You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Townsend worth more than Zaha ?
November 16 2026 6.52am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Townsend worth more than Zaha ?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
billtheglazier Flag twickenham 28 Jan 19 4.25pm

I Wasnt sure if I should start a new post but feel this is a separate topic to other posts.
As has been said on other posts Andros has been immense for us this season and I guess most Palace fans would give him the player of the season status so far.
Wilf in my opinion is the most exciting player Ive ever seen in a lifetime of watching Palace from the days of Johnny Byrne,Peter Taylor,Vince Hillaire Don Rogers and Lombardo...Wilf ranks the highest imo.
But this season Andros has shown greater skills,speed and awareness and I believe has generally troubled defenses as much as Wilf,if not more.If he carries on in this current trajectory for further seasons, he will be up there with the above Palace greats.

Wilf has seemingly lost his enthusiasm a little and frequently ambles back following his sorties in attack.
I feel hes ready to move on and we should replace him with a player such as Gerard Deulofeu who I think would fit in well.
I shall seriously miss Wilf but he must go in my opinion, for his own sake as well as ours.

 


[Link]
Following The Palace since 1956,
Rocking the Blues since 68.!!

premier fan Flag BR4 28 Jan 19 4.31pm


I disagree

Wilf is worth more than Andros
We shouldn't sell our talisman
And AWB is probably our player of the season so far.

I do agree that Wilf is not as good as last season but he's still a brilliant player that can win games for us.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 28 Jan 19 4.42pm

Andros gives a lot of effort every game which is always great to see as a fan compared to Wilf's apparent disinterest from time to time.

However Andros does have the capacity to occasionally not match that with quality, although the same could be said for Wilf I suppose.

I would suggest Wilf is still the bigger asset, however I understand the post, Andros is a quality player that we're lucky to have and his performances this season, and of late, are far outranking Wilf's.

That said, I wouldn't sell either of them off the back of 10-15 games!

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

thechaddyboy Flag Peterborough 28 Jan 19 5.14pm

And to think there was talk of him going back to Newcastle not so long back although not sure it was fueled by Andros himself. Think Wilf edges it due to the tricks & flicks but I'd hate to lose either of them

 


Red & Blue since 73'

Vaibow Flag vancouver/croydon 29 Jan 19 1.17am

Andros is exactly the type of player we need. Not only that, but he seems level headed and perhaps knows his limit - which has a big influence surely.

Wilf, if he was on the books at watford and available, he would never chose a club like us and we ultimately wouldn't be trying to sign him.

Thing is, recently AT has been consistently good, scored a worldie - wilf hasn't either.

Some fans really need to understand what kind of player we need and what a club can do for some players.

 


This was once a quality forum....

Maine Eagle Flag USA 29 Jan 19 1.26am

No.

 


Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.

PalaceSi Flag Brockley 29 Jan 19 2.25am

Andros is worth about £15M, Wilf north of 50M.
Wilf is wanted by virtually all the top 6, Andros wouldn't get in any of their teams. There's a world of difference though Andros's highlights reel is certainly improving and he is putting in some decent shifts.
He doesn't have 2/3 people on him every time he gets the ball though something Wilf has to deal with every game.

 

crvenaeagle Flag 29 Jan 19 3.52am

Willies form has dropped ever since the his referee comments fiasco.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 29 Jan 19 6.24am

Originally posted by PalaceSi

Andros is worth about £15M, Wilf north of 50M.
Wilf is wanted by virtually all the top 6, Andros wouldn't get in any of their teams. There's a world of difference though Andros's highlights reel is certainly improving and he is putting in some decent shifts.
He doesn't have 2/3 people on him every time he gets the ball though something Wilf has to deal with every game.

Who out of the top 6 has made a bid for him ? None of them are interested or they’d have bought him.
I don’t think that either would get in any of their starting elevens, great for us though.

Edited by Casual (29 Jan 2019 6.29am)

 

Casual Flag Orpington 29 Jan 19 6.28am

Can’t believe that Zaha is spoken about as not reaching his peak yet and on another thread it was said that Townsend is slowing down and getting old. They are 26 and 27. Zaha has a lot more natural ability than Townsend , but mentally one is like a boy and the other one a man.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 29 Jan 19 8.46am

Townsends contribution to the team overall has been far greater than Zaha this season, no question, but Zaha would command a larger fee.
Go figure!

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 29 Jan 19 9.01am

Wilf has had a couple of games where he has been marked out of the game that is all, Townsend is doing what he should do but he is doing the defending bit very well at the moment so shines brightly, teams can cope with one tricky player reasonably well but two gives them the
defensive shits, look at Spurs all fit.

Wilf is a threat every game no team can ignore him for one second, good on Townsend to step up like he is though, if he keeps it up we will finish above Everton like I said before.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 29 Jan 19 9.02am

Originally posted by Casual

Can’t believe that Zaha is spoken about as not reaching his peak yet and on another thread it was said that Townsend is slowing down and getting old. They are 26 and 27. Zaha has a lot more natural ability than Townsend , but mentally one is like a boy and the other one a man.

One gets rough treatment.

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 29 Jan 19 9.04am

That's why we notice his behaviour.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 29 Jan 19 9.45am

Townsend has better mental toughness. Plays hard with controlled aggression for 95 minutes. I cannot remember him sulking or looking cross.

A bloody good eagle

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

Fatherken Flag 29 Jan 19 10.30am

was on Sunday and if Zaha carries on playing like he did at the weekend I would drop him

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 29 Jan 19 11.06am

Townsend had many loans to clubs when at Spurs.
he know that other players had to work hard at those clubs as they have mortgages.. he has a toughness Wilf will never have!!

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

Townsend has better mental toughness. Plays hard with controlled aggression for 95 minutes. I cannot remember him sulking or looking cross.

A bloody good eagle

 

A1969Eagle Flag Redhill 29 Jan 19 11.15am

Something needs to happen!!
100% class player
But is he a team player?
Or is it about trying to do all the tricks and turn but not seeing the passes, his quite capable off, but rather do more efficient passes/runs until he gets his form back

Timid tackles, he falls over and moans

Yes always seem to have two players around him, but if he could only gamble with passing quicker sometimes, but we have to be aware Van Aanholt (in poor form a from his high levels last season) link up play isn't good this season, last year was amazing.....

He ambers back!!!!! but is that a disguise??
Always moaning to other team players about a better ball to him but how often the other way round without moaning, "shrugs of shoulders".. "it wasnt my fault...."

COME OF WILF!!


Originally posted by Fatherken

was on Sunday and if Zaha carries on playing like he did at the weekend I would drop him

 

Part Time James Flag 29 Jan 19 12.27pm

I wouldn't want to lose either player. But if we're talking price tags, Wan Bissaka's must be close to being the biggest in our team now. Form, coupled with his age, he's got to be our most valuable asset.

 




twist Flag Miami, Florida 29 Jan 19 1.08pm

Andros is definately more energetic, goes on more runs, but delivers less in and around the box.

WIlf can be frustrating, both to us fans and the opposing players, depending on his mood. But far and above delivers more in and around the box than Andros.

If Wilf would stop flopping and play to the refs whistle, the refs would protect him more, and he would be top quality. It can be easy to take wilf out of a game just by messing with his head.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Townsend worth more than Zaha ?