This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Scott Dann
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
jjsperling 30 Mar 19 7.01pm |
|
|
Why does everyone seem to think that Dann is better than Kelly. He was awful today. Terrible defending and every time the ball was at his feet he'd just hoof it 30 yards away from any palace player. Kelly's gotta be in against spurs
|
HesHereHesThere Beckenham 30 Mar 19 7.25pm |
|
|
Bang on agree
|
Casual Orpington 30 Mar 19 7.41pm |
|
|
Yep agree. Kelly is a very good back up center back. Anyone that thinks of him negatively is remembering him as a full back, where he is shocking.
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 30 Mar 19 7.55pm |
|
|
He got absolutely roasted by that guy in the first half. I just couldn’t believe how slow he was.
|
Tickled pink Cornwall 30 Mar 19 10.32pm |
|
|
Injury didn't do him any favours, Kelly is miles and miles better.
|
Brinscall Eagle Brinscall Lancashire/ Villamartin ... 30 Mar 19 10.43pm |
|
|
We will need Kelly against Spurs on Wednesday or we will end up conceding loads. With Dann as good as he is there are too many spaces left when he plays. Kelly must play on Wednesday.COYP
|
Rachid Rachid Rachid 30 Mar 19 11.10pm |
|
|
Horses for courses. Kelly gets bullied against big / strong teams as we saw at against Watford.
Dann’s the wrong side of thirty and come back from a career threatening injury but stronger defending the penalty area.
|
Maine Eagle USA 30 Mar 19 11.18pm |
|
Originally posted by jjsperling
Why does everyone seem to think that Dann is better than Kelly. He was awful today. Terrible defending and every time the ball was at his feet he'd just hoof it 30 yards away from any palace player. Kelly's gotta be in against spurs
His distribution today was an absolute joke.
It wasnt even non league standard.
He is being asked to spray some balls around by the manager I expect, and is not, and never has been any good at that. The manager should recognize that and instruct him not to go long except when under pressure.
He is no Sakho.
Trump lost. Badly. Hahahahahahaha.
|
Eaglecoops CR3 31 Mar 19 11.37am |
|
|
Good solid player, great in the air, but past his best now. We should maybe sell him this summer as he would still do a great job in the Championship. Perhaps bring in the youngster who is being touted as a talent as fourth centre back next season.
|
Phil’s Barber Crowborough 31 Mar 19 2.16pm |
|
|
I agree with the consensus so far on this thread. Great player for us in the past and a good club Captain but yesterday showed he really is past it now at this level.
He was exposed so badly yesterday for his lack of pace and his distribution was shocking. Yes he is good in the air but we need far more than that at this level. Having both Dann and Tomkins as our two centre backs gives us potentially the slowest and least mobile pairing in the league.
|
Hrolf The Ganger 31 Mar 19 2.27pm |
|
|
The problem is signing players who are quality and will sit on the bench. We have two very good CH but when one is injured we have to rely on the likes of Dann and Kelly. Neither are really good enough at the top level.
We have to try and find someone who fits the bill in the summer because our season could have been a lot worse had Sakho been injured earlier.
|
Loz83 Crawley 31 Mar 19 9.33pm |
|
|
hes looking like hes past it, im getting a puncheon vibe from him, just lacking that extra yard that you need at this level. still good in the air though and he might get back in the swing if things. kelly is much more mobile and a better passer. just shows what a top player sakho is, gutted he got injured.
|
ChrisGC Wantage 31 Mar 19 10.09pm |
|
|
The knee injury and the time out associated with it has taken its toll I'd say.
Shame, because he was a very, very good player. One of the best CBs we've had in years.
|
Willo South coast - west of Brighton. 31 Mar 19 11.28pm |
|
Originally posted by Loz83
hes looking like hes past it, im getting a puncheon vibe from him, just lacking that extra yard that you need at this level. still good in the air though and he might get back in the swing if things. kelly is much more mobile and a better passer. just shows what a top player sakho is, gutted he got injured.
I agree with the general thrust of these comments.
Dann looks accomplished in the air but on the ground he doesn't appear to be the quickest or the most mobile.In his early 30s now and not the player he was.
|
pstrutt Busselton, WA 05 Jun 19 5.09pm |
|
|
[Link]
Only fair that the speculation is out there given he is third / fourth choice.
I would still like him as cover and I wonder if his lack of pace is due the injury itself or the time he has spent out and therefore no longer as match fit as he once was.
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.
|
ChrisGC Wantage 05 Jun 19 5.18pm |
|
Originally posted by pstrutt
[Link]
Only fair that the speculation is out there given he is third / fourth choice.
I would still like him as cover and I wonder if his lack of pace is due the injury itself or the time he has spent out and therefore no longer as match fit as he once was.
He's done a bloody good job for us and up until the knee was mustard. Certainly one of the best centre backs we've had in the last 30 years.
6 million seems a fair price for a player that we know as fans is finished at this level after that injury. He moves to a big club, I imagine on good money for what would be his final career contract, filling in admirably when needed.
Seems ideal for all.
|
Rudi Hedman Caterham 05 Jun 19 5.29pm |
|
|
He’s on a lot of money now as a backup, as long as we can find a good, cheaper alternative. £65k or more.
COYP
|
YT Oxford 05 Jun 19 6.40pm |
|
|
Is it somewhat perverse that he's being described as potentially excellent cover for Newcastle, but we no longer regard him as valid cover for CPFC, at a transfer fee of zero?
Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 05 Jun 19 7.05pm |
|
Originally posted by ChrisGC
He's done a bloody good job for us and up until the knee was mustard. Certainly one of the best centre backs we've had in the last 30 years.
6 million seems a fair price for a player that we know as fans is finished at this level after that injury. He moves to a big club, I imagine on good money for what would be his final career contract, filling in admirably when needed.
Seems ideal for all.
Agreed. For about three seasons after signing I would say he was borderline worth an England call up.
Was never quick but has lost pace since injury.
Good servant, wish him well if leaves.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 05 Jun 19 7.42pm |
|
|
If Scott goes we had better have someone good to replace him, because he has been terrific for us. When he came back into the side after Sakho being injured, we actually looked a threat from corners for the first time in a very long time....
|