This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Selling Scott Dann to Fulham?
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
Maine Eagle USA 28 Jan 19 3.08pm |
|
|
Apparently they are sniffing around and we would get Cahill in on loan if it happens.
Understand he wants to play but he is potentially one injury away from starting for us and why would we want to make Fulham better?
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
matthau South Croydon 28 Jan 19 3.14pm |
|
|
Heard it aswell
I guess it makes sense on the basis that we are currently skint
Cahill loan, Dan sold for millions
|
Buckspalace Thornborough 28 Jan 19 3.25pm |
|
|
No Dann needs to stop as cover for either Sakho or particularly Tomkins who does suffer from niggly injuries. Dann can step straight back in, do not need Cahill here, I do fear in the summer that Mamadou Sakho may go also.
|
topcat Holmesdale / Surbiton 28 Jan 19 3.30pm |
|
|
I'd be surprised if this happened.
It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.
|
I'mPalace Till I Die 28 Jan 19 3.51pm |
|
|
He's on high wages right... so if we can reduce the wage bill then I guess it makes sense for this transfer. We have Kelly as back-up who is coming along well and could buy another young CB. We don't want Cahill though imo
|
premier fan BR4 28 Jan 19 4.27pm |
|
|
We'd be silly to sell Dann and I think the player would end up playing in the Championship. I can't see this happening.
|
SW19 CPFC Addiscombe West 28 Jan 19 4.30pm |
|
|
In an ideal world we keep Tomkins, Dann, Kelly and Sakho on the books.
But if we're in a situation of 10m for Dann and freeing up some wages to get another player in, then going probably makes sense. We managed to cope quite well with having just Kelly as backup while Dann was out and Kelly has performed brilliantly most times he's been called upon.
He's also younger than Dann, probably on less wages, and maybe happier to be a squad player. As a former key player and club captain, with only 2 or 3 more years left at a high level I think it would be fair to let him explore other options to get one last contract/more playing time elsewhere.
I don't think this is a Murray situation, especially if we have Cahill coming in on loan to cover for the rest of the season. Emotionally it will be sad to see him go but logically, I think it makes sense.
Did you know? 98.0000001% of people are morons.
|
taylors lovechild 28 Jan 19 4.32pm |
|
|
Fulham's defence is sh*t. Let's leave it that way please. If we sold Dann and replaced him with Cahill that would be mad as surely Cahill is on at least if not more money? If Dann wants to go to Celtic or something then maybe, but given we have supported him through his injury he shouldn't be too demanding. Go in the summer if you want Scott, but not now.
|
NEILLO Shoreham-by-Sea 28 Jan 19 4.35pm |
|
|
Scott's the wrong side of 30 and just been out for a year.
I don't think he would command an especially high fee.
Would rather keep him than sign Cahill, but I'm sure Dann wants to play every week and not act as cover.
Old, Ungifted and White
|
Crystal ClearCPFC Croydon 28 Jan 19 5.40pm |
|
|
It would be silly to sell him to one of the teams around us which would only strengthen them. If Fulham really want him then they can wait until the end of the season. If they want him now then nothing less than 15 million.
then go ahead and spend 7 million of it on a defender next season. spend the other 8 million towards a striker this season.
|
YT Oxford 28 Jan 19 6.33pm |
|
Originally posted by premier fan
We'd be silly to sell Dann and I think the player would end up playing in the Championship. I can't see this happening.
Plus he must now have the sniff of more big cup matches in his nostrils.
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
matthau South Croydon 28 Jan 19 6.48pm |
|
Originally posted by Crystal ClearCPFC
It would be silly to sell him to one of the teams around us which would only strengthen them. If Fulham really want him then they can wait until the end of the season. If they want him now then nothing less than 15 million.
then go ahead and spend 7 million of it on a defender next season. spend the other 8 million towards a striker this season.
And that may well be what’s happening. Fulham maybe offering us silly money
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 28 Jan 19 8.19pm |
|
|
A big risk selling a good player to a relegation rival. One who could make the difference for them. If it was to China for silly money absolutely but not Fulham
|
sprites Auckland 28 Jan 19 8.30pm |
|
|
Have to keep our better players. Plus he's one of our leaders. Madness to sell.
|
chris123 hove actually 28 Jan 19 8.33pm |
|
Originally posted by sprites
Have to keep our better players. Plus he's one of our leaders. Madness to sell.
He organises all the time too which I like as we are often not vocal at the back.
|
merganser 28 Jan 19 8.42pm |
|
|
And he’s a proven goalscorer!
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 28 Jan 19 10.20pm |
|
|
Very very silly move.
|
sprites Auckland 28 Jan 19 11.50pm |
|
|
This is actually really crucial. Until last weekend where Tonks nodded one in, we'd been totally ineffectual at corners. No threat. Dann is a master and contributes 3-8 goals a season from set piece. Could make a big difference.
|
crvenaeagle 29 Jan 19 3.57am |
|
|
Is Cahill actually any better than Dann? I wouldn't have said so, old fart with a square head.
|
Maine Eagle USA 29 Jan 19 4.47am |
|
Originally posted by crvenaeagle
Is Cahill actually any better than Dann? I wouldn't have said so, old fart with a square head.
All things considered I would rather retain Scott Dann than replace him with Cahill.
This may be more about the sh*t state of financial affairs that parish has presided over than anything else, if we do sell him.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|