You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best three replacements if Roy steps down
November 16 2026 6.32am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Best three replacements if Roy steps down


Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
hastingseagle67 Flag 07 Apr 19 9.05am

So lots of people would like Roy to go but not many have a realistic replacement in mind. Here’s mine.

1. Chris Wilder (Sheffield United) best manager in the Championship by far.

2. Christian Streich (SC Freiburg) - almost a younger version of Roy doing wonders with a small club in the Bundesliga and has a good record of bringing through young talent.

3. Steven Gerard (Rangers) bit of a punt being so inexperienced but his playing career should command a great deal of respect. As our feeder club (Chelsea) May have to hold onto their players, Liverpool could be our go to club to pick up young talent and his connections may help us. Question is, is premier league with us more appealing than Europe with Rangers.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

aashman12 Flag 07 Apr 19 9.23am

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

So lots of people would like Roy to go but not many have a realistic replacement in mind. Here’s mine.

1. Chris Wilder (Sheffield United) best manager in the Championship by far.

2. Christian Streich (SC Freiburg) - almost a younger version of Roy doing wonders with a small club in the Bundesliga and has a good record of bringing through young talent.

3. Steven Gerard (Rangers) bit of a punt being so inexperienced but his playing career should command a great deal of respect. As our feeder club (Chelsea) May have to hold onto their players, Liverpool could be our go to club to pick up young talent and his connections may help us. Question is, is premier league with us more appealing than Europe with Rangers.

Would like to add graham potter to the list, got Swansea playing and went toe to toe with city in the cup.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 07 Apr 19 9.23am

Clarke at killy not doing too bad.

 

PeatlingPalace Flag Peatling Leicestershire, UK 07 Apr 19 9.46am

Benitez?

 


When they kick out your front door. How you gonna come ?

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Apr 19 9.50am

Originally posted by cryrst

Clarke at killy not doing too bad.

Steve Clarke was one I was interested in but I think he likes a drink a wee too much.

 


COYP

davehuggins Flag 07 Apr 19 9.53am

I hope RH will stay as IMO he is so good for a club of our size. But if he did go Stevie G looks to be doing a good job at Rangers, would he be able to step up is the question?

 

Silverfox50 Flag Thornton-Cleveleys 07 Apr 19 10.06am

Neil Harris

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 07 Apr 19 10.23am

Originally posted by Silverfox50

Neil Harris

Is Alan Mullery still alive?

 

Park Road Flag 07 Apr 19 10.25am

Jose Mourinho is looking for a new project and he does like us...

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 07 Apr 19 10.48am

We need a top coach who can improve players, the added value can be immense. Rafa Benitez would be perfect in my view - caveated with the wish that Roy goes when he is ready.

 

Lyons550 Flag Shirley 07 Apr 19 10.59am

Originally posted by aashman12

Would like to add graham potter to the list, got Swansea playing and went toe to toe with city in the cup.


Agree with this ^^

 


The Voice of Reason In An Otherwise Mediocre World

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Apr 19 11.03am

Originally posted by chris123

We need a top coach who can improve players, the added value can be immense. Rafa Benitez would be perfect in my view - caveated with the wish that Roy goes when he is ready.

How do you bring a new manager in with one already here who goes when he is ready?

 


COYP

chris123 Flag hove actually 07 Apr 19 11.14am

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

How do you bring a new manager in with one already here who goes when he is ready?

Well just giving an example, but with a caveat of not until Roy is ready, he's earned that completely.

 

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 07 Apr 19 11.20am

Originally posted by chris123

Well just giving an example, but with a caveat of not until Roy is ready, he's earned that completely.

In that case the options will keep changing and Benitez may not be an option. Who knows what goes on in Benitez’s mind. Maybe he’ll not like the idea of us wanting him when Roy retires, or maybe he’ll value that loyalty for himself.

 


COYP

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 07 Apr 19 11.25am

Originally posted by Silverfox50

Neil Harris

Lee Bowyer just to p*ss off the clowns

I like Roy but I am worried that next season maybe a season too many for him. I don't see us spending money on fixing our obvious problems so he will have to motivate the players again possibly without Zaha and or AWB. You can only do that so many times.

The problem is there is no obvious replacement. I like Sean Dyche but we are on a par with Burnley so why would he want to come to Palace.

 


One more point

taylors lovechild Flag 07 Apr 19 11.29am

Probably unlikely that he'd come here but Rudi Garcia at Marseille has a history of transforming clubs' fortunes with attractive and attacking football and would be my first choice. Given we have a strong French-speaking contingent (Sako, Sakho, Zaha, Souare) that might help any transition. Second choice for me would be somewhat of a risk in Tony Popovic. He has built up a reputation in Australia for creating fit, disciplined teams and seems to take an Allardyce approach in terms of using analytics, etc. which could help give us an edge. Downside is he has no managerial experience at a high level (aside from that brief stint as our assistant manager). Third choice would be Wagner. Huddersfield fans still speak highly of him and I think with a better squad he could do well.

 

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 07 Apr 19 12.04pm

1 Mikel Arteta,done his Apprenticeship working with pep,and was intervieweded for Arsenal job,worth a shout with Roy as director off football.

2 Rafa Benitez,looks like he could be leaving Toon and is a very good manager,has lots of connections in the game.

3 Chris Wilder at Sheff utd,tactically very good and doing a cracking job,looks like his taking them up but will be in high demand if they fall at the final hurdle.

Swansea coach is another who should be considered.

 

Donald T Trump Flag edenbridge 07 Apr 19 12.56pm

Originally posted by monkey

Seen in Southwater works for the Weed

Is Alan Mullery still alive?

 

hastingseagle67 Flag 07 Apr 19 1.59pm

Are Benitez and Mourinho serious suggestions? I am not mocking, but would like to understand the thought process that people would think managers of that level would come to Palace.

 


has resisted writing a single post on the Ross McCormack thread !!!

black eagle. Flag south croydon. 07 Apr 19 2.27pm

Originally posted by hastingseagle67

Are Benitez and Mourinho serious suggestions? I am not mocking, but would like to understand the thought process that people would think managers of that level would come to Palace.

So who would your three suggestions be?

 

Page 1 of 6 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Best three replacements if Roy steps down