You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Future of football
November 16 2026 5.41am

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Future of football


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
dreamwaverider Flag London 23 Sep 20 7.57am

In light of banning all fans from grounds, other than the prem who rely on sky as their main source of income, how will other pro clubs survive? I think their main source by far is the gate, hospitality etc. Without that I can’t see their chairmen funding huge wages with no income.
This means player will effectively have to accept a few Bob each or their clubs will simply fold. This is looking very serious

 

CPFC1965 Flag Warrington 23 Sep 20 8.24am

The reality is that England has a disproportional number of professional clubs that have always existed hand to mouth. Maybe it is time to restructure the football league and salary caps across the board. Change the Championship into Premier 2, which it effectively is now but without the funding.

 

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 23 Sep 20 8.30am

Eventually it will all even itself out, once players contracts come to an end. Going forward new player contracts will have to be for less. If you were on on 100k per week but now only get 60k then so be it, it’s still better than working on a building site for £150 a day

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Sep 20 8.37am


It is very worrying in Scotland. To take one example - Dunfermline, a mid-size Championship club (average home crowd 4620) made a profit of £5,644 in 2018 while many clubs were already operating at a loss.
At this level the promotion or relegation of one local rival or a cup tie against the Old Firm can make a big difference in terms of revenue.
It’s hard to see how clubs in lower divisions can survive.

 

dreamwaverider Flag London 23 Sep 20 9.12am

Let’s be straight. This is ALL about players wages (managers too).
It will eventually boil down to whether they want to be pro players or not. I doubt the premier will share. Too greedy. Maybe they will be allowed to pick up lower clubs as feeders? They will be free by then.
Profesional footballers will need to get together to sort this out.
I can’t see any of the existing contracts being torn up. It’s what comes out of the ashes that counts.
Tradesman are now on £80k pa plus so I suppose when the game has adjusted we could be looking at say £250k pa. so much healthier.

 

CrazyBadger Flag Ware 23 Sep 20 9.27am

I agree that Wages age the major outlay, and should be reduced if possible. But, if we reduce wages significantly - and this especially applies to wages in the Prem, whats to stop players simply moving abroad in search of better wages, and weakening our own league?

 


"It was a Team effort, I guess it took all players working together to lose this one"

Dubai Eagle Flag 23 Sep 20 9.41am

In pretty much any industry, the best workers , achievers, players, performer (those in most demand) , will undoubtedly follow the money -

 

spartakev2 Flag Anerley 23 Sep 20 9.53am

The big clubs will break away and form a european league, taking all the tv money with them....

 

Badger11 Flag Beckenham 23 Sep 20 10.24am

Some good points made I agree with most.

I think the era of crazy money for bang average players is coming to an end which is why I am not bothered that many of our squad are out of contract at the end of next season. With one or 2 exceptions I expect they will be offered less money.

How many of our squad would walk into another PL side? Those that can will be looked after if not by us by another club. The rest can moan as much as they like but a player on 50k a week who is not wanted on those terms elsewhere can be replaced from the Championship where the players and their clubs will be very keen to move.

It is quite likely that Sky and the big boys will form some kind of breakaway league however I do not want to see that and if it happens say goodbye to everything below the Championship.

As for our players going abroad, never going to happen. The better players have always had that option but the other major leagues are in a financial mess maybe even worse than us so the same rule applies great players will always be alright.

Worrying times if you love football, unfortunately the FA are spineless and the clubs selfish and greedy I really hope I am wrong about this.

Edited by Badger11 (23 Sep 2020 10.26am)

 


One more point

doombear Flag Too far from Selhurst Park 23 Sep 20 10.59am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I agree that Wages age the major outlay, and should be reduced if possible. But, if we reduce wages significantly - and this especially applies to wages in the Prem, whats to stop players simply moving abroad in search of better wages, and weakening our own league?


The same problem as here - Covid 19 with its various forms of lockdown, and I suspect foreign leagues are more dependent on matchday income than the Prem clubs.

 

Eaglehamster Flag Storrington 23 Sep 20 10.59am

Originally posted by CrazyBadger

I agree that Wages age the major outlay, and should be reduced if possible. But, if we reduce wages significantly - and this especially applies to wages in the Prem, whats to stop players simply moving abroad in search of better wages, and weakening our own league?

Won't there be reduced wages worldwide?

 


I have now sufficient funds to last me the rest of my life. Provided I don't buy anything.

Ginger Pubic Wig Flag Wickham de L'Ouest 23 Sep 20 1.39pm

One of the best things about England is the depth of the game. These tiny clubs with fervent fans and rich histories.

It made me very sad when Bury folded. I have a massive soft spot for them (they're my 2nd team). It would be tragic to see 40 or 50 lower league sides fold.

You just have to hope they don't lose their stadia. If they don't, hope remains.

 


If you want to live in a world full of kindness, respect and love, try to show these qualities.

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Sep 20 1.40pm


There has been talk for years of a European League; the Champion’s League extended to season length. Everyone else would essentially become feeder clubs.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 23 Sep 20 5.03pm

In the current circumstances I don’t know why Sky haven’t approached all clubs about a “season ticket” to air all games for their fans to view live..!!

So we as Palace fans would be able to purchase a “”season ticket” watch all Palace games live and the same for supporters of other clubs.

Their are cameras at all games.

Revenue shared between Sky and the clubs.

Just seems to make sense to me given the current circumstances.

Smaller clubs may fair better, given the lower capacities of their grounds - take us for example Selhurst capacity what 26K - sure Sky would sign up more “virtual” Palace season ticket holders than that..!!

It ain’t ideal I know, but would generate revenue for all clubs and Sky - whilst enabling fans and probably more fans than usual to watch and support their Team live.!!

I’m sure better brains than me have thought of this already - but I’m really struggling to see this would not be a viable option - or at the least something to explore and discuss..!!

It’s a “win, win” scenario always round:

Clubs get additional revenue
Sky get additional revenue
Fans get to watch their team live

Thoughts?

COYP

 

pompeyeagle Flag Relocated to Shropshire 23 Sep 20 5.36pm

These are very worrying times for all spectator sports, football being just one of them. I understand why the government have made this decision. You can’t be telling people they can’t gather in groups of more than six and then let thousands of fans in a stadium, the public just wouldn’t stand for it but it wouldn’t surprise me if the league had to be restructured maybe going back to a third division north and south again, maybe even all the teams below the championship having to go part-time.

 

Plaistow Eagle Flag 23 Sep 20 6.09pm

Originally posted by pompeyeagle

These are very worrying times for all spectator sports, football being just one of them. I understand why the government have made this decision. You can’t be telling people they can’t gather in groups of more than six and then let thousands of fans in a stadium, the public just wouldn’t stand for it but it wouldn’t surprise me if the league had to be restructured maybe going back to a third division north and south again, maybe even all the teams below the championship having to go part-time.

No need for that in the Digital age - as my suggestion.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 23 Sep 20 8.12pm

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

In the current circumstances I don’t know why Sky haven’t approached all clubs about a “season ticket” to air all games for their fans to view live..!!

So we as Palace fans would be able to purchase a “”season ticket” watch all Palace games live and the same for supporters of other clubs.

Their are cameras at all games.

Revenue shared between Sky and the clubs.

Just seems to make sense to me given the current circumstances.

Smaller clubs may fair better, given the lower capacities of their grounds - take us for example Selhurst capacity what 26K - sure Sky would sign up more “virtual” Palace season ticket holders than that..!!

It ain’t ideal I know, but would generate revenue for all clubs and Sky - whilst enabling fans and probably more fans than usual to watch and support their Team live.!!

I’m sure better brains than me have thought of this already - but I’m really struggling to see this would not be a viable option - or at the least something to explore and discuss..!!

It’s a “win, win” scenario always round:

Clubs get additional revenue
Sky get additional revenue
Fans get to watch their team live

Thoughts?

COYP

There are a couple of issues. One would be the existing rights contracts. So there is already a full schedule of matches for Sky Sports Subscribers, plus BT sport, plus NBC, Bein sports etc. Why would any of these people want to pay more? They're probably paying 20-40 a month as it is, could be more.
This leads to the other issue: price, especially when balanced with demand. You say 26 thousand would buy the Palace season ticket, perhaps more. Maybe you're right. However, I would think there wouldn't be that many who would pay the full price of a season ticket in one go to watch Palace - or pretty much any team. The price would have to be cheaper. I would maybe pay 20 a month to watch every Palace game on TV. Perhaps people would pay more?
However, even if say 30,000 people paid 20 a month for Palace and the club was given half (less seems more likely, considering the amount of TV money we already get). It's still 600,000 a month overall, gross before anything else. That's nowhere near enough to do more than pay a few player's wages. It nowhere near replaces lost matchdays income.
Man U and Liverpool etc, Real Madrid: those are the kind of teams that could perhaps get a million, or hundreds of thousands of subscribers. Again, doing nothing much to help a situation. In fact, accelerating a breakaway of 'elite' [glory hunting fairweather] clubs across Europe.
I just wonder how much people would pay and how many would subscribe to teams like Barnsley, for example? I don't think it would help much but it isn't a bad idea. Some kind of virtual ticket - run by the clubs themselves - may get the clubs a bit more money than a Sky deal? But it still has the problem of existing rights.

Edited by ASCPFC (23 Sep 2020 8.14pm)

 


Red and Blue Army!

DutchEagleJohan Flag Vlissingen, Netherlands 23 Sep 20 8.23pm

My sentiments exactly Ginger. Done 69 of the "92" which is not even 92 anymore as is and the experience overall is fantastic. Now I am a sucker for old stadia, and the lower leagues offer so much on that. Very remote from the Premier League but bedded in the community just as much if not more and really it does not matter all that much how professional that is or how much the players get payed.

Originally posted by Ginger Pubic Wig

One of the best things about England is the depth of the game. These tiny clubs with fervent fans and rich histories.

It made me very sad when Bury folded. I have a massive soft spot for them (they're my 2nd team). It would be tragic to see 40 or 50 lower league sides fold.

You just have to hope they don't lose their stadia. If they don't, hope remains.

 

RH8Eagle Flag Oxted 24 Sep 20 12.08am

Originally posted by Plaistow Eagle

In the current circumstances I don’t know why Sky haven’t approached all clubs about a “season ticket” to air all games for their fans to view live..!!

So we as Palace fans would be able to purchase a “”season ticket” watch all Palace games live and the same for supporters of other clubs.

Their are cameras at all games.

Revenue shared between Sky and the clubs.

Just seems to make sense to me given the current circumstances.

Smaller clubs may fair better, given the lower capacities of their grounds - take us for example Selhurst capacity what 26K - sure Sky would sign up more “virtual” Palace season ticket holders than that..!!

It ain’t ideal I know, but would generate revenue for all clubs and Sky - whilst enabling fans and probably more fans than usual to watch and support their Team live.!!

I’m sure better brains than me have thought of this already - but I’m really struggling to see this would not be a viable option - or at the least something to explore and discuss..!!

It’s a “win, win” scenario always round:

Clubs get additional revenue
Sky get additional revenue
Fans get to watch their team live

Thoughts?

COYP

I could see Sky and BT etc being cut out completely one day as really with the internet the clubs could stream their own games along with their other content that’s already going out, they would earn more that way. BUT it would not help the vast majority of the lower leagues as younger fans would slowly gravitate towards the big boys and the divide would grow even across the premier league the earning difference would be huge and unassailable.

Football is a crazy business as the players are taking so much from the clubs they play for in persuit of the premier league, it’s led to supporters often sitting in out dated stadia with crap facilities and paying good money for the privilege.
Football could well do with a rebalancing of the finances, I can’t imagine any money coming from the government so it could well be a messy painful time

 

Goal Machine Flag The Cronx 24 Sep 20 7.18am

It would be a nice gesture if the Premier League players could agree a temporary salary reduction for the season and to donate it to the football league under an official tax efficient charity arrangement. Say 20% reduction for those earning over £50k pw and 10% for those below £50k pw.

Many workers are taking pay cuts as a short term temporary measure so I don’t think it’s unreasonable.

I won’t hold my breath though...

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Palace Talk > Future of football