You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Most overrated players
November 22 2026 7.33pm

This page is no longer updated, and is the old forum. For new topics visit the New HOL forum.

Most overrated players


Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>
the.universal 23 Sep 20 10.28am

A post on a separate topic got me thinking, who do you think are the most overrated players in the prem?

For me it’s always the young English players. In past times; Wilshere and Barkley.

Nowadays, Declan Rice would be a clear number one for me. Add Stones, Pickford, Alli and Lingard.

Dean Henderson is coming up on the sidelines too. Not done enough yet to justify the hype.

Any foreign ones worth mentioning?

 


Vive le Roy!

Tom-the-eagle Flag Croydon 23 Sep 20 10.48am

Originally posted by the.universal

A post on a separate topic got me thinking, who do you think are the most overrated players in the prem?

For me it’s always the young English players. In past times; Wilshere and Barkley.

Nowadays, Declan Rice would be a clear number one for me. Add Stones, Pickford, Alli and Lingard.

Dean Henderson is coming up on the sidelines too. Not done enough yet to justify the hype.

Any foreign ones worth mentioning?


Harry Maquire.

Good player but 80 million???

Not as good as Cayhill in my opinion.

 


"It feels much better than it ever did, much more sensitive." John Wayne Bobbit

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Sep 20 10.53am

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle

Harry Maquire.

Good player but 80 million???

Not as good as Cayhill in my opinion.

Good call.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Sep 20 11.02am

People generally over estimate young players because they are putting emotion into it.

It's why I liked Richard Shaw's tough love evaluation of our younger players....which has mostly proven accurate....seemed to cost him his job though(or maybe he said it because he knew he was going).

There's too much hyperbole and desire for positivity over rational evaluation and I think that's what leads to these over estimations.

Remember that 'golden generation' of English players who were given lavish praise and were expected to win championships yet didn't.....it shows the human tendency to 'overegg' the pudding out of an excess of positivity.

Hardly a crime but it's still leads some down the garden path.

Meyer is an example of a Palace player who was overrated....Big wages but we were hoping for more of an impact than what we got.

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Sep 20 11.23am

I really rate Rice - he’s head and shoulders above anyone else at West Ham every time I watch them.

Don’t think anyone really rates Dele or Lingard anymore - Lingard in particular is one of the most ridiculed in the league, Dele looks like he took his foot off the gas and thought he’d made it.. his accomplishments up to 21/22 were incredible though.

Maguire probably a fair shout.

I’ve always thought Coutinho was very overrated, and Firmino gets a very easy ride given how few goals he scores.

Would also throw Giroud’s name into the mix - never scored enough goals at the top level.. Arsenal would’ve won the prem 15/16 with any competent goalscorer, but he went on a 15 game drought. Also failed to score a single goal in France’s World Cup win despite playing every game. A good footballer, clearly very talented, but never been a top level forward.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Sep 20 11.31am

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

People generally over estimate young players because they are putting emotion into it.

It's why I liked Richard Shaw's tough love evaluation of our younger players....which has mostly proven accurate....seemed to cost him his job though(or maybe he said it because he knew he was going).

There's too much hyperbole and desire for positivity over rational evaluation and I think that's what leads to these over estimations.

Remember that 'golden generation' of English players who were given lavish praise and were expected to win championships yet didn't.....it shows the human tendency to 'overegg' the pudding out of an excess of positivity.

Hardly a crime but it's still leads some down the garden path.

Meyer is an example of a Palace player who was overrated....Big wages but we were hoping for more of an impact than what we got.

Don’t agree at all - they underperformed internationally for a variety of reasons, but that generation was clearly ‘golden’ and they cleaned up for a long time at club level; the likes of Terry, Ferdinand, Cole, Lampard, Gerrard, Scholes, Rooney were all widely accepted as amongst the best players in Europe at the time - look at all the peer-voted Team of the Year awards and individual awards around that time.. they all regularly feature.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Sep 20 11.49am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Don’t agree at all - they underperformed internationally for a variety of reasons, but that generation was clearly ‘golden’ and they cleaned up for a long time at club level; the likes of Terry, Ferdinand, Cole, Lampard, Gerrard, Scholes, Rooney were all widely accepted as amongst the best players in Europe at the time - look at all the peer-voted Team of the Year awards and individual awards around that time.. they all regularly feature.


The 'golden generation' were promoted as being serious championship contenders and winners. The statistics show that sadly wasn't the case. Indeed, not doing as well as previous less lauded generations

I view, your comment that this is down to 'a variety of reasons' as an excuse for what was in reality an overestimation.

At the end of the day it comes down to the quality of players and the reality is that they were over hyped in comparison to their opposition.

I'm not for one minute suggesting that they weren't generally the best within the English system.

It wasn't the 'golden generation'...it was the 'hyped and commercialized generation'.

Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2020 11.50am)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

A89M Flag Streatham 23 Sep 20 11.51am

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

I really rate Rice - he’s head and shoulders above anyone else at West Ham every time I watch them.

Don’t think anyone really rates Dele or Lingard anymore - Lingard in particular is one of the most ridiculed in the league, Dele looks like he took his foot off the gas and thought he’d made it.. his accomplishments up to 21/22 were incredible though.

Maguire probably a fair shout.

I’ve always thought Coutinho was very overrated, and Firmino gets a very easy ride given how few goals he scores.

Would also throw Giroud’s name into the mix - never scored enough goals at the top level.. Arsenal would’ve won the prem 15/16 with any competent goalscorer, but he went on a 15 game drought. Also failed to score a single goal in France’s World Cup win despite playing every game. A good footballer, clearly very talented, but never been a top level forward.

Doesn't get as many goals as he should but the impact he has on those around him is perfect for how Klopp sets his team up. It's more evident when he's out injured and Origi takes his place - they don't seem to have the same intensity. IMO - Without Firminio in the team, Salah and Mane don't score as many goals as they have..

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Sep 20 12.27pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays


The 'golden generation' were promoted as being serious championship contenders and winners. The statistics show that sadly wasn't the case. Indeed, not doing as well as previous less lauded generations

I view, your comment that this is down to 'a variety of reasons' as an excuse for what was in reality an overestimation.

At the end of the day it comes down to the quality of players and the reality is that they were over hyped in comparison to their opposition.

I'm not for one minute suggesting that they weren't generally the best within the English system.

It wasn't the 'golden generation'...it was the 'hyped and commercialized generation'.

Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2020 11.50am)

That doesn’t make any sense - they were serious championship winners, just not at international level, which is probably 5% or less of a players career. Surely it makes more sense to judge them on the 95%, of which they all had distinguished careers.

The statistics very much support the fact that they were amongst the best players in the world at the time. We can go into specifics of why it didn’t work with England, but judging them as overrated based on underperformance in a tiny percentage of games across careers of huge success is illogical.

 

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Sep 20 12.32pm

Originally posted by A89M

Doesn't get as many goals as he should but the impact he has on those around him is perfect for how Klopp sets his team up. It's more evident when he's out injured and Origi takes his place - they don't seem to have the same intensity. IMO - Without Firminio in the team, Salah and Mane don't score as many goals as they have..

To some extent, yes, but I think it’s a very overstated argument to try and defend him - his chance conversion statistics are poor, and Salah/Mane have always been prolific wide players.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Sep 20 12.41pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

That doesn’t make any sense - they were serious championship winners, just not at international level, which is probably 5% or less of a players career. Surely it makes more sense to judge them on the 95%, of which they all had distinguished careers.

The statistics very much support the fact that they were amongst the best players in the world at the time. We can go into specifics of why it didn’t work with England, but judging them as overrated based on underperformance in a tiny percentage of games across careers of huge success is illogical.

I think you are straying from what I said.

I'm saying that they didn't live up to their promotion. I think that's factual and not in serious contention. The hype for the 'golden generation' just didn't come true.

Now you seem to want to argue around ideas I haven't pushed and then call me illogical, which is a straw-man

Now if you want to get into the weeds over why this supposedly championship winning generation didn't deliver I'm willing to hear you out.

However, I put it to you that in comparison to their opposition they were overhyped.

You keep going on about awards. Are you saying that English players won more awards then other nations at that time? Or indeed were the most valuable compared to their international opposition?


Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2020 12.42pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

EverybodyDannsNow Flag SE19 23 Sep 20 12.54pm

Originally posted by Stirlingsays

I think you are straying from what I said.

I'm saying that they didn't live up to their promotion. I think that's factual and not in serious contention. The hype for the 'golden generation' just didn't come true.

Now you seem to want to argue around ideas I haven't pushed and then call me illogical, which is a straw-man

Now if you want to get into the weeds over why this supposedly championship winning generation didn't deliver I'm willing to hear you out.

However, I put it to you that in comparison to their opposition they were overhyped.

You keep going on about awards. Are you saying that English players won more awards then other nations at that time? Or indeed were the most valuable compared to their international opposition?


Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2020 12.42pm)

Do you only consider ‘championships’ as international ones? Because failing that your argument makes no sense - they all won the lot at club level, were key players in the most successful teams of that era, and their individual statistics to this day support the fact they were top level players.

Look at the CV of a Cole, Lampard, Terry or Ferdinand and explain how they underachieved - I’m genuinely curious how that can be argued.

 

Stirlingsays Flag 23 Sep 20 1.16pm

Originally posted by EverybodyDannsNow

Do you only consider ‘championships’ as international ones? Because failing that your argument makes no sense - they all won the lot at club level, were key players in the most successful teams of that era, and their individual statistics to this day support the fact they were top level players.

Look at the CV of a Cole, Lampard, Terry or Ferdinand and explain how they underachieved - I’m genuinely curious how that can be argued.


I'd already answered your domestic level query in a follow up post. I'm not claiming they weren't good players.

My post was about hype and it used the 'golden generation' label as an example. I used it in relation to what was stated about England's players performing on the international stage saying they didn't win anything or even look like it.

Please let's not go round in circles. I'm fine with you thinking the opposite.

Edited by Stirlingsays (23 Sep 2020 1.18pm)

 


'Who are you and how did you get in here? I'm a locksmith. And, I'm a locksmith.' (Leslie Nielsen)

Painter Flag Croydon 23 Sep 20 1.19pm

Jordan Pickford.

 

martin2412 Flag Living The Dream 23 Sep 20 1.24pm

Originally posted by the.universal

A post on a separate topic got me thinking, who do you think are the most overrated players in the prem?

For me it’s always the young English players. In past times; Wilshere and Barkley.

Nowadays, Declan Rice would be a clear number one for me. Add Stones, Pickford, Alli and Lingard.

Dean Henderson is coming up on the sidelines too. Not done enough yet to justify the hype.

Any foreign ones worth mentioning?

I think it was probably my post stating that Pickford and Stones were imo the most over rated players in the Prem that prompted you to create this thread.

I'd like to therefore nominate the world's numero uno over rated player as...... Neymar. In my opinion he's a pile of dogshyte.

Edited by martin2412 (23 Sep 2020 1.25pm)

 

the.universal 23 Sep 20 1.32pm

Originally posted by martin2412

I think it was probably my post stating that Pickford and Stones were imo the most over rated players in the Prem that prompted you to create this thread.

I'd like to therefore nominate the world's numero uno over rated player as...... Neymar. In my opinion he's a pile of dogshyte.

Edited by martin2412 (23 Sep 2020 1.25pm)

I would’ve also said Ibrahimovic back in the day but now I’ve come to appreciate his talents.

 


Vive le Roy!

Teddy Eagle Flag 23 Sep 20 1.50pm

Originally posted by Tom-the-eagle


Harry Maquire.

Good player but 80 million???

Not as good as Cayhill in my opinion.

Looking at a couple of Man U forums their fans agree entirely. They’re not keen on Luke Shaw either. Both too slow and easily caught out of position.
Their opinion of Lindelof is much, much worse but has he ever been over rated?

 

Pete53 Flag Hassocks 24 Sep 20 3.23pm

My take on the Golden Generation is that they were all very effective performers in domestic football, and all played a very important role for their clubs, and in that context, you might argue they weren't overrated.

However, on the international stage the Golden Generation England team looked deficient against the top world footballing nations of that time, and certainly didn't live up to the expectations we were led to believe we were entitled to.

I recall watching the 2006 and 2010 World Cups and thinking that we looked quite pedestrian , and some of our passing and ball retention was very poor. Also, the creativity that was required to breakdown opposition defences, and not just those of the top sides, wasn't there either - 6 goals in 5 games in 2006 and 3 goals in 4 games in 2010.

And let's not forget we didn't even qualify for Euro 2008.

So, I think you can argue that they were over-rated as the England teams they populated never looked remotely like they were good enough to go all the way.

 

ASCPFC Flag Pro-Cathedral/caravan park 24 Sep 20 5.07pm

Originally posted by Pete53

My take on the Golden Generation is that they were all very effective performers in domestic football, and all played a very important role for their clubs, and in that context, you might argue they weren't overrated.

However, on the international stage the Golden Generation England team looked deficient against the top world footballing nations of that time, and certainly didn't live up to the expectations we were led to believe we were entitled to.

I recall watching the 2006 and 2010 World Cups and thinking that we looked quite pedestrian , and some of our passing and ball retention was very poor. Also, the creativity that was required to breakdown opposition defences, and not just those of the top sides, wasn't there either - 6 goals in 5 games in 2006 and 3 goals in 4 games in 2010.

And let's not forget we didn't even qualify for Euro 2008.

So, I think you can argue that they were over-rated as the England teams they populated never looked remotely like they were good enough to go all the way.

The current lot looked worse than that in the last couple of matches. I'm not sure many of them are rated highly enough to be over rated. The stand out, best player, arguably star, is Kane. Most of the rest average. I would say Rashford is good on his day.
Dier, Stones, people like that, aren't necessarily highly rated amongst their club fans. Let alone the nation.

 


Red and Blue Army!

norwayeagle Flag Trondheim 24 Sep 20 5.38pm

Maguire, Stones, Henderson.

 

Page 1 of 2 1 2 > Last >>

You are here: Home > Message Board > Football Talk > Most overrated players