the Government just to go for one of the Heathrow Options. This has informed today's vote and why the Gatwick application has not been voted on. So in 2015 it was very much Gatwick vs Heathrow.

Gatwick may still be able to get a vote on its application, but it's been kicked into the long grass for now, thanks in part to this Airports Commission Review.

A mistake IMO.

Boris quoted today in Standard as saying he doesn't think he'll need to lie in front of the Bulldozers and Heathrow will never happen. Could well be right. Doesn't mean he's not a supine invertibrate protplasmic jelly for not voting on it tonight though.

 

jeeagles Flag 25 Jun 18 12.35pm

It still seems you have an agenda against Boris rather than a desire to provide the optimum infrastructure solution.

It's this petty political squabbling which has resulted in UK infrastructure being such a mess.

 

Brentmiester_General Flag Front line in the battle against t... 25 Jun 18 12.58pm

Boris being disingenuous. Well I never.

Edited by Brentmiester_General (25 Jun 2018 12.59pm)

 


"We love you Palace, we f@cking hate Man U, We love you Palace, we hate the brighton too, We love you Palace we play in red 'n' blue, so f@ck you, and you ...

CambridgeEagle Flag Sydenham 25 Jun 18 2.42pm

Originally posted by jeeagles

It still seems you have an agenda against Boris rather than a desire to provide the optimum infrastructure solution.

It's this petty political squabbling which has resulted in UK infrastructure being such a mess.

I support his stance on this one, just not his cowardice and self-interested actions (as per).

I can sort of see his point, but he should have stuck to his principles once the PM mandated the whips to make this one a whipped vote and stuck up for his constituents in the proper fashion. His words hold so little value these days and that's a shame for his constituents and the public when being represented by him in foreign affairs. May could have allowed a free vote and would probably have won.

I do want the best result and I believe it's not expanding Heathrow, but demolishing Heathrow and building a brand new modern, fit for purpose airport in the Thames Estuary.

This would create huge numbers of jobs, a massive boost to the Heathrow area from huge numbers of new homes, offices, retail etc. better air quality in the capital. Plus an airport with greater capacity and longer hours of operation that could compete with the likes of schipol. Could also have new rapid links via Crossrail expansion and Javelin.

I agree Heathrow may still never happen. On Boris I think this shows once again that he can't be trusted.

 

jeeagles Flag 25 Jun 18 11.56pm

Originally posted by CambridgeEagle

I support his stance on this one, just not his cowardice and self-interested actions (as per).

I can sort of see his point, but he should have stuck to his principles once the PM mandated the whips to make this one a whipped vote and stuck up for his constituents in the proper fashion. His words hold so little value these days and that's a shame for his constituents and the public when being represented by him in foreign affairs. May could have allowed a free vote and would probably have won.

I do want the best result and I believe it's not expanding Heathrow, but demolishing Heathrow and building a brand new modern, fit for purpose airport in the Thames Estuary.

This would create huge numbers of jobs, a massive boost to the Heathrow area from huge numbers of new homes, offices, retail etc. better air quality in the capital. Plus an airport with greater capacity and longer hours of operation that could compete with the likes of schipol. Could also have new rapid links via Crossrail expansion and Javelin.

I agree Heathrow may still never happen. On Boris I think this shows once again that he can't be trusted.

By not voting it’s almost like he’s admitting he’s wrong. Which is something that politicians never do.

Boris Island was a nice thought, but it’s a non starter.

The cost of reclaiming the land in the Thames would be huge, as would be the risk. It’s littered with munitions, the US Montgomery is slap bang in the middle and still a huge exclusion zone. The ecological impact of building on undeveloped sites would be massive. It would impact on shipping and the hydrology of the river. There’s no existing infrastructure. Plus you’ll face far bigger opposition local opposition to moving an airport to a location where there previously wasn’t one compared to expanding an existing one (just look at all the issues with HS2). There’s further risks such as bird strikes, wind and settlement issues.

Then look at the staffing needs to service the airport. Heathrow indirectly employs over 100,000 people. You wouldn’t find staff in those numbers in Gravesend and you wouldn’t be able to move all your staff to a small town on the midway.

Taking that many jobs away from the area would kill it. It would be like Sheffield or South Wales after thatcher destroyed the unions. Go to Luton or Crawley and you’ll see how many people there are emplyed by the airport.

Heathrow has existing access from the M4, M25, Paddington, the Piccadilly line, and shortly the elizabth line. That’s 10’s of billions of pounds worth of infrastructure.

I think Schipol was smaller than Heathrow when expansion talk started. The Dutch have the advantage of a flat landscape that lends itself to building airports.

I have little simpathy for most of the local residents. It’s akin to the people who have bought houses on the Holmesdale road and complain about the noise. Unless you’ve been there since the 1920’s you should have known this was always likely.

It would be interesting to see how politicians have previously voted on this. I’m sure it’s a free vote because the can’t force MP’s to change there mine on how they previously voted on the same issues without causing mass embarrassment.


 

Pussay Patrol Flag 26 Jun 18 6.04am

If Boris voted against the government he'd have to resign if I'm correct?

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Dave58 Flag Ipswich 26 Jun 18 9.55am

We need expansion without a doubt. I flew from London city last week. That’s becoming overcrowded already with really long queues at security. They are even flying to places such as skiathos which used to be solely from Gatwick. Too much money has been spent on Heathrow to bulldoze it. They should have made that decision before they built terminal 5 or the Heathrow express and cross rail. Gatwick has rubbish links to London. The Gatwick express and Gatwick station are an embarrassment. I agree with the Thames estuary airport as we need a 24/7 airport. I’m thinking it’s too late now and only a matter of time before Heathrow landing slots are extended into the night.

 

Stuk Flag Top half 26 Jun 18 3.11pm

Well that was marginal...

 


Optimistic as ever

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Heathrow Expansion