You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)
November 16 2026 5.36am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

James McCarthy (rumour)


Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>
Petereagle Flag Brockley 02 Aug 20 6.26am

[Link]

Keep him, he's been an excellent addition to the squad

 

EddieMac Flag 02 Aug 20 8.20am

Originally posted by Petereagle

[Link]

Keep him, he's been an excellent addition to the squad

Madness to let him go. I don’t think we will.

 

JohnB Flag 02 Aug 20 8.38am

£4m profit on a player in a season isn't bad though. Especially if it allows us to get a replacement in that is more effective going forward.

The main thing I'd miss about him is him being a banker for a yellow card in a bet builder.

Opens 365, Palace Vs anyone, betbuilder, player to be carded, Milivojevic, McCarthy. 6/1. Lump.

 

Painter Flag Croydon 02 Aug 20 8.52am

Originally posted by Petereagle

[Link]

Keep him, he's been an excellent addition to the squad

I would agree, rather let McArthur go at 32 years old his legs are going, rarely plays 90 minutes.

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 Aug 20 9.53am

Originally posted by JohnB

£4m profit on a player in a season isn't bad though. Especially if it allows us to get a replacement in that is more effective going forward.

The main thing I'd miss about him is him being a banker for a yellow card in a bet builder.

Opens 365, Palace Vs anyone, betbuilder, player to be carded, Milivojevic, McCarthy. 6/1. Lump.

Profit?? I thought we paid £8 million for him, maths is not my strong point, but I make that a 3 million loss!!

 

Spiderman Flag Horsham 02 Aug 20 10.01am

Originally posted by monkey

Profit?? I thought we paid £8 million for him, maths is not my strong point, but I make that a 3 million loss!!

Nowhere near £8m think it was about £900,000

 

Tickled pink Flag Cornwall 02 Aug 20 10.15am

[Link]

 

monkey Flag Sittingbourne,but made in Bromley 02 Aug 20 10.17am

Originally posted by Spiderman

Nowhere near £8m think it was about £900,000

I think this should go in the ‘I don’t know what I’m talking about thread’ because having googled it to set my memory straight, I’ve read everything from undisclosed fee to 2.97 million through to 8 million

 

kenners46 Flag sydenham village 02 Aug 20 10.21am

Sell him, although he is very good at pointing

 

taylors lovechild Flag 02 Aug 20 10.27am

He's been a decent squad player but nothing more. At 3m seems like we did good business, but I wouldn't be hugely upset if we sold him on at a profit and I certainly wouldn't miss his floaty set-pieces. We might see more of Jairo too. I'd miss McArthur more, despite his age, who I think was an outside bet for the POTY.


 

JohnB Flag 02 Aug 20 10.42am

Originally posted by monkey

I think this should go in the ‘I don’t know what I’m talking about thread’ because having googled it to set my memory straight, I’ve read everything from undisclosed fee to 2.97 million through to 8 million

I'm pretty sure the £8m fee was on a load of Everton fan websites but it was much lower around the £1m mark.

Just checked on The Athletic and this was by Dom Fifield who is pretty close to the club:


Cahill may command a competitive wage on a two-year deal but he was a free agent after six-and-a-half glittering seasons at Chelsea. McCarthy, once the second-most expensive signing in Everton’s history, would cost less than £1 million. There was little risk involved in bringing them in and Hodgson, while still expectant over the addition of a right-back and striker, would be appeased by their arrival.

Edited by JohnB (02 Aug 2020 10.45am)

 

Noz Flag North Hampshire 02 Aug 20 11.31am

I've got to say that I have not really been impressed by McCarthy. We were chasing him for a few seasons as far as I know, but I don't really know why. Perhaps the nasty injuries he sustained whilst at Everton had an affect on him, but he seems to lunge in too early on a tackle, slightly recklessly. His yellow card count rivals Milovojevic. Perhaps we have been playing him out of position in that defensive to mid midfielder role? Sorry but I won't be crying my eyes out if he goes to villa for 5m.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 02 Aug 20 12.15pm

He's been reasonable value for us (assuming the £3m price tag was right) and he isn't at the top of my list of players to shunt out. We've already got the (or one of the) smallest first team squads in the EPL, so need to bring in more than we let go.
I want to see more coming in before we let players go. I don't want us to be signing players at the last minute in desperation.

 

cpj Flag Kent 02 Aug 20 12.47pm

Awful player - did nothing except get booked. I'll drive him to Villa myself.

 

BelfastEagle Flag 02 Aug 20 12.54pm

A player who after the game leaves you scratching your head wondering what exactly he did and was he even on the pitch.

 

Nubes Flag London 02 Aug 20 1.07pm

The thing is a lot of fans get caught up in the moment and are far too emotionally attached to what is happening at the time.

During lockdown the whole team have played below expectations for whatever the reasons.

I remember prior to lockdown the groundswell on McCarthy was that he was a valued member of the team / squad and his attributes were well documented through numerous posts.

Now I’m reading posts to the contrary to what many had posted prior to lockdown. Everyone needs to disregard the performances post Bournemouth and remember how players were playing when there was a competitive edge and points to play for during the first 23 of the season.

Guita was terrible during lockdown but that isn’t a reflection on the season As they lost 20 to 30 % of their hunger due to being safe after the Bournemouth game and from the start of pre season and across the season the target was prob 40 points . They will be in the beach mentally once reaching that target if that’s what you been working towards for 9 months .

 

palace99 Flag New Mills 02 Aug 20 1.25pm

think we paid £3m upfront, maybe more linked to appearances.

He did ok , but I'd take the £5m and let him go.

Need younger legs in midfield and some creativity and if other 3 are fit he is always on the bench

 

braunstoneagle Flag the middle of bumf*** nowhere... 02 Aug 20 2.23pm

i think he is decent enough but would take £5m for him tbf. 29 years old out of contract next summer.

if we are looking to lower the average age of the squad it makes sense to sell him.

 


‘Football isn’t instant coffee. You have to work at it. You must grow the bean, grind it.’ Ian Holloway


Cucking Funt Flag Clapham on the Back 02 Aug 20 2.35pm

Originally posted by braunstoneagle

i think he is decent enough but would take £5m for him tbf. 29 years old out of contract next summer.

if we are looking to lower the average age of the squad it makes sense to sell him.

Only if he's replaced by someone younger, though, and that's by no means guaranteed.

 


Wife beating may be socially acceptable in Sheffield, but it is a different matter in Cheltenham

Putitout Flag Oxford 02 Aug 20 2.45pm


Most of the noise is coming out of connections to Villa, and Birmingham, in general. So there could be something in this.
Palace need to strengthen the squad . But then again if Mc,Carthy hasn’t impressed enough , maybe take the profit and try again.

 

Page 1 of 5 1 2 3 4 5 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > James McCarthy (rumour)