You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Squad value January 2020
November 16 2026 5.54am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Squad value January 2020


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
CharlesPaterson Flag 16 Jan 20 2.48am

Just over 2 weeks to go till the end of another transfer window.

Got me thinking, what is the realistic value of each player?

I know we're not likely to get many bids but if we did, what could we realistically get for them?

GK

Vicente
Henners
Henderson

DEF

Wardy
PVA
Tomkins
Dann
Sakho
Cahill
Kelly
Woods

MID

Schlupp
Max
Luka
Andros
Kouyate
Jairo
Brandon
Jimmy Mac
James Mac

FOR

Conor
Wilf
Jordan
Benteke
Sorloth

Would be interesting to see what people's valuations are.

 

aj36094 Flag Derbyshire 16 Jan 20 9.17am

[Link]

My opinion:

GK

Vicente £12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age)
Henners £3M
Henderson £0

DEF

Wardy £4M
PVA £7M
Tomkins £4M
Dann £500K
Sakho £6M
Cahill £4M
Kelly £1M
Woods £300k

MID

Schlupp £7M
Max £8M
Luka £8M
Andros £11M
Kouyate £8M
Jairo £5M (should rise if form continues)
Brandon £1M
Jimmy Mac £4M
James Mac £2

FOR

Conor £2M
Wilf £50M
Jordan £11M
Benteke £4M
Sorloth £4M (Based on performances in Turkey)

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Jan 20 10.03am

Originally posted by aj36094

[Link]

My opinion:

GK

Vicente £12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age)
Henners £3M
Henderson £0

DEF

Wardy £4M
PVA £7M
Tomkins £4M
Dann £500K
Sakho £6M
Cahill £4M
Kelly £1M
Woods £300k

MID

Schlupp £7M
Max £8M
Luka £8M
Andros £11M
Kouyate £8M
Jairo £5M (should rise if form continues)
Brandon £1M
Jimmy Mac £4M
James Mac £2

FOR

Conor £2M
Wilf £50M
Jordan £11M
Benteke £4M
Sorloth £4M (Based on performances in Turkey)

My only disagreement here would be Benteke, he just can’t score and as a striker that really effects his value SP must have been on something to extend his contract at 125K a week. His current value is a free just to get rid of him and save the wages sadly I fear even as a free there will be takers!

 

Fatherken Flag 16 Jan 20 12.10pm

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward £2m
Cahill £6m
Andros £5m
Jorden £11m no chance £5m at best
Benteke £6m

 

ARGILE OLD GEEZER Flag PORTIMAO 16 Jan 20 12.47pm

Originally posted by aj36094

[Link]

My opinion:

GK

Vicente £12M (based on form we could get more, but will decrease quickly due to age)
Henners £3M
Henderson £0

DEF

Wardy £4M
PVA £7M
Tomkins £4M
Dann £500K
Sakho £6M
Cahill £4M
Kelly £1M
Woods £300k

MID

Schlupp £7M
Max £8M
Luka £8M
Andros £11M
Kouyate £8M
Jairo £5M (should rise if form continues)
Brandon £1M
Jimmy Mac £4M
James Mac £2

FOR

Conor £2M
Wilf £50M
Jordan £11M
Benteke £4M
Sorloth £4M (Based on performances in Turkey)

Tomkins £4M, you would have a dozen clubs biting your hand off for anything under 15£M

 

Tequila Sunrise Flag 16 Jan 20 1.03pm

Tomkins is a bit injury prone but definitely worth more than Ward, who is in my opinion a championship player at best.

 

taylors lovechild Flag 16 Jan 20 1.31pm

Given how much players are going for in today's market I would say some of the valuations are pretty low here. if fit then my estimates would be something like:

GK

Vicente 10m
Henners 5m
Henderson 0

DEF

Wardy 4m
PVA 15m
Tomkins 15m
Dann 4m
Sakho 15m
Cahill 4m
Kelly 5m
Woods 500k

MID

Schlupp 10m
Max 8m
Luka 15m
Andros 20m
Kouyate 10m
Jairo 7m
Brandon ?
Jimmy Mac 6m
James Mac 6m

FOR

Conor 5m
Wilf 60m
Jordan 9m
Benteke 10m
Sorloth 6m

 

Den1923 Flag 16 Jan 20 4.40pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward £2m
Cahill £6m
Andros £5m
Jorden £11m no chance £5m at best
Benteke £6m

No one hates Benteke, I just think based on form he has no value, if you can get 6mil for him, I’m sue SP will be happy to give you 10%,

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 17 Jan 20 2.44pm

I will surprise a few and say that I think we only have 10 players who'd fetch more than £5m

 

Rachid Rachid Rachid Flag 17 Jan 20 10.12pm

Originally posted by Fatherken

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward £2m
Cahill £6m
Andros £5m
Jorden £11m no chance £5m at best
Benteke £6m

Is it the system that led to him missing 20 from 23 "good" chances in 2017-18 (ie the season his problems began) and his head falling off ?

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 17 Jan 20 10.21pm

Originally posted by Rachid Rachid Rachid

Is it the system that led to him missing 20 from 23 "good" chances in 2017-18 (ie the season his problems began) and his head falling off ?

It was the system that made him take the ball off Luka for *that* penalty, honest guv!

 

Shifty97 Flag Croydon 18 Jan 20 10.11am

Originally posted by Fatherken

I see the Benteke haters are out again it is the system we play not him

Back to the thread

I agree with most of this except
Ward £2m
Cahill £6m
Andros £5m
Jorden £11m no chance £5m at best
Benteke £6m

It’s not the system we play, he misses many chances, is lazy, movement is poor, nothing to do with the system, he still gets a lot of chances in the system we play but he just can’t score

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 18 Jan 20 1.24pm

I prefer to take Alan Mullery's valuation of the club into account.

 


Red and Blue Army!

mattteo Flag 21 Jan 20 11.23am

The squad's overall transfer balance since the winter of 2017 (when I first started writing the transfer threads) has been of minus 43 million pounds (95 million invested, 52 recovered), with investments in Sorloth, Jach, among others. I won't even go backwards to speak of the 30 million on Benteke!! Meyer arrived free, but on a gigantic salary.

The current possible transfer values of the squad are:

.............Tosun (0-loan)...................
..............(Benteke)(10m).................
.............................................
Zaha(60m).....J. Ayew(15m)....Townsend(15m)
(Schlupp)(15m)...(Wickham)(0m)....(Meyer)(10m)
.............................................
........Kouyate (10m).....Milivojevic (20m)..
.......(McArthur)(5m-age)...(McCarthy)(3m)...
.............................................
PVA(10)...Cahill(0-age)..Tomkins(20)..Ward(10)
(Riedewald....................................
5m).....(Sakho)(20).(Dann)(ending).(Kelly)(10)
..............................................
..............Guaita (15m)....................
..............Hennessey(2m)...................

That's a 255 million squad, with assets also in Sorloth, who may be worth another 10 million. Transfermarkt lists the squad at 217 million euros, but I think my estimations hold. Sure, you could add another 20 million to the price of Zaha, or you could take away from Sakho given his recent injuries, but I think these are more realistic.

Average age of squad is 29,1 years, the oldest in the Premier League.

Edited by mattteo (21 Jan 2020 11.26am)

 

samprior Flag Hamburg 21 Jan 20 12.01pm

Originally posted by mattteo

The squad's overall transfer balance since the winter of 2017 (when I first started writing the transfer threads) has been of minus 43 million pounds (95 million invested, 52 recovered), with investments in Sorloth, Jach, among others. I won't even go backwards to speak of the 30 million on Benteke!! Meyer arrived free, but on a gigantic salary.

The current possible transfer values of the squad are:

.............Tosun (0-loan)...................
..............(Benteke)(10m).................
.............................................
Zaha(60m).....J. Ayew(15m)....Townsend(15m)
(Schlupp)(15m)...(Wickham)(0m)....(Meyer)(10m)
.............................................
........Kouyate (10m).....Milivojevic (20m)..
.......(McArthur)(5m-age)...(McCarthy)(3m)...
.............................................
PVA(10)...Cahill(0-age)..Tomkins(20)..Ward(10)
(Riedewald....................................
5m).....(Sakho)(20).(Dann)(ending).(Kelly)(10)
..............................................
..............Guaita (15m)....................
..............Hennessey(2m)...................

That's a 255 million squad, with assets also in Sorloth, who may be worth another 10 million. Transfermarkt lists the squad at 217 million euros, but I think my estimations hold. Sure, you could add another 20 million to the price of Zaha, or you could take away from Sakho given his recent injuries, but I think these are more realistic.

Average age of squad is 29,1 years, the oldest in the Premier League.

Edited by mattteo (21 Jan 2020 11.26am)

Interesting to see it laid out but I think you're being slightly generous.

I'd say half the amounts for
Sakho, Ward and Kelly. And 10 max for Schlupp and Townsend. Even then I don't think there'd be too many suitors. Possibly promoted teams or teams in an injury crisis at a push. This is not to say I don't rate them at palace but would others see fit to make such investments. As always it doesn't really matter what we value players as it's just what someone is willing to pay. As per the situation with Wilf.


Edited by samprior (21 Jan 2020 12.04pm)

 

silvertop Flag Portishead 21 Jan 20 4.05pm

Originally posted by mattteo

The squad's overall transfer balance since the winter of 2017 (when I first started writing the transfer threads) has been of minus 43 million pounds (95 million invested, 52 recovered), with investments in Sorloth, Jach, among others. I won't even go backwards to speak of the 30 million on Benteke!! Meyer arrived free, but on a gigantic salary.

The current possible transfer values of the squad are:

.............Tosun (0-loan)...................
..............(Benteke)(10m).................
.............................................
Zaha(60m).....J. Ayew(15m)....Townsend(15m)
(Schlupp)(15m)...(Wickham)(0m)....(Meyer)(10m)
.............................................
........Kouyate (10m).....Milivojevic (20m)..
.......(McArthur)(5m-age)...(McCarthy)(3m)...
.............................................
PVA(10)...Cahill(0-age)..Tomkins(20)..Ward(10)
(Riedewald....................................
5m).....(Sakho)(20).(Dann)(ending).(Kelly)(10)
..............................................
..............Guaita (15m)....................
..............Hennessey(2m)...................

That's a 255 million squad, with assets also in Sorloth, who may be worth another 10 million. Transfermarkt lists the squad at 217 million euros, but I think my estimations hold. Sure, you could add another 20 million to the price of Zaha, or you could take away from Sakho given his recent injuries, but I think these are more realistic.

Average age of squad is 29,1 years, the oldest in the Premier League.

Edited by mattteo (21 Jan 2020 11.26am)

There's always a price. And zero for Cahill, Dann and Wickham is frankly nonsense.

 

mattteo Flag 21 Jan 20 7.50pm

Originally posted by silvertop

There's always a price. And zero for Cahill, Dann and Wickham is frankly nonsense.

It's in how much the team could get for them, not how much the players costs.

For example, Dann is ending his contract. The team can get exactly 0 for him.

Wickham may go on loan to a Championship club, but they won't pay right now for a man who has been injured so long. Cahill would only leave for free if he'd leave.

 

mattteo Flag 21 Jan 20 7.54pm

Originally posted by samprior

Interesting to see it laid out but I think you're being slightly generous.


Edited by samprior (21 Jan 2020 12.04pm)

Yeah, I tried to be fair though. I also posted in the Transfer Talk section in my thread and I tried to say that I could have built a better squad, worth more money since 2017 until now. But I also tried to be fair to the club management and say that the figure for which they bought Sakho still holds.

I mean, surely Palace would not agree to sell Sakho for less than 20 million. But there might be no one to offer this money anymore...

Kind of like the Tekkers situation..

 

CharlesPaterson Flag 21 Jan 20 9.41pm

Originally posted by mattteo

The squad's overall transfer balance since the winter of 2017 (when I first started writing the transfer threads) has been of minus 43 million pounds (95 million invested, 52 recovered), with investments in Sorloth, Jach, among others. I won't even go backwards to speak of the 30 million on Benteke!! Meyer arrived free, but on a gigantic salary.

The current possible transfer values of the squad are:

.............Tosun (0-loan)...................
..............(Benteke)(10m).................
.............................................
Zaha(60m).....J. Ayew(15m)....Townsend(15m)
(Schlupp)(15m)...(Wickham)(0m)....(Meyer)(10m)
.............................................
........Kouyate (10m).....Milivojevic (20m)..
.......(McArthur)(5m-age)...(McCarthy)(3m)...
.............................................
PVA(10)...Cahill(0-age)..Tomkins(20)..Ward(10)
(Riedewald....................................
5m).....(Sakho)(20).(Dann)(ending).(Kelly)(10)
..............................................
..............Guaita (15m)....................
..............Hennessey(2m)...................

That's a 255 million squad, with assets also in Sorloth, who may be worth another 10 million. Transfermarkt lists the squad at 217 million euros, but I think my estimations hold. Sure, you could add another 20 million to the price of Zaha, or you could take away from Sakho given his recent injuries, but I think these are more realistic.

Average age of squad is 29,1 years, the oldest in the Premier League.

Edited by mattteo (21 Jan 2020 11.26am)


After watching that tonight, I stand by my comment, we've only got 10 players who'd fetch more than £5m

Guita
Ayew
Wilf
Luka
Tomkins
PVA
Max
Schlupp
Riedwald
Kouyate

 

the.universal 21 Jan 20 10.27pm

Originally posted by CharlesPaterson


After watching that tonight, I stand by my comment, we've only got 10 players who'd fetch more than £5m

Guita
Ayew
Wilf
Luka
Tomkins
PVA
Max
Schlupp
Riedwald
Kouyate

Glad you’re not doing the deals then :0)

 


Vive le Roy!

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Squad value January 2020