This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
We have won 11, drawn 9 , lost 15. If our first 30 games had been seqeuntially win, That would have put us 15th/16th in table. Games 31-35 produce 3 wins and 2 draws. We then have 42 pts but off a 5 game streak of not losing. So, if we had flirted more with relegation but had a great run past five games I suggest Roy would be praised not receiving the criticism he is now. You think that a manager thats team has played absolute sh*t over 5 games and got no points is receiving more criticism than if the same manager was on a great run, the past 5 games? Yes that is correct.
|
|
|
The point being the points total is more important than anything else. Originally posted by Casual
Originally posted by HKOwen
We have won 11, drawn 9 , lost 15. If our first 30 games had been seqeuntially win, That would have put us 15th/16th in table. Games 31-35 produce 3 wins and 2 draws. We then have 42 pts but off a 5 game streak of not losing. So, if we had flirted more with relegation but had a great run past five games I suggest Roy would be praised not receiving the criticism he is now. You think that a manager thats team has played absolute sh*t over 5 games and got no points is receiving more criticism than if the same manager was on a great run, the past 5 games? Yes that is correct.
Responsibility Deficit Disorder is a medical condition. Symptoms include inability to be corrected when wrong, false sense of superiority, desire to share personal info no else cares about, general hubris. It's a medical issue rather than pure arrogance. |
|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Whatever did happen to the AWB money? Distributed amongst shareholders ? Your testing the youngsters is logical but football is not logical. I agree if we suspect youngsters not good enough then let's find out Edited by HKOwen (14 Jul 2020 11.01am) I believe it supplemented the high player wages so we could still report we're in the black and looking good for FFP.
|
|
|
Originally posted by The Dolphin
If you had offered most of us 42 points before the season began then we would have torn the proverbial hand off! Quite agree.
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
I agree, survival is target every year. Problem we have is over spending on wage bill to survive so not sustainable. I think we are 9th or 10th highest wage bill so if that is the measure we are underperforming. This year we reached practical safety quite early, certainly after Bournemouth game and the rest is plain to see in the results. Players are in job done mode Realistically this season we are going to finish 14th on 42 points. Trying to make this as objective as possible. We've got the 9th highest wage bill, 12th highest revenue, and 15th biggest stadium, and 14th most valuable squad (£212.90m apparently, with a very limited sell on value). On that, 9th to 15th is a reasonable expectation of where we should be. Much as it pains me to say it, on that basis, Roy isn't doing a terrible job. I'll settle for below average and declining.
|
|
|
If at the end of last season, this current squad had been posted as a suggestion, it would have been unanimously below expectation. Max Meyer is the only player under the age of 27 we've signed for 2 years. The year before was only Riedewald and Sorloth. None of them play. We have 20 senior players, one of whom (Wickham) is out on loan. Within 2 years, 9 of those 20 players will be at least 32. Cahill, Guaita, Hennessey, McArthur, Tomkins, Ward, Kouyate, Sakho, Kelly. Within 3 years, you can add Milivojevic, Van Aanholt, Benteke, McCarthy. The squad is 3/4 players short anyway, and we'll receive very little money for the 13 players listed above. According to [Link] we have the 4th lowest squad value in the league. We probably need to buy 12 players in the next 2 years, and ship 7 or 8 of the above list, having completely wasted this year as a chance to get going on that. That means we now need to do big overhauls, which often end up in relegation unless you buy extremely well (which we tend not to do). To me, the state of the club vs last year is below expectation.
26th January 2010 - Enter Administration |
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
If at the end of last season, this current squad had been posted as a suggestion, it would have been unanimously below expectation. Max Meyer is the only player under the age of 27 we've signed for 2 years. The year before was only Riedewald and Sorloth. None of them play. We have 20 senior players, one of whom (Wickham) is out on loan. Within 2 years, 9 of those 20 players will be at least 32. Cahill, Guaita, Hennessey, McArthur, Tomkins, Ward, Kouyate, Sakho, Kelly. Within 3 years, you can add Milivojevic, Van Aanholt, Benteke, McCarthy. The squad is 3/4 players short anyway, and we'll receive very little money for the 13 players listed above. According to [Link] we have the 4th lowest squad value in the league. We probably need to buy 12 players in the next 2 years, and ship 7 or 8 of the above list, having completely wasted this year as a chance to get going on that. That means we now need to do big overhauls, which often end up in relegation unless you buy extremely well (which we tend not to do). To me, the state of the club vs last year is below expectation. You cannot argue against those stats and the resultant expectation of where the club is at.
|
|
|
Originally posted by ambrose7
If at the end of last season, this current squad had been posted as a suggestion, it would have been unanimously below expectation. Max Meyer is the only player under the age of 27 we've signed for 2 years. The year before was only Riedewald and Sorloth. None of them play. We have 20 senior players, one of whom (Wickham) is out on loan. Within 2 years, 9 of those 20 players will be at least 32. Cahill, Guaita, Hennessey, McArthur, Tomkins, Ward, Kouyate, Sakho, Kelly. Within 3 years, you can add Milivojevic, Van Aanholt, Benteke, McCarthy. The squad is 3/4 players short anyway, and we'll receive very little money for the 13 players listed above. According to [Link] we have the 4th lowest squad value in the league. We probably need to buy 12 players in the next 2 years, and ship 7 or 8 of the above list, having completely wasted this year as a chance to get going on that. That means we now need to do big overhauls, which often end up in relegation unless you buy extremely well (which we tend not to do). To me, the state of the club vs last year is below expectation. If we could get Sakho and Bentenke off the wage bill and bring in younger replacements from the Championship or abroad then that would be a good start. Those two alone would probably cover the wages of 4 less experienced players. If we get the young lad in from West Brom then hopefully that's the right-back situation sorted. I think if we proceed with Roy's holding three then we probably don't need any new central midfielders for next season. Whether Zaha stays or goes we need at least one new winger and then maybe, just maybe, we might finally sign a quality striker. Despite the understandable scepticism, I actually think we are on solid ground to rebuild the squad as we have no significant debt and we barely touched the 50m from Wan Bissaka. On top of that, the positive of an older squad is that it would probably make it easier for younger players to come in and find their feet, relying on the experience of those around them. The club have failed to deliver on my expectations in the transfer market this past few years, but I actually do think they have a plan, even if it isn't a particularly exciting one!
|
|
| jeeagles |
|
|---|---|
|
Originally posted by HKOwen
Most people think the 50M for Wan Bissaka has gone already to repay loans from " investors ". We desperately need a significant upgrade at right back. Benteke and Sakho still contracted for another year and no one else will pick up their wages so don't expect they will be off the payroll soon no significant saving unless something happens with Meyer Edited by HKOwen (15 Jul 2020 10.39am) We’ve got the same right back every other managers had since we were promoted.
|
|
All images and text on this site are copyright © 1999-2025 The Holmesdale Online, unless otherwise stated.
Web Design by Guntrisoft Ltd.