You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the transfer window (Summer 2018 edition)
November 16 2026 7.24am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Rate the transfer window (Summer 2018 edition)


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Bangell Flag Oxford 09 Aug 18 8.36pm

IN:
Guaita (Free)
Kouyate (Undisclosed; 9-11m?)
Meyer (Free)
Ayew (Loan)

OUT:
Cabaye (Free)
Delaney (Free)
Lee (Free)
Sako (Free)
Cavalieri (Free)
Jach (Loan)

For me, this is an 8/10 when you consider that we had very little money to work with and have accumulated a huge wage bill. Kouyate is a proven PL midfielder and Meyer may be one of our greatest ever signings in time. Both should cover the losses of Cabaye and RLC. Ayew will give some competition to our strikers and is a more mobile kind of player than our stable of target men.

We're left with a solid squad:

GK: Hennessey, Guaita, Speroni

LB: PVA, Souare (Schlupp if necessary)
CB: Tomkins, Sakho, Dann, Kelly (Riedewald if necessary)
RB: Wan-Bissaka, Ward

LW: Schlupp
CM: McArthur, Luka, Meyer, Riedewald, Kouyate
RW: Townsend

ST: Zaha, Benteke, Ayew, Sorloth, Wickham

With Puncheon, Kaikai, and Williams as potential cover for any of those midfield positions; we could also see Zaha or Ayew out wide. Overall we're in good shape.

Edited by Bangell (09 Aug 2018 8.37pm)

 

CP81 Flag Kent 09 Aug 18 8.42pm

A lot better than I was expecting. 8/10 for me.

 


Palace 2 Charlton 0 1981

Tyrelli Flag London 09 Aug 18 8.48pm

Originally posted by CP81

A lot better than I was expecting. 8/10 for me.

A Solid 7/10 for me ... Really excellent work considering what we had money wise (based on what media / club / SP said) I think we did miss out on a Striker, which would have given us more punch ... but otherwise very happy, and probably the biggest "transfer" was keeping Zaha.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 09 Aug 18 8.50pm

I tend to agree. Better than I expected, and not all done in the last hour, but the proof of the pudding will be how the new boys actually get on.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

DANGERCLOSE Flag London 09 Aug 18 8.54pm

9/10 Excellent

We got the players we needed

 

pssguy Flag 09 Aug 18 8.55pm

An upgrade for Puncheon and Kaikai would have been good
but would have liked to have taken another top team youngster on loan as was successful last year

Ayew and Kouyate are solid Premier League players but the key to the success, or otherwise, of the window will be Meyer.

If he clicks; Benteke or Wickham can score sufficient goals; and we are have a much less injury-prone season then I'm optimistic that we could be pushing for a Europa place and keep Zaha another year

7/10

 

Loz83 Flag Crawley 09 Aug 18 9.06pm

I think we’ve done great and only spent 10m , compared to Fulham , wolves and Brighton. I think them 3 clubs will be under pressure to stay up after spending that amount. I think ayew will surprise a few people, cracking player!

 

Jimmy Flag Balham 09 Aug 18 9.29pm

It's pretty apparent to us all that we have hit the wage limit for a club like ours with our limited stadium income etc.

So to keep the big names and add a couple of potential high quality replacements is fantastic.

Yes it would have been nice to get another hot stuff loan, but again money or available suitable players could be a factor.

So for me.. based on FFP limitations and the potential of the new names.

8

 


Happy happy JOY, JOY!

Aray Flag South London 09 Aug 18 9.31pm

As Parish said last night you can only judge its success much further down the line. But the biggest issue was Zaha and he's still ours.

Addressing the loss of Cabaye in the centre as our playmaker was the next most important issue and that, on paper, has got to be seen as having been accomplished. Of course the proof is in the pudding but Meyer - having played in the same position for Schalke could be an improvement. Maybe even a significant one!

We've all moaned about the keeper situation although Wayne has stopped the clangers but seems like Guaita will be our number one. Job done.

Attacking midfielder was next and here I'm not convinced we've improved. I don't really count RLC as a Palace player. Is Ayew better than Sako? Meh.

But then maybe we'll have a different set up this year - Kouyate is a better all-round midfielder than RLC - who obviously has fantastic potential.

Then central defence - Kouyate is also actually a really good central defender when called upon according to my WetSpam mates. I believe that is where he plays as an international. So we have cover and Dann will be back. The good thing is this means a youth player might get to play cup games.

Speaking of player development - the fact we haven't done a West Ham means that we could see some youth players emerge.

Before I started this I was toying with a 6 out of 10 but that was mainly because I find Ayew uninspiring. Now I've thought about it and pieced together the issues we had and the solutions I have to say its a solid 7 maybe even 8 given our limited funds.

 

DeanMiles Flag Telford 09 Aug 18 9.52pm

7/10. 8 if Punch goes out on loan and is not in the 25 man squad.

I think a CB was needed but I'm not unhappy.

 

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 09 Aug 18 9.58pm

for what we could realistically have hoped to achieve, and for being affordable: 9 1/2 out of 10.

obviously not the lavish spending of some, but that was never going to happen. and we kept Wilf.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 09 Aug 18 9.59pm

It’s ok. We needed to replace Cabaye and Loftus-Cheek. I have never seen Meyer play but hopefully he can replace Cabaye. Between Kouyate and Ayew we have hopefully replaced RLC. That was the minimum we needed to do and so therefore it’s ok. Would have loved to have had Origi. I think he would have been excellent but such is life

 

Medway Eagle Flag Whitstable Kent 09 Aug 18 10.04pm

8/10 for me good business with the little money SP & DF had. With the 1 loan players that's perfect as if money is tight we have room to bring in another loan in January

 

dg1937 Flag 09 Aug 18 10.05pm

Solid 7 from me - I think. Really it depends if Meyer is all he's cracked up to be. If he's has good as we are led to believe and settles in quickly then this could be a 9.

We've also, I presume left ourselves a little bit of wriggle room for January depending on how things are going.

 

Mwncisee Flag Middlesbrough 09 Aug 18 10.08pm

Given that we are seeing significant rises in player prices each window we have done shrewd business this window. Cleared some off the books and replaced where we needed to. We will never know the total costs, signing on fees etc but looks like we have done what we needed to at a fraction of the cost of other clubs.

Of course can't judge Ayew, Kouyate, Guiata and Meyer yet. Will Ayew offer anything or just be a `meh` average player? Is Kouyate the solid midfielder we hope he is or the player Spammers are happy to get rid of? Is Guita the great keeper we think he is or another Mandanda? Is Meyer the bargain of the season, a young creative player with bags of potential or a boy with an overinflated opinion of himself?

We won't know until at least a few months time but in my opinion all risks worth taking at little outlay.

A solid 7 1/2 out of 10 for me.

 

EagleinSF Flag San Fransisco 09 Aug 18 10.13pm

8.5 / 10 from me.

Given our financial constraints we've lowered our squad's age/wages and potentially improved it too.

And we have space for another load in Jan (I think there may be a few available with the bloated squads of several clubs now) or maybe even space/cash to make some astute signings as needed.

Its going to be interesting.....

 

chateauferret Flag 09 Aug 18 10.15pm

Very decent window. Four players with good pedigrees in the door, probably £60m worth with about £10m outlay and another fee later if we keep Ayew. And Wilf going nowhere.

Addressed most of our issues within that without shipping in lots of possible duds on big wages. Think Fulham and Wolves have gone in like a kid in a candy shop and will end up with a few Mutches in there. But then someone forked out £50m for Richarlison who is a known dud so you never know.

Only concern is still not sure we've got enough creativity in that midfield, strong though it otherwise clearly is.

 


============
The Ferret
============

MKGlazier Flag Milton Keynes 09 Aug 18 10.16pm

Appears to me an excellent window, a stronger squad and only spent a minimal amount.....Strangely, the only one I would have liked to have added after seeing Fulham nick him on loan, would have been TFM, back to us to cover all the back line...but that's just nit picking...and as the Yids have shown it's just as important to keep your players as buy new ones....so a very good transfer period for us.

 

brides Flag Arnside . Lake District 09 Aug 18 10.32pm

money a bit tight, but for 9.5 million we have had a fantastic window, off loaded some huge wage earners, and Meyer will be a great signing, we can look forward to a good season under Roy

Only issue we did not let some of the kids go on loan, they could do with some game time

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 09 Aug 18 10.41pm

I think it’s for us an excellent window. Defensive cover like TFM would have been perfect, but this is pretty darn close.

We kept Zaha, that alone makes this a great window, everyone else is a bonus.

Meyer looks a player and I can’t wait to see him fit and in the team.

Kouyate is a great signing and so is Ayew, they are the sort of players that can push for a starting place and even if they can’t break in, it offers genuine quality from the bench for a the first time since promotion.

Guita we have to wait and see, but we needed a keeper and we brought in one.

I was getting worried seeing the money that others have spent and the number of players, but for me we have done everything we needed to and we haven’t spent big, so we should have some for January and we have a loan space, so we effectively still have a hand to play in January. If someone from a big team like RLC or Welbeck can’t get in to the team, we are in a prime position to offer them a 6 month loan.

A great window and a smart window from Dougie and Steve.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Rate the transfer window (Summer 2018 edition)