You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR legal challenges
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

VAR legal challenges


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
steeleye20 Flag Croydon 28 Jul 20 4.19pm

In what circumstances can VAR invoke a legal challenge?

Bournemouth considering it apparently, a recent shocker of an evening which ended with the VAR people admitting their errors had affected 3 PL results, I think this was Villa v Sheff Utd.

Their equipment was faulty (apparently) which should be their responsibility.


 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 28 Jul 20 4.25pm

Sour grapes from Bournemouth.

 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 28 Jul 20 4.30pm

I don't think they can win..

Other teams could say but if this and that happened we would have done this.

Also who knows if Villa would have lost that game.

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 28 Jul 20 6.21pm

It won't happen it's no different to a referee making a blunder unless you can prove intent it's just bad luck.

 


One more point

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 28 Jul 20 6.36pm

Originally posted by Badger11

It won't happen it's no different to a referee making a blunder unless you can prove intent it's just bad luck.

Exactly. If it does happen then I want us to go after Clattenburg for cheating us out of the cup in 2016.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Jul 20 7.18pm

Should have been challenged at the time. No chance of winning because no-one can say that Villa wouldn’t have won. If Sheff Utd aren’t challenging it... no chance

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 28 Jul 20 7.19pm

Originally posted by martin2412

Exactly. If it does happen then I want us to go after Clattenburg for cheating us out of the cup in 2016.

Exactly he has admitted his errors but still laughs at his record when reffing Palace games

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 28 Jul 20 8.53pm

It's not VAR they are trying to blame.
It's the Hawkeye thing as it didnt work to prove a ball had crossed the goal line.
That being said they wernt good enough so they can be the small town in southampton again.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Jul 20 10.06pm

Originally posted by cryrst

It's not VAR they are trying to blame.
It's the Hawkeye thing
as it didnt work to prove a ball had crossed the goal line.
That being said they wernt good enough so they can be the small town in southampton again.


Correct. The problem is no-one knows how the game would have finished if the goal had been awarded. The game would have restarted from the centre spot, instead of carrying on and would have followed a different course. IMHO Bournemouth will be wasting money by taking legal action on this one.

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 29 Jul 20 7.05am

Originally posted by doombear


Correct. The problem is no-one knows how the game would have finished if the goal had been awarded. The game would have restarted from the centre spot, instead of carrying on and would have followed a different course. IMHO Bournemouth will be wasting money by taking legal action on this one.

Agreed

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 29 Jul 20 7.47am

Originally posted by cryrst

It's not VAR they are trying to blame.
It's the Hawkeye thing as it didnt work to prove a ball had crossed the goal line.
That being said they wernt good enough so they can be the small town in southampton again.

According to Hawkeye they had 7 cameras and by bad luck and for the first ever a player was blocking the view from each of them hence the technology failure.

In human terms it is no different to the referee and linesman saying they didn't spot something because their view was obstructed. I believe the rules allow for mistakes to be made it's only if you can show that the referee was bribed or the technology sabotaged that you would have a case.

Regarding the specific incident the solution lies with more technology in this case VAR. The VAR camera's clearly showed what happened so the VAR officials should have used their common-sense and alerted the referee that something was wrong and to go look at the monitor. Hopefully they have now been instructed to intervene which after all is the point of VAR a clear and obvious error.

 


One more point

steeleye20 Flag Croydon 29 Jul 20 9.21am

There were 2 other VAR failures that night.

And that is the whole point, we have given VAR 2 years to get it right but it doesn't, causing more hold-ups more controversy and still making wrong decisions, in which case what is the point.

In fact our PL football is becoming a lottery, there is no point in attending matches if it is decided remotely.

I wanted it to succeed after seeing the success of DRS in cricket, but they are chalk and cheese.

One benefit for those relegated is that they can play football once again without it.

The more changes and allowances you make for VAR, the worse it becomes.



 

Superhorns3 Flag Harpdenden 29 Jul 20 10.32am

I did read at the time VAR wasn't allowed to intervene for some reason which just about sums it up!

But it can rule on toe nails being offside and "handballs" for a shoulder .

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Jul 20 10.54am

Originally posted by steeleye20

There were 2 other VAR failures that night.

And that is the whole point, we have given VAR 2 years to get it right but it doesn't, causing more hold-ups more controversy and still making wrong decisions, in which case what is the point.

In fact our PL football is becoming a lottery, there is no point in attending matches if it is decided remotely.

I wanted it to succeed after seeing the success of DRS in cricket, but they are chalk and cheese.

One benefit for those relegated is that they can play football once again without it.

The more changes and allowances you make for VAR, the worse it becomes.



The difference with drs is that the final decision is umpires call even after its proved he may have it wrong. Hawkeye predicts the ball height and movement but not ground conditions on the pitch. In that way the umpire may be correct on an LBW even after its shown missing by hawkeye.
All the ref in football needs to do is have the final say in a tight offside or subjective decisions.
Basically look at the monitor. At least then the fans,well I would, think it wasnt a remote decision by a n other. Well Collina is now involved I read so maybe a forced change to the refs decision of using the monitor might happen.
In europe the refs do look and I dont think there are as many arguments as over here.

 

Nicholas91 Flag The Democratic Republic of Kent 29 Jul 20 5.15pm

I still think it should be like other sports and each team has a set number of challenges in a game for the opportunity to use VAR relating to Dismissals, goals and Penalties.

 


Now Zaha's got a bit of green grass ahead of him here... and finds Ambrose... not a bad effort!!!!

BlueJay Flag UK 29 Jul 20 6.01pm

Originally posted by steeleye20

In what circumstances can VAR invoke a legal challenge?

Bournemouth considering it apparently, a recent shocker of an evening which ended with the VAR people admitting their errors had affected 3 PL results, I think this was Villa v Sheff Utd.

Their equipment was faulty (apparently) which should be their responsibility.


VAR is imperfect but I don't see legal challenges as the way to go, and it opens a whole new can of worms that we can all do without.

 

BlueJay Flag UK 29 Jul 20 6.03pm

Originally posted by Nicholas91

I still think it should be like other sports and each team has a set number of challenges in a game for the opportunity to use VAR relating to Dismissals, goals and Penalties.

Not a bad idea really. It would add an element of strategy and hopefully stop the endless complaining.

 

cryrst Flag The garden of England 29 Jul 20 8.23pm

Originally posted by BlueJay

Not a bad idea really. It would add an element of strategy and hopefully stop the endless complaining.


Unless the appeal would be to force the ref to check pitchside. Now that's the way to go with appealing although it would still be refs call.
Our 'goal' against villa might well have stood.

 

eritheagle Flag Erith 30 Jul 20 6.05am

Originally posted by steeleye20

In what circumstances can VAR invoke a legal challenge?

Bournemouth considering it apparently, a recent shocker of an evening which ended with the VAR people admitting their errors had affected 3 PL results, I think this was Villa v Sheff Utd.

Their equipment was faulty (apparently) which should be their responsibility.


The night of the 3 VAR mistakes was a different night.
This was when Bournemouth got away with one as Kane should've got a penalty against them for being shoved over by King.
The other 2 errors being Fernandez getting a generous penalty v Aston Villa (which helped B'mouth) and that odious little twerp Ward-Prowse cheating for a penalty v Everton.

Aston Villa v Sheff Utd was the first game back after lockdown and the only other game that night was Man City v Arsenal (re-arranged fixtures due to League Cup final).

 

crvenaeagle Flag 30 Jul 20 1.37pm

Originally posted by cryrst

The difference with drs is that the final decision is umpires call even after its proved he may have it wrong. Hawkeye predicts the ball height and movement but not ground conditions on the pitch. In that way the umpire may be correct on an LBW even after its shown missing by hawkeye.
All the ref in football needs to do is have the final say in a tight offside or subjective decisions.
Basically look at the monitor. At least then the fans,well I would, think it wasnt a remote decision by a n other. Well Collina is now involved I read so maybe a forced change to the refs decision of using the monitor might happen.
In europe the refs do look and I dont think there are as many arguments as over here.

You mean the revered Collina?

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > VAR legal challenges