You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Penalty takers - Who is our best ever?
November 16 2026 6.33am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Penalty takers - Who is our best ever?


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Eltham Eagle Flag 08 Apr 19 7.57am

I can't remember being more confident than I am in Luka when we get a spot kick. But is he our best ever?

Who could be the contenders
Dave Madden - Scored against Blackburn and we got promoted. Can't remember another!

Ian Wright - I was only a youngster at the time but I think he could tuck them away. However, both him and Brighty were responsible for the 997 missed in the game against Brighton!

Andy Johnson - Won more than he scored and holds the record for most in a season. But I feel he did miss a few and was never 100% confident

Glenn Murray - Terrible penalty taker. About a 50/50 chance. But better than Benteke!

Luka - Missed against City (we would have been the first to beat them that season) and also against Everton. But apart from those 2, magnificent finishing, especially when setting the record straight at Man City this season.

But for me the best was Jedi. I don't remember him taking that many but I certainly don't remember him missing one. The one away at West Ham particularly nice when guaranteeing us Premier League status.

Would love Luka to beat AJs record this season. Great player and captain.

 


Now here's Wright, his first chance to see what he can do, and he's through, it's Wright, ohhhh what an impact by the substitute. And it's Ian Wright who's sent the Palace fans into ecstasy!

Lanzo-Ad Flag Lanzarote 08 Apr 19 8.19am

Francis Lee with 15 for Man City 1n 1971/72 is the most in any top division, played more matches they, I think 42.
AJ is most prem only 11

 


“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn

Fatherken Flag 08 Apr 19 9.03am

I liked the way Andy Grey took penalty's . He would start his run up from the halfway line . When he kicked the ball it would be with a lot of power and go straight over the goal , to the side off the goal or even hit the floodlight's but if it went in he would take the goalkeeper with it or rip a hole in the back of the net . Maybe not the best penalty taker but a lot of fun to watch .

 

chris123 Flag hove actually 08 Apr 19 9.11am

Halfway up and above, just inside the post - a well hit penalty is unstoppable. Murray sometimes went down the middle, Luka doesn't anymore (thank you for the correction).

Edited by chris123 (08 Apr 2019 9.30am)

 

peterg Flag Anerley 08 Apr 19 9.24am

Luka does go down the middle - or rather he used to! He went down the middle against Man City last season and it was saved. I think he went down the middle at Everton this season, also saved, costing us the match. However it looks like - in view of those failures - he doesn't go down the middle any more.

 


The right place at the right time

Ghostship Flag Norfolk 08 Apr 19 10.00am

Dean Gordon used to taken brilliant penalties he would blast them in with his left foot and I think he only ever missed once.

 

Bexley Eagle Flag Bexley Kent 08 Apr 19 11.09am

Jedi took a decent penalty. Luka clearly doesn't do too bad

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 08 Apr 19 11.14am

Originally posted by Eltham Eagle

I can't remember being more confident than I am in Luka when we get a spot kick. But is he our best ever?

Who could be the contenders
Dave Madden - Scored against Blackburn and we got promoted. Can't remember another!

Ian Wright - I was only a youngster at the time but I think he could tuck them away. However, both him and Brighty were responsible for the 997 missed in the game against Brighton!

Andy Johnson - Won more than he scored and holds the record for most in a season. But I feel he did miss a few and was never 100% confident

Glenn Murray - Terrible penalty taker. About a 50/50 chance. But better than Benteke!

Luka - Missed against City (we would have been the first to beat them that season) and also against Everton. But apart from those 2, magnificent finishing, especially when setting the record straight at Man City this season.

But for me the best was Jedi. I don't remember him taking that many but I certainly don't remember him missing one. The one away at West Ham particularly nice when guaranteeing us Premier League status.

Would love Luka to beat AJs record this season. Great player and captain.


I think Madden scored five out of five in his twenty odd games for us.

I would however say Luka took a better penalty but Madden was the much better player.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Yellow Card - User has been warned of conduct on the messageboards Hrolf The Ganger Flag 08 Apr 19 11.21am

Surely Andy Johnson is the only player to rival Milo.

He used to win lots of penalties and then score them.
Now we have the Wilf and Milo show.

I don't remember having other players who could win that many penalties in the past so the person who took them did not stand out so much.

 

thai-eagle Flag chiang mai 08 Apr 19 11.47am

Does Wilf get credited With assist for all the penalties he wins?

 

It's only a game Flag Praa Sands 08 Apr 19 12.55pm

Itzik Zohar

 


A stockbroker urged me to buy a stock that would triple its value every year. I told him, at my age, I don't even buy green bananas!


monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 08 Apr 19 1.50pm

Where might we be now if it wasn’t for super cool Kevin Phillips?

 

Painter Flag Croydon 08 Apr 19 2.34pm

[quote=It's only a game;3430708]

Itzik Zohar

100% record.

 

collier row eagle Flag romford essex via another galaxy 08 Apr 19 2.40pm

Originally posted by monkey

Where might we be now if it wasn’t for super cool Kevin Phillips?

Spot on, where is Kevin these days, we will always be grateful for that brilliant pen. I'm off to watch it again on YouTube!!

 

RyWa Flag Beckenham 08 Apr 19 2.48pm

I think it has to be between Luka or AJ, statistically across their careers (Not just Palace), AJ has scored 22 out of 26 pens, missing 4.
Luka has scored 19 out of 22, missing 3.
Both are great records, and its hard to call a clear favourite.. Interestingly, AJ never missed a Premier League penalty, though he did miss two in the same game for Everton in a European game off the back of not scoring for 6 months.
Just shows its down hill once you leave the Palace

Edited by RyWa (08 Apr 2019 2.51pm)

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 08 Apr 19 10.01pm

Don’t know the stats, but I remember AJ missing a few. Always felt Freedman was better. Luka is lethal.

Sticking it out there... Tony Popovic. Didn’t take many, but he knew where the top corner was.

 

jeeagles Flag 08 Apr 19 10.15pm

Originally posted by Goal Machine

Don’t know the stats, but I remember AJ missing a few. Always felt Freedman was better. Luka is lethal.

Sticking it out there... Tony Popovic. Didn’t take many, but he knew where the top corner was.

Freedman was the designated penalty taker as far as I remember. Didn't take them in the premiership as AJ was on his own, but certainly handed AJ the ball for the penalty vs Brighton.

Haven't we got the record for the most misses in a row under Alan Smith too?

 

n wales eagles Flag llandudno 09 Apr 19 7.25am

John Sewell got to be my number one Think it was 1970 on a cold manchester night when John stepped up to steer one under Alex Stepney to earn us a point Certainly warmed me up Got to go matrons just come in with my porridge

 

Elpis Flag In a pub 09 Apr 19 8.58am

Gareth Southgate should have taken more penalties for us , he could have done with the practice .

Luka is though our best ever , no question .

 

slubglurge Flag welling 09 Apr 19 11.05am

Jedi without doubt. He only took a few but never looked like missing

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Penalty takers - Who is our best ever?