This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
4 goalkeepers in 25 man squad!!
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
glaziermart 04 Sep 19 8.30am |
|
|
4 goalkeepers in the squad!! Why the hell would we need that?? Its absolutely scandalous. Shows what a pathetic summer window it was
[Link]
|
pstrutt Busselton, WA 04 Sep 19 8.34am |
|
|
I assume one of Dion-Curtis Henry or Joe Tupper is a keeper? I haven't even heard their names among the under 21s. Are they merely there on the basis of age otherwise we can't use them even in am emergency?
EDIT: Which doesn't sound all that scandalous.
Edited by pstrutt (04 Sep 2019 8.35am)
SUPEREDIT: It is scandalous as they are both keepers. I make it FIVE altogether.
Edited by pstrutt (04 Sep 2019 8.38am)
So I manage a Workshop which provides a safe learning environment for blokes struggling with PTSD and other mental health issues. Being a Palace fan isn't listed yet.
|
Lanzo-Ad Lanzarote 04 Sep 19 8.38am |
|
|
Dion-Curtis Henry and Joe Tupper are both keepers so that's actually 5 keepers.
“That’s a joke son, I say, that’s a joke.” “Nice boy, but he’s sharp as a throw pillow.” “He’s so dumb he thinks a Mexican border pays rent” “ “Son… I say, son, some people are so narrow minded they can look through a keyhole with both eyes.”__ Forhorn Leghorn
|
JohnB 04 Sep 19 9.09am |
|
|
I think both of them are the oldest of the eligible U21's so as we had 23 players over 21 for the squad registration, they probably got added as a matter of course. None of the other clubs felt the need to add to their list to make 25 though so not sure why the club didn't just leave them in the U21 list.
It does mean in January, we can remove both of them and sign 2 players without having to sell anyone to make room.
Doesn't take away from the fact we should have brought in 2 full backs and another striker this window.
Looking forward to January though and signing Matty James and Isaac Hayden.
|
Midlands Eagle 04 Sep 19 9.11am |
|
Originally posted by glaziermart
4 goalkeepers in the squad!! Why the hell would we need that?? Its absolutely scandalous. Shows what a pathetic summer window it was
You are correct in that it was a pathetic summer window but although we probably won't need all those keepers we have to list 25 players if we have that many who are over the age limit and the two development squad players are just making up the numbers
|
Bexley Eagle Bexley Kent 04 Sep 19 9.48am |
|
|
We would all like to have seen a few more fresh faces join in the summer however here is the way I see it: We sold a right back who had one premier league season under his belt for 50 million. That seems like decent business to me. We are left with the players we had before AWB emerged on the scene, so not a disaster. We bought Ayew as a squad player for 2.5 million. He probably has been our best player so far this season. If he continues his good form he will be worth much more. In McCarthy and Camarasa we brought in experience and cover for midfield roles offering some flexibility but certainly in McCarthy’s case the type of player Roy likes. A free 3rd choice keeper. As we have done over previous seasons we may look to bring a striker in on loan in January if we are struggling.
|
Fatherken 04 Sep 19 9.52am |
|
|
teams only need 2 goalkeepers and an outfield who can play in goal , and we have got 5 !!!!
|
Midlands Eagle 04 Sep 19 10.19am |
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
teams only need 2 goalkeepers and an outfield who can play in goal , and we have got 5 !!!!
What part of "they are just making up the numbers" are you having difficulty understanding?
|
vic rouse basingstoke 04 Sep 19 10.29am |
|
Originally posted by Midlands Eagle
What part of "they are just making up the numbers" are you having difficulty understanding?
Why do you feel the need to belittle people all the time?
|
Painter Croydon 04 Sep 19 10.53am |
|
Originally posted by Fatherken
teams only need 2 goalkeepers and an outfield who can play in goal , and we have got 5 !!!!
I seem to remember both Guaita and Hennessy were both injured at the same time and Speroni stood in last season. Are you suggesting we should be putting Zaha in goal, if our only 2 keepers are injured in your view, if he is the best outfield player in goal.
Imagine the meltdown.
|
Nicholas91 The Democratic Republic of Kent 04 Sep 19 11.06am |
|
|
Don't bite back, you get a yellow card.
Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 04 Sep 19 5.46pm |
|
|
5 goalkeepers in the 25 man squad on the basis of Joe Tupper and Dion Curtis Henry being over 21 on the 01/01/1998. If they were born after this date then they would not need to be registered as they are classed as ‘under 21’.
You may not realise this, but if the club have a player over 21 years old at the club they must be registered as part of the 25 man squad unless they are out on loan. You cannot submit a 23 man squad leaving out players over 21 if they are still at the club. This basically means you cannot pick and choose and leave players out of the 25 man squad in order to sign more free agents etc
This is also why we released Kleton Petroneou with a year left on his contact a few years back as he had to be Registered and was taking a place.
|
Ginger Pubic Wig Wickham de L'Ouest 04 Sep 19 6.22pm |
|
|
I may be wrong but does it not list only 24?
If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.
|
ARGILE OLD GEEZER PORTIMAO 05 Sep 19 7.20am |
|
|
He has a point though, even I understood it.
|
dreamwaverider London 05 Sep 19 7.50am |
|
|
Hahaha. Were you a ref before you came on here? Hahaha.
|
dreamwaverider London 05 Sep 19 7.56am |
|
|
Wonder how many other clubs have registered FIVE keepers? Well we have let in the least number of goals in the premier so far so it says something about us I suppose.
|
Fatherken 05 Sep 19 10.17am |
|
|
Midlands Eagle before making comment read what I said , I said "teams" in general not just our team I will now go back to feeding my pigs , they are more interesting
|
mattteo 05 Sep 19 8.18pm |
|
Originally posted by rossboss29
You may not realise this, but if the club have a player over 21 years old at the club they must be registered as part of the 25 man squad unless they are out on loan. You cannot submit a 23 man squad leaving out players over 21 if they are still at the club. This basically means you cannot pick and choose and leave players out of the 25 man squad in order to sign more free agents etc
What in God's name are you talking about? That's how players get left out of the PL squad. It has happened with a lot of players from a lot of teams. Brice Dja Djedge is just one example from last year at Watford.
|
rossboss29 Portsmouth 06 Sep 19 9.55pm |
|
|
[Link]
Count the players in their 25 man squad. There are 25. The meaning of my post is you cannot name 24 players in a squad and leave out a player if they are over 21.
This is also why we were unable to resign Sako at the start of last season, as we couldn’t loan out Puncheon in time. I hope you are satisfied with the explanation.
Link below in regards to Caroll and Newcastle and being unable to leave space for free agents if you have a squad of players who are of age
[Link]
[Link]
Edited by rossboss29 (06 Sep 2019 10.19pm)
|
Tom-the-eagle Croydon 06 Sep 19 10.15pm |
|
Originally posted by glaziermart
4 goalkeepers in the squad!! Why the hell would we need that?? Its absolutely scandalous. Shows what a pathetic summer window it was
[Link]
Personally I don't think its enough.
I'd like to see our entire back five made up of keepers. All with their kits and gloves on.
"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit
|