This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.
var
Visit the current forum | Forum Rules
hayling eagle 17 Jul 20 12.03am |
|
|
Well, you've had two seasons of VAR now.
Are you all happy with it? I bet you're not.
Are you stuck with it? You bet you are.
Only solution? Turn off your televisions and don't go to the grounds when we're allowed back.
No, didn't think you would like that. Oh well. Get used to VAR and stop moaning.
|
Teddy Eagle 17 Jul 20 12.08am |
|
Originally posted by hayling eagle
Well, you've had two seasons of VAR now.
Are you all happy with it? I bet you're not.
Are you stuck with it? You bet you are.
Only solution? Turn off your televisions and don't go to the grounds when we're allowed back.
No, didn't think you would like that. Oh well. Get used to VAR and stop moaning.
Or get relegated into a division which magically exists without it.
|
Cpfc1861 17 Jul 20 12.11am |
|
|
All VAR has done is confirmed referees are either incompetant or corrupt either way it's terrible the decisions ain't good. FA should make all the referees reapply for jobs or bring in foreign refs who speak english they are better and more likely to be impartial.
|
Teddy Eagle 17 Jul 20 12.38am |
|
|
Just remove all decision making from referees and let VAR decide everything. He can show cards when told to , whoosh his disappearing spray around and run around looking important.
|
Superhorns3 Harpdenden 17 Jul 20 8.35am |
|
|
It highlights that officials are still woefully very inconsistent and some of the rules are not good for the game - nit picking in terms of offsides and handballs .
|
the silurian The garden of England.(not really) 17 Jul 20 9.07am |
|
Originally posted by Cpfc1861
All VAR has done is confirmed referees are either incompetant or corrupt either way it's terrible the decisions ain't good. FA should make all the referees reapply for jobs or bring in foreign refs who speak english they are better and more likely to be impartial.
money talks, anyone from anywhere can be corrupted
|
palace chick South Croydon 17 Jul 20 9.27am |
|
|
Don’t think the referee’s are any better or worse with VAR. Mostly they get the decisions correct as before. Problem seems more with VAR and instructions to referees to go to the monitor and check. I suppose it’s also a grey area for us fans as well as I still believe having seen it so many times that the ball came of Sakho’s shoulder for the disallowed goal v Villa and that Ayew’s offside goal decision last night was incorrect. The penalty not given not going to VAR or the ref not being requested to see it on a monitor makes a mockery of using technology available - grrr!
|
kenners46 sydenham village 17 Jul 20 9.33am |
|
|
Should set a time limit of 20-30 seconds, anything over confirms its not clear and obvious
|
the silurian The garden of England.(not really) 17 Jul 20 9.41am |
|
Originally posted by palace chick
Don’t think the referee’s are any better or worse with VAR. Mostly they get the decisions correct as before. Problem seems more with VAR and instructions to referees to go to the monitor and check. I suppose it’s also a grey area for us fans as well as I still believe having seen it so many times that the ball came of Sakho’s shoulder for the disallowed goal v Villa and that Ayew’s offside goal decision last night was incorrect. The penalty not given not going to VAR or the ref not being requested to see it on a monitor makes a mockery of using technology available - grrr!
VAR is the modern day Clattenberg, always wants to be the star of the show!!
|
southnorwoodhill 17 Jul 20 9.42am |
|
|
VAR in theory is fine. It's the incompetence of the officials that needs highlighting, the standard of refereeing is absolutely woeful. When a ball hits a player on the upper shoulder and goes into the net, and that goal is disallowed despite VAR allowing the opportunity to review the situation over and over, well then that official is either corrupt or incompetent and not fit for duty.
|
crvenaeagle 17 Jul 20 9.47am |
|
|
Old Dave down the pub's opinion is that they're purposefully making a s*** show of VAR so they have a reason to get rid of it again.
|
Teddy Eagle 17 Jul 20 10.01am |
|
|
If not actual corruption then the VAR officials should undergo unconscious bias training. Or at least agree to explain their decisions after the game.
|
taylors lovechild 17 Jul 20 10.01am |
|
|
I try not to judge it on the games we're involved in knowing I am always going to have a bias, but there are massive inconsistencies in how it's being used. Sometimes things are reviewed over and over while others are reviewed for seconds. I mean, how could it have got the Bruno Fernandes penalty decision against Villa so wrong? Because it only reviewed it very, very briefly. Referees have had meetings recently to discuss how it should be being used and I think rather than some grand conspiracy it is just that they do not have a clear set of guidelines as to how to use it (or they're interpreting them differently). Sadly for some teams this experiment could have cost them points which are the difference between staying up or not, or getting into Europe or not.
We had some luck earlier in the season with VAR, but the last two games it has definitely not looked kindly on us. Hopefully next season there will at least be some clarity around how it should be used. Also, they need to introduce some new blood into the refereeing pool as some of the fat old f**ks have grown too long in the tooth and seem stuck up their own ars*s. How can you get paid as much they do and be allowed to turn up to games with a beer belly (aka Jonathan Moss)?
|
steeleye20 Croydon 17 Jul 20 10.23am |
|
|
Covid-19 has meant empty stadiums.
But it looks like VAR means the same to me.
What is the point in going to a football match?
And they are making wrong decisions so what can possibly be the point of VAR if it is not 100% accurate.
Credit to players and staff for keeping their sanity.
SP tweets is it a busted system, the answer must be yes.
|
doombear Too far from Selhurst Park 17 Jul 20 10.31am |
|
|
I like the concept of VAR. HOWEVER: 1. it has been brought in before it is technologically good enough to do the job especially with regard to offside 2. the refs/officials in the Prem have been given poor guidelines especially with regard to handball. There's one rule when defending and another when attacking; that's surely wrong. 3. it is not clear what constitutes a clear and obvious error. 4. Not all incidents are being looked at 5. Refs get to see the pitchside monitor in some instances (red card offences only?) when our Italian friend Pierluigi Collina (who in my book was one of teh best ever refs)gets stuck in to his new job, hopefully we will get a more consistent system.
|
Gary St.Andrews Kenley 17 Jul 20 10.31am |
|
|
It seems that this season In particular there have been some really poor decisions and the last 2 weeks the focus has been on us. The Sakho disallowed goal for handball, now I am not a medical expert but I have never known the collar bone to be recognised as part of the arm.
As for the Ayew offside, for VAR to scrutinise the video footage for as long as they did means the goal should have stood. What ever happened to the attacking side having an advantage. The angle shown was not conclusive on television so the goal should have stood, end of.
I don’t want to say if the boot had been on the other foot, United would have been awarded the goal, but even I am questioning it now.
|
Fatherken 17 Jul 20 10.36am |
|
|
VAR is killing the fun and sprit fro the game . I agree with the earlier comment that the officials who look at VAR should be asked why they did or not give whatever . I also think , now that ref's who are well paid , they should after the match [ like players and managers ] be interview on TV .
|
Teddy Eagle 17 Jul 20 10.57am |
|
Originally posted by doombear
I like the concept of VAR. HOWEVER: 1. it has been brought in before it is technologically good enough to do the job especially with regard to offside 2. the refs/officials in the Prem have been given poor guidelines especially with regard to handball. There's one rule when defending and another when attacking; that's surely wrong. 3. it is not clear what constitutes a clear and obvious error. 4. Not all incidents are being looked at 5. Refs get to see the pitchside monitor in some instances (red card offences only?) when our Italian friend Pierluigi Collina (who in my book was one of teh best ever refs)gets stuck in to his new job, hopefully we will get a more consistent system.
Point 3 is vital. Last night Maguire wrapped is arms round Ayew in the area and didn’t let him move. Either the ref saw it and didn’t give anything which was a clear and obvious error or he missed it as the linesman missed the offside and VAR must have seen it but presumably couldn’t intervene.
|
ASCPFC Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 17 Jul 20 12.22pm |
|
|
Just another anti fan but pro TV load of bollocks. How much more can fans take? We've got high pricing, poor experience, poor travel links, heavy handed policing/ stewarding, over paid mercenary players, moaning managers, buying the league and the refereeing has got worse, when it seemed impossible for it to be any worse. Now, we have every small team's goals checked and the big teams call for VAR at will. Note, if a Man U player had been fouled as Wilf was, Ole would have made a TV sign, play would have stopped, and it would have been checked. That is blatant corruption.
Red and Blue Army!
|
Teddy Eagle 17 Jul 20 1.10pm |
|
|
It’s tempting to think it would’ve turned into FergieVision if old Bacon Face was still in power.
|