You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who is going to be moving on..??
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Who is going to be moving on..??


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Aug 20 2.17pm

With Eze coming in and looks like others to follow;

• Fraser
• One of Mateta, Edoard or Watkins
• Kotchap
• Then a couple of loanees

There must be a balancing of the books, need to move a few players on and nudge them out of “the nest”.
So who is going to/might be on their way..??

• Meyer – I like Max as a player, but he’s had chances and never quite nailed it – maybe a little lightweight for the at this point for the Prem – but I fear could come back and bite us.
• Riedewald – Ditto Meyer.
• Sakho – Again I like Sakho, but always concerned there is a mistake just around the corner. Probably now 3rd choice centre half if everyone is fit after Tomkins and Cahill, maybe even 4th if Roy persists with trying Kouyate at centre half. Then you have the potential of Kotchap coming in.
• Dann – has been great for us but sadly think his time might be done but not sure we would get much interest.
• Townsend – Didn’t play a lot last season, I was half expecting him to be a “makeweight” in the Eze deal.
• Schlupp – can’t see it Roy seems to like him – and when fit always performs well, good bench player and gives us cover all down the left and in central midfield.
• Ayew – no double player of the year last season, although think his opportunities maybe a little more limited next season.
• Benteke – again with Benteke I think it’s there, but his confidence seems shot – maybe a move would suit all parties.
• Zaha – the big one..!! I’m becoming less sure about Zaha leaving by the day – at the end of the season it was a definite yes for me, he’s off, was showing no interest and looked for all the world like a player who wanted to be moving on. Now he’s being pictured happily smiling in the new kit, playing and scoring in friendlies. On from that Eze’s comments about our plans, playing with great players etc.. Beyond that no real bids or suitors coming out of the “woodwork”. Time will tell..!!
Just some thoughts, obviously not all of them will go – but will be interesting..!!

On leavers I would like us to “ship out” Hennessey and bring in Butland – it’s just a personal view but think that would be a great move.

COYP

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Aug 20 2.28pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

With Eze coming in and looks like others to follow;

• Fraser
• One of Mateta, Edoard or Watkins
• Kotchap
• Then a couple of loanees

There must be a balancing of the books, need to move a few players on and nudge them out of “the nest”.
So who is going to/might be on their way..??

• Meyer – I like Max as a player, but he’s had chances and never quite nailed it – maybe a little lightweight for the at this point for the Prem – but I fear could come back and bite us.
• Riedewald – Ditto Meyer.
• Sakho – Again I like Sakho, but always concerned there is a mistake just around the corner. Probably now 3rd choice centre half if everyone is fit after Tomkins and Cahill, maybe even 4th if Roy persists with trying Kouyate at centre half. Then you have the potential of Kotchap coming in.
• Dann – has been great for us but sadly think his time might be done but not sure we would get much interest.
• Townsend – Didn’t play a lot last season, I was half expecting him to be a “makeweight” in the Eze deal.
• Schlupp – can’t see it Roy seems to like him – and when fit always performs well, good bench player and gives us cover all down the left and in central midfield.
• Ayew – no double player of the year last season, although think his opportunities maybe a little more limited next season.
• Benteke – again with Benteke I think it’s there, but his confidence seems shot – maybe a move would suit all parties.
• Zaha – the big one..!! I’m becoming less sure about Zaha leaving by the day – at the end of the season it was a definite yes for me, he’s off, was showing no interest and looked for all the world like a player who wanted to be moving on. Now he’s being pictured happily smiling in the new kit, playing and scoring in friendlies. On from that Eze’s comments about our plans, playing with great players etc.. Beyond that no real bids or suitors coming out of the “woodwork”. Time will tell..!!
Just some thoughts, obviously not all of them will go – but will be interesting..!!

On leavers I would like us to “ship out” Hennessey and bring in Butland – it’s just a personal view but think that would be a great move.

COYP

Ooops forgot Sorloth and Wickham - both going for me..!!

COYP

 

Crystal_Clear Flag Belfast 28 Aug 20 2.44pm

Moving on some of these is going to very difficult.

1. We need to find a club that wants them.
2. Some are on very high wages they wont get elsewhere
3. We might need them because of injuries.

Just looked at premier league injuries website, all of these have no scheduled return date.

Gary Cahill, James Tomkins, Mamadou Sakho, Christian Benteke, Patrick Van Annaholt.

So currently we only have Dann and Kelly fit for CB. That list also includes 2 of our biggest earners.

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 28 Aug 20 2.48pm

Some decent points Plaistow. FWIW I think the main two to move on would be Sakho & Meyer and potentially Benteke.

Sakho is still worth a few bob as he’s a very good player (when fit) and there would be interest from the French Ligue 1. It would recoup some money and be a huge amount of wages freed up.

Same thing for Meyer really, he just hasn’t had the impact required for someone who is in the top 5 earners at the club. Free up the wages and get a transfer fee in for someone who we signed on a free transfer.

Benteke is less obvious for me, yes his wages are significant but we don’t know quite how large they are since we re-negotiated his extended contract last year. He has the potential to be good again (as we saw brief glimpses of it last Season) and I just don’t know how much we could get four him in a transfer fee.

I’d keep Schlupp, Townsend and Dann as all three are good squad members and Dann in particular was excellent last season filling in for Tomkins/Cahill/Sakho and we do need Central Defensive cover because our First team regulars in that position are so injury prone (add Kelly to the three mentioned above).

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 28 Aug 20 3.05pm

For me Wickham and Sakho need to move on. Both are injury prone ( rather stating the obvious with CW).

Also, Benteke. He's now gone 3 seasons only scoring a handful of goals. The question is do we wait until we find a replacement before offloading him?

It's a shame that Max hasn't found his niche in the side. I think we all had high hopes of him, but unless Roy can employ him gainfully, and indeed Max can show himself to be worthy of a starting place, then I can't see much future for him.

As for Wilf I think he needs fresh pastures. Unless he is willing to knuckle down and give his all for Palace then I see no point in keeping him.

There are probably one or two others who are borderline cases but it will depend on who else might come in and possibly render them surplus to requirements.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Aug 20 3.49pm

Dazza has posted elsewhere that Sakho and possibly Meyer may be moved on. If that happens then significant wages will be saved. Although Meyer is technically very good, he doesn't seem physically strong enough for this league, sadly and now we have Eze, he's further down the pecking order.

As for others,
Schlupp is good and IMO can play further forward as he can and does score goals for us. He's a useful option from the bench.

Townsend seems to have lost his way. He's listed on the club site as a midfielder but doesn't IMO fulfil that role. If he can't play wide up front on either wing then we should let him go. He's unlikely to be more than a bench warmer and occasional sub this season if we are successful in bringing in Fraser and a CF.

Riederwald is promising IMO and has shown his worth in filling in when needed. I can see him becoming a regular when some of our older CDMs depart over the next couple of years.

Benteke remains an enigma. He did some good work in some of his games last seasons - even got MOTM on one occasion if I'm not mistaken. I'm inclined to keep him to see how he performs with Eze and possibly Fraser to supply him

Wickham - sorry this hobbling injury case has to go. A shame because he showed a lot of promise as a youngster at Ipswich and Sunderland.

Dann - we can't afford to let him go this year given the injury prone CBs we have.

In summary then, I'd be happy to see Sakho, Meyer and Wickham go this window and possibly Townsend in January if he hasn't regained his mojo (or some of it) by then.

Edited by doombear (28 Aug 2020 3.50pm)

 

Phil’s Barber Flag Crowborough 28 Aug 20 4.28pm

Yes, forgot about Wickham, another definite one to move on...even before any other CF’s come in. He quite simply isn’t good enough, reliable enough or fit enough.

 

topcat Flag Holmesdale / Surbiton 28 Aug 20 5.22pm

Sörloth looks as if he's on his way out, possibly even for a profit. After the Grimsby game I would have been happy for Palace to pay off his contract.

I suspect Andros, Mayer and Sakho will be off, so long as we can get a new CB in.

The wages for Benteke will scare bidders off so I think we need to hope that with better service he will regain the form from the first year of his contract. He wasn't bad last season but obviously needs to score 13 goals a season (or 30 goals to make up for the barren seasons)

If Wickham had done better out on loan someone would have put in a bid for him. Maybe a loan to Turkey or the SPL where anyone can score?


 


It's 106 miles to Chicago, we got a full tank of gas, half a pack of cigarettes, it's dark... and we're wearing sunglasses.

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 28 Aug 20 6.25pm

Originally posted by topcat

Sörloth looks as if he's on his way out, possibly even for a profit. After the Grimsby game I would have been happy for Palace to pay off his contract.

I suspect Andros, Mayer and Sakho will be off, so long as we can get a new CB in.

The wages for Benteke will scare bidders off so I think we need to hope that with better service he will regain the form from the first year of his contract. He wasn't bad last season but obviously needs to score 13 goals a season (or 30 goals to make up for the barren seasons)

If Wickham had done better out on loan someone would have put in a bid for him. Maybe a loan to Turkey or the SPL where anyone can score?



Trabsonspor may be in need of a new striker if the rumours turn out to be true!

 

the.universal 28 Aug 20 7.02pm

Originally posted by Phil’s Barber

Some decent points Plaistow. FWIW I think the main two to move on would be Sakho & Meyer and potentially Benteke.

Sakho is still worth a few bob as he’s a very good player (when fit) and there would be interest from the French Ligue 1. It would recoup some money and be a huge amount of wages freed up.

Same thing for Meyer really, he just hasn’t had the impact required for someone who is in the top 5 earners at the club. Free up the wages and get a transfer fee in for someone who we signed on a free transfer.

Benteke is less obvious for me, yes his wages are significant but we don’t know quite how large they are since we re-negotiated his extended contract last year. He has the potential to be good again (as we saw brief glimpses of it last Season) and I just don’t know how much we could get four him in a transfer fee.

I’d keep Schlupp, Townsend and Dann as all three are good squad members and Dann in particular was excellent last season filling in for Tomkins/Cahill/Sakho and we do need Central Defensive cover because our First team regulars in that position are so injury prone (add Kelly to the three mentioned above).

Free transfer as in £20m signing on fee. Horrendous waste of cash.

 


Vive le Roy!

Stirlingsays Flag 28 Aug 20 7.52pm

Crystal Clear made three very relevant points.....that just seem to have been ignored.

1. We need to find a club that wants them.
2. Some are on very high wages they wont get elsewhere
3. We might need them because of injuries.

Each of these players needs to be judged within that context. When I look at what's realistic it limits what's likely to happen.

• Meyer – I also like Max as a player, good technical players are not legion outside of the top six. He can play in a variety of positions and is on high wages. I don't see him leaving because of that and I think he has a utility part to play for us.
• Riedewald – He's similar to Meyer but more defensive. I think he's a good squad player to have but if I was a promoted side coming up from the championship I would be looking to nap him.
• Sakho – He's on a hundred grand a week and is thirty plus is prone to the odd mistake. Don't get me wrong he's a quality centre half with good distribution but centre half is a strong area for us and selling Sakho now would be the better move in my view.
• Dann – he's a great back up centre half for us and should end his career much as Delaney did.
• Townsend – I'm half way about Townsend. He is a player with selling potential who is a bit hot and cold. I think if we get Fraser it's possible he could be off if a strong bid comes in...but it's more likely he's staying.
• Schlupp – a player valued within the set up....can't see him going anywhere.
• Ayew – going nowhere, I'd be highly surprosed.
• Benteke – just recently signed a new contract. I think he's seen as a back up striker now. He's only be sold if a bid comes in that matches the valuation, which isn't likely....but who knows, maybe if Villa get a bit desperate.
• Zaha – if he doesn't go soon then the nearer we get to transfer end line the more attractive he'll appear to those big clubs anxious that they haven't signed anyone significant. I will be highly surprised if he's still here and playing games for us come the start of the season.
• Sorloth– I think the one thing we can be sure of is he won't be playing in a Palace shirt again.
• Wickham– if he's sold, with his injury history, it'll be for pennies....with his contract going till June 2021 it's more likely he'll be loaned and then released.


Edited by Stirlingsays (28 Aug 2020 11.26pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

deleted 25 Flag 28 Aug 20 7.52pm

Plaistow Patricia is moving on

 

ex hibitionist Flag Hastings 28 Aug 20 9.03pm

it shud be harmonica and hobo stick for ...

Meyer
Sakho
Benteke
Wickham

and I'd put McArthur on the list if we can get a younger replacement

and I'm not sure we need five defensive midfielders (six if you include Meyer), so maybe Kouyate as well, keep Riedewald

 

Casual Flag Orpington 28 Aug 20 9.10pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

With Eze coming in and looks like others to follow;

• Fraser
• One of Mateta, Edoard or Watkins
• Kotchap
• Then a couple of loanees

There must be a balancing of the books, need to move a few players on and nudge them out of “the nest”.
So who is going to/might be on their way..??

• Meyer – I like Max as a player, but he’s had chances and never quite nailed it – maybe a little lightweight for the at this point for the Prem – but I fear could come back and bite us.
• Riedewald – Ditto Meyer.
• Sakho – Again I like Sakho, but always concerned there is a mistake just around the corner. Probably now 3rd choice centre half if everyone is fit after Tomkins and Cahill, maybe even 4th if Roy persists with trying Kouyate at centre half. Then you have the potential of Kotchap coming in.
• Dann – has been great for us but sadly think his time might be done but not sure we would get much interest.
• Townsend – Didn’t play a lot last season, I was half expecting him to be a “makeweight” in the Eze deal.
• Schlupp – can’t see it Roy seems to like him – and when fit always performs well, good bench player and gives us cover all down the left and in central midfield.
• Ayew – no double player of the year last season, although think his opportunities maybe a little more limited next season.
• Benteke – again with Benteke I think it’s there, but his confidence seems shot – maybe a move would suit all parties.
• Zaha – the big one..!! I’m becoming less sure about Zaha leaving by the day – at the end of the season it was a definite yes for me, he’s off, was showing no interest and looked for all the world like a player who wanted to be moving on. Now he’s being pictured happily smiling in the new kit, playing and scoring in friendlies. On from that Eze’s comments about our plans, playing with great players etc.. Beyond that no real bids or suitors coming out of the “woodwork”. Time will tell..!!
Just some thoughts, obviously not all of them will go – but will be interesting..!!

On leavers I would like us to “ship out” Hennessey and bring in Butland – it’s just a personal view but think that would be a great move.

COYP

Why would Ayews opportunities be limited next season? Not trendy enough for us ( like when we replaced the old balding Murray with the young tanned , tattooed Wickham??) how did that pan out?
Was our best attacking player last year, probably relegated without him. Should be out main man. Think he’s better as a second striker or playing a bit wider.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 28 Aug 20 9.53pm

Originally posted by Vincehair

Plaistow Patricia is moving on

Sorry, I don’t understand.

 

southnorwoodhill Flag 29 Aug 20 10.06am

Those who are near the end of their contracts and sicknote high earners, the club needs a clear out and doesn't have the finance to carry those who contribute little but take much. So, the likes of Benteke, Wickham, and Sahko for starters. Meyer doesn't fit Hodgson's system and is on big money so him too. Zaha should go, mainly because he put in a transfer request.
The aim should be to get the average squad age down by 4/5 years and reduce wages - extra salary should come by way of bonuses for performance.

 

Casual Flag Orpington 29 Aug 20 10.21am

Originally posted by southnorwoodhill

Those who are near the end of their contracts and sicknote high earners, the club needs a clear out and doesn't have the finance to carry those who contribute little but take much. So, the likes of Benteke, Wickham, and Sahko for starters. Meyer doesn't fit Hodgson's system and is on big money so him too. Zaha should go, mainly because he put in a transfer request.
The aim should be to get the average squad age down by 4/5 years and reduce wages - extra salary should come by way of bonuses for performance.

Agree. We should be 60 grand a week maximum , maybe plus bonuses. The teams round us aren’t paying £400 grand a week on 4 players.

 

coulsdoneagle Flag London 29 Aug 20 10.33am

Originally posted by ex hibitionist

it shud be harmonica and hobo stick for ...

Meyer
Sakho
Benteke
Wickham

and I'd put McArthur on the list if we can get a younger replacement

and I'm not sure we need five defensive midfielders (six if you include Meyer), so maybe Kouyate as well, keep Riedewald

McArthur has been one of our most consistent and important players for years. Absolute madness. As for the rest of them I agree except Benteke. He’s our only out and out striker at the club bar Wickham and he was starting to look much better second half of the season. I’d like to see him given a chance with another creative attacking player because he has been feeding off scraps for 2 years.

 

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 29 Aug 20 10.45am

Originally posted by coulsdoneagle

McArthur has been one of our most consistent and important players for years. Absolute madness. As for the rest of them I agree except Benteke. He’s our only out and out striker at the club bar Wickham and he was starting to look much better second half of the season. I’d like to see him given a chance with another creative attacking player because he has been feeding off scraps for 2 years.


The extension of Jimmy Mac's contract suggests he isn't going anywhere just yet (but I suppose if a decent offer were made for him we might let him go).

I agree with you re Benteke although a lot will depend on the final make-up of our squad at the end of this window. In any event, if Dazza is to be believed (and I do believe him) Benteke is staying with us.

I'm happy to see Sakho, Meyer and Wickham off our books so as to free up wages and provide us with more wriggle room in future windows.

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 29 Aug 20 1.11pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

With Eze coming in and looks like others to follow;

• Fraser
• One of Mateta, Edoard or Watkins
• Kotchap
• Then a couple of loanees

I have to say I wish I had your optimism. I would be over the moon if we brought in 3 more players let alone another 5.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Who is going to be moving on..??