You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2?
November 16 2026 6.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

3-5-2?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 9.42am

Correct me if i am wrong but didnt Brighton play just Murray up front.
If so why did we play a back 4? Surely wouldnt a 3-5-2 formatoimisen have been far more beneficial and attack minded without sacrificing our defensive duties. We would have no doubt one the midfield, given us the width so badly needed in order to get balls into the box and given their 2 Centre backs something to think about. The midfield having Kouyate and Meyer included this giving us the balance of toughness and flair, so badly missing yesterday.
My team would have been......
Guaita

Dann
Tompkins
Kelly

Wan-Bissaka
Luka
Meyer
Kouyate
Schlupp

Zaha
Batman

We are too much of a one trick Pony at home and so predictable.and with it so easy to play against. I have to saa yesterday reminded me of England home ganes under Roy...... clueless!

 


Bring back Brolin

PatrickA Flag London 10 Mar 19 9.58am

I mentioned 3-5-2 as an option earlier in the season and was drowned with protests that our back 3 didn’t have the pace or experience of playing this formation.
However, when teams only play one striker and don’t commit players forward I can see merit in the formation.
We can outnumber teams in midfield, attack across the width of the pitch and have our front 2 roam up front and drag the central defenders out of position.
Not a chance of Roy doing it though - he’s a dyed in the wool 4-4-2 or 4-3-3 man.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 10 Mar 19 10.08am

For those who want Roy sacked, I suppose this would probably do the trick; it certainly worked on that Dutch bloke.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

MonsterMunch Flag Cambridge 10 Mar 19 10.13am

Originally posted by bexleydave

For those who want Roy sacked, I suppose this would probably do the trick; it certainly worked on that Dutch bloke.

I don’t want Roy sacked now. However this form cannot continue any longer. Roy does not show any signs of being able to come up with a solution at home. I’m sure the owners are already thinking this way. Mutual agreement in the summer I would imagine.

 

PatrickA Flag London 10 Mar 19 10.25am

De Boer tried the formation with the inexperienced Riedewald and Fossu Mensah as two of the 3 defenders and also experimented with Luka in the back 3 and Townsend at wing back.
Just because it didn’t work with one set of players it doesn’t mean it won’t work with another set of players.
Clearly we need a different tactical approach at home whether at the start or during games.
Even try 4-4-2 again if necessary, but try and gain control of the midfield and give the strikers some decent service.

 

bexleydave Flag Barnehurst 10 Mar 19 10.26am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

I don’t want Roy sacked now. However this form cannot continue any longer. Roy does not show any signs of being able to come up with a solution at home. I’m sure the owners are already thinking this way. Mutual agreement in the summer I would imagine.

I don't think two of the main shareholders give a toss either way do they? For me, the problem at home is more about team selection and substitutions than formation; although I wouldn't object to seeing 4-4-2 tried a bit more. IF we stay up this season I'm 50:50 on Roy's immediate future as there has to be a time when we have some consistency in management and, at least on the face of it, Roy does seem to be able to work with Parish.

 


Bexley Dave

Can you hear the Brighton sing? I can't hear a ******* thing!

"The most arrogant, obnoxious bunch of deluded little sun tanned, loafer wearing mummy's boys I've ever had the misfortune of having to listen to" (Burnley forum)

NEILLO Flag Shoreham-by-Sea 10 Mar 19 10.44am

Originally posted by MonsterMunch

I don’t want Roy sacked now. However this form cannot continue any longer. Roy does not show any signs of being able to come up with a solution at home. I’m sure the owners are already thinking this way. Mutual agreement in the summer I would imagine.

As I mentioned elsewhere, he's in good company there - Holloway, Pulis, Allardyce and Pardew also were unable to resolve the problem.

I think the news re the sale of the club has the potential to see a number of key changes, the managers position being just one of them.

 


Old, Ungifted and White

Elpis Flag In a pub 10 Mar 19 10.49am

Originally posted by PatrickA

De Boer tried the formation with the inexperienced Riedewald and Fossu Mensah as two of the 3 defenders and also experimented with Luka in the back 3 and Townsend at wing back.
Just because it didn’t work with one set of players it doesn’t mean it won’t work with another set of players.
Clearly we need a different tactical approach at home whether at the start or during games.
Even try 4-4-2 again if necessary, but try and gain control of the midfield and give the strikers some decent service.

I would agree with above. 352 is easily adaptable to 532 , 541 ,351-1 without having to make subs which would be right up Roys street .

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 11.00am

Originally posted by bexleydave

For those who want Roy sacked, I suppose this would probably do the trick; it certainly worked on that Dutch bloke.

For the record i do not with to see Roy sacked just change fornation at home. As a PL Manager with 40 years experience he ought to be able to adapt, after all that is what a training pitch is all about.

 


Bring back Brolin

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 10 Mar 19 1.52pm

Originally posted by bexleydave

For those who want Roy sacked, I suppose this would probably do the trick; it certainly worked on that Dutch bloke.

FDB seemed as pragmatic as Roy, wishing to play this system every game when it clearly wasn't working over 4 games. Roy could easily give this a go in say 1 match when there is limited attacking threat at home, say the Udders at home ? Can't really think why he could not try this, as clearly our formation at home isn't working.

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Booted Eagle Flag Bristol 10 Mar 19 2.18pm

Originally posted by NEILLO

As I mentioned elsewhere, he's in good company there - Holloway, Pulis, Allardyce and Pardew also were unable to resolve the problem.

I think the news re the sale of the club has the potential to see a number of key changes, the managers position being just one of them.

Haven't looked at the stats for these managers (Ollie can be ignored as we weren't good home or away under his brief stay as manager in the PL) but feel that this season the difference between home and away results seems more marked. We did show Jekyll and Hyde tendencies under Pards but that was one half of the season to the next. Under Pulis we were scrapping for everything throughout the team, personnel seem different now.

Edited by Booted Eagle (10 Mar 2019 2.20pm)

 


“ [T]here are known knowns; there are things we know that we know.There are known unknowns; that is to say there are things that, we now know we don't know.But there are also unknown unknowns – there are things we do not know we don't know. ”
—United States Secretary of Defense, Donald Rumsfeld

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Mar 19 3.00pm

Bizarre suggestion. We have 3 centre backs total at the moment, none of whom will really step forward to give an extra man in midfield. Wilf should not be playing up front, he should be wide with Andros on the other side. What Roy should have done yesterday was play Meyer in the central 3, or go with two sitting midfielders and Meyer behind the striker.

Roy is not operating with the set of players that he wants. He doesn't want Meyer, but there's a disconnect with the scouting team so that's who he was given rather than a proper replacement for RLC.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 10 Mar 19 3.14pm

Originally posted by Bangell

Bizarre suggestion. We have 3 centre backs total at the moment, none of whom will really step forward to give an extra man in midfield. Wilf should not be playing up front, he should be wide with Andros on the other side. What Roy should have done yesterday was play Meyer in the central 3, or go with two sitting midfielders and Meyer behind the striker.

Roy is not operating with the set of players that he wants. He doesn't want Meyer, but there's a disconnect with the scouting team so that's who he was given rather than a proper replacement for RLC.

You know this for an undeniable fact? Examples, sources please.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 3.43pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

You know this for an undeniable fact? Examples, sources please.

It wouldn’t surprise me.

 


Bring back Brolin

rollercoaster Flag Cornwall 10 Mar 19 3.55pm

Not sure it matters to the Roy out let's get someone foreign in Brigade.
Would have been a big risk to change formation so radically for a game like this. I don't think we've got the personnel or frankly the ability to successfully switch systems. Even FDB realised that a Kelly/Dann/Tomkins combination would not work as these players would really struggle to get out wide when required and struggle to bring the ball out of defence.

I think we pressed forward fairly well in the game. Our passing was poor and we didn't get he ball forward quickly enough, not the formation that was wrong. Looked like 6 in midfield most of the game. We could have gone all out and started with two strikers but given our finishing ability, I suspect Brighton would have outscored us.

So for me at home, our problems for me are:
Lack of quality shooting from outside the box.
Poor short and long passing.
Not enough movement from the forwards.
Midfield not getting ahead of the striker.
Slow passing
Free kicks and corners.

With packed defences, free kicks and corners are the commonest route to goal and we have had none of this (apart from Pens). I think the team need to do more prep/practice, vary the taker and get more variations into our set-plays.

 

dynamicdick Flag Dormansland 10 Mar 19 7.30pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Not sure it matters to the Roy out let's get someone foreign in Brigade.
Would have been a big risk to change formation so radically for a game like this. I don't think we've got the personnel or frankly the ability to successfully switch systems. Even FDB realised that a Kelly/Dann/Tomkins combination would not work as these players would really struggle to get out wide when required and struggle to bring the ball out of defence.

I think we pressed forward fairly well in the game. Our passing was poor and we didn't get he ball forward quickly enough, not the formation that was wrong. Looked like 6 in midfield most of the game. We could have gone all out and started with two strikers but given our finishing ability, I suspect Brighton would have outscored us.

So for me at home, our problems for me are:
Lack of quality shooting from outside the box.
Poor short and long passing.
Not enough movement from the forwards.
Midfield not getting ahead of the striker.
Slow passing
Free kicks and corners.

With packed defences, free kicks and corners are the commonest route to goal and we have had none of this (apart from Pens). I think the team need to do more prep/practice, vary the taker and get more variations into our set-plays.

Some good points made but part of my opening OP was that as a Ptem club and coupled with Roy’s 40 years of experience we ought to be capable of switching formations and with ease. Training should accommodate this. We are at present so limited in this area which, must also be frustrating for the players. I would repeat that I am not in the Roy Out camp but want more flexibility.

 


Bring back Brolin

AdelaideEagle Flag Adelaide 10 Mar 19 10.05pm

I really wish we could take a decent corner. We get so excited and applaud when we win a corner, really? I moan coz I wonder if we can hit it past the first defender. The low fizzing corners invariably get headed like a bullet away out of the danger zone and then the opposition push out and opportunity lost. Loft one up with a bit of height and less speed and the ball might even stay in the box for at least the chance of a 2nd effort?

Palace were always dangerous at corners, now we cannot make a decent contest. Rant over

 


True Blue Red 'n' Blue !!!

Bangell Flag Oxford 10 Mar 19 10.23pm

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

You know this for an undeniable fact? Examples, sources please.

Well the alternative is that Roy really wanted Meyer but now that he's at the club, he realises he doesn't want him after all.

Meyer obviously isn't the type of midfielder that Roy wants for him system, that's why he doesn't play. Thinking back to last season's January transfer window, when Roy clearly did not want Rakip or Jach and made a point of not playing them, I don't think it's unreasonable to suggest that there's a disconnect between the scouting department and the manager. I really do think the Meyer signing was a case of 'Ooh, here's an exciting young German international on a free, what an opportunity - let's sign him up!'
Only for him not to be played in any of the matches where he's the obvious choice (Wolves home, Newcastle home, Brighton home)...

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 10 Mar 19 10.40pm

Originally posted by rollercoaster

Not sure it matters to the Roy out let's get someone foreign in Brigade.
Would have been a big risk to change formation so radically for a game like this. I don't think we've got the personnel or frankly the ability to successfully switch systems. Even FDB realised that a Kelly/Dann/Tomkins combination would not work as these players would really struggle to get out wide when required and struggle to bring the ball out of defence.

I think we pressed forward fairly well in the game. Our passing was poor and we didn't get he ball forward quickly enough, not the formation that was wrong. Looked like 6 in midfield most of the game. We could have gone all out and started with two strikers but given our finishing ability, I suspect Brighton would have outscored us.

So for me at home, our problems for me are:
Lack of quality shooting from outside the box.
Poor short and long passing.
Not enough movement from the forwards.
Midfield not getting ahead of the striker.
Slow passing
Free kicks and corners.

With packed defences, free kicks and corners are the commonest route to goal and we have had none of this (apart from Pens). I think the team need to do more prep/practice, vary the taker and get more variations into our set-plays.

So just about every aspect of our forward play then. Makes you wonder what they do in training every day.
Oh wait, it must be practicing passing sideways and backwards very slowly...and practice makes perfect..

 

aashman12 Flag 11 Mar 19 7.56am

Originally posted by dynamicdick

Correct me if i am wrong but didnt Brighton play just Murray up front.
If so why did we play a back 4? Surely wouldnt a 3-5-2 formatoimisen have been far more beneficial and attack minded without sacrificing our defensive duties. We would have no doubt one the midfield, given us the width so badly needed in order to get balls into the box and given their 2 Centre backs something to think about. The midfield having Kouyate and Meyer included this giving us the balance of toughness and flair, so badly missing yesterday.
My team would have been......
Guaita

Dann
Tompkins
Kelly

Wan-Bissaka
Luka
Meyer
Kouyate
Schlupp

Zaha
Batman

We are too much of a one trick Pony at home and so predictable.and with it so easy to play against. I have to saa yesterday reminded me of England home ganes under Roy...... clueless!

So we move zaha inside away from where he does all his damage and drop the hard working class act that is Townsend.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > 3-5-2?