You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Nobel winning biologist, James Watson.
November 21 2026 11.04pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Nobel winning biologist, James Watson.


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jan 19 11.23am

[Link]

This story infuriates me.

To persecute a man, not just any man, an eminent scientist, for his opinions is a shameful display of the kind of fascist attitudes that prevail in our scientific community and wider society.

Disagree with him, produce counter evidence by all means but don't resort to this disgraceful tactic.

A man's worth is not measured entirely by his intelligence but in the practical world, you can't keep putting square pegs in round holes merely to satisfy some ideological fashion.
We test people's intelligence all the time at school and in higher education so why do we bother? Maybe all us thickies should protest and demand that all the evidence of our limited academic ability be suppressed.

All this begs the question, how far would these zealots go to sustain their idealistic fantasy?
Also, how can we trust in science when it clearly picks and chooses the bits that fit with the fashionable 'correct' enforced consensus?

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Jan 19 12.59pm

It is the old race card again.
If a black guy says that black people generally can run faster and jump higher than a white people i would agree.
Does that make him racist.?
In the film django which is based on slavery this exact point is made near the end of the film.
If it was bollox why didnt anyone object when it was released.
This was a witch hunt on watson because some people cant handle the truth.
It hurts as they say.
I will also catergorically state that there are a great many extremely clever black people.
That though doesnt disprove watsons general point.
There are probably black people who would agree with this but will be shut down as it wouldnt fit the ideological points being forced on society.

 

ogloc19 Flag 13 Jan 19 2.18pm

Urgh, just went on the writers twitter. Daughter is a 9th grade 'activist' and 'cartoonist'. So worrying

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 13 Jan 19 2.54pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

[Link]

This story infuriates me.

To persecute a man, not just any man, an eminent scientist, for his opinions is a shameful display of the kind of fascist attitudes that prevail in our scientific community and wider society.

Disagree with him, produce counter evidence by all means but don't resort to this disgraceful tactic.

A man's worth is not measured entirely by his intelligence but in the practical world, you can't keep putting square pegs in round holes merely to satisfy some ideological fashion.
We test people's intelligence all the time at school and in higher education so why do we bother? Maybe all us thickies should protest and demand that all the evidence of our limited academic ability be suppressed.

All this begs the question, how far would these zealots go to sustain their idealistic fantasy?
Also, how can we trust in science when it clearly picks and chooses the bits that fit with the fashionable 'correct' enforced consensus?

What are your thoughts on his findings Hrolf, do you think that white people are more clever than black people?

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 13 Jan 19 3.41pm

if you got a proper scientific training then the facts and the evidence always carry more sway than the opinions and rhetoric.

so who is wrong ? who is right ? who knows ?

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Pussay Patrol Flag 13 Jan 19 3.56pm

Originally posted by cryrst

It is the old race card again.
If a black guy says that black people generally can run faster and jump higher than a white people i would agree.
Does that make him racist.?
In the film django which is based on slavery this exact point is made near the end of the film.
If it was bollox why didnt anyone object when it was released.
This was a witch hunt on watson because some people cant handle the truth.
It hurts as they say.
I will also catergorically state that there are a great many extremely clever black people.
That though doesnt disprove watsons general point.
There are probably black people who would agree with this but will be shut down as it wouldnt fit the ideological points being forced on society.

That's very complimentary of you

 


Paua oouaarancì Irà chiyeah Ishé galé ma ba oo ah

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jan 19 4.59pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

What are your thoughts on his findings Hrolf, do you think that white people are more clever than black people?

What I think doesn't matter. However, this chap would not make such claims without evidence to back it up.

What is more important is that a renowned scientist and founder of genetics can be punished for having an informed opinion.

Just think about that for a minute.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 13 Jan 19 5.20pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

What I think doesn't matter. However, this chap would not make such claims without evidence to back it up.

What is more important is that a renowned scientist and founder of genetics can be punished for having an informed opinion.

Just think about that for a minute.

That does not normally stop you from expressing your opinion.

I'm not disagreeing with your post by the way. Just wondering if you agree with what he says.

So do you think that White people are more intelligent than black people?


 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Jan 19 6.40pm

Originally posted by Pussay Patrol

That's very complimentary of you

Thats the only line you read i guess.
But context doesnt matter within this subject does it!

If there is evidence then just because it "seems"
Racist to it doesnt mean it is.
Thats the problem now.
The fact that any thing said against anyone who isnt white is racist.
Take gangs and tell me they are not a majority of black individuals.
Do you really think they are clever to
Firstly join a gang
Secondly show off about it
Thirdly stab and be stabbed.

Where are all the white gangs.
Oh sorry
Surely they must be slightly more enlightened not to do it.

The evidence is there in its most basic form but lets not talk about it and try to find a solution.
Lets brush it away and like its not true.
That is true racism; not even accepting it may be true, not even wanting to entertain helping the situation. so dont give me the big arrow pussey because you and yours are so subconciously racist its beyond comparrison.

 

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jan 19 7.10pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

That does not normally stop you from expressing your opinion.

I'm not disagreeing with your post by the way. Just wondering if you agree with what he says.

So do you think that White people are more intelligent than black people?



I'm flattered that you think my opinion is so important but it is still not relevant to this thread.

What is relevant is the selective use of scientific data to satisfy the 'progressive' mob.
What's more, they didn't just criticise this man but actually removed some of his, no doubt, well earned honours.
This guy is not just any old scientist, he is one of the founders of genetics.

Totally unacceptable. This how you might expect a religion to behave, not the scientific community.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jan 19 7.33pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

That does not normally stop you from expressing your opinion.

I'm not disagreeing with your post by the way. Just wondering if you agree with what he says.

So do you think that White people are more intelligent than black people?



On average Europeans are more 'intelligent' than Africans but less intelligent than East Asians.

East Asians have the highest average intelligence in the world. There are other groups who do better in verbal intelligence but overall that's what the statistics seem to show.

However, any one individual is rarely a perfect example of a genetic European or African or whatever. However, if we strictly stick to averages we can make basic statements.

However, individuals aren't defined by a group average. For example, I've taught intelligent and not so intelligent examples of just about every category of human.

It's also very true that intelligence is only one factor.....the most important factor in some respects but still just one attribute.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jan 2019 7.36pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 13 Jan 19 7.35pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger

[Link]

This story infuriates me.

To persecute a man, not just any man, an eminent scientist, for his opinions is a shameful display of the kind of fascist attitudes that prevail in our scientific community and wider society.

Disagree with him, produce counter evidence by all means but don't resort to this disgraceful tactic.

A man's worth is not measured entirely by his intelligence but in the practical world, you can't keep putting square pegs in round holes merely to satisfy some ideological fashion.
We test people's intelligence all the time at school and in higher education so why do we bother? Maybe all us thickies should protest and demand that all the evidence of our limited academic ability be suppressed.

All this begs the question, how far would these zealots go to sustain their idealistic fantasy?
Also, how can we trust in science when it clearly picks and chooses the bits that fit with the fashionable 'correct' enforced consensus?

Great post.

What has happened to this great man is a complete disgrace......This is what the left do.....they destroy people if they regard them as having the 'wrong' opinions. A lot of people are intimated if they have something to lose.

This guy is part of such an important breakthrough that is responsible for so much good in the world.

History will restore him.

Edited by Stirlingsays (13 Jan 2019 7.40pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Jan 19 8.11pm

I have no idea if Watson is correct. However as a scientist he should know that if you are going to put forward a theory that goes against the consensus then you had better back it up with facts. As a geneticist I would have thought he could point to the DNA strand that supports his theory?

From what I have read today he hasn't done that and apparently neither has anyway else. Most scientists will argue that the differences between peoples are socio-economic and cultural and have nothing to do with genetics. They maybe wrong but it is up to someone to prove that.

I find it sad that he is being vilified for his views and his great achievement is being over looked. From what I read he is not a racist just a person making a controversial statement with very little to back it up.

Edited by Badger11 (13 Jan 2019 8.29pm)

 


One more point

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 13 Jan 19 10.11pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I have no idea if Watson is correct. However as a scientist he should know that if you are going to put forward a theory that goes against the consensus then you had better back it up with facts. As a geneticist I would have thought he could point to the DNA strand that supports his theory?

From what I have read today he hasn't done that and apparently neither has anyway else. Most scientists will argue that the differences between peoples are socio-economic and cultural and have nothing to do with genetics. They maybe wrong but it is up to someone to prove that.

I find it sad that he is being vilified for his views and his great achievement is being over looked. From what I read he is not a racist just a person making a controversial statement with very little to back it up.

Edited by Badger11 (13 Jan 2019 8.29pm)


On what are you basing this assumption?

I'm sure a man of his background would not make such a statement unless he can support it.
The question is whether those condemning him can support their argument with facts or if they are just being conformist for unscientific reasons.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 13 Jan 19 10.45pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


On what are you basing this assumption?

I'm sure a man of his background would not make such a statement unless he can support it.
The question is whether those condemning him can support their argument with facts or if they are just being conformist for unscientific reasons.

I have seen this story in a number of articles and several radio reports. If he has evidence then they are not reporting it.

 


One more point

cryrst Flag The garden of England 13 Jan 19 11.00pm

Originally posted by Badger11

I have seen this story in a number of articles and several radio reports. If he has evidence then they are not reporting it.

And judging peoples reactions due to it being about race do you think they would?

 

chateauferret Flag 13 Jan 19 11.00pm

Originally posted by Hrolf The Ganger


On what are you basing this assumption?

I'm sure a man of his background would not make such a statement unless he can support it.
The question is whether those condemning him can support their argument with facts or if they are just being conformist for unscientific reasons.

I would have thought it were straightforward to produce sample surveys of different races that show to a given confidence level that there are statistically significant differences between them in terms of intelligence, physical strength, size, sensory perception, longevity etc. etc. etc. And that should surprise nobody: they evolved in different environments and those environments demanded different attributes for survival, growth and competition with other hominid species.

It says nothing about the relative value of races or peoples and that is where some people have got it wrong. Some wine is red and some is white. Is white wine "better" than red wine? Of course not. It's just different.

 


============
The Ferret
============

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 14 Jan 19 12.24am

Originally posted by Badger11

I have seen this story in a number of articles and several radio reports. If he has evidence then they are not reporting it.

The man co discovered DNA. Do you think he might know what he is talking about?
This is about silencing uncomfortable truths. Science might be full of them.

Research involving nature v nurture, for example, has been covered up in the past.
There was a recently exposed experiment where US government scientists split up quadruplet boys and made them live different lives to see what happened. The results were not published.

The men behind the curtain don't want us to know what they know and they want us to think the right thoughts.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 14 Jan 19 12.33am

Originally posted by chateauferret

I would have thought it were straightforward to produce sample surveys of different races that show to a given confidence level that there are statistically significant differences between them in terms of intelligence, physical strength, size, sensory perception, longevity etc. etc. etc. And that should surprise nobody: they evolved in different environments and those environments demanded different attributes for survival, growth and competition with other hominid species.

It says nothing about the relative value of races or peoples and that is where some people have got it wrong. Some wine is red and some is white. Is white wine "better" than red wine? Of course not. It's just different.

in Evolution, environment is everything.

Eskimo peoples are short, with short arms and legs and a torso which is evolved to conserve heat. Fair enough.

the irish are world champions at digesting cow's milk.

australian aboriginals have a supernatural ability to remember landmarks across large boring undulating terrains of land.....

in all cases because that characteristic saved the lives of their forebears.

as for intelligence ? it must be environment again. A cushty environment with a generous dole will spawn lazy stupids. A nasty rat race will favour cunning rats. An environment which gives opportunities to for teams to succeed, and not loners, will breed team-players.

like ascertaining what women want in a man....its complex and multivariate. Stephen Hawking was super clever, yet many footballers wives would prefer to stick with the footballer.

tall trees was the environment that made giraffes tall. Human environments across all history and geography are all different...fostering differences in the people. Its basic science. But its not all about IQ. Its adaptation to environments.

Tibetans have adaptations to high altitude living...in the genes. Whether they were clever or stupid was of lesser importance. What pretty woman in Tibet wants to marry a bloke who spends his whole time sitting in the corner trying to catch his breath ? who will dance with her at the ball tonight ?

imagine if Silicone Valley stayed the same for 200 years. Eventually all the kids being born there would have a natural talent for computer programming. Failure computer-programmers cannot afford the high cost of living in Silicone Valley and always move away....and have kids somewhere far away.

my theory on the extremely high IQ of some groups of European Jews is after hundreds and hundreds of years of persecution and harshness from Romans & later Christians ... the clever jews learned to survive - the other jews didnt survive the persecutions. The fact of so many Physics Labs in america having so many jewish number-crunchers working there could be a innate talent with numbers following hundreds years of their forebears being banned from most professions but allowed to work as moneylenders. The Merchant of Venice is all based on a real history. Sometimes environment favours intelligence, sometimes it doesn't.

for most mammal species, the females will mostly all reproduce. Only the successful males will do so. therefore much of the pressures on natural selection happen down the male line. Males must often compete with each other in a way that may seem unseemly if you saw two females fighting each other.

if you are a tenth generation.. <insert profession here >.... the chances are you will have a natural talent for that job. If i told you the room beside you was filled with sons of professional basketball players and goalkeepers what sort of height would you expect those kids to be ?

Environment is everything. For sure, humanity did not stop evolving 50,000 years ago when we left Africa. Its every year, even up to today. If you are connected to South London you are royalty, if its Brighton you smell of birdsh..t

Edited by PalazioVecchio (14 Jan 2019 1.01am)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Stirlingsays Flag 14 Jan 19 1.43am

The work on intelligence has pretty much been done to death.....the work on twin studies brought up in different environments and their scores for example.

However what the research has shown is that....what we are call innate intelligence is something between 50 - 80 percent set from genetics....it's probably in reality nearer that higher end.

You can't just become Einstein from a great environment.....You can't just become McCartney from a great environment......Just as you can't grow longer arms you can't become greater than your intellectual potential.

Because intelligence is so highly prized and it is connected to massive value judgements.....people just don't want to hear it.

But the truth isn't about making people feel good.

However, no one should feel guilty over their genetics and we want a society that works for everybody regardless of ability.....In my book intelligence is not as important as allegiance.

Besides work on genetics will hopefully eventually result in humans ridding ourselves of the terrible life limiting affects of genetically set retardation......though obviously those technologies will also be open to abuse.

Anyway, It doesn't matter how smart a group is if everyone is pulling in different directions.

The establishment simply hide the findings when it comes to 'race'. They don't like what it shows because it's not politically correct and offends their ideas on equality. When it's brought up they obfuscate and question the findings far more than they would other findings...and they look to destroy the individuals presenting them.

That's what has happened here.....just as it happened to Charles Murray.


Edited by Stirlingsays (14 Jan 2019 3.05am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Nobel winning biologist, James Watson.