You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Catalonia
November 21 2026 10.41pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Catalonia


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
buzby1 Flag Devon 19 Oct 19 11.54am

The situation in Hong Kong is understandable - the people there want democracy and not the authoritarian rule of China. Catalonia and the riots going on in Barcelona are more puzzling. Barcelona and the region around it is among the most wealthy and wealth-making in Spain. It's not as if they are oppressed minority. Yes, they identify as Catalans and not Spanish and this leads to destructive nationalism. Something there's far too much of in the world, Given Spain's history and the Civil War in particular, destructive nationalism is very bad news. It looks and feels indulgent.

Interested to know what others think.

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 19 Oct 19 12.32pm

the alternative to Nationalism ?

being governed by a faceless, voiceless, multiculti regime ?

like the EU, China, etc. These rulers do not respect national identity, language, ethnicity.


Force the Catalans to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun ? Franco already tried that.

Its got nothing to do with wealth. The Norwegians are wealthier than us. Would you force them to drop their language and identity to speak English 24/7 ? or to pay their taxes to support a dole-head in a Welsh mining town ? or to stop singing their own national anthem ?

dream on.

The 'Nation-State' works better than its alternatives. When this is forgotten there is often trouble :

the Kurds
Kashmir
Ulster
the Balkans


the Catalans are a nation with a language at least as vibrant as Welsh, Scots Gallic or Danish. To accuse them of being Spanish is as arrogant as calling a Dutchman an 'off kilter German'.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2019 12.42pm)

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

YT Flag Oxford 19 Oct 19 12.51pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the alternative to Nationalism ?

being governed by a faceless, voiceless, multiculti regime ?

like the EU, China, etc. These rulers do not respect national identity, language, ethnicity.


Force the Catalans to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun ? Franco already tried that.

Its got nothing to do with wealth. The Norwegians are wealthier than us. Would you force them to drop their language and identity to speak English 24/7 ? or to pay their taxes to support a dole-head in a Welsh mining town ? or to stop singing their own national anthem ?

dream on.

The 'Nation-State' works better than its alternatives. When this is forgotten there is often trouble :

the Kurds
Kashmir
Ulster
the Balkans


the Catalans are a nation with a language at least as vibrant as Welsh, Scots Gallic or Danish. To accuse them of being Spanish is as arrogant as calling a Dutchman an 'off kilter German'.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2019 12.42pm)

Run that by me again?

The sight of proud Catalonians smashing up their own capital city strikes me as a tad bizarre.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

buzby1 Flag Devon 19 Oct 19 1.11pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the alternative to Nationalism ?

being governed by a faceless, voiceless, multiculti regime ?

like the EU, China, etc. These rulers do not respect national identity, language, ethnicity.


Force the Catalans to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun ? Franco already tried that.

Its got nothing to do with wealth. The Norwegians are wealthier than us. Would you force them to drop their language and identity to speak English 24/7 ? or to pay their taxes to support a dole-head in a Welsh mining town ? or to stop singing their own national anthem ?

dream on.

The 'Nation-State' works better than its alternatives. When this is forgotten there is often trouble :

the Kurds
Kashmir
Ulster
the Balkans


the Catalans are a nation with a language at least as vibrant as Welsh, Scots Gallic or Danish. To accuse them of being Spanish is as arrogant as calling a Dutchman an 'off kilter German'.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2019 12.42pm)

 

buzby1 Flag Devon 19 Oct 19 1.13pm

What's wrong with a multi-cultural government, Palazio? Seems to me to be a good idea.

Spent some time in Barcelona - don't remember anyone being forced to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun.

Chose your causes worth fighting for. This isn't one of them.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 19 Oct 19 1.21pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the alternative to Nationalism ?

being governed by a faceless, voiceless, multiculti regime ?

like the EU, China, etc. These rulers do not respect national identity, language, ethnicity.


Force the Catalans to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun ? Franco already tried that.

Its got nothing to do with wealth. The Norwegians are wealthier than us. Would you force them to drop their language and identity to speak English 24/7 ? or to pay their taxes to support a dole-head in a Welsh mining town ? or to stop singing their own national anthem ?

dream on.

The 'Nation-State' works better than its alternatives. When this is forgotten there is often trouble :

the Kurds
Kashmir
Ulster
the Balkans


the Catalans are a nation with a language at least as vibrant as Welsh, Scots Gallic or Danish. To accuse them of being Spanish is as arrogant as calling a Dutchman an 'off kilter German'.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2019 12.42pm)


Eh?

No one is forcing them to speak Spanish just like no one is forcing you or me to speak English or the bloke who owns my local newsagent speaking Urdu.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

corkery Flag Cork City 19 Oct 19 1.34pm

Spain doesn't believe in self determination, just look at Gibraltar. Gibraltar wants nothing to do with Spain but the Spanish insist that they become part of Spain anyway.

Compare that to the UK. The Scots had a vote, the Falklands had a vote, Malta had a vote etc.

 


We'll never die

W12 19 Oct 19 6.30pm

At this stage I would support almost any independent claim that was made in any socialist/communist country.

I would dissolve the union (taking Northern Ireland with us) to get away from the commie SNP and the impossible to sell Welsh party.

The Welsh and the Scots are now just a drain on England.

 

W12 19 Oct 19 6.31pm

Originally posted by W12

At this stage I would support almost any independent claim that was made in any socialist/communist country.

I would dissolve the union (taking Northern Ireland with us) to get away from the commie SNP and the impossible to spell Welsh party.

The Welsh and the Scots are now just a drain on England.

 

eagleman13 Flag On The Road To Hell & Alicante 19 Oct 19 6.40pm

Originally posted by W12

At this stage I would support almost any independent claim that was made in any socialist/communist country.

I would dissolve the union (taking Northern Ireland with us) to get away from the commie SNP and the impossible to sell Welsh party.

The Welsh and the Scots are now just a drain on England.

Oh dear

You haven't got a clue, FYI, I live out here

 


This operation, will make the 'Charge Of The Light Brigade' seem like a simple military exercise.

Rudi Hedman Flag Caterham 19 Oct 19 10.03pm

I’d let Scotland go.

 


COYP

W12 19 Oct 19 10.16pm

Originally posted by Rudi Hedman

I’d let Scotland go.

Free Time, thumbs up award!

 

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 20 Oct 19 11.49pm

Originally posted by buzby1

What's wrong with a multi-cultural government, Palazio? Seems to me to be a good idea.

Spent some time in Barcelona - don't remember anyone being forced to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun.

.


Franco did. An odious little man. Not forgotten.

Today Spanish is tolerated in Catalunya , but Catalan must have at least equal status.

Catalan independence is a wonderful idea.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

johnno42000 Flag 21 Oct 19 4.08pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the alternative to Nationalism ?

being governed by a faceless, voiceless, multiculti regime ?

like the EU, China, etc. These rulers do not respect national identity, language, ethnicity.


Force the Catalans to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun ? Franco already tried that.

Its got nothing to do with wealth. The Norwegians are wealthier than us. Would you force them to drop their language and identity to speak English 24/7 ? or to pay their taxes to support a dole-head in a Welsh mining town ? or to stop singing their own national anthem ?

dream on.

The 'Nation-State' works better than its alternatives. When this is forgotten there is often trouble :

the Kurds
Kashmir
Ulster
the Balkans


the Catalans are a nation with a language at least as vibrant as Welsh, Scots Gallic or Danish. To accuse them of being Spanish is as arrogant as calling a Dutchman an 'off kilter German'.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2019 12.42pm)

What exactly do you mean by 'dole-head'? I am on the dole and live in a town that was decimated when the pits closed. I have also been in employment since the age of 17 (57 now) and during that time have been on the dole for around 18 months in total.

Am I a dole-head?

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

YT Flag Oxford 21 Oct 19 4.26pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

What exactly do you mean by 'dole-head'? I am on the dole and live in a town that was decimated when the pits closed. I have also been in employment since the age of 17 (57 now) and during that time have been on the dole for around 18 months in total.

Am I a dole-head?

With your background, I'm I interested to know how/why you became a Palace fan. Maybe that's for a different thread though.

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

johnno42000 Flag 21 Oct 19 4.33pm

Originally posted by YT

With your background, I'm I interested to know how/why you became a Palace fan. Maybe that's for a different thread though.

I was born in Sydenham but my dad was Welsh, from a little place called Clydach Vale. He was a miner down here, moved to London after the war and became a docker.When I was a kid he told me not to support Millwall and Palace were on an easy bus route, number 75.

I moved to Wales around 20 years ago after becoming homeless in London (I had relatives down here who offered to help) and have worked practically ever since.

Edited by johnno42000 (21 Oct 2019 4.35pm)

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

YT Flag Oxford 21 Oct 19 6.42pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

I was born in Sydenham but my dad was Welsh, from a little place called Clydach Vale. He was a miner down here, moved to London after the war and became a docker.When I was a kid he told me not to support Millwall and Palace were on an easy bus route, number 75.

I moved to Wales around 20 years ago after becoming homeless in London (I had relatives down here who offered to help) and have worked practically ever since.

Edited by johnno42000 (21 Oct 2019 4.35pm)

Thanks, mate. On reflection, I misconstrued your earlier post by assuming that you were living in Wales at the time of the mine closures. Even so, like many of us, you've had an interesting path to the doors of Selhurst.

When I was a lad living in Erith and my dad started taking me to the occasional Charlton Athletic home game, he told me that Millwall supporters could be quite 'forthright', given that a large number of them were dockers. No offence meant to your old man, obviously!

 


Palace since 19 August 1972. Palace 1 (Tony Taylor) Liverpool 1 (Emlyn Hughes)

PalazioVecchio Flag south pole 21 Oct 19 7.46pm

Originally posted by johnno42000

What exactly do you mean by 'dole-head'? I am on the dole and live in a town that was decimated when the pits closed. I have also been in employment since the age of 17 (57 now) and during that time have been on the dole for around 18 months in total.

Am I a dole-head?

i would define a 'dole-head' as somebody happy to live on the dole and never seek work. The Catalans seem happy to support their own dole-heads but not the dole-heads living in the Castilian Speaking parts of Spain.

a poshy in Sant Cugat Barcelona will feel aggrieved to support a dole-head in Nijar, Almeria. Not really the same Tribe.

Catalan independence is about language, identity and economics.

 


Kayla did Anfield & Old Trafford

johnno42000 Flag 21 Oct 19 8.21pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

i would define a 'dole-head' as somebody happy to live on the dole and never seek work. The Catalans seem happy to support their own dole-heads but not the dole-heads living in the Castilian Speaking parts of Spain.

a poshy in Sant Cugat Barcelona will feel aggrieved to support a dole-head in Nijar, Almeria. Not really the same Tribe.

Catalan independence is about language, identity and economics.

Fair enough, not sure why you picked on Welsh mining towns though?

 


'Lies to the masses as are like fly's to mollasses...they want more and more and more'

Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 22 Oct 19 8.45pm

Originally posted by PalazioVecchio

the alternative to Nationalism ?

being governed by a faceless, voiceless, multiculti regime ?

like the EU, China, etc. These rulers do not respect national identity, language, ethnicity.


Force the Catalans to speak Spanish at the barrel of a gun ? Franco already tried that.

Its got nothing to do with wealth. The Norwegians are wealthier than us. Would you force them to drop their language and identity to speak English 24/7 ? or to pay their taxes to support a dole-head in a Welsh mining town ? or to stop singing their own national anthem ?

dream on.

The 'Nation-State' works better than its alternatives. When this is forgotten there is often trouble :

the Kurds
Kashmir
Ulster
the Balkans


the Catalans are a nation with a language at least as vibrant as Welsh, Scots Gallic or Danish. To accuse them of being Spanish is as arrogant as calling a Dutchman an 'off kilter German'.

Edited by PalazioVecchio (19 Oct 2019 12.42pm)

But that's pretty much what the Dutch are, though.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > News & Politics > Catalonia